Back to California Disability

Emma Thompson

Can I cancel SDI claim and refile next quarter for higher benefit amount?

Okay so I've been out since early October with a back injury and I filed my SDI claim right away like you're supposed to. But now I'm realizing my highest earning quarter was actually Q3, which just ended, and I'm worried the base period they're using for my claim might not include enough of my better-paid work. I think I heard somewhere that if you cancel and refile later, EDD might calculate your benefit amount using a different base period that includes more recent wages. Not sure if that's actually a thing or if I'd just be throwing away my current claim for no reason. Has anyone looked into this? I really can't afford to get this wrong because I'm still not cleared to go back and bills aren't waiting.

DE 2525XX came in from my doctor's office two weeks late and I wasn't sure if the extension was going to go through. Ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) after I burned through most of a week trying that 1-800-480-3287 line. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed they had received the DE 2525XX and that it was matched to my claim. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ

0 coins

Claimyr, what does that actually do? I've never heard of it and I have a question about my own claim's start date that nobody can seem to answer.

0 coins

You hand EDD's line the waiting and your phone rings when an agent there picks up. That's the whole thing.

0 coins

Ah okay, that actually makes sense. My start date showed something unexpected in SDI Online and I want to get that sorted before my first payment drops.

0 coins

Eight mornings I tried that line. Got the recording every single time. Knowing there's another way in is useful.

0 coins

Canceling a claim to chase a higher base period is not something EDD allows as a strategy, and I had to learn that the hard way when I thought the same thing after my own claim was filed. The base period is set by the date your disability begins, full stop. EDD uses the wages from the highest-paid quarter of the 12-month period that runs from roughly 5 to 18 months before your claim start date. Your disability started in October, so that window is already fixed.

0 coins

So even if I withdrew and waited, the base period would still be anchored to when I actually got hurt?

0 coins

Exactly right. The disability start date is what anchors everything. Waiting to refile wouldn't shift that calculation.

0 coins

EDD spells this out in the benefit calculation section on their site. The quarter used is the highest-earning one inside that fixed 12-month base period, not whatever quarter is most recent when you file.

0 coins

yeah you cant just pick a different start date, edd decides that based on when your doctor says you couldnt work, not when you filed

0 coins

That makes sense. I guess I was confusing the filing date with the disability start date.

0 coins

a lot of people mix those up, the filing date really doesnt matter for the calculation

0 coins

The base period question comes up a lot and there's a wrinkle worth knowing: if your base period wages are low because of a prior disability, EDD has an alternate base period option. But if that's not your situation, your October start date sets the window and no refiling changes it.

0 coins

I wasn't out before this, so probably not the alternate base period situation. Good to know that exists though.

0 coins

The benefit calculator on EDD's site lets you plug in your quarters to see the estimate before the Notice of Computation arrives. Worth running your actual numbers before assuming the worst.

0 coins

Wait, there's a calculator? Where do I find that? I've been guessing at my benefit amount this whole time and kind of panicking about it.

0 coins

It's on edd.ca.gov under the disability insurance section. Just search 'DI benefit calculator' and it should come right up.

0 coins

Start date on my claim showed wrong in SDI Online and I needed to get that corrected before anything else moved. Tried the phone line Tuesday and Wednesday morning, nothing got through. Used Claimyr and reached an agent who confirmed the actual date EDD had on file matched my doctor's certification, so the display was just a lag.

0 coins

Claimyr is genuinely good, I used it too. The agent I spoke with told me my payment was set up for direct deposit and confirmed the account number on file matched what I had entered. Huge relief after all the confusion about whether the card or the deposit was going to come first.

0 coins

Direct deposit or the card, did EDD say which one was faster to arrive or is it just whenever they process it, anyway

0 coins

The agent didn't say which was faster, just confirmed the deposit details were correct on their end. I figured I'd just watch for it.

0 coins

The start date thing mattered to me because my waiting period days depended on it. Once the agent confirmed the date was right, I stopped worrying.

0 coins

I tried canceling a claim once years ago thinking I could refile smarter. EDD just told me my disability onset date was my disability onset date and that was the end of it. You'd basically be delaying your payments for zero benefit.

0 coins

Yeah that's what I'm starting to understand. The base period isn't something I can game by waiting.

0 coins

Delay payments, same calculation. Not worth it.

0 coins

I'm in a somewhat similar situation and I'm scared I made a mistake. I filed my claim but I'm not sure my doctor submitted the medical certification yet and it's been 11 days. If the certification comes in late does that mess up the base period too?

0 coins

The medical certification being late doesn't change your base period at all. What matters is that it comes in within 49 days of your disability start date. After EDD gets it, they'll contact you about the claim status, usually within about 14 days.

0 coins

49 days, okay I need to write that down. My doctor's office has been slow and I didn't know there was a hard deadline.

0 coins

Call the office and confirm they have your receipt number from SDI Online. That's what they use to find and submit the certification. Without it the form can't get matched to your claim.

0 coins

Receipt number, got it. I actually never gave them that. Going to call right now.

0 coins

My coworker told me she canceled and refiled and got more money. I believed her for a while but then I looked into it and I think she just had a gap in a prior claim that reset things, not the same as what you're describing here.

0 coins

There are situations where a new separate disability period later in the year results in a different base period by default, not because someone gamed the system but just because time passed and a new injury or condition started a new claim. That's probably what happened to your coworker.

0 coins

That tracks, she was out twice in the same year for different things. So it wasn't about canceling, the second claim just naturally had a different window.

0 coins

Right, two separate claims two separate base periods. Canceling the first one wouldn't have done anything.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation is worth actually reading carefully when it arrives! It shows the specific quarter they used and the wages they counted. Sometimes people are surprised it's higher than expected because EDD picks your best quarter automatically.

