Back to California Disability

Ava Harris

Can I apply for SDI if voluntary plan private insurer denies my claim?

So my employer has a Voluntary Plan instead of the state SDI program, and I filed a disability claim with the private insurer they use when I had to stop working because of a back issue that my doctor said would keep me out for at least six weeks. The insurer just sent me a denial letter and I honestly don't know what to do next. Someone at work mentioned the state program might still be able to cover me but I'm not sure if that's even possible when your employer opted out with a Voluntary Plan. Has anyone actually gone through this? Can I apply for SDI if voluntary plan private insurer denies my claim, or am I just completely out of luck at this point? I don't want to miss some deadline while I'm sitting here confused.

The denial letter timing really matters here, so hang onto it. I went through something similar with my employer's Voluntary Plan last spring and ended up needing to reach EDD directly to sort out my medical certification situation. I tried the disability line for days and nothing, so I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) and ended up talking to an actual EDD agent. The agent pulled up my claim and told me my doctor's certification hadn't been matched to my file yet, which was holding everything up. Video on getting a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. On your actual question, EDD handles Voluntary Plan appeals separately, and you'd want to ask EDD how your specific denial counts under state rules.

0 coins

The receipt number piece tripped me up too. I used Claimyr and the agent confirmed the receipt number my provider used didn't match what was in my file, so the cert was just sitting unmatched.

0 coins

May I ask, when the agent found that mismatch on your receipt number, did they tell you the certification needed to be resubmitted or just corrected on their end?

0 coins

The agent said my provider needed to find the claim in SDI Online with the right receipt number and resubmit. Once they did that it moved forward.

0 coins

Wait so the doctor has to use the exact receipt number from when you filed? I didn't know that. I think I just gave my doctor my name and claim number. Should I go back and check?

0 coins

The SDI Voluntary Plan rules are genuinely worth reading on EDD's site because they're more specific than most people expect. EDD does have a process when a Voluntary Plan denies a claim, but how it works in your situation is something you'd need to ask EDD directly since it depends on details they'd need to look up.

0 coins

So there is some kind of path forward then? I wasn't sure if the denial just meant it was completely over. How do I even start that conversation with EDD?

0 coins

SDI Online in myEDD has a Request Claim Update option, and Ask EDD is the online contact form. Either one gets your question to EDD in writing, which is useful if you want a record of what you asked.

0 coins

I didn't realize Ask EDD was actually useful until I used it for my own claim question. Got a response in a few days. Worth trying while you're also trying the phone.

0 coins

Denial letter has an appeal deadline on it. Read it before anything else. Don't let that date pass while you're figuring out the EDD side.

0 coins

There's a date on there, it's 30 days from the letter. So I need to move on both things at once basically.

0 coins

Yep. Appeal the Voluntary Plan denial and contact EDD at the same time. Don't wait on one for the other.

0 coins

This is the right call. Clock is ticking on that appeal window.

0 coins

The EDD disability line is a joke. I spent three mornings in a row hitting that line before 9am and got hung up on every single time. I don't know how anyone actually reaches a person there.

0 coins

Tuesday mornings have been slightly better in my experience but only slightly.

0 coins

I tried Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday. The line just ends the call. No hold music, nothing.

0 coins

ive been getting cut off too its not just you

0 coins

The waiting period question came up for me in a weird way on my own claim, so I ended up phoning EDD about it. Used Claimyr and got through to an agent. She confirmed that the seven-day waiting period on my claim started on the first day I was unable to work, not the day my medical cert was submitted, which I had completely wrong in my head. That cleared up why my first payment was later than I expected.

0 coins

That sounds like marketing to me honestly. No way you just got through to someone at EDD after everyone here is saying the line hangs up on them.

0 coins

I had the same doubt actually. Then I tried it on my own claim because I needed to ask about my Notice of Computation amount. The agent pulled up my file and read me the weekly benefit figure right off it. She works for EDD, not some third party.

0 coins

Alright, I'll try it. I've been trying that line since Tuesday and I'm getting nowhere.

0 coins

The waiting period confusion is real. I thought my benefits would start the day I stopped working. The seven days at the start being unpaid is not obvious from the way the forms are worded.

0 coins

For the record on the waiting period point above: the first seven calendar days of a new DI claim are a non-payable waiting period. The eighth day is the first day that can be paid. That's separate from how long processing takes.

0 coins

So if I'm out for two weeks I'd only get paid for one week effectively? That's what I had wrong this whole time.

0 coins

For a two-week disability, yes, roughly one payable week after the waiting period. The waiting period is day one through seven, payment-eligible starts day eight.

0 coins

I told three different people the wrong thing about this before I finally understood it. The waiting period is not processing time, it's literally just the first seven days aren't paid, period.

0 coins

does the voluntary plan denial letter have to say why they denied it bc mine just said ineligible and nothing else

0 coins

The letter should have a reason, but if it doesn't, contacting the insurer in writing to request the specific basis for the denial is a reasonable next step before the appeal deadline passes.

0 coins

ok ill email them today, deadline is coming up fast

0 coins

Get it in writing from them. Phone calls don't leave a trail.

0 coins

If your employer's Voluntary Plan is denying and you believe the denial is wrong, the appeal goes to that insurer first per the terms of their plan. EDD gets involved at a different stage. The SDI Online message center or Ask EDD are the right places to explain your situation and ask EDD where you stand.

0 coins

I didn't realize the Voluntary Plan appeal and the EDD question were separate tracks. I was treating them as the same thing.

0 coins

They involve different parties. The insurer handles their own appeal. EDD is a separate question about what state coverage, if any, applies to your situation.

0 coins

This distinction took me a while to figure out too. The insurer's appeal process and EDD's rules don't run on the same timeline or through the same channels.

0 coins

My coworker went through a Voluntary Plan thing last year and she said the whole thing took way longer than a regular SDI claim because there were two separate processes going on. She ended up filing through SDI Online to get EDD in the loop early. Not sure if that applies here but worth knowing.

0 coins

Filing in SDI Online while the Voluntary Plan appeal is still going, is that something EDD expects or would that cause confusion on their end?

0 coins

Asking EDD directly through Ask EDD or the Request Claim Update in SDI Online about your specific situation is the cleaner move before filing anything, so you know what they'd want you to do.

0 coins

I'm kind of in a similar spot and I've been scared to do anything wrong because I don't want to mess up whatever options I have left. Do you lose the right to go to EDD if you wait too long on the Voluntary Plan side?

0 coins

Deadlines under SDI generally run from the disability start date, so letting time pass without contacting EDD carries risk. Asking EDD now while tracking the insurer's appeal deadline is the safer approach.

0 coins

Okay that's what I needed to hear. I'll send something through Ask EDD today.

0 coins

Glad you're moving on it. The deadline piece is the part that bites people when they wait.

0 coins

What form did you use to file the VP claim? Was it their own form or the DE 2501?

0 coins

Their own form, not the DE 2501. The insurer sent it when I reported the disability to HR.

0 coins

That's normal. Voluntary Plans have their own paperwork. If EDD gets involved you'd go through SDI Online or the DE 2501 for the state side.

0 coins

The DE 2501 is the paper option for the state claim. SDI Online through myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ is the faster route if you end up needing to file on the state side.

0 coins

Base period question actually came up for me when I tried to figure out if my wages even qualified me for state SDI. Used Claimyr after losing an entire morning on the hold line and finally talked to an EDD agent. She looked up which quarter of my base period they'd use and confirmed the wages from my highest quarter were on file. That alone told me my claim wasn't going to get kicked out for a wage issue.

0 coins

When you talked to the agent, did she say anything about how to tell which quarter they look at? I'm trying to figure out if my hours last year count or not.

0 coins

She said it's the highest-paid quarter from a specific twelve-month window before the claim start date and that the Notice of Computation would show exactly which quarter they used. I let her read me the quarter and the amount off my file so I could check it myself.

0 coins

been trying that disability line for like two weeks now. mornings, afternoons, doesn't matter. good to know there's another way.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation tells you your potential weekly benefit amount. It is not an approval. People mix that up constantly.

0 coins

I think I would have made exactly that mistake. So getting the Notice doesn't mean the claim is approved, just that they calculated what it could be?

0 coins

Correct. The claim is approved when payments actually come or you get a determination notice. The computation notice is just the math.

0 coins

The DE 429D is the Notice of Computation. Keep it because it shows your weekly benefit figure and your maximum benefit amount.

0 coins

The part about going through SDI Online while the VP appeal is pending sounds right to me. You don't want to be in a spot where the VP denial is final and you've missed EDD's window too.

0 coins

Yeah that's my fear. Two deadlines running at once and I miss both.

0 coins

Ask EDD in writing today so at least EDD has a record that you reached out and when. Covers you a little.

0 coins

My situation was totally different but I did learn that filing on time in SDI Online is what protects you from missing the window! The 49-day rule from your disability start date is a real cutoff.

0 coins

That 49-day window applies to the claimant's part and to the medical certification from the treating provider. Both need to be in within that period.

0 coins

Both parts, got it! I didn't realize the doctor's deadline was the same window as mine.

0 coins

The provider has to submit the medical certification no later than 49 days after the disability start date too. If the Voluntary Plan process ate up most of that time, it's worth checking where you are on that clock.

0 coins

genuine question, if i have workers comp for the injury piece does that affect SDI at all? asking for someone else but also kind of for myself

0 coins

EDD says it's not common to get both workers' comp and SDI at the same time, and that there are exceptions. That's about as specific as anyone can be here. EDD would need to know your situation to say more.

0 coins

ok so it's not a flat no, just complicated. noted.

0 coins

Workers comp is a work injury. SDI is for things not at work. When both apply it gets complicated fast and EDD has to sort it out.

0 coins

The doctor side of this matters too. Your treating provider needs to submit the medical certification through SDI Online using your claim receipt number, or on paper if the claim was filed on paper. If they haven't done that yet and you're still inside the 49-day window, that's worth confirming with their office soon.

0 coins

The receipt number, is that the number SDI Online gives you right after you submit your part of the claim? I want to make sure I'm giving the office the right one.

0 coins

Yes, SDI Online gives you that receipt number when you finish your Claimant's Statement. That's the one your provider needs to find the claim in the system.

0 coins

Worth writing it down somewhere safe. I had my doctor's office lose it and had to dig back through my own records to give it to them again.

0 coins

If EDD ultimately determines that a Voluntary Plan denial entitles you to pursue the state program, the claims process runs through SDI Online just as it would for any other DI claim. The form is the DE 2501 on paper or the online equivalent in myEDD. The medical certification piece stays the same either way.

0 coins

That's actually reassuring. At least I know the state process isn't totally different from what I've already started.

0 coins

The core steps don't change. The complication is confirming that you're eligible to access the state program given the Voluntary Plan situation, which only EDD can answer for your specific case.

0 coins

I keep thinking about my own situation reading this. Mine isn't a VP denial but the SDI Online process is confusing enough that having a clear path laid out like this helps.

0 coins

my employer never told us we were on a voluntary plan until i tried to file. found out when hr sent me the insurers form instead of the edd one

0 coins

That's such a common story. So many people don't know their employer opted out of the state plan until they're already trying to file a claim.

0 coins

yeah it was a whole surprise. i thought i was just filing SDI normally

0 coins

HR should have told you at hire. Doesn't help you now but worth knowing for next time, and worth asking them directly what your rights are under the VP.

0 coins

EDD's disability line says wait times are long and then drops you. Been that way for years. The whole system is built to wear you out.

0 coins

Three days of trying last week. The line either puts me on hold for 40 minutes or ends the call. No in-between.

0 coins

same experience every time i try. its demoralizing.

0 coins

The frustration is real. SDI Online's Request Claim Update and Ask EDD at least give you a way to put something in writing when the phone line doesn't go anywhere.

0 coins

Update: I sent a message through Ask EDD explaining the VP denial and asked EDD where I stand on the state program. Also appealed the insurer's denial in writing today before the deadline. Waiting to hear back on both. At least I'm not just sitting here anymore.

0 coins

Moving on both tracks at once is exactly the right call.

0 coins

Documenting the dates you filed both the Ask EDD message and the VP appeal is worth doing now while they're fresh. It may matter later.

0 coins

Good. The 49-day clock from your disability start date is still running on the medical certification side too, so keep your provider in the loop about what's happening.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure