ESD denied my claim without explanation - call now or wait for hearing?
So frustrated right now. Just checked my ESD account and saw my UI claim was denied yesterday after waiting 5 weeks in adjudication. The determination letter just says I'm 'not eligible under RCW 50.20.050' with no real explanation or details. There's an appeal option that says I can request a hearing with OAH, which I already submitted. The notice says I have to wait 4-6 weeks for a hearing date. My question is - should I try calling ESD to get someone to explain WHY I was denied before the hearing? I was laid off from my warehouse supervisor position after 3 years when they downsized, so I don't understand the problem. Or is calling just a waste of time at this point? Has anyone actually gotten through to someone who could explain a denial? I'm worried because I've got maybe 2 weeks of savings left and no idea what the actual issue is that I need to prepare for at the hearing.
19 comments
Lola Perez
they did the same thing to me!! denied with that exact code which is voluntary quit but i was laid off too. the system is broken. don't waste ur time calling, literally impossible to get thru
0 coins
Ethan Scott
•Did you get a hearing? What happened? I'm trying to figure out if there's any chance to fix this before the hearing or if I'm just screwed for the next month+
0 coins
Nathaniel Stewart
RCW 50.20.050 refers to voluntary quit provisions. If you were truly laid off due to downsizing, this is likely a misclassification. Your employer might have reported it incorrectly as you quitting rather than being laid off. DEFINITELY try to reach ESD before your hearing. You'll want to understand exactly what information they have that led to the denial so you can prepare proper documentation for your hearing. Bring your termination letter if you have one, any communications about the downsizing, and contact information for anyone who can verify you were laid off. If you wait until the hearing without understanding the specific issue, you may not bring the right evidence.
0 coins
Ethan Scott
•Thank you! This makes sense now. My company called it a "voluntary separation program" even though it was basically take the package or be fired later. Maybe that's where the confusion is. I'll try to get through to ESD.
0 coins
Riya Sharma
same thingg happened to my brother last month! the 'voluntary quit' code but he was defintley laid off. so stupid! he got it fixed at the hearing but took like 2 months to get the money ugh
0 coins
Santiago Diaz
I successfully appealed a similar denial last year. Here's what worked for me: 1. Upload all documentation proving your layoff to your ESD account (termination letter, emails about downsizing, etc) 2. Try calling ESD every day at 7:59am right when they open - this is crucial 3. If you can't get through, use Claimyr (claimyr.com) - it helped me get through after weeks of failing. They have a video showing how it works: https://youtu.be/7DieNd3C7zQ?si=26TzE_zGms-DODN3 4. When you reach an agent, specifically ask for a "redetermination based on new information" - use those exact words 5. Get the agent's ID number and note the date/time of call In my case, they fixed it before the hearing once I got someone to actually look at my documentation. Calling is definitely worth it if you can actually reach someone.
0 coins
Ethan Scott
•This is super helpful, thank you! I do have the layoff documents and emails. I'll try the early morning calls but if that doesn't work I might try that Claimyr service - never heard of it before but sounds worth it if it actually gets you through.
0 coins
Millie Long
•I tried Claimyr when I was disqualified last month and it actually worked. Got through in like 20 minutes after trying for days on my own. Just FYI it doesn't guarantee they'll fix your issue but at least you can talk to someone.
0 coins
KaiEsmeralda
wait im confused...if you appealed already dont you just wait for the hearing now? can they even change it once u appealed?
0 coins
Nathaniel Stewart
•Yes, ESD can issue a redetermination even after an appeal has been filed. If they realize there was an error or misunderstanding, they can correct it without going through the whole hearing process. The appeal stays in place until/unless the issue is resolved.
0 coins
Debra Bai
I was in almost the exact same situation in January! My employer called my layoff a "voluntary separation" even though the alternative was being terminated in the next round of cuts. Classic corporate doublespeak. I spent THREE WEEKS trying to call ESD with no luck. When I finally got through (using the Claimyr service someone else mentioned), the agent immediately saw the problem. My employer had checked "voluntary quit" on their response form. The agent initiated a "redetermination" and contacted my employer for clarification. Took about 10 days, but they reversed the decision without me needing a hearing. Don't wait for the hearing if possible - that's 4-6 more weeks without benefits. Try getting through to clarify this first. The voluntary quit misclassification happens ALL THE TIME with corporate downsizing packages.
0 coins
Ethan Scott
•This is EXACTLY my situation. They offered a "voluntary separation package" but made it very clear they'd be doing layoffs next if not enough people took it. I didn't consider that would cause problems with unemployment. I'll definitely try to reach ESD and get this fixed. Thanks for explaining!
0 coins
Gabriel Freeman
This happened to me too but after the hearing i still lost because i signed something saying it was voluntary even though everyone knew it was really a layoff. Make sure u didn't sign anything like that!! bring ALL your paperwork!!
0 coins
Ethan Scott
•Oh no, I did sign a voluntary separation agreement. But it was clearly part of a downsizing and they told us it was either take the package or risk being laid off with nothing. Would text messages from my manager help prove this?
0 coins
Santiago Diaz
•ABSOLUTELY save those text messages! Any documentation showing you were effectively forced to take the "voluntary" package is critical evidence. Print them out with timestamps visible and bring them to your hearing if it gets to that point. Those messages could make all the difference.
0 coins
Millie Long
Just another thought - check if ur employer contested ur claim. Log into ur ESD account and look for any employer protests or responses. Sometimes they'll show what the employer said. That might tell u why u were denied without having to call.
0 coins
Ethan Scott
•Great idea! I just checked and there's nothing visible in my online account. Just the determination letter with the RCW code but no details about what my employer said.
0 coins
Nathaniel Stewart
Based on everything in this thread, you're dealing with a common issue where "voluntary separation packages" during downsizing get misclassified as voluntary quits. You have two parallel paths to pursue: 1. Continue with your appeal/hearing process. Start gathering ALL documentation: - The voluntary separation offer - Any communications indicating the alternative was potential layoff - Those text messages from your manager (crucial evidence) - Timeline of events leading to your separation - Witness contacts who can verify the nature of the downsizing 2. Simultaneously try reaching ESD for a redetermination: - Try the early morning calls - Consider the Claimyr service others mentioned if necessary - Specifically request a "redetermination based on new information" - Explain that this was effectively a layoff despite the terminology Don't give up on either path until one succeeds. Many people successfully overturn these denials when they can prove the voluntary separation was effectively a layoff in disguise.
0 coins
Ethan Scott
•Thank you so much for laying this out so clearly. I'm gathering all my documentation now and will start calling tomorrow morning. If I can't get through after a few days I'll try that service. I'll update here if I get it resolved!
0 coins