0 coins

Haven't gotten mine yet, still waiting. How long does it usually take to show up?

0 coins

Mine came about a week after the medical certification was confirmed received. Not a guarantee of timing but that's what I saw!

0 coins

The notice arrives before any payment usually. When it does, check the quarter listed and the wages in that quarter against your own records. If something looks off you have 30 days from the issue date to appeal.

0 coins

Notice of Computation on my claim had a wage amount that didn't match what I expected from that quarter. Tried the EDD line six times across three days and couldn't get a person. Ended up using Claimyr and the agent walked me through which quarter they pulled and what wages were on record from my employer's reports. The number was actually right once I understood what period they were looking at.

0 coins

Honestly sounds like marketing to me, a service that just gets you on the phone? I don't know.

0 coins

Felt the same way when I first heard about it. Tried it anyway when my Notice of Determination arrived and I had no idea what to do next. The agent told me the denial was because EDD hadn't received confirmation of my wages in the base period yet, and they said a notice would go out with appeal instructions. Helped me know what to actually wait for.

0 coins

Okay a denial situation is exactly what I'd want to talk to someone about. Might actually give it a shot.

0 coins

The quarter thing is what I was originally confused about too. Knowing the agent can literally look at which quarter they used is reassuring.

0 coins

Waiting period question, does it start from when you file or when the disability starts, I could never get a straight answer on this, anyway

0 coins

Disability start date, not filing date. The seven days run from day one of the disability and they're not payable no matter what. First payable day is day eight.

0 coins

So those seven days just disappear no matter what, got it, anyway

0 coins

yeah the waiting period is not about processing time its literally just unpaid days built into every new claim

0 coins

To answer the original question directly: no, withdrawing a filed claim to refile in a later quarter won't increase your benefit amount. EDD calculates from your disability onset date, and that's not something a refile resets. The best quarter in your base period is selected automatically.

0 coins

Really appreciate the direct answer. I think I was overthinking it and looking for a loophole that doesn't exist.

0 coins

Use the calculator on EDD's site with your actual wage history. You might find the amount is better than you feared.

0 coins

Unemployment versus SDI is something I mixed up early on. I thought maybe I could switch to unemployment while waiting for SDI to process and double dip for a couple weeks. EDD's pretty clear that you can't collect both for the same days.

0 coins

Exactly, and unemployment also requires being able and available to work every week. If you're out on a disability you don't meet that requirement, so unemployment isn't the right program while you're still unable to work.

0 coins

Yeah I figured that out before I did anything, thankfully. SDI was the right one for my situation.

0 coins

Different programs different rules. Good you caught it.

0 coins

Base period thing aside, what actually happens if someone files and their wages in that base period are really low, like maybe they just started the job. Do they get nothing?

0 coins

EDD requires at least $300 in wages subject to SDI deductions during the base period. If total wages are below that threshold the claim won't qualify. But if someone has $300 or more it at least opens the door even if the weekly amount comes out small.

0 coins

Makes sense, so it's not all or nothing, just proportional to what you earned in that window.

0 coins

The SDI deduction on a California paystub is listed as CASDI. If you've been having that taken out, those wages count toward the base period.

0 coins

been trying to get through to edd for a week about whether my certification matched, nobody picks up ever

0 coins

The SDI Online message option through myEDD at least creates a paper trail. Under your claim ID there's a Request Claim Update option. Not instant but it's something when the phones are impossible.

0 coins

didnt know that existed, trying it today

0 coins

Also check with your provider's office that they used your receipt number when they submitted. A mismatched or missing number is the most common reason a certification doesn't show as received.

0 coins

The refiling idea comes up a lot and I get why it seems logical. Wages went up, file later, get more. But the whole system is built around protecting you from the moment you can't work, not from whenever it's most convenient to file.

0 coins

That framing actually helps. It's insurance, so it kicks in at the loss event not when you strategize around it.

0 coins

Exactly. And if the amount on your Notice of Computation is genuinely wrong due to an error, there's an appeals process for that.

0 coins

Canceled claims don't get refiled with a better base period. They just get canceled. The math doesn't change.

0 coins

Blunt but accurate. I went down that research rabbit hole too before my claim and came to the same conclusion.

0 coins

Saved you some time at least.

0 coins

For anyone still unsure about their benefit amount before the Notice of Computation arrives, myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ is where you log in to check claim status and your SDI Online details. The notice will show up there too once it's issued!

0 coins

I keep forgetting to check SDI Online and just refresh my email waiting for something. Good reminder to actually go log in.

0 coins

Logged into myEDD this morning and my claim still shows pending but at least I can see what's there. Waiting on the Notice of Computation now.

0 coins

Worth noting that the 52-week maximum on a DI claim is another reason not to delay filing unnecessarily. Every week you wait to file after you're disabled is potentially a week of benefits you don't get back.

0 coins

That's a good point I hadn't even thought about. I filed pretty quickly but I could see someone delaying hoping to hit a better quarter and then losing weeks on the other end.

0 coins

And the 49-day filing window means waiting too long can disqualify you entirely. Filing promptly is almost always the right call.

0 coins

yeah 49 days goes faster than you think especially if youre sick or recovering and not really tracking dates

0 coins

Your Q3 wages are probably already in your base period anyway depending on when your claim started. The window goes back 5 to 18 months from your start date so an October claim would typically pull from somewhere in 2025 through early 2026.

0 coins

Actually that's a helpful point. If the base period goes back that far, Q3 might already be in there. I should run the calculator and check.

0 coins

For an October start date the highest-earning quarter inside that specific 12-month base period is what EDD picks. Run your quarterly wages through the EDD calculator and you'll see which one they're likely to use.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure