Back to New York Unemployment

Freya Pedersen

Quit job because of stress can I get unemployment in NY?

My job was making me physically sick — migraines every Sunday night, couldn't sleep, lost about 15 pounds over six months. I was a project coordinator at a mid-size logistics company and the pressure was genuinely unmanageable. My direct supervisor would send emails at 2am expecting responses before 7am, and when I flagged the workload to HR they basically told me to 'manage my time better.' I tried to tough it out but eventually I had to choose between my health and that paycheck. Put in my two weeks and left. Now I'm trying to figure out if I even qualify for unemployment. Everything I read says quitting usually means no benefits, but I've also seen stuff about 'good cause' exceptions. I genuinely don't know if what I went through counts. I never got a formal diagnosis for the stress — I saw my doctor once and she told me to reduce stress but that's as far as it went. No written documentation, no HR complaint on file because I did that verbally. Filed with NYSDOL about ten days ago and my claim is sitting there. No determination letter, no adjudication notice, nothing. Has anyone actually gotten approved after quitting for stress or health reasons? What documentation do you need? I feel like I walked into a brick wall.

My claim went through adjudication after I quit my last job, and what I learned the hard way is that NYSDOL really scrutinizes voluntary separations. The 'good cause' standard they apply is pretty strict — it basically has to be a situation where a reasonable person in your shoes would have felt they had no choice but to leave. Health and working conditions absolutely can qualify, but you have to be able to show you tried to fix the problem first before walking out. The verbal HR complaint hurts you here. NYSDOL wants to see that you gave your employer a chance to address whatever drove you out. A written complaint, an email, even a text exchange — anything that shows you raised the issue formally and they ignored it. If you have any emails where you mentioned the workload or stress, pull those together now.

0 coins

My email history might actually save me here. I did email my supervisor twice about the workload, though I framed it as asking for help prioritizing rather than a formal complaint. Would those count?

0 coins

Those emails matter — bring them. NYSDOL adjudicators look at the full picture, not just what's labeled 'formal complaint.' An email asking for help with workload overload still documents that you raised the issue. The framing might not be perfect but it's evidence you tried to address it before quitting.

0 coins

Agree with this completely. The documentation angle is what makes or breaks these cases. I've seen people get denied with solid reasons and approved with thin ones, and the difference was almost always paperwork trail.

0 coins

Went through almost this exact situation two years ago — quit a job in healthcare administration because of a toxic environment and what I'd describe as a hostile supervisor situation. Filed for UI and hit a wall when NYSDOL opened an adjudication on my claim. Spent three weeks trying to reach someone by phone to understand what they needed from me. The hold times were absolutely brutal, got disconnected twice after waiting over an hour each time. A friend told me about Claimyr (claimyr.com) — it waits on hold with NYSDOL so you don't have to, and you end up on the phone with a live NYSDOL agent without sitting there yourself. There's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. That's how I finally got someone on the line who actually walked me through what documentation my adjudicator needed. Turned out they just wanted a written statement from me detailing the conditions. Submitted it, got approved about two weeks later.

0 coins

Wait so you got approved after quitting? That's what I really needed to hear. How specific did your written statement have to be — like dates and incidents or more of a general overview?

0 coins

My statement included specific dates when the issues occurred, what exactly happened each time, what I did to try to resolve it, and why I ultimately felt I had no other option. The more concrete the better. Vague statements about stress won't move the needle — you want it to read like a timeline.

0 coins

The hold time issue is REAL. My phone died once after 90 minutes on hold and I wanted to throw it out a window. Good to know there are options.

0 coins

Had a similar phone nightmare trying to reach NYSDOL about my adjudication status. After days of getting nowhere, I used Claimyr and finally ended up talking to an actual agent. She told me my claim needed a separation statement from me and I had no idea because nothing showed up in my Unemployment Services account. Without getting someone on the phone I'd probably still be waiting.

0 coins

The Unemployment Services portal really doesn't tell you anything useful when you're in adjudication. 'In progress' is all it ever says.

0 coins

Mine said the same thing for five weeks. Five. Weeks. And then one morning it updated to approved with no explanation of what changed.

0 coins

Five weeks is terrifying to read. Did you get any back pay for the weeks you were waiting during adjudication?

0 coins

Yes — my approved determination covered all the weeks from my original filing date, so I did receive benefits for those weeks once it was resolved. Keep filing your weekly certifications no matter what while you wait.

0 coins

There's a distinction that matters a lot in these voluntary quit cases: quitting versus being constructively discharged. Constructive discharge is when your employer made conditions so unbearable that quitting was essentially forced — that's actually treated differently and can strengthen your position. The pattern you're describing with the 2am emails and the HR brush-off starts to sound like it could be framed that way, depending on how consistent and documented it was.

0 coins

My situation definitely felt like being pushed out rather than choosing to leave. I didn't know that term had any legal weight in unemployment claims. How do I actually use that framing when I submit documentation?

0 coins

Your written statement to NYSDOL is where you spell it out. Focus on the pattern of conduct — frequency, specific incidents, management's failure to respond — rather than just describing how you felt. The feeling is secondary; the documented pattern of conditions is what matters to an adjudicator.

0 coins

This is accurate. I work adjacent to HR and the constructive discharge framing does legitimately come up in NYSDOL cases. It's not a magic word but it orients the adjudicator to look at employer conduct rather than just your decision to leave.

0 coins

ok but everyone i know who quit got denied no matter what they said lol. nysdol doesnt care about your reasons they just check the box that says you quit and move on

0 coins

My denial letter after quitting said exactly that at first — but it also told me I had the right to appeal. Appealed with documentation and had the decision reversed. The initial adjudication isn't always the end of it.

0 coins

The denial rate for voluntary quits is high, that's true. But 'high' isn't 'universal.' Good cause quits do get approved, they just require more documentation and often an appeal. The system isn't set up to make it easy, but it's not a guaranteed dead end.

0 coins

ok fair i didn't actually go through the appeal thing so maybe i'm speaking out of turn there

0 coins

Before you do anything else, make sure you're filing your weekly certifications every single week even though nothing's been decided yet. I made the mistake of thinking I should wait until my claim was approved before certifying, and I ended up losing several weeks of benefits that I couldn't recover because I hadn't certified for them. The system requires you to certify each week to stay eligible for that week's payment.

0 coins

Already doing this — certified for weeks two and three this past Sunday. The job search requirements are weird though, is there an exception when you're in adjudication?

0 coins

You still have to complete your three job search activities per week and log them. Adjudication being open doesn't pause the weekly requirements. If you get approved and your logs show gaps in job searches, those weeks can be denied even if the rest of your claim goes through.

0 coins

Three activities per week is current standard, yes. Worth noting that creating or updating a profile on a job site counts as one activity, not just applications. So if you're hitting walls finding relevant positions some weeks, check what NYSDOL counts as valid activities — it's broader than most people realize.

0 coins

My cousin went through something similar — quit because of a terrible manager, applied for unemployment. She got denied at first but appealed and had a hearing. At the hearing she actually got to talk through everything that happened and the judge overturned the denial. She said the hearing was way less scary than she expected.

0 coins

How long did her appeal process take from filing to hearing?

0 coins

Hers took about eight weeks from when she filed the appeal to when she got the hearing date, then another two weeks for the written decision after that. So roughly ten weeks total. It was a lot of waiting but worth it.

0 coins

Appeals hearings are over the phone, not in person, which makes them way less intimidating. And you can have someone represