


Ask the community...
One final tip - get everything reviewed by qualified counsel before closing. With $2.8M on the line, the legal review cost is worth it for peace of mind. They can spot issues you might miss and ensure everything complies with both UCC requirements and your state's specific rules.
Great discussion here! Just wanted to add one practical point from a recent deal - when you're dealing with multiple members in an LLC, I always request a certified copy of the member resolution authorizing the specific person to sign financing documents. Even if someone has general signing authority, having a specific resolution for the transaction provides extra protection. Also, for your $2.8M deal, consider having the signing party provide a certificate of good standing for the LLC - it's not required by the UCC but many lenders want it to confirm the entity is still validly existing at closing. Good luck with your deal!
Excellent advice about the member resolution, Diego! I'm relatively new to secured lending but this thread has been incredibly helpful. The resolution requirement makes total sense for additional protection on larger deals. Quick question - is there a standard form for these member resolutions or does each deal require custom language? Also wondering if anyone has experience with situations where the LLC operating agreement restricts certain financing decisions and requires unanimous member consent rather than just manager authority?
I had a similar issue with PayPal Working Capital about 6 months ago. What finally worked for me was sending a formal demand letter via certified mail to their legal department, not just calling customer service. I included copies of my payoff documentation, referenced the specific UCC-1 filing number, and cited my state's requirements for timely termination of security interests. I also mentioned that continued delay could result in damages to my business and that I would hold them liable for any financing opportunities lost due to their failure to file the required UCC-3 termination. Within two weeks of receiving the certified letter, they filed the termination statement. Sometimes you need to approach it from a legal compliance angle rather than just customer service requests. The key is making it clear that you understand your rights and their obligations under the UCC.
This certified mail approach is brilliant! I never thought about going directly to their legal department with a formal demand letter. That definitely carries more weight than phone calls to customer service. Do you happen to remember what specific language you used regarding state UCC requirements? I want to make sure I reference the right statutes when I draft my letter. The liability angle for lost financing opportunities is also really smart - puts them on notice that there are real business consequences to their delays.
@f005f545477f That's exactly the approach I needed to hear about! I've been getting nowhere with phone calls. Could you share what address you used for PayPal's legal department? I want to make sure my certified letter reaches the right people. Also wondering if you included a specific deadline in your demand letter - like "please respond within 15 days" or something similar? I'm dealing with time pressure on my equipment financing so want to give them a reasonable but firm timeline to act.
I'm dealing with a similar UCC lien issue right now with a different fintech lender, and this thread has been incredibly eye-opening. It's frustrating how these alternative lenders seem to have no standardized process for UCC-3 terminations after payoff. Traditional banks handle this automatically, but these newer companies treat it like an afterthought. I'm definitely going to try the "secured transactions department" approach and the certified mail to legal department strategy. It's concerning how many businesses are probably stuck with these phantom liens on their credit reports without even realizing it. Has anyone here had success getting retroactive damages from a lender for delayed UCC terminations? My situation has been dragging on for over 60 days and I've already lost one financing opportunity because of it.
This is a really common source of confusion! For your construction equipment (excavator and dump truck), you're definitely dealing with title liens rather than UCC-1 filings. Since these are motor vehicles, the security interest gets perfected by recording a lien directly on the certificate of title through your state's DMV system, not through UCC filings with the Secretary of State. The lender should coordinate this process with the equipment dealer at closing, but I'd recommend asking them specifically about the timeline and which party handles the DMV paperwork. Make sure they're already registered as an approved lienholder with your state's DMV to avoid any delays. This is actually simpler than UCC filings in many ways - no debtor name matching issues and no need for continuation filings every five years.
This is super helpful! So basically the title itself acts as the filing system instead of needing separate UCC paperwork. That makes way more sense now. Do you know if there's anything special I need to do on my end, or should the lender and dealer handle everything once I sign the loan docs?
Usually the dealer and lender handle most of the title paperwork, but you should verify a few things: 1) Make sure your lender is pre-registered with your state's DMV as an approved lienholder (you can check this on your state DMV website), 2) Confirm who's responsible for registering the vehicles if they're coming from out of state, and 3) Get a clear timeline for when the titles will be issued with the liens recorded. Some states allow temporary operation permits while the permanent titles are being processed, which might be relevant for your construction equipment that needs to move between job sites.
I went through this exact same situation with my landscaping business last year! The term "non-UCC filing" is definitely confusing - it basically means any security interest that gets perfected through a system other than UCC-1 filings. For your excavator and dump truck, you're looking at certificate of title liens since they're motor vehicles. The good news is this is actually more straightforward than UCC filings once you understand it. The lender will have their lien recorded directly on the vehicle titles through your state's DMV system. Just make sure to ask your lender for a clear timeline of when this needs to happen relative to when you take possession of the equipment. Most dealers are used to coordinating this process, but it helps to have everyone on the same page about timing so your deal doesn't get held up.
Thanks for sharing your experience! It's reassuring to hear from someone who's been through this exact situation. When you went through this with your landscaping business, did you run into any issues with the timing between taking possession and getting the liens recorded? I'm worried about that gap where I might have the equipment but the security interest isn't perfected yet. Also, did your state DMV process the title liens quickly, or was there a significant waiting period?
I just went through this exact scenario with a different equipment lender and it's frustrating how common this is. One thing that really helped speed up my case was using a document verification service to spot discrepancies before escalating. I uploaded my loan docs and UCC filings to check for any mismatches that might be causing their automated termination system to fail. Turned out there was a slight difference in how my business entity name was formatted between the original loan and the UCC filing - something like "ABC Services LLC" vs "ABC Services, LLC" with the comma. Once I pointed out this specific issue in my demand letter, they were able to fix it much faster than when I was just asking them to "look into it" generally. Also, definitely check both state and county records for any fixture filings if your solar panels are permanently attached to the building. Texas requires dual filing for fixtures in many cases, so there could be multiple UCCs that need termination. Don't give them any more time to drag their feet - three weeks is already too long for what should be a routine administrative task.
Welcome to the community Andre! I can see you're dealing with a really frustrating situation that unfortunately many of us have experienced. Your point about document verification is spot on - those seemingly minor formatting differences can absolutely cause automated systems to fail. I had a similar issue where "Inc." vs "Incorporated" in the entity name caused a 6-month delay in getting a UCC release processed. For anyone else reading this thread, it's worth noting that some lenders have completely outsourced their UCC filing and termination processes to third-party services, which adds another layer where things can go wrong. The key is documentation and persistence - keep records of every interaction and don't let them off the hook with vague responses. Also, if you're in Texas like the original poster, the Department of Banking complaint process is very effective for getting lender attention quickly.
I'm dealing with a similar UCC release issue right now with a different lender, and this thread has been incredibly helpful. One thing I'd add is to also check if your loan servicer changed during the life of the loan - sometimes UCC releases get stuck when there's been a transfer of servicing rights and the new servicer doesn't have proper authorization to file terminations. You might need to track down who actually holds the lien rights now vs. who you've been dealing with for customer service. Also, if you're planning to apply for new credit soon, consider getting a UCC search report from a commercial service to have official documentation of what's currently filed against your business. This can help speed up underwriting for your new credit line even while you're still fighting to get the old lien terminated. The fact that you paid off in November and it's now mid-January means you're well past any reasonable timeframe for automatic processing.
That's a really important point about loan servicer transfers that I hadn't considered! I actually need to double-check if Goodleap transferred my loan servicing at any point. Looking back at my payment history, I think I might have gotten some notices about account changes last year that I didn't pay much attention to at the time. Do you know how to find out who actually holds the lien rights now? Is that information typically available through the UCC search, or do I need to contact Goodleap directly to get that clarification? I'm definitely going to get an official UCC search report before applying for our credit line - that's smart advice about having documentation ready for underwriters.
Zane Gray
OP, sounds like you're on the right track asking these questions upfront. Most UCC s9-609(b)(2) problems happen when people rush the process. Take your time, follow the statutory requirements, and document everything. The equipment isn't going anywhere while you get the paperwork right.
0 coins
Alfredo Lugo
•Thanks everyone for the advice. Feeling much more confident about handling this properly now. Going to double-check our security agreement language and prepare a comprehensive notice.
0 coins
Zane Gray
•Smart approach. Better to spend extra time on compliance than deal with litigation later.
0 coins
Camila Jordan
Just wanted to add my experience with UCC s9-609(b)(2) compliance - the timing really is critical. I've handled several equipment repos and always send the notice by certified mail with return receipt requested at least 10 days before any planned sale. Also make sure to include the debtor's right to an accounting of the unpaid indebtedness and charges. For $180k worth of equipment, I'd also recommend getting a professional appraisal before the sale to help justify the sale price if challenged later. The cooperative debtor attitude is good, but don't let that make you complacent on following proper procedures.
0 coins
Abby Marshall
•Great points about the certified mail and professional appraisal. As someone new to UCC compliance, I'm wondering - is there a standard timeline most lenders follow from default to disposition? Also, when you mention the debtor's right to an accounting, does that need to be a detailed breakdown of principal, interest, fees, and repo costs, or can it be more general?
0 coins