Back to MOHELA

Ava Johnson

How to lower student loan payment after SAVE ends MOHELA married filing separately PSLF

So my head is spinning trying to figure this out. My wife and I both have federal loans through MOHELA and we've both been working toward PSLF — she's a public school teacher and I'm at a county health department. We were on SAVE and now that plan is gone (or basically frozen in limbo, whatever you want to call it) and I have no idea what our payments are going to look like going forward or what we should even do about filing our taxes jointly vs separately to keep our IDR payments manageable while we're both still chasing that 120-payment mark. Has anyone actually worked through this — like the math of married filing separately to keep the payment lower when you're both on PSLF track? Our recertification is coming up and I genuinely don't know if I should be switching plans, changing how we file, or just sitting tight. Would really appreciate hearing from anyone who's navigated this recently with MOHELA specifically because I've seen conflicting info everywhere about which IDR plans are still accepting new enrollments right now.

Claimyr got me through to a MOHELA agent in under 20 minutes when I was stuck in this exact same mess — SAVE going sideways, recertification looming, didn't know which plan to switch to. I'd been on hold for over two hours the day before and got disconnected. Claimyr basically holds the queue spot for you and calls when an agent is free. Site is claimyr.com if you want to look it up. Talking directly to a MOHELA specialist who could actually see my account made a huge difference because they could tell me exactly which plans were showing as available on my account and what my projected payment would be on each one. Worth trying before you spend another afternoon on hold guessing.

0 coins

Two hours and then disconnected is my MOHELA experience exactly. Going to check that site out.

0 coins

Already bookmarked claimyr.com — if I can actually get someone who can pull up my account and tell me what plans are showing, that alone would be worth it. I keep reading general answers online but nobody can tell me what's available specifically for my loan type.

0 coins

Same situation, found this thread searching for exactly this. The hold times right now are brutal, everyone is trying to figure out the SAVE situation at the same time.

0 coins

Married filing separately is the move if you're both going for PSLF and you want to keep your IDR payments based only on your own income. The way it works: on most income-driven plans, if you're married and file jointly, your spouse's income gets counted when they calculate what you owe each month. File separately and only your income counts. The tradeoff is you lose some tax benefits — things like the student loan interest deduction and potentially the earned income credit depending on your situation. But if you're both on PSLF track and both expecting forgiveness, the math often comes out in favor of filing separately anyway because you're not trying to pay the loans off, you're trying to minimize payments until forgiveness. Run the actual numbers with a tax person who knows student loans though, because everyone's situation is a little different.

0 coins

That tracks with what I've been reading but seeing it laid out plainly helps. So if we both file separately, both our IDR payments drop because neither of us has the other's income added in. And then since we're both going for forgiveness anyway we don't care that the total we pay over time might be more — we just need the monthly to be manageable while we accumulate the 120 payments.

0 coins

One thing to add — the specific IDR plan matters too for how the income calculation works. SAVE was calculating payment differently than PAYE or IBR did in terms of the percentage of discretionary income. So which plan you land on after SAVE affects the base payment amount before the filing status even comes into play.

0 coins

This is the right general framework but please please please actually talk to a tax professional before changing your filing status. The numbers can go either way depending on what state you're in and what deductions you'd lose. Don't just take forum advice on this one.

0 coins

September 2027 is when my wife's PSLF clock hits 120 and we've been managing this exact tradeoff for years. Filed separately since 2021. The amount we 'lost' by filing separately in tax benefits was way less than what we would have paid in higher loan payments every month if we'd filed jointly. But that math only works if both people are on PSLF track with significant loan balances. If one spouse has tiny loans or no loans, the calculation flips.

0 coins

Both of us have sizeable balances — she's got grad school loans from her master's in education, mine are from a combined undergrad and professional degree. So we're not in the situation where one person has almost nothing.

0 coins

September 2027 is coming up fast actually. Are you already past 120 qualifying payments or still counting?

0 coins

She's at 103 payments last count on her MOHELA account. Still waiting for a couple employer certifications to process. The count on the account doesn't update instantly after you submit the form — takes several weeks sometimes.

0 coins

103 payments and counting, that's the light at the end of the tunnel right there. Hoping mine looks like that someday.

