Back to MOHELA

Tami Morgan

MOHELA ICR payment count shows 120 payments left but StudentAid shows two

Ok so I'm genuinely confused and kind of panicking a little. I've been on the Income Contingent Repayment plan for years working toward the 25-year forgiveness, and something is clearly broken between MOHELA and StudentAid.gov because they're showing completely different numbers. On my MOHELA account it says I have 120 payments left on ICR. That's TEN YEARS worth of payments. On StudentAid.gov it shows two payments remaining. TWO. As in I should basically be done. I have no idea which one to trust. My loan history goes back a long time and I've had a couple of different servicers before MOHELA took over. I'm terrified that if I call someone they'll just go with the MOHELA number and I'll be stuck making payments for a decade that I shouldn't have to make. Has anyone else seen this kind of discrepancy? Which system is actually tracking the right count?

Wait, have you tried calling MOHELA about this yet? Because if you haven't, honestly save yourself the hold time nightmare first — I found a service called Claimyr (claimyr.com) that gets you through to an actual MOHELA agent way faster than sitting on hold forever. I used it when my payment count looked wrong after my transfer and it was the only way I actually got a human on the phone without losing my whole afternoon. For something this serious with a 118-payment gap you really need to talk to someone directly.

0 coins

118-payment gap is a good way to put it lol. I haven't called yet because honestly I didn't even know where to start. I'll check out that Claimyr site, that hold time thing is exactly what I was dreading.

0 coins

Does Claimyr actually work for MOHELA specifically? I've had such bad luck with their phone lines I'm almost skeptical anything helps.

0 coins

Yeah it worked for MOHELA when I used it, that's specifically where I needed it. Got through in a fraction of the time I'd been waiting before.

0 coins

Which number do you actually trust more — did your previous servicer send you any paperwork when the loans transferred that showed a payment count at the time of transfer?

0 coins

I got some transfer notices but honestly I didn't save them all carefully. I think the count at transfer was somewhere in the 90s for payments made but I can't be certain now.

0 coins

Transfer notices are gold for exactly this situation. If you can dig through old email or paper mail from around when MOHELA took over, that snapshot count could be the proof you need that something went wrong after the transfer.

0 coins

Exactly what I was thinking. The transfer paperwork is basically a timestamp that neither system can easily argue with.

0 coins

So here's the thing to ask MOHELA when you get them on the phone: ask them specifically how they calculated your remaining payment count under ICR and where the number came from. The reason that question matters is that ICR forgiveness tracks total months of qualifying payments, and if the system imported your payment history incorrectly when your loans transferred, it might have reset or miscounted. StudentAid.gov pulls from a different data source than what MOHELA displays on its own dashboard, which is why you can see two totally different numbers at the same time. The official record of your payment history lives at the federal level, so a mismatch like this usually means MOHELA's display hasn't synced properly with that federal record — but you need them to confirm that in writing, not just verbally.

0 coins

In writing specifically — is there a way to request that or do I just ask the agent to send me something?

0 coins

Ask the agent to document whatever they tell you in a case note and ask them to send you a written summary or secure message confirming the correct count. Some agents will, some won't, but always ask. If they say the StudentAid number is right, ask them to update MOHELA's display to match.

0 coins

This happened to me with a different kind of count discrepancy and the written confirmation thing was crucial. The first agent told me one thing verbally and then it took months to actually get it corrected because nothing was documented.

0 coins

ok genuine question — does it matter which plan you're on for which number to believe? like i always thought studentaid.gov was just the master record but maybe that's wrong

0 coins

StudentAid.gov does generally pull from the federal data, but it's not always real-time and can lag. For ICR specifically the servicer is supposed to be tracking the payment count on the account, so ideally they should match. When they don't it usually means something in the import or the update cycle went sideways.

0 coins

So basically both could technically be wrong? That's a terrifying sentence.

0 coins

Both being wrong is rare but a mismatch this big — 118 payments — is unusual enough that it's almost certainly a data error rather than just a lag. Something actually broke somewhere.

0 coins

Just want to flag one thing that tripped me up for months — are you sure the number on MOHELA's side is showing remaining payments and not something else, like total loan term remaining in months or some other field? I ask because I once misread a field on my account that turned out to be something completely different from what I thought it was counting.

0 coins

I went back and looked again just now. It literally says under my repayment progress section something like 'payments remaining' and shows 120. And StudentAid.gov under the repayment information tab shows 2 remaining payments for forgiveness eligibility. So I'm reading them the same way.

0 coins

Ok so you've double-checked both — that rules out the misread scenario and makes this a genuine data problem. That's actually clarifying even though it's frustrating, because now you know exactly what to tell MOHELA.

0 coins

The StudentAid.gov tab that says forgiveness eligibility — that's the specific one that's supposed to reflect your IDR payment count toward the 25-year forgiveness. If that shows 2, your federal record thinks you're almost done.

0 coins

THIS IS SUCH A COMMON THING and nobody talks about it enough. MOHELA's display and StudentAid.gov are NOT always the same and when they differ by this much it's almost always because the payment history import from a previous servicer got garbled. I went through almost the exact same thing. The MOHELA count was dramatically overstating my remaining payments because it hadn't correctly imported years of qualifying payments from my old servicer. It took me four phone calls and a complaint to the FSA Feedback Center to get it resolved but it DID get resolved and my count corrected.

0 coins

Four phone calls — ugh. But also encouraging that it actually got fixed. Did you end up filing that FSA complaint or did the calls fix it before you needed to?

0 coins

I filed the complaint after the third call because I felt like I was getting nowhere, and then weirdly it resolved about two weeks later. Can't say for sure if the complaint caused it or if the third call finally triggered something, but I'm glad I filed it.

0 coins

The FSA Feedback Center complaint actually does seem to move things. I've heard this from multiple people. It's like it escalates the case internally even if you never hear back directly about the complaint itself.

0 coins

Ask them this when you call: what does your payment history actually show for the period before MOHELA took over your loans? Because here's the thing — the servicer that handled your loans before MOHELA was supposed to send over your complete payment history when the transfer happened. If that data arrived incomplete or with a gap, MOHELA's system might be treating those missing months as if they never happened, which would inflate how many payments you have left. Your federal record on StudentAid.gov might have the complete history from before the transfer because it was never dependent on that servicer-to-servicer handoff.

0 coins

That actually makes a lot of sense as an explanation. So the StudentAid number might be right because it has the full history, and MOHELA just never got all of it?

0 coins

That's the most likely explanation for a gap this large, yes. It's not that MOHELA is lying to you — their system just might have incomplete data to work from. The fix is getting them to reconcile against the federal record.

0 coins

I've seen this exact thing happen when loans moved to MOHELA a while back. Servicer transfers in general are sloppy with historical payment data and it creates exactly this kind of mess years later when people are close to forgiveness.

0 coins

OP have you tried calling yet? I had a payment count issue a while back — different situation but same general vibe of 'these two numbers cannot both be right' — and I finally got through to someone useful using Claimyr (claimyr.com). I'd been calling MOHELA on my own and either getting disconnected or just giving up after an hour on hold. The Claimyr route got me to an agent who actually had the authority to submit a correction request on my account while I was on the phone.

0 coins

Not yet, I've been trying to gather all my documentation first so I actually know what to say when I call. Good to know about Claimyr, I keep seeing it mentioned and I think I'm going to use it.

0 coins

Gathering documentation before you call is smart honestly. Agents respond better when you can cite specific dates and counts rather than just saying the numbers look wrong.

0 coins

Totally agree on preparing first. I'd just also say — once you're ready, don't wait too long. The longer a discrepancy like this sits, the more complicated the correction can get.

0 coins

What's the difference between ICR forgiveness and PSLF? Because I keep seeing people mix them up and I want to make sure OP isn't in that situation.

0 coins

They're different tracks. PSLF requires you to work for a qualifying employer like a government agency or a 501(c)(3) nonprofit, make 120 payments on an income-driven plan or certain other plans, and you get the remaining balance forgiven after those 120 payments — which is 10 years. ICR forgiveness is just about time on the plan regardless of employer, but the timeline is 25 years, and you're counting qualifying payments toward that 25-year total. OP said ICR specifically so they're on the 25-year track.

0 coins

Ok so the 120 payments left showing on MOHELA could look like a full PSLF requirement even though OP isn't on that track. That's what threw me.

0 coins

Yeah I'm definitely ICR, not PSLF. I never worked for a qualifying employer. So if StudentAid is showing 2 payments left, I'm looking at potentially being at 298 out of 300 qualifying months, which is wild to think about.

0 coins

Have you downloaded your full payment history from both MOHELA and StudentAid.gov? Because when I had a discrepancy — mine was way less dramatic but still stressful — I put both payment histories side by side in a spreadsheet and could literally see the month where MOHELA's records went blank and StudentAid's kept going. That made the phone call so much easier because I could tell the agent exactly which months were missing from their system.

0 coins

I haven't done that yet but this is exactly the kind of prep I should be doing. How do you download it from StudentAid.gov — is it under the loan details section?

0 coins

On StudentAid.gov go into your loan details and there should be a payment history section — you can download or print it from there. MOHELA's payment history is in your account under the payment tab. The formats are different so you'll probably need to do some manual matching but it's worth the hour of work.

0 coins

The spreadsheet approach is genuinely the move here. Agents can dismiss a vague 'the numbers don't match' complaint way more easily than a document that shows them specifically which months are missing.

0 coins

wait how does icr even work for the payment count toward forgiveness, is every payment you make counted or just some of them

0 coins

Every payment you make on time while on ICR counts toward the 25-year total — there's no qualifying employer requirement like there is for PSLF. So if OP has been on ICR consistently for all these years, their count should reflect all those months. The question is just whether MOHELA's system has an accurate record of all of them.

0 coins

ok so if the studentaid number is right, op has like 23 years of payments already counted. that's wild that the numbers can be that far apart

0 coins

Genuinely yes. I've been making these payments for a very long time and the idea that MOHELA might have just lost most of that history in a transfer is terrifying.

0 coins

I know someone who had a nearly identical situation — MOHELA showing way more payments remaining than StudentAid.gov — and they said the thing that finally moved it was using Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to MOHELA without the insane hold times, then specifically asking the agent to open a payment history review case and referencing the federal IDR tracker number from StudentAid.gov. The agent apparently had a tool where they could directly compare what MOHELA had on file versus what the federal record showed, and once they saw the gap they escalated it internally.

0 coins

Referencing the IDR tracker number specifically — do you know where on StudentAid.gov that number lives? I want to make sure I have it ready.

0 coins

I believe it's under the repayment information section on your StudentAid.gov dashboard, in the IDR details for your specific loan. The person I know said they screenshotted the whole page so they could read it off to the agent easily.

0 coins

Having that federal tracker reference number is a good tip. It gives the agent something concrete to look up in their system rather than just taking your word that StudentAid.gov shows something different.

0 coins

Can I ask how long you've been on ICR specifically? Because I'm trying to figure out if the StudentAid number being 2 is plausible given your timeline.

0 coins

I've been in repayment for a long time, well over 20 years if you count all the way back. I had some deferment periods in there early on but I think most of my time counts as qualifying payments under ICR. So yes, 2 remaining is plausible — which is exactly why the MOHELA number of 120 is so alarming.

0 coins

Over 20 years in repayment and MOHELA is showing 120 left — yeah that's almost certainly a data import error from a transfer. That math just doesn't work any other way.

0 coins

Deferment periods don't count toward ICR payment count just to flag that — but OP said most of their time wasn't deferment, so the StudentAid number of 2 remaining still sounds plausible.

0 coins

Something nobody's mentioned yet — after you get this corrected, make sure to get a written confirmation of your updated qualifying payment count from MOHELA, and also check that StudentAid.gov updates to match. Sometimes the correction happens on one side and doesn't propagate to the other, and then three months later you're dealing with another discrepancy.

0 coins

That's such a good point. So even after they fix it I need to monitor both systems for a while to make sure they actually stay in sync.

0 coins

At least for a couple billing cycles, yes. The transfer-related data syncs can be inconsistent even after a correction is logged.

0 coins

And if MOHELA issues a forgiveness discharge after those two payments, check StudentAid.gov to make sure the discharge is reflected there too. The discharge should show up on both sides but after what you've described I would just manually verify everything.

0 coins

Does filing a complaint with FSA Feedback Center hurt your account in any way? Like will MOHELA treat you differently if they know you filed one?

0 coins

No, filing a complaint with the FSA Feedback Center doesn't hurt your account. MOHELA can't retaliate against a borrower for filing one — these are federal loans and there are rules about that. The complaint basically triggers a formal review process that MOHELA has to respond to, which is why it tends to actually move things. If anything it creates a paper trail that works in your favor.

0 coins

Ok good to know. I've been scared to file one for my own issue for that reason.

0 coins

Please file it if you have a real issue. I was scared too but it's genuinely just a tool for getting attention on a problem that's being ignored.

0 coins

One more thing to understand before you call — ask them whether your administrative records show any periods where your loans were in forbearance during the transfer process. Sometimes when loans move servicers they get put into an administrative forbearance temporarily, and depending on how that was coded it could affect what gets counted. It's worth asking whether any months got dropped from your count because of how forbearance was recorded during or after the transfer.

0 coins

I did have a period after the transfer where my payments seemed paused for a couple months. I assumed it was just normal transfer processing. Could that have messed up the count?

0 coins

It shouldn't mess up qualifying counts if it was coded correctly as administrative forbearance, but if it was coded as something else or if the system dropped those months from the import it could affect what MOHELA sees. Worth asking specifically about how those months are coded on your account.

0 coins

The post-transfer forbearance period is a known data landmine for people trying to track IDR payment counts. I've seen it cause issues for other people in forums like this.

0 coins

i genuinely cannot believe loan servicers are allowed to have this much variation between their own display and the federal display like this should not be possible in 2026

0 coins

RIGHT? It's federal student loan data. It should be one unified system. The fact that we're out here making spreadsheets comparing payment history exports from two different websites trying to figure out how many years of our financial lives are accounted for is absurd.

0 coins

like imagine if your bank statement showed a different balance than your bank's app. people would lose their minds. but somehow this is just normal for student loans

0 coins

the whole system was built over decades by different agencies and servicers with different databases, that's why it's like this. doesn't make it ok just explains it

0 coins

For what it's worth — if StudentAid.gov shows 2 remaining and that turns out to be correct, please come back and update this thread. I think a lot of people in similar situations would find it really helpful to hear how the resolution actually played out when the StudentAid number was the right one.

0 coins

I absolutely will. This whole situation has been so stressful and confusing that if sharing the outcome helps someone else I'm very happy to do it. I'll post back after I talk to MOHELA.

0 coins

Fingers crossed for you that the StudentAid number is right. Two payments left after all this time would be an incredible outcome.

0 coins

please update us op this thread has me invested now

0 coins

MOHELA AI

Expert Assistant
Secure