Back to California Disability

Malik Davis

Can I apply for unemployment after SDI claim discontinued for missing medical exam

So my SDI claim got discontinued because I missed a medical exam that EDD had scheduled, and now I'm completely lost about what to do next. My disability was for a back injury I got outside of work and I had been receiving payments for about six weeks. I didn't even realize the exam was something I had to show up to until I got a notice saying my claim was discontinued. Now I'm wondering, can I apply for unemployment after SDI claim discontinued for missing medical exam, or is there some other way to get income coming in? I'm still not fully recovered but my doctor says I could probably do desk work, so I'm not sure if that means I should try unemployment or try to fix the SDI situation first. Has anyone dealt with this before?

Waiting period question tripped me up on my own claim last month, so I called and asked the agent to confirm exactly which seven days were the non-payable ones. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get to someone at EDD's disability line after my own attempts went nowhere for three days. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. Agent confirmed the waiting period started on my claim's first day and the first payable day was day eight, which lined up with what I'd been paid. On your actual question, the SDI and unemployment rules are very different about what you need to qualify, so it matters which one fits where you are right now.

0 coins

Three days of trying the disability line and then some service gets you through? That reads like an ad someone wrote.

0 coins

Felt the same way when I first saw the name, honestly. But I'd been dialing since Tuesday with nothing to show for it, so I tried it last week. Agent told me my payment for the week I was asking about had already been issued, which was what I needed to know. Not paid by a mystery, just EDD's own staff.

0 coins

Alright, fair enough. If it got an actual EDD person on the line I'll take another look at it.

0 coins

Wait, so the waiting period is the first seven days and you don't get paid for those at all? I thought it was just processing time. Does that change if the claim gets discontinued and then restarted or something?

0 coins

The discontinued claim and the unemployment question are actually two separate things worth untangling. EDD's own language is that you can't get unemployment and disability for the same days, and unemployment requires you to be able to work and available every week you claim. So if your doctor says you can do desk work now, that's the question EDD cares about for unemployment, not the SDI history.

0 coins

Okay so if I'm cleared for desk work, I could technically file for unemployment even while the SDI discontinuation is still sitting there unresolved?

0 coins

The two claims run separately. What matters for unemployment is whether you're able and available to work right now. The SDI discontinuation doesn't block an unemployment filing, but EDD decides each claim on its own facts.

0 coins

EDD deciding each claim on its own facts, yeah, tell me how that goes when you can't get anyone on the phone to explain what happened.

0 coins

Miss the exam, claim stops. That's how it works. First thing I'd do is look at the notice, see if there's an appeal option and what the deadline is.

0 coins

The notice did come with an appeal form, the DE 1000A I think. I just didn't know if appealing made sense or if I should just move on to unemployment.

0 coins

Thirty days from the date on the notice. Don't let that run out while you're deciding.

0 coins

Appeal and unemployment don't cancel each other out. You can do both.

0 coins

My cousin had her claim stop for a documentation issue and she just filed for unemployment thinking that was the fix. EDD ended up asking her about why she stopped the SDI and it got complicated. Not saying don't do it, just that it got tangled.

0 coins

Was she still not able to work when she filed for unemployment? Because that's kind of the crux of it right, you have to actually be available.

0 coins

She was sort of in between, like you, where the doctor said light duty was okay. I think that's why it got confusing.

0 coins

The rule is that every week you claim unemployment you have to be able and available to work. If there's any week where that wasn't true, claiming unemployment for those days isn't right. The SDI is for the days you can't work.

0 coins

Nobody at EDD can explain to you why the exam was scheduled or what happens now because getting a human on that line is basically a part-time job.

0 coins

Tried for a solid week after my own notice came. Morning, afternoon, didn't matter.

0 coins

Exactly. And the kicker is the clock on your appeal is ticking while you're trying to get someone to explain what the notice even means.

0 coins

The SDI Online message option at least creates a record if you can't get through by phone.

0 coins

I'm not sure I understand the medical exam part. I thought EDD just goes off what your doctor submits, the medical certification. Is the exam a totally different thing they can require separately? Not sure how I missed that this was a thing.

0 coins

EDD can request an independent medical examination to verify that the disability is still ongoing. It's separate from the certification your own doctor does. Missing that one is what can get a claim discontinued.

0 coins

I had no idea that was possible. So my doctor's paperwork isn't necessarily the last word on it?

0 coins

Your doctor's certification starts the claim and covers extensions, but EDD has the option to request an independent exam. The notice for it would have come to you in the mail.

0 coins

Base period quarter question on my own claim took forever to sort out, so I ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to someone at EDD's disability line. Agent pulled up my claim and confirmed which of the four quarters they used for the highest wages, which explained why my weekly amount on the Notice of Computation looked the way it did. Worth knowing before you decide whether to appeal or file something new.

0 coins

Did the agent just tell you the quarter outright, or did you have to ask a specific way?

0 coins

Just gave them my claim ID and asked which base period quarter showed the highest wages. They read it right off.

0 coins

I've been hitting redial on that disability line since last Thursday and not once got a person. Good to hear there's a way that actually works.

0 coins

if your doc says desk work is okay then honestly just file unemployment and move on, the sdi stuff is already done at that point

0 coins

The SDI discontinuation isn't necessarily final, though. If the appeal window is still open, the original claim can potentially be addressed. Filing unemployment separately is a different step, not a replacement for that.

0 coins

oh didnt know you could appeal a discontinued one, thought once they cut it thats just it

0 coins

Thirty days from the notice date. Same appeal window as anything else EDD sends out.

0 coins

The DE 1000A is definitely the form you want for the appeal. Make sure you write out what happened with the medical exam, as much detail as you can! An administrative law judge looks at it if the appeal is late, but try to get it in within 30 days either way.

0 coins

Is there anything specific I should include about why I missed the exam? Like does the reason matter to them?

0 coins

Yes, the reason matters a lot! Explain the circumstances in as much detail as you can on the form. If the appeal ends up being late, the judge looks at whether the delay itself had a good reason too.

0 coins

Keep any documentation you have from around the time of the exam, appointment records, anything that shows what was happening. It may help with the explanation.

0 coins

Unemployment while still unable to work doesn't fly. If the desk work clearance is real and current, file. If it's partial, talk to your doctor about what they'd actually put in writing.

0 coins

My doctor was pretty casual about it, like verbally said I could probably do sitting work, but I don't have anything written. Does that matter?

0 coins

EDD goes by what's documented. Verbal is you, paper is your doctor.

0 coins

For unemployment you wouldn't need a doctor's note, you just need to honestly answer that you're able and available to work each week you certify. If you can't honestly answer yes, that week isn't unemployment territory.

0 coins

been there. the notice comes and suddenly you're scrambling to figure out what any of it means while also trying to figure out how to pay rent.

0 coins

Yes, exactly this. The notice language is so formal and I just panicked.

0 coins

the appeal form at least gives you a place to write what actually happened. worth filling it out even if you're not sure.

0 coins

From a practical standpoint, these are really two separate questions. The appeal addresses what already happened with the SDI claim. The unemployment question is about where you are right now physically. Both can move at once.

0 coins

That actually helps me feel less like I have to pick one or the other.

0 coins

You don't. File the appeal before the 30 days runs. Then figure out the work availability question separately.

0 coins

Payment method on my claim kept showing the old card info and I couldn't figure out if it updated, so I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get someone at the disability line. Agent checked and told me the payment method on file was still the Money Network card, which was actually fine since that's what I wanted anyway. If your claim does get reinstated after an appeal you'd want to make sure your payment info is current too.

0 coins

My claim is pending and I've been worried about whether my direct deposit info went through correctly. I want to ask EDD directly. I'll try Claimyr for that. What do I need to have ready?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number, your claim ID from SDI Online, and the bank account number you think you entered. That's what I had when the agent pulled it up anyway.

0 coins

EDD scheduling a medical exam isn't something most people know about until it's too late. The notice goes to whatever address they have on file. If that address was old, that's part of what you'd explain on the appeal.

0 coins

Actually my address was current. I think the notice came but I genuinely didn't understand I had to do anything.

0 coins

Then say that on the appeal. That's your explanation.

0 coins

An honest account of what happened is really all you can give them. Judges deal with real situations, not perfect ones.

0 coins

For the unemployment side, the UI claim looks at a totally different base period for wages. So even if the SDI base period came out low, the UI calculation might be different. Worth filing to find out if you meet the wage requirements there too.

0 coins

Different base periods, yes, and also different weekly certification questions. UI asks every week whether you were able and available, and you have to say yes to get paid for that week.

0 coins

So I'd have to honestly answer that each week when I certify for unemployment?

0 coins

Every single week. And it has to be true, not what you hope is true or what your doctor said in passing.

0 coins

Medical certification question on my claim was holding everything up because I couldn't tell from SDI Online if the provider's submission had actually come through. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get to an EDD agent. Agent looked it up and said the certification was received but hadn't been matched to my claim yet, and told me to give it a few more days before following up again.

0 coins

The unmatched certification thing happened on mine too. Agent I spoke with confirmed the same, that the form was there but not linked, and once it matched the pending weeks resolved. Used Claimyr for that one and got through on a morning I'd already spent two hours redialing.

0 coins

So even when the certification is received it might still show pending for a bit?

0 coins

That's what the agent told me, and the payment did come through after. Didn't have to do anything else.

0 coins

Don't forget that if you get the SDI reinstated through an appeal and there were weeks you were actually disabled during the gap, those might be recoverable too. The appeal form is where you lay that out.

0 coins

Okay that actually changes my thinking a bit. I assumed the discontinued weeks were just gone.

0 coins

The appeal is the mechanism for that argument. EDD and ultimately the administrative law judge decide, but laying it out on the form is how it gets considered.

0 coins

Exactly! Put everything in writing on the DE 1000A and don't leave anything out.

0 coins

Couldn't figure out which quarter of my wages they were using to calculate my benefit amount, so I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get to EDD's disability line and the agent pulled it up. Said they used the highest-paid quarter from my base period, which was a quarter where I'd worked a lot of overtime. Explained why the number on my Notice of Computation was higher than I expected.

0 coins

Did you have to do anything specific to get them to actually look at the base period details, or did they just pull it up when you gave your claim number?

0 coins

Just gave them the claim ID. They had everything right there.

0 coins

I've been trying that disability line off and on for going on two weeks. Nice to hear someone actually got through.

0 coins

The SDI line and the unemployment line are two different numbers by the way. Getting discontinued on SDI doesn't mean you suddenly have better luck reaching the UI line. Just flagging that so you're not surprised.

0 coins

I didn't even think about that. So I'd be dealing with a whole different EDD line for the unemployment question?

0 coins

Yes, completely separate. SDI is 1-800-480-3287, UI is its own line. Two different departments basically.

0 coins

And two different claim processes in myEDD. The SDI appeal goes back to the SDI folks, the UI claim is a fresh filing through the unemployment side.

0 coins

To put it plainly: if you're appealing the SDI discontinuation, do that through the DE 1000A before the 30 days is up. If you're able to work now, you can file for unemployment in parallel. Neither one cancels the other, they just cover different days and different situations.

0 coins

This is the clearest summary I've seen in this whole thread. Thank you.

0 coins

Get the appeal in first. That deadline is the only thing with a hard cutoff right now.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure