Back to New York Unemployment

Connor Murphy

Who is exempt from unemployment tax in NY? NYSDOL breakdown

So I've been going down a rabbit hole trying to figure out who is exempt from unemployment tax because my employer just told me they don't pay into it for my position and that's why I supposedly can't file a UI claim. I work part-time for a small nonprofit doing administrative work and they're claiming I'm exempt. I honestly don't know if they're right or just trying to dodge paying into the system. I've been at this job about 14 months, work around 22 hours a week, and they let me go last week saying it was a budget cut. Now I'm stuck wondering if I even have any options here or if I'm just out of luck. Has anyone actually dealt with this situation where your employer claims they're not required to pay unemployment tax for your work?

Wait, is this a religious nonprofit or just a regular 501c3? Because those are treated really differently when it comes to unemployment tax obligations in New York.

0 coins

It's a regular 501c3, not a church or anything like that. They do housing advocacy work. Why does that distinction matter so much?

0 coins

So 501c3 nonprofits in NY actually do have to cover unemployment for their workers, but they get to pick how they do it — either pay into the state fund like normal employers do, or they can be what's called a reimbursable employer and pay dollar-for-dollar when claims are paid out. Either way, their workers can usually still file. The employer is probably confused about their own setup, honestly.

0 coins

Okay before anything else — I went through almost the exact same runaround last spring when my former employer said something similar. I tried phoning NYSDOL for like two weeks straight and kept hitting busy signals or getting cut off after 45 minutes on hold. Someone in another forum mentioned Claimyr (claimyr.com) — it waits on hold with NYSDOL so you end up speaking directly with a live agent. There's also a demo at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE if you want to see how it works. I finally got an actual NYSDOL rep on the line who told me my employer HAD been paying in and I was eligible the whole time. Filed and got approved within two weeks after that conversation.

0 coins

Two weeks of busy signals sounds like exactly where I'm headed. Did the agent you spoke with actually look up whether your employer was registered and paying in?

0 coins

Yeah, the agent pulled up the employer account right there on the call. They could see the tax contribution history. That's really the only way to know for sure — NYSDOL has records on every registered employer in the state.

0 coins

Honestly this is the move. I spent three days trying to reach anyone at NYSDOL about an adjudication issue and got nowhere. Some of these things you genuinely cannot resolve without talking to a person.

0 coins

Here's what I'd do first if I were you — file the claim anyway and let NYSDOL sort out the employer's tax status. The reason I say that is because your employer telling you they don't pay in doesn't actually stop you from filing. NYSDOL will investigate the employer's account as part of processing your claim, and if the employer hasn't been paying when they should have been, that becomes their problem, not yours.

0 coins

They haven't been paying when they should have been — could that mean I'm still protected somehow even if they owe back taxes?

0 coins

New York actually does have provisions where workers aren't penalized for an employer's failure to contribute properly. You'd still be entitled to benefits if the employer was legally required to pay in. It gets complicated, but that's exactly why talking to NYSDOL directly matters here — they can tell you exactly where your employer stands.

0 coins

Agreed, file first and ask questions second. I did the opposite once and lost weeks of potential benefit time while I tried to research everything myself. Also — if you have trouble getting through on the phone, Claimyr worked well for me when I needed to actually speak with someone about a complicated employer situation like this.

0 coins

My understanding is that the main categories exempt from unemployment tax in NY are sole proprietors paying themselves, certain agricultural workers under specific conditions, some domestic workers depending on how much the household pays them annually, and corporate officers in some very small S-corps. A nonprofit doing housing advocacy with 22-hour-a-week admin staff doesn't fit any of those buckets as far as I can tell.

0 coins

Corporate officers thing is interesting — could they be claiming I'm somehow an officer even though I'm just an admin assistant?

0 coins

Technically possible but it would be a stretch. Officers who are exempt are typically actual shareholders or principals of the company, people with real ownership stakes. An administrative assistant position wouldn't normally qualify for that classification. If they're trying to call you an officer to avoid the tax, that's something NYSDOL auditors actually look at.

0 coins

This is a really good breakdown. I went through something similar at a small LLC and they were calling me an 'independent contractor' when I was clearly an employee by every measure. NYSDOL sided with me after reviewing the working relationship.

0 coins

Okay wait — is this thread about whether the EMPLOYER is exempt from paying unemployment tax, or whether the WORKER is exempt from some kind of deduction? Because I'm seeing people use this term two different ways and it's confusing me too.

0 coins

Unemployment tax in NY is entirely on the employer side — workers don't pay into it at all from their paychecks. So when people say 'exempt from unemployment tax' they always mean the employer's obligation to pay FUTA and SUTA contributions, not any worker deduction.

0 coins

Oh okay that actually makes the original post make a lot more sense now. So the employer is claiming THEY are exempt from contributing, which then flows downstream to affect whether the worker can claim benefits. Got it.

0 coins

Exactly, yes. My employer is saying THEY don't have to pay in, so therefore I can't collect. That's the core of what I'm trying to untangle.

0 coins

NONPROFIT DOESN'T MEAN EXEMPT!! I cannot stress this enough. I worked HR for a nonprofit for six years and the number of small organizations that genuinely believe their 501c3 status gets them out of unemployment obligations is staggering. It does not. What it DOES do is give them an option to self-insure instead of contributing to the state fund. Either way, their employees can still file UI claims.

0 coins

Self-insure — does that mean if I file, they'd have to pay out of pocket instead of NYSDOL covering it?

0 coins

If they chose the reimbursable employer route, yes — they reimburse the state for whatever benefits are paid out to former employees rather than paying quarterly taxes upfront. But from your end as the claimant it works exactly the same. You file, NYSDOL pays you, the employer gets billed on the backend. Your benefits aren't reduced or delayed because of how the employer chose to fund them.

0 coins

This is actually really important information. I always assumed nonprofits were just... exempt. Never realized there's this whole alternative funding structure they can use.

0 coins

Have you checked your pay stubs to see if anything was withheld related to unemployment? Though as someone noted above, NY unemployment tax is employer-side only, so there wouldn't be a line item for it on your stub. But sometimes small nonprofits make payroll errors that show up in weird ways.

0 coins

I looked through several stubs and nothing weird is showing up. Standard federal and state income tax, Social Security, Medicare. Nothing else.

0 coins

That actually lines up with how it's supposed to look. The absence of an unemployment deduction from your check doesn't tell you anything about whether your employer was paying their share — those are completely separate calculations that happen on the employer's end.

0 coins

My situation last year was slightly different but related — I had a gig where the company was paying me as a 1099 contractor but treating me like an employee in every practical way. When I lost that work I tried to file UI and got tangled up in adjudication for months because NYSDOL had to determine my actual worker classification. Eventually got approved but it took a long time and a lot of phone calls.

0 coins

Were you eventually considered an employee for purposes of the claim?

0 coins

Yeah, NYSDOL looked at things like whether I set my own hours, used my own equipment, had multiple clients, etc. I failed basically every independent contractor test so they reclassified me and approved the claim. The employer fought it but NYSDOL has pretty clear standards for this.

0 coins

The ABC test is what NYSDOL generally uses for worker classification. Most people who think they're independent contractors actually don't pass it when you look at the specifics. Good outcome for you though.

0 coins

Filing the claim is free and takes maybe 20 minutes online. The worst that can happen is they determine you're not covered and you're in the same position you're in now. Best case, your employer was wrong or was required to cover you and you get benefits. There's no real downside to filing and finding out.

0 coins

True, I've been overthinking this. I think I'm scared they'll say I'm ineligible and then I'll somehow owe something or get in trouble.

0 coins

Filing in good faith when you believe you may be eligible doesn't create any liability for you. You're not making a fraudulent claim by filing and asking NYSDOL to investigate. The investigation process is exactly what it's there for.

0 coins

I was scared of the same thing my first time filing. The process is actually pretty straightforward once you're in it. File, check your Unemployment Services portal regularly, and respond quickly to anything they send you.

0 coins

I went through weeks of trying to get clarity on an employer coverage question and couldn't get anywhere through the website alone. Eventually used Claimyr to get an agent on the line and they were able to look into the employer's registration status directly in their system — took maybe 15 minutes to get real answers after weeks of going in circles. For something like what you're describing, you really need a live person who can actually access the employer records.

0 coins

How specific were the answers you got? Like did they actually confirm or deny whether the employer had been paying contributions?

0 coins

Very specific — the agent told me the exact registration status of the employer, whether they had any outstanding issues, and what my options were given that information. It wasn't vague at all. That's the kind of answer you can only get from someone with system access.

0 coins

This is the thing people don't realize — the NYSDOL website is useful for some stuff but it cannot answer employer-specific tax registration questions for you. That information is only accessible to reps with backend system access.

0 coins

What industry does this nonprofit work in? Housing advocacy you said — are there any government grants involved? Sometimes organizations that receive certain federal funding have different obligations and I'm wondering if that's where the confusion is coming from on their end.

0 coins

They do receive some HUD funding for certain programs. I genuinely have no idea if that changes anything about their unemployment tax status.

0 coins

Federal grant recipients don't get a pass on state unemployment tax obligations from what I understand. If anything federal funding sometimes comes with additional worker protection requirements. But I'm not an expert on this — definitely worth asking NYSDOL directly.

0 coins

HUD funding to a nonprofit doesn't affect NYSDOL unemployment tax requirements either way. Those are two completely separate regulatory tracks. The nonprofit either qualifies for an exemption under New York Labor Law or it doesn't, and federal funding status isn't one of the criteria.

0 coins

Had almost this exact same issue — employer at a small arts nonprofit insisted I wasn't covered. I'd been trying to reach NYSDOL for weeks and kept getting dumped into voicemail or sitting on hold for over an hour before the line went dead. Used Claimyr and ended up talking to an actual NYSDOL agent who explained that my employer had been paying in as a reimbursable employer and I was absolutely eligible. Filed that same afternoon.

0 coins

Reimbursable employer keeps coming up — so if mine is set up that way, the process should work basically the same as a regular employer?

0 coins

From the claimant's side, yes, completely the same process. You file, you certify weekly, you do your three job search activities, you get paid. The reimbursable vs. contributory distinction is entirely an employer accounting matter.

0 coins

The only scenario where it gets messier is if the nonprofit has gone bankrupt or stopped operating — then the reimbursable structure can create complications because there's no employer left to pay the state back. But a functioning organization in a budget-cut situation? Should be totally fine.

0 coins

Have you actually told your employer in writing that you disagree with their assessment and plan to file? Sometimes when employers realize a former employee intends to file, they suddenly remember their obligations. Not always, but it can shake loose useful information at minimum.

0 coins

I haven't done that yet. Would doing that hurt my claim in any way if I do it and then file?

0 coins

No, putting them on notice that you plan to file won't hurt your claim. It's not a confrontational act — it's normal. And sometimes HR people at small nonprofits genuinely don't know their own setup and start doing research when prompted.

0 coins

I'd actually document that communication too. If the employer later tries to argue they told you upfront that you weren't covered and you proceeded anyway knowing that, having a paper trail showing you disputed their position matters.

0 coins

I know this is kind of beside the main question but — have you looked into whether you might qualify under base period wages from any other jobs? Sometimes people have enough wages from multiple employers that they qualify even if one employer's contributions are in question.

0 coins

I haven't had any other jobs during the past 18 months or so. This was my only income source.

0 coins

Okay then it really does hinge on this one employer's status. That's why getting a definitive answer from NYSDOL about whether they've been contributing is so important — everything flows from that one fact.

0 coins

The base period thing is worth understanding anyway for future reference — NYSDOL looks at wages from roughly 12-18 months before your claim date, and if you had any other employment in that window it could count. But yes, if this nonprofit is your only recent employer, their contribution status is the whole ballgame here.

0 coins

Makes sense. And my wages from them should be more than enough to qualify if they were actually paying in — I earned around $28,000 over the past year.

0 coins

$28,000 in wages is more than enough to meet NY's monetary eligibility thresholds — the minimum is pretty low, like a few thousand dollars. So if the employer was paying in, you'd have no problem qualifying on the wage side.

0 coins

That's really the question then — not whether you earned enough, but whether NYSDOL has a record of your employer making contributions on those wages. File and let them figure it out.

0 coins

Did they give you any paperwork when you were let go? Sometimes small nonprofits will give a separation notice or even a letter explaining the reason for termination. That documentation can be really helpful when NYSDOL contacts your former employer to verify the separation reason.

0 coins

They gave me a one-paragraph letter saying my position was eliminated due to budget constraints. That's pretty much it.

0 coins

Budget constraints and position eliminated is actually a good separation reason from your perspective — that's a clear involuntary layoff with no misconduct involved, which is exactly what NYSDOL needs to see. Keep that letter safe and have it ready.

0 coins

Agreed, that letter is gold. Budget-driven elimination is about as clean a separation reason as you can have. No misconduct, no quit, no dispute about why you left. That part of your claim should sail through.

0 coins

My employer also tried to claim I wasn't covered when I filed two years ago. Turned out they had just been paying FUTA (federal) but somehow thought that covered their state obligation too. NYSDOL sorted it out and I got benefits — the employer got hit with back taxes and penalties.

0 coins

So NYSDOL can actually go after the employer retroactively for unpaid contributions?

0 coins

Yes, and they do. If NYSDOL determines your employer was required to pay in and didn't, they assess the back contributions plus penalties and interest. The employer's failure to comply doesn't wipe out your eligibility — it just creates a tax problem for them.

0 coins

NYSDOL takes employer non-compliance pretty seriously, especially after they've had a former employee try to claim and the investigation reveals unpaid contributions. That's a red flag that triggers a full audit of the employer's payroll records.

0 coins

I'm honestly a little surprised your employer said this directly to you. Most of the time employers just respond to the NYSDOL verification request and state their position there — they don't usually preemptively tell departing employees they can't file. Makes me wonder if they're actually trying to discourage you from even trying.

0 coins

That's actually a really interesting point. They did phrase it very much like 'you won't be able to get unemployment' rather than 'here's our tax situation and what it means.

0 coins

Employers can't legally tell you not to file. They can respond to NYSDOL's verification and contest your claim through proper channels, but discouraging someone from filing by misrepresenting their eligibility is a different matter. File regardless.

0 coins

Worth noting to NYSDOL if it comes up — that the employer proactively told you that you couldn't file. The rep handling your claim might find that detail relevant depending on what they find when they look into the employer account.

0 coins

You've gotten really solid information in this thread. At this point the action items seem pretty clear — file the claim, gather your pay stubs and that termination letter, and get an actual NYSDOL agent on the phone who can check the employer's contribution history. I used Claimyr when I was stuck trying to reach anyone at NYSDOL during a complicated employer dispute and it made getting to an agent a lot faster. Whatever route you take, don't let the employer's comments stop you from at least trying.

0 coins

This thread has genuinely been more helpful than anything I found through official channels. I'm going to file today and also try to get a rep on the phone to ask about the employer's status before my claim starts processing if possible.

0 coins

Filing first is the right call. The claim starts the investigation process and you don't lose anything by getting the wheels turning while you also try to reach someone by phone.

0 coins

Good luck — come back and update us. This kind of employer situation is more common than people realize and the resolution is usually in the claimant's favor when the employer was actually obligated to contribute.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure