Back to California CalFresh

Isaac Wright

Why is my CalFresh so low this month?

Kids are fed, barely, but the balance on the GSA card after deposits has been noticeably lower than what we got approved for and I cant figure out why. We didn't report any income change, nothing changed with the household size, same address. The Notice of Action from the last recertification showed a certain amount and what actually hits the card each month is less. I called the county number twice and sat on hold both times until it cut me off. BenefitsCal just shows the case as active so I have no idea what changed. Anyone run into this where the benefit amount dropped without any letter explaining it?

Had the exact same thing happen, benefits dropped out of nowhere, no letter, no explanation in BenefitsCal. I spent three mornings in a row trying to get the county on the phone and the line either rang busy or the hold music stopped and it just disconnected. Maddening.

0 coins

County phone lines are a joke. I gave up after a week of trying. Went in person instead, that actually worked.

0 coins

Going in is tough with the job schedule but I might have to. Did they fix it on the spot when you showed up?

0 coins

They pulled up the case right there and found a deduction had dropped off. Got a corrected notice mailed out the same day.

0 coins

A state hearing request was sitting on my case unresolved for two months and I had no idea it had affected my benefit amount. Tried the county line maybe a dozen times before I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to someone. The worker looked up my case and confirmed the hearing request was recorded and gave me the date it was filed. Video on reaching a live person at CalFresh: https://youtu.be/eZ19FHRETv8

0 coins

When you got through, did you have your case number ready or did they look you up another way?

0 coins

Had the case number and the last four of my Social. Worker pulled everything up in about a minute.

0 coins

been trying that line since tuesday. every time it just rings and rings. good to know there's another way.

0 coins

Benefits dropping without a new Notice of Action sent to you first is worth looking into carefully. Your county has to give written notice at least ten days before they lower benefits, so if you didn't get one, that's worth asking about at the county office or in writing through BenefitsCal.

0 coins

Checked the mailbox going back a couple months and nothing. BenefitsCal doesn't show any new notices either.

0 coins

Upload a message in BenefitsCal asking what Notice of Action was issued and when. That creates a paper trail.

0 coins

Good move. I did exactly that once and the county responded within a few days with the notice date.

0 coins

There are a few things that can quietly change a benefit amount without you realizing. Did anything shift with income, even slightly, or did someone in the household turn an age that affects eligibility? Also worth checking if a deduction, like a shelter cost, wasn't updated correctly at recertification.

0 coins

Income has been the same, nobody aged out of anything. The shelter cost is the one I hadn't thought about.

0 coins

Shelter deductions can get dropped or not carried over right if something changed in how the county entered it. That alone could account for a noticeable difference.

0 coins

Wait, is a shelter deduction something I have to report separately every year or does the county just keep it from last time? I didn't know that was even a thing.

0 coins

At recertification you typically go over all expenses including shelter costs. If the new form didn't reflect your current rent, the deduction might have changed.

0 coins

I'm not sure if this is related but I think I read somewhere that if your income goes over a certain threshold you're supposed to report it and benefits could get adjusted. I don't totally understand how the IRT works though.

0 coins

The IRT is the income reporting threshold. If your household income goes over that number mid-period, you have to report it within ten days and the county can adjust benefits from there.

0 coins

So if nobody reported anything and income didn't go up, that shouldn't be the reason then, right?

0 coins

Correct. If income stayed the same and no one reported a change, the IRT side of it isn't the issue here.

0 coins

My amount dropped after my SAR 7 and I didn't notice for almost two months lol. Turned out I'd listed my hours differently than the prior period and they recalculated from that.

0 coins

Did they send a Notice of Action about the adjustment or did you just spot it on the card?

0 coins

I spotted it on the card first, then went back through my mail and found the NOA buried under stuff. It had been mailed almost a month before I looked for it.

0 coins

That happens all the time, the notice comes and people don't recognize what it is and set it aside. Always open anything from the county no matter how boring the envelope looks.

0 coins

check if the semiannual report changed anything. happened to me after i turned in the sar 7 and my hours looked higher than they were because i listed gross not what i actually take home

0 coins

Gross vs net, I never thought about which one to put. That could actually be it.

0 coins

yeah they go off gross income. if you put net by accident the numbers look different and benefits shift

0 coins

Earned income on the SAR 7 is listed as gross. If the county entered it correctly from what you wrote, the calculation would be based on that gross figure.

0 coins

Have you looked at your ebtEDGE app or the EBT Customer Service line to see if the deposit amounts match your Notice of Action each month? Sometimes comparing those two gives you a clue about when the amount changed!

0 coins

Haven't done that comparison month by month. Going to pull up the last three months tonight and see where it shifted.

0 coins

The month it first dropped is usually the clue, because then you can line it up with what was happening on the case around that time.

0 coins

An interview appointment on my recertification got moved without anyone telling me, and the new date didn't show up clearly in BenefitsCal. I ended up talking to a county worker through Claimyr and she confirmed the rescheduled interview date and what documents to bring. Helped me stop guessing and just show up prepared.

0 coins

My SAR 7 submit month is coming up and I've been going back and forth on whether the county received the form I sent. Going to try Claimyr for that.

0 coins

Have your case number handy and the date you submitted the SAR 7. The worker can check whether it's showing as received on their end.

0 coins

Is a recertification interview different from the first interview when you apply? I have one coming up and I'm nervous about what they'll ask.

0 coins

They cover household size, income and expenses again, similar to the original interview. Having your pay stubs and rent information ready makes it straightforward.

0 coins

Worth knowing your state hearing rights here. If the county lowered benefits without giving you proper notice at least ten days before it happened, you can ask for a state hearing within 90 days of that notice date and benefits may continue at the prior level until the decision comes through.

0 coins

Ninety days from the notice date, got it. Where do I actually request one?

0 coins

Phone is 800-743-8525, or there's an online option through CDSS, or the back of the Notice of Action itself has instructions.

0 coins

Requesting before the effective date is the key part. If you wait until after, the continuation provision doesn't apply.

0 coins

Noted. I want to find out what the notice even said first before I decide whether to request one.

0 coins

Benefits going lower mid-period without explanation can sometimes trace back to a data entry error at the county rather than anything you did. It happens. Getting a worker to actually look at the case is the fastest way to find out.

0 coins

County errors are real. Mine had the wrong household size for three months before anyone caught it.

0 coins

Exactly. The case file is what the worker sees, and it may show something different from what you remember reporting.

0 coins

My neighbor had her amount cut in half and it turned out the county had dropped one of her kids from the case somehow. She had no idea until she went in and asked them to show her the household composition on file.

0 coins

That's scary, I should ask them to read back the household members they have on file for us.

0 coins

Absolutely ask. The worker can tell you exactly who is listed and you can spot any errors right there.

0 coins

Shouldn't the county notice if they suddenly have a different household size from one period to the next? Seems like something that should trigger a review.

0 coins

You'd think so, but it doesn't always flag automatically. Human eyes on the case matter.

0 coins

Deposit day on my case is tied to the last digit of my case number, and one month the amount posted was lower than the NOA showed. I used Claimyr to get a county worker on the line and she confirmed the issuance amount for that month matched what the county had calculated, which meant the NOA I was reading was from the prior period, not the current one.

0 coins

Last digit of my case number means my benefits post on the eighth. Had an issue recently where the amount didn't match and I used Claimyr too. Once the worker confirmed the application's filing date was entered correctly, I could see that my first full benefit period hadn't started yet, which explained the lower amount. The county had prorated the first month.

0 coins

Wait, the first month can be a different amount? I didn't know they could prorate it.

0 coins

been calling since the third and nothing. three days of mornings wasted on that line.

0 coins

I'm kind of scared that if I call and ask too many questions they might review my case and find something that actually lowers my benefits further. Is that a real thing that can happen?

0 coins

Calling to ask about your own case doesn't trigger a review. The county isn't going to penalize you for asking what your benefit amount is based on.

0 coins

Okay that's actually reassuring. I've been scared to ask.

0 coins

Ask away. You have every right to know what's in your case file.

0 coins

Pull out the most recent Notice of Action and look at the gross income and deductions listed. Then look at the one before it. If a number changed between the two, that's your answer right there for why the amount shifted.

0 coins

Going to do this side by side tonight. I have both notices somewhere.

0 coins

Pay close attention to the shelter cost line. That's often where the difference shows up.

0 coins

An exemption from the work rules was something I needed confirmed on my case because the county had a different status recorded than what I'd reported. Ended up talking to a worker through Claimyr and she confirmed what the case showed for my work-rule status and what I'd need to verify to update it.

0 coins

Every time I've tried that number I get a recording that plays for a while and then just ends the call. Tried it on four different mornings last week. I don't see how anyone gets through.

0 coins

Tried the same line before that for weeks. Used Claimyr and ended up talking to a real county worker. She told me the work-rule exemption category on my case and confirmed the documentation I needed to submit.

0 coins

Had a similar situation with the work hours requirement. County had my hours logged wrong and I needed it corrected before my next report period.

0 coins

Alright, might give that a try. At this point I've got nothing to lose on that line.

0 coins

The CDSS site publishes income and eligibility limits and they update them. If your household income is close to any threshold, it's worth checking the current limits rather than assuming the amount from last year still applies.

0 coins

Hadn't thought to check the limits myself. I always assumed the county would notify me if something changed on their end.

0 coins

They should send a Notice of Action, but checking the limits yourself gives you a baseline to compare against what the NOA says.

0 coins

Have you logged into BenefitsCal recently and looked at whether there are any pending items or tasks on the case? Sometimes the county is waiting for something and benefits get adjusted in the meantime.

0 coins

Logged in and I do see a task I hadn't noticed. It's asking for updated income verification. That might be it.

0 coins

There you go. Upload whatever they're asking for as soon as you can and message through BenefitsCal to let them know you submitted it.

0 coins

A pending verification task can definitely hold up the full benefit amount. Getting that in should clear things up pretty quickly.

0 coins

if you call the ebt helpline they can at least tell you what the deposit amounts have been each month. its 877-328-9677. they cant fix the case but at least you know where the number is coming from

0 coins

Called the helpline and they read me the last four deposit amounts. The drop started in October and it was exact, same lower amount each month since then.

0 coins

now you know when it started. take that date to the county and ask what changed on the case in october

0 coins

October is also when new income limits took effect for the federal fiscal year. If your case was up for review around that time the timing could be connected.

0 coins

Sounds like the BenefitsCal task was the missing piece. Upload that income verification and add a note asking the county to confirm whether that's what caused the lower amount. You'll know a lot more once a worker looks at it.

0 coins

Uploaded everything tonight and sent a message through BenefitsCal. The task showed a document received notice a few minutes after I submitted. Going to wait and see what the NOA says.

0 coins

That's the right move. If the new NOA shows a correction back to your original amount, you'll know the verification was the gap.

0 coins

Glad you figured out there was a pending task. I'm going to check my BenefitsCal for tasks right now because I honestly never look at that part.

0 coins

What happens if you upload the income verification and they still don't fix the amount? Is there a next step beyond waiting?

0 coins

State hearing is the next step if the county doesn't correct it and you think the amount is wrong. You have 90 days from the Notice of Action date to request one.

0 coins

And if you request before the effective date they keep paying at the higher amount until the hearing decision comes through?

0 coins

That's the rule, yes, as long as you request before whatever effective date the notice shows.

0 coins

Hoping it doesn't come to that but good to know the option is there if the NOA still looks wrong.

0 coins

California CalFresh AI

Expert Assistant
Secure