ESD appeal hearing Tuesday - how to prepare for unemployment hearing?

I went through an appeal hearing last month. It was over the phone with an Administrative Law Judge. Make sure you have ALL your paystubs, W2s, and any communication with your employer about your hours. Write down key dates and hours worked so you don't get flustered. The judge will ask you questions first, then ESD might have a representative ask questions too. Be super clear about your work history and why you believe your employer reported incorrect information. Speak slowly and clearly. You don't need a lawyer, but you definitely need to be organized with your facts. Good luck!

OMG i had my hearing and i was SO nervous but it was actually pretty chill. just be honest u don't need a fancy lawyer or anything. make sure ur phone is charged lol mine almost died halfway thru 😂

Here's what you need to do to prepare for your OAH hearing: 1. Gather all evidence showing your correct work hours (pay stubs, time cards, emails from supervisors, bank deposits) 2. Submit these documents to OAH before the hearing (there should be instructions in your hearing notice) 3. Write a timeline of your employment with specific dates and hours 4. Prepare a brief statement explaining why you believe ESD's decision was incorrect 5. Be ready 15 minutes before the scheduled time 6. Take notes during the hearing The hearing will most likely be by phone. You'll be sworn in, and the judge will explain the process. Be respectful, don't interrupt, and stick to facts rather than emotions. I've been through three of these hearings (won two). The key is organization and staying calm.

Yes, exhibits are your supporting documents. There should be instructions in your hearing notice about how to submit them - usually by fax or through their online portal. Make sure to do this ASAP as there's typically a deadline for submission before the hearing. Also make sure to have copies of EVERYTHING during the actual hearing so you can reference them when needed. Number your pages so you can say "looking at exhibit 3, page 2" etc.

I think your also allowed to have witnesses if someone can back up your claim about hours. Like maybe a coworker who knows you were there?? Just a thought.

Look, I hate to be that person, but ESD appeal hearings are EXTREMELY formal and by-the-book. I lost my appeal because I wasn't prepared enough. One thing no one mentioned: when you get on the call, write down the judge's name. Address them as "Judge [Last Name]" not just "sir" or "ma'am". BE EARLY for the call. If you're even 5 minutes late, they can dismiss your case. Also, don't ramble or go off-topic. These judges hear dozens of cases a day and get annoyed if you waste time. Stick to FACTS ONLY.

I tried calling ESD like 50 times to get clarification before my hearing and could never get through. The waiting time was insane and I kept getting disconnected. Super frustrating when you're trying to prepare properly.

my cosin had a appeal and they made him fax all his stuff but then at the hearing they said they never got it but he had the fax confirmation so the judge postponed it which was actually good because he had more time to prepare just saying keep copies of EVERYTHING

Whatever you do, DON'T LOSE YOUR COOL during the hearing!!! I got frustrated when ESD kept interrupting me and started arguing, and the judge basically shut me down after that. Even if they say things that aren't true, stay calm and wait your turn to respond. It's REALLY hard but so important.

btw if u win do they pay u all the back benefits right away? i'm curious about this too