

Ask the community...
This thread has been incredibly helpful! I'm in a similar situation with my 84-year-old father and was also worried about Social Security impacts. After reading everyone's experiences, I feel much more confident that my retirement benefits will be safe since they're based on work history, not assets. I wanted to share one additional tip that helped us - when we set up the "convenience only" joint account that others mentioned, the bank also suggested adding email and text alerts for all transactions over a certain amount (we chose $100). This way both my dad and I get notified immediately if there's any unusual activity, which has been great for fraud protection and also helps him feel like he's still aware of what's happening with his money even when I'm helping manage things. Also, for anyone considering the POA route, I found that getting multiple certified copies of the POA document upfront saved time later - different banks, insurance companies, and service providers all wanted their own copy on file. Thanks to everyone who shared their experiences - it's so reassuring to know we're not alone in navigating these decisions!
That's such a smart idea about setting up the transaction alerts! I hadn't thought about doing that but it makes perfect sense - it gives you both oversight for fraud protection while helping your dad maintain some sense of control and awareness of his finances. That balance between helping and preserving independence seems really important. And thanks for the tip about getting multiple certified copies of POA documents - I can definitely see how that would save a lot of time and hassle later when you need to provide copies to different institutions. These practical tips from people who've actually been through the process are so valuable!
This has been such an enlightening discussion! I'm in a very similar situation with my 79-year-old mother and was losing sleep over whether helping her with finances might somehow impact my Social Security benefits when I retire in a few years. Reading through everyone's experiences has been incredibly reassuring - it's clear that retirement benefits are calculated based on your work record, not your current assets or account access. I'm definitely going to explore the "convenience only" joint account option that so many people recommended. I had no idea banks offered different types of joint account arrangements! The transaction alerts suggestion is brilliant too - that seems like a great way to maintain oversight while helping Mom feel like she's still in control. One question for the group: has anyone dealt with a situation where the elderly parent was initially resistant to getting help with finances? My mom is very independent and I'm worried about how to bring this up without making her feel like I think she can't handle things anymore. Any advice on having that initial conversation would be really appreciated! Thanks to everyone who shared their stories - you've turned what felt like an impossible decision into a manageable plan with clear options to consider.
Just wanted to add one more thing that might help with your decision - you mentioned being 62 and planning to take benefits early. Have you considered whether you'll still be working? If you're planning to work while collecting Social Security before your full retirement age, you could hit the earnings test limit ($22,320 for 2024). If you earn more than that, they'll reduce your benefits by $1 for every $2 you earn over the limit. This applies to both your own retirement benefits AND any divorced spousal benefits you might receive. The earnings test goes away once you reach full retirement age, but it's something to factor into your timing decision. Also, when you do call SSA, ask them to run scenarios showing your benefit amounts at different claiming ages (62, full retirement age, and 70) so you can see the long-term impact of claiming early versus waiting. Sometimes seeing the actual dollar differences over your lifetime can help with the decision.
Thanks for bringing up the earnings test! I hadn't fully considered that aspect. I was planning to work part-time for a few more years, probably earning around $15,000-18,000 annually, so it sounds like I'd be under the limit. But it's good to know this applies to both my retirement benefit AND any spousal top-up I might get. The idea of asking SSA to run scenarios at different claiming ages is really smart. I've been so focused on just getting something at 62 that I haven't actually calculated what waiting until my full retirement age (66 and 4 months) would mean in total dollars over my lifetime. Given that my ex's benefit is so much higher, maybe the survivor benefit calculation changes things enough that waiting could be worth it. Do you know if the earnings test also applies to survivor benefits when that time comes?
Great question about survivor benefits and the earnings test! Yes, the earnings test does apply to survivor benefits if you're under full retirement age when you start collecting them. The same limits apply - for 2024 it's $22,320, and they reduce benefits by $1 for every $2 over that limit. However, here's something important to consider: survivor benefits have more flexible timing rules than retirement benefits. You can claim survivor benefits as early as age 60 (or 50 if disabled), but you might want to coordinate the timing strategically. Some people take their own reduced retirement benefit early, then switch to survivor benefits later, or vice versa depending on which strategy maximizes their lifetime benefits. Since your ex's benefit is significantly higher than yours, it might make sense to delay your own retirement benefit (letting it grow with delayed retirement credits) and potentially claim survivor benefits first when the time comes, if that occurs before you reach age 70. But this gets pretty complex and really depends on the specific timing and amounts involved. Definitely ask SSA to model different scenarios including survivor benefit timing when you call!
I'm in a somewhat similar situation and found this thread really helpful! One thing I wanted to add is that you might want to double-check whether your ex-husband has already filed for benefits. If he has, you can apply for divorced spousal benefits immediately. But if he hasn't filed yet, you'll need to have been divorced for at least 2 years (which you definitely have been since 2001). Also, I learned the hard way that SSA doesn't always volunteer information about all the benefits you might be eligible for. When you call, specifically ask about "divorced spousal benefits" and "divorced survivor benefits" - don't just ask about "ex-spouse benefits" generally. The terminology matters and can help ensure you get complete information. One more tip: if you do decide to take your benefits at 62, make sure to ask SSA to put a note in your file about your interest in future divorced spousal and survivor benefits. This can help streamline the process when you're ready to apply for those additional benefits later.
This is such valuable advice! I never would have thought about the specific terminology mattering when talking to SSA, but that makes total sense. I'll definitely ask specifically about "divorced spousal benefits" and "divorced survivor benefits" when I call. The tip about putting a note in my file is brilliant too - I can imagine how much easier it would be to apply later if there's already documentation of my interest and eligibility. Since you mentioned you're in a similar situation, did you end up finding out whether your ex had already filed? I'm curious how that process works - do they tell you right away when you apply, or is there some way to find out beforehand? Also, did you decide to take your benefits early or wait? I keep going back and forth on this decision, especially after reading about all the complexities with the RIB-LIM rule and how early claiming affects survivor benefits down the road.
Welcome to everyone joining the community! As another newcomer who literally just created an account after experiencing this exact same panic, I'm amazed at how this thread has become a gathering place for people all going through identical SSA earnings record anxiety! I've been working steadily all of 2024 but when I checked my Social Security account yesterday and saw nothing but zeros, I immediately thought my employer had made some catastrophic error in reporting my wages. The relief of finding this discussion and learning that this is completely normal - even predictable - has been enormous. What really gets me is how this seems to be a universal American experience that happens like clockwork every spring, yet there's absolutely no preparation or communication from SSA about it. In an era where I can track my Amazon package in real-time and get instant notifications about my bank balance, discovering that a major government system operates on 4-6 month delays using batch processing feels surreal. The explanations about W-2 processing timelines and Annual Wage Reporting have been incredibly educational. I'm definitely joining the reformed "obsessive account checker" club and setting a reminder to look again in late summer instead of daily panic-checking. This community has provided more practical, understandable information in one thread than I could find anywhere on official government websites. Thank you to everyone for sharing your experiences and helping newcomers navigate this confusing but apparently completely normal bureaucratic process!
Welcome to the community! I'm also brand new here and just went through this exact same rollercoaster of emotions - that moment when you see zeros and your heart drops thinking your entire work history has somehow vanished! It's both comforting and absurd to discover that this mass panic happens every single year like some kind of twisted seasonal tradition. Your point about the contrast between real-time package tracking and SSA's ancient batch processing really hits home. It's wild that in 2024 we can get instant updates on practically everything else, but when it comes to something as important as our retirement earnings, we're still dealing with systems that feel like they're running on 1980s technology! I'm also joining the "reformed obsessive checker" support group and setting that August calendar reminder. This thread has been like finding an oasis of real information in a desert of confusing government websites. It's amazing how much more helpful community knowledge is compared to official bureaucratic resources. Thanks for sharing your experience - knowing we're all navigating this outdated system together makes it so much less stressful!
As a newcomer to this community, I just wanted to add my voice to what's clearly become a massive support thread for people experiencing SSA earnings record anxiety! I discovered this discussion after checking my account this morning and seeing the dreaded zeros for 2024 - that immediate gut-punch feeling that something must be terribly wrong. Reading through everyone's experiences has been incredibly reassuring. It's both hilarious and frustrating to learn that this panic happens to thousands of people every spring like some kind of predictable government-induced stress test! The fact that SSA apparently does nothing to warn people about these processing delays is honestly baffling in 2024. The technical explanations about W-2 batch processing and the 4-6 month timeline have been so helpful. As someone who's used to instant everything - from banking updates to delivery tracking - learning that a major government system still operates like it's the 1980s has been a real eye-opener. I'm definitely adopting the community wisdom of stopping my obsessive account checking and setting a reminder for August instead. This thread has provided more practical, understandable information than hours of trying to navigate official SSA resources. Thank you to everyone for sharing their knowledge and helping newcomers like me realize this is just an unfortunate but normal part of dealing with government bureaucracy!
I'm so sorry you're facing this situation - it's truly shocking that someone could remove you from payroll without your knowledge after decades of work. One avenue that hasn't been mentioned yet is checking with your state's Workers' Compensation board or Unemployment Insurance office. These agencies sometimes maintain employment records that are separate from what SSA has, and they might show you as an employee during those missing years. Also, if your family business had any contracts, licenses, or permits during that time period, try to get copies. Sometimes these documents list all the people authorized to act on behalf of the business, which could help establish your role. For the SSA interview, I'd suggest asking specifically about the "good cause" exceptions to the normal time limits for correcting earnings records. Given that your removal from payroll was done without your knowledge, this could potentially qualify as fraud or manifest injustice. One more thought - if you had any business insurance policies (liability, property, etc.) during those years, the applications often list all the business owners or key employees. Insurance companies keep records for a long time, so it might be worth checking with your old insurance agent. Don't lose hope. Even if it's an uphill battle, the potential impact on your retirement security makes it worth fighting for every possible avenue.
These are excellent suggestions about checking with Workers' Comp and Unemployment Insurance offices! I never would have thought of those agencies having separate employment records. The insurance angle is really smart too - we definitely had business liability insurance, and I remember having to sign paperwork for it multiple times over the years. If those applications show me as a business owner or key employee, that could be huge for establishing my role during the missing years. I'm going to add all of these to my list of things to research before my SSA call. It's overwhelming but also encouraging to know there might be multiple paper trails out there that I haven't thought of yet. Thank you for taking the time to think through all these possibilities - it means so much to have people who understand how important this is for my future.
I'm heartbroken reading your story - this is such an unconscionable betrayal by someone who was supposed to protect your interests. The fact that you discovered this so close to retirement makes it even more devastating. One thing that might help your case is requesting your complete SSA file through a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request. Sometimes there are internal notes or correspondence that could shed light on when/how your earnings record was modified. You can file this online at ssa.gov. Also, have you considered checking with your local Small Business Administration (SBA) office? If your family business ever applied for any SBA loans or programs, those applications often require detailed information about all business owners and key employees. The SBA keeps extensive records that could help establish your role in the company. Another avenue: if you filed any business tax returns jointly (Form 1065 partnerships or 1120S S-corp returns), the IRS should have copies going back many years. These returns often show profit/loss distributions to partners or shareholders, which could help prove your ownership stake even if payroll records are missing. The "fraud or manifest injustice" exception that others mentioned is real - the key is building a compelling case with whatever documentation you can gather. Your ex's deliberate removal of you from payroll without your knowledge during a marriage could absolutely qualify as fraud. Don't let anyone tell you this is hopeless. Thirty years of work deserves to be recognized in your Social Security record.
Connor Gallagher
As a newcomer to this community, I'm really grateful to see such detailed and helpful responses to this question! I'm in a similar situation where I'm trying to understand Social Security benefits for my family's financial planning. Reading through all these responses has been incredibly educational - I had no idea about the difference between PIA and actual benefit amounts, or that delayed retirement credits don't affect spousal benefits. The tip about looking for the "Benefit Verification Letter" in the my Social Security account seems like the easiest starting point, and I appreciate everyone sharing their experiences with calling SSA and visiting offices in person. One question I have after reading all this: if someone's spouse has their own Social Security work record AND qualifies for spousal benefits, does SSA automatically calculate both and pay the higher amount? Or do you have to specifically request that they compare the two options? Thank you to everyone who shared their knowledge and experiences - this kind of community support makes navigating these complex systems so much easier for those of us just starting to figure it all out!
0 coins
Daniel Price
•Welcome to the community! Great question about how SSA handles the comparison between own benefits and spousal benefits. From what I understand, SSA does automatically calculate both and pay whichever is higher - you don't need to specifically request the comparison. When your spouse applies for benefits, they'll look at both her own work record and her spousal benefit eligibility, then pay the higher amount. However, it's still really valuable to know both numbers ahead of time for your own planning purposes. You can ask SSA to provide both calculations when you call or visit, which helps you understand all your options and make informed decisions about timing. This thread has been such a goldmine of practical advice - I'm bookmarking it for my own future reference!
0 coins
ShadowHunter
As someone new to this community and Social Security planning, I'm amazed by how helpful everyone has been in this thread! I'm facing a similar situation with my own retirement planning and had no idea about the complexity around PIA vs. actual benefit amounts. After reading through all these detailed responses, I wanted to share that I just tried the suggestion about checking the "Benefit Verification Letter" in my Social Security account, and it worked perfectly! For anyone else struggling with this, here's exactly where I found it: Log into your my Social Security account → Go to "Replacement Documents" section → Click "View Benefit Verification Letter" → The PIA (Primary Insurance Amount) is clearly listed there. This saved me from having to call or visit an office, though it sounds like both of those options work well too based on everyone's experiences. The key insight that delayed retirement credits don't affect spousal benefits was huge for my planning - I had that completely wrong! Thanks to everyone who took the time to explain this so thoroughly. This community is such a valuable resource for navigating these complicated systems!
0 coins