0 coins

IBR is still available as an option from what I understand even with the SAVE situation, and for people who took out loans before a certain cutoff there's also the original IBR formula versus the newer one. The percentage of discretionary income you pay differs between them. PAYE is in a complicated spot right now — check what's actually showing as available on your MOHELA account under repayment plan options rather than relying on what you read because the available options have been shifting. MOHELA's account page or StudentAid.gov is going to show you what you can actually enroll in right now.

0 coins

This is exactly why I'm confused — I keep reading that certain plans are or aren't available and I can't tell if the article I'm reading is from last month or eighteen months ago. The MOHELA account itself is probably the only source that actually reflects my situation right now.

0 coins

Loan date matters a lot here — borrowers who took out their first loan before July 2014 have access to the original IBR which caps at 15% of discretionary income, newer borrowers cap at 10%. That cutoff trips a lot of people up.

0 coins

PAYE has been frozen for new enrollments from what I've seen on my account, but I honestly can't tell if that's permanent or temporary and whether it varies by loan type. This whole situation is a mess to navigate.

0 coins

Something that burned us: when we switched IDR plans mid-year our qualifying payment count paused while MOHELA processed the application. They put the account in administrative forbearance during the review period. That forbearance did not count toward PSLF for us — I had to call and ask specifically because the notice we got didn't make it totally clear. If you're switching plans, ask MOHELA specifically whether the forbearance period during processing counts toward your 120 or not.

0 coins

Wait, so there's a gap in qualifying payments when you switch plans? How long did the processing forbearance last for you?

0 coins

About six weeks from when we submitted to when the new plan kicked in. The months in administrative forbearance didn't count on our PSLF tally. It's not a disaster if you know to expect it, but we didn't and it was frustrating to realize after.

0 coins

Six weeks is a long time to have payments paused and not counting. Did interest keep accruing during that period?

0 coins

My account showed interest still running during that forbearance, yes. The IDR application forbearance isn't the same as a COVID-era forbearance — it's just a processing pause. Check your own account and any notices MOHELA sends during the transition because the details vary.

0 coins

Had a similar situation and ended up using Claimyr a second time specifically to ask about the administrative forbearance question during plan switching — wanted to confirm in writing from the agent what would and wouldn't count. The agent walked me through what my account showed and I took notes with timestamps. If you end up switching plans, getting a MOHELA agent on record saying what the forbearance status is can be really useful if something looks wrong later. claimyr.com is the site, same recommendation as above.

0 coins

Taking notes with timestamps during the call is smart. I've had experiences with MOHELA where I got one answer one day and a different answer another day from a different rep.

0 coins

Documentation is everything with student loans. Screenshot your payment count, download your payment history, save every notice. The systems aren't always consistent.

0 coins

Asking them to note it on your account during the call is also worth doing — you can ask the rep to log the conversation summary so if you call again the next rep can see what was discussed.

0 coins

My coworker who is also a county employee just went through recertification with MOHELA after SAVE ended and switched to IBR. Her payment did go up from what it was on SAVE but it was lower than she feared. She filed separately too. The key thing she said was that she submitted the IDR application well before her recertification deadline so there was no gap in her plan status. Waiting until the last minute apparently can cause problems.

0 coins

How far in advance did she submit? I don't know exactly when my recertification window opens.

0 coins

About 90 days before the deadline from what she told me. She said the application was on StudentAid.gov and that MOHELA updated her account within a few weeks of approval.

0 coins

90 days out feels like a lot of lead time but honestly with MOHELA processing times right now probably smart.

0 coins

The married filing separately calculation works like this in plain terms: most IDR plans look at your adjusted gross income from your most recent tax return. File jointly and that number includes both spouses' income. File separately and each person's IDR payment is based only on their own AGI. If your incomes are significantly different, the lower earner gets a noticeably lower payment when filing separately. If you earn about the same, the effect is smaller but it still removes the other person's income from your calculation.

0 coins

This is clearer than anything I've read on official sites. So it's literally just about which tax return they pull the AGI from.

0 coins

Exactly. The IDR payment calculation pulls from your tax return AGI. Some plans also let you submit current income documentation if your income dropped since you filed — worth asking MOHELA about if that applies to you.

0 coins

Worth noting that if you haven't filed taxes yet for the most recent year they sometimes use the year before. Knowing which year they're pulling from when you recertify is important.

0 coins

Does anyone know if switching from SAVE to IBR resets your qualifying payment count? This is my nightmare scenario — I've been counting carefully and I don't want a plan switch to wipe anything.

0 coins

Switching plans doesn't reset your count. Your qualifying payment history stays on your PSLF tracker regardless of which IDR plan you're on, as long as the new plan is also a qualifying plan and you're still at a qualifying employer. The count only goes forward on the new plan — the old payments don't disappear.

0 coins

Confirmed from personal experience — switched plans twice and my count continued from where it was. The count is attached to your loans and employer history, not to any specific IDR plan.

0 coins

That is such a relief to hear. I was genuinely scared to switch because I thought I'd lose ground.

0 coins

Something nobody mentioned yet: if you switched to married filing separately primarily for student loan purposes, you're locked into that for the tax year. You can't file jointly and separately in the same year, obviously, but also you can't go back and amend a separate return to joint after the deadline in most cases. So if you decide to file separately this year to lower your IDR payment, that's your filing status for the whole year with all the other tax implications that come with it.

0 coins

That's a good point. So the decision on filing status affects everything — not just the loan payment calculation but all the other tax stuff too. Reinforces that we need to actually run the numbers with someone who knows taxes.

0 coins

Exactly. A CPA or tax professional who has experience with student loans is worth the cost here. The married filing separately decision has ripple effects throughout the whole return.

0 coins

This whole thread is making me realize I've been treating the tax and loan decisions as separate when they're really the same decision.

0 coins

Just want to say this thread is exactly what I needed too — my husband and I are in almost the same situation, two teachers, both at MOHELA, both on PSLF track, both trying to figure out what happens to our payments now that SAVE is gone. The married filing separately question has been keeping me up at night.

0 coins

Two teachers, that makes it even more important to get this right because the PSLF end date is the whole plan, right? Messing up the payment amount now affects affordability on the way to forgiveness.

0 coins

Exactly. We can technically afford higher payments but that money is just gone — it's not like it comes back or accelerates forgiveness. PSLF forgives whatever's left after 120 payments, so a higher payment just means we pay more out of pocket with no additional benefit.

0 coins

This is the core logic of PSLF planning that a lot of people miss. You're not trying to pay it down faster — you're trying to keep the monthly payment as low as legally possible while maintaining qualifying status.

0 coins

Third mention of Claimyr in this thread and I'll add my own experience — used it after spending two separate days trying to get through to MOHELA about exactly this scenario, the married filing separately question and what plans were showing as available on my specific account. The agent I reached was able to confirm which plans I was eligible for and explain the administrative forbearance timeline for a plan switch. That conversation gave me enough information to make an actual decision. claimyr.com if you haven't tried it.

0 coins

The part about confirming which plans are available on your specific account is what I keep coming back to — the general information online doesn't tell me what MY account can actually do right now.

0 coins

Two days of trying is exactly the kind of thing that makes people just give up and stay on whatever plan they're on even if it's not optimal.

0 coins

That was almost me. I nearly just stayed put because the effort to reach anyone felt impossible. Glad I found a way through eventually.

0 coins

My MOHELA account still shows SAVE as my plan even though the whole plan is in limbo. I've been in the forbearance they put everyone on. Does that forbearance count toward PSLF? I've seen conflicting answers on this.

0 coins

The SAVE-related forbearance situation has been specifically addressed — check your MOHELA account notices and StudentAid.gov for the most current guidance because this has been evolving. The status of whether specific forbearance months count has changed over time and what your account shows may be different from what was true six months ago.

0 coins

This is one of those cases where you genuinely need to look at what your own account and the official notices say rather than relying on what you read in a forum from any date. The situation has been moving.

0 coins

Okay that's fair. I've been avoiding looking too closely because I'm scared of what I'll find. Time to actually log in and read the notices.

0 coins

Can I ask a dumb question — when you do the married filing separately calculation, do they use this year's taxes or last year's? Because my income changed a lot this year compared to last year and I'd want to make sure they're using the right number.

0 coins

Typically they pull from the most recent return you filed when you recertify your IDR. If your income dropped significantly since your last return, some plans let you submit current income documentation — pay stubs or a self-certification — instead of the tax return. Ask MOHELA when you recertify what options you have if the tax return doesn't reflect your current income.

0 coins

Current income documentation can be a big deal if you had a job change. The process for submitting it is on StudentAid.gov as part of the IDR application — there's a section where you can certify your current income instead of using tax return data.

0 coins

My income went up not down, so I definitely want them using last year's return if possible. Good to know the recertification timing matters.

0 coins

One more practical thing for anyone in this situation: if you're going to switch IDR plans, do it through StudentAid.gov, not by calling MOHELA. The application on StudentAid.gov creates a paper trail and your status updates there. Calling in a plan change request by phone creates a lot of room for things to get lost or delayed. Submit the application online, then call to confirm receipt if you want, but initiate it through the official channel.

0 coins

Doing it through StudentAid.gov directly is good advice — I assume there's a status tracker once you submit so you can see where it is in processing?

0 coins

Yes, StudentAid.gov shows the status of your IDR application. Watch it and if it shows any issue or gets stuck, then it's worth calling MOHELA to find out what's happening.

0 coins

Screenshot the confirmation page when you submit. And then screenshot the status every week or two while it's processing. I've had things disappear from online systems with no explanation.

0 coins

This is a bit of a tangent but it's related — when our loans transferred to MOHELA a couple years ago my autopay didn't transfer over. I found out when I saw my payment wasn't coming out and I had technically missed a payment. Had to re-enroll autopay directly with MOHELA. The interest rate discount for autopay also didn't apply until I re-enrolled. If you've switched servicers at any point, double-check your autopay is actually active on your MOHELA account.

0 coins

Ours transferred to MOHELA about two years ago and I honestly can't remember if I re-enrolled autopay or if it just carried over. Going to check this tonight.

0 coins

This happened to a friend — she thought autopay was set up because it had been with the previous servicer. Turned out it wasn't active with MOHELA and she had a 90-day gap before she noticed. Caused a lot of stress.

0 coins

Exactly. MOHELA's account page shows autopay status pretty clearly once you're logged in — it's worth a quick check even if you think it's fine.

0 coins

Late to this thread but adding one more thing — Claimyr also worked for me to get through about a completely different MOHELA issue (a payment that posted to the wrong loan in my account) and I ended up mentioning the IDR plan question while I had the agent on the line. They answered both things in the same call. If you have multiple MOHELA questions piling up, one good call can clear a lot of them. claimyr.com is where I found it, same as others have said here.

0 coins

Combining questions in one call is smart. I have at least three things I want to ask about and the idea of calling three separate times is exhausting.

0 coins

A payment posting to the wrong loan in your account sounds terrifying. Glad you got it sorted. How long had it been posting wrong before you caught it?

0 coins

Two months before I noticed. The total balance looked right on the main screen but the allocation between loans was off. Had to look at the individual loan breakdown to catch it. Download your payment history and look at it at the loan level, not just the account level.

0 coins

To wrap back to the original question: the short version is that married filing separately to lower IDR payments is a real and legitimate strategy when both spouses are chasing PSLF, the math needs to be run against what you'd lose in tax benefits to confirm it's worth it in your specific case, the available IDR plans right now are in flux so check your MOHELA account and StudentAid.gov directly, and switching plans creates a short administrative forbearance window that you should ask about specifically to understand whether it counts toward your 120. None of this is simple but it's manageable if you get the right information.

0 coins

This is a good summary. My action items coming out of this thread: check our autopay is active on MOHELA, log in and read the notices about the SAVE forbearance situation, actually call MOHELA (maybe via Claimyr given the hold times everyone's describing) to ask what plans are available on our specific accounts, and then sit down with a tax professional before making the filing status decision. Feels like a plan.

0 coins

That's exactly the right sequence. Talk to MOHELA first to know your options, then talk to a tax person with the actual plan options in hand so they can run real numbers.

0 coins

Good luck — this stuff is genuinely complicated and the fact that you're thinking through it carefully before recertification rather than after is already putting you ahead of most people.

0 coins

Following this thread for updates. OP please come back and share what you find out — a lot of us are navigating the same thing.

0 coins

MOHELA AI

Expert Assistant
Secure