Social Security Administration
CommunityGovernment Services


Ask the community...
I'm planning to retire and start taking SS benefits in December 2025 (turning 63 in November). I know it's before my FRA and there's that $22,340 earnings limit for 2025. My question is: do they count what I've already earned January-November BEFORE I start collecting? I'll have made around $58,000 by then from my full-time job, so if they count the whole year's income, I'll be way over the limit right from the start. Does the earnings test only apply to months AFTER I begin collecting benefits? I'm really hoping they don't look at my pre-retirement income in 2025 because otherwise my benefits would be reduced significantly. Anyone deal with this situation before?
I'm currently collecting survivor benefits since I took them early at 62 (after my husband passed 3 years ago). The amount is significantly higher than what my own retirement would have been at full retirement age. My FRA is 66 and 8 months, which I'll reach on October 5th this year. Here's my dilemma - I just got offered a really good part-time position at my friend's small business. Do I have to wait until I hit my FRA in October before I can accept this job? I'm worried about the earnings limit and if I'll get penalized for working before reaching my FRA. The extra income would really help with medical bills I wasn't expecting this year. Anyone dealt with this situation before?
When my sister turned 66 (her FRA) she got a job and her benefit check went UP the next year! Something about recalculation of her benefits because she was working again. So working might actually help your benefit amount in the long run too!
That's correct. If you work after beginning benefits and your earnings are higher than one of your previous 35 highest earning years (which are used to calculate your benefit), SSA will automatically recalculate your benefit amount the following year. However, this applies to retirement benefits based on your own record, not necessarily survivor benefits.
I think what matters most is how much this job is gonna pay you. If it's just a few hours a week maybe you don't even hit the limit? My cousin works at Walmart just 15 hours a week and stays under just fine.
I'm trying to make a smart decision about my Social Security timing. I'm currently 63 and working a decent-paying consulting job that I plan to keep for about 2 more years. From what I understand, if I claim SS benefits now, I'd lose $1 for every $2 I earn above $22,320 (2025 limit?), which would basically wipe out a big chunk of my benefits. My husband thinks I should just wait until 65 to apply since I'm still earning good money. But I keep seeing these articles about claiming strategies and I'm second-guessing everything. Is waiting the obvious choice here or am I missing some angle that would make filing at 63 worthwhile despite the earnings test? Would appreciate any insights from folks who've navigated this decision!
i filed at 62 while working part time and regret it so much!!! they take back so much of my check some months i barely get anything. plus when i do fully retire my benefit is permanently lower. wish i had just waited.
If it's been less than 12 months since you first filed, you might be able to withdraw your application! It's called a Form SSA-521. You have to pay back all the benefits you've received, but then it's like you never applied at all and your benefit can grow again. Worth looking into if you're really regretting your decision! But if it's been over 12 months, unfortunately you're locked in.
Based on what you've shared, waiting until your consulting work ends makes the most financial sense. One additional factor to consider: tax implications. When you're working and also receiving Social Security benefits, up to 85% of your SS benefits may become taxable depending on your combined income. This is separate from the earnings test and is another reason many working people delay benefits. If you both have solid earnings records, a common strategy for married couples in good health is for the higher earner to delay until 70 (maximizing the eventual survivor benefit) while the lower earner claims at FRA. This provides some income flow while still optimizing your household's lifetime benefits.
I hadn't even thought about the tax angle! That's a really good point. And yes, my husband's benefit will be about 30% higher than mine based on our earnings histories. I'll definitely look more into the strategy you suggested about me claiming at FRA and him waiting until 70. Thank you for this detailed insight!
I'm so frustrated with Social Security right now! I'm 67 (past my FRA but not 70 yet) and I've been caught in an administrative mess for months. Originally claimed my retirement benefits last summer, but then found out I could get higher survivor benefits from my late husband's record. So I requested to withdraw my retirement application and repay the benefits I'd received (about $14,500 for 4 months of payments). Here's where the nightmare begins: I sent SSA a check to repay in August. After 3 months of them not cashing it, I called and the rep told me to stop payment on that check and bring a new one to the local office. So I did exactly that in November - delivered a new check in person to make sure it was processed. That check cleared my bank account within days. But now, 3 months later, SSA is STILL saying I owe the exact same amount! My survivor benefit application is completely stalled because they claim I haven't repaid the retirement benefits. I've brought bank statements showing the cleared check to my local office, even got an official letter from my bank confirming the check was cashed by the Treasury. The SSA office basically shrugged and said "our system shows you still owe." To make things more confusing, I received a 1099 from SSA showing I had repaid the benefits, but when I mentioned this, the local office said "that's not really accurate" whatever that means! I've made 3 in-person visits and countless phone calls. I need those survivor benefits to start. Has anyone successfully resolved this kind of administrative mess with SSA? What else can I try?
i think they sometimes do this on purpose to save money. my neighbor had something similar and they kept "losing" his paperwork for like 6 months!! he had to get really mad and threaten to call his congressman before they finally fixed it. the whole system is rigged to make it hard for us seniors!!
EXACTLY!!! SS is trying to save money by making things so complicated that people give up! My moms friend waited 9 MONTHS for them to fix a payment issue. Its not an accident that there system is so broken!!!
Having worked at SSA for many years, I can assure you this isn't an intentional delay tactic. The reality is that SSA's computer systems were built in the 1980s and have been patched together with updates over decades. Different parts of the system don't communicate well with each other. Withdrawal cases are particularly complicated because they touch multiple systems - benefits, earnings records, treasury payments, and tax reporting. It's a genuine technical limitation, not a conspiracy to deny benefits. The agency is actually working on a massive systems overhaul, but it will take years to complete.
Update: I just got back from another office visit after using all the specific terminology suggested here. What a difference! I asked for a Technical Expert specifically and mentioned "Critical Payment Correction" and "Administrative Action Review." The TE actually found that my payment HAD been recorded but in a different part of their system than what shows on my online account. They're initiating a correction process that she said should take about 2 weeks to sync up their records. In the meantime, they're starting my survivor benefits provisionally! Thank you all SO MUCH for your help with this - I would never have known what to ask for without your suggestions.
That's fantastic news! I'm so glad you were able to get this resolved. This is exactly why it's important to use the correct terminology - it helps cut through layers of confusion. The provisional benefits are especially good news since that means you won't have to wait for the full administrative correction to be completed before receiving income. Be sure to keep documentation of everything, including the name of the Technical Expert who helped you, just in case there are any future questions about this situation.
I'm getting really anxious about all this talk of Social Security running out of money. I keep hearing rumors that Congress might slash benefits for future retirees but possibly 'grandfather in' people already receiving payments. I'm 63 and eligible for reduced retirement benefits, but was planning to wait until my FRA at 67. My situation is a bit complicated - I did receive survivor benefits as a surviving divorced spouse for about 4 years after my ex passed away in 2018, but I stopped those payments when I got a decent job in 2022. I'm wondering if being previously 'in the system' for survivor benefits would protect my future retirement benefits if cuts happen? Does anyone know if I should just apply for retirement benefits NOW at a reduced rate to make sure I'm 'grandfathered in' before any potential cuts? Or am I already protected because I previously received survivor benefits? My financial advisor says wait until 67, but with all this uncertainty, my anxiety is through the roof. What would you do?
what about that thing where if u worked for the government ur ss gets cut? my friend had that happen, windfall something?
That's the Windfall Elimination Provision (WEP) and Government Pension Offset (GPO). These have been part of Social Security law since the 1980s and only affect people who receive pensions from jobs where they didn't pay Social Security taxes. It's not a recent cut and doesn't apply to the vast majority of workers who paid into Social Security throughout their careers.
I really appreciate everyone's input. I think I'm going to take a breath and not make a hasty decision based on fear. The 25% permanent reduction would be a big hit to take just to avoid a theoretical future cut that might not even happen, especially since it sounds like near-retirees like me would likely be protected anyway. Still anxious about it, but at least I understand the situation better now. I'll talk to my financial planner again with this new perspective.
That's a wise approach. One additional point to consider: if you're still working, there's also an earnings limit until you reach full retirement age. In 2025, you'll lose $1 in benefits for every $2 you earn above $22,750 (approximately). So if you're still earning decent income, that's another reason waiting might make financial sense in your situation.
Ezra Bates
Wait isn't the earnings limit going up for 2025? I thought I saw somewhere it was going to be more than $22,340?
0 coins
Brooklyn Foley
You're right to question this. The 2025 limit hasn't been officially announced yet. The $22,340 figure is likely an estimate based on previous COLA increases. The actual 2025 limit will be announced in October 2024, and it will probably be a bit higher depending on the COLA for 2025. For planning purposes though, the $22,340 estimate is reasonable.
0 coins
Keith Davidson
dont forget they also look at how many months before u reach FRA... the earnings limit is different in the year u reach full retirement age too
0 coins
Avery Saint
AuthorGood point. I won't reach my FRA until 2029, so I'll have the lower earnings limit for several years. I'll need to be careful about any part-time work I might do after officially retiring.
0 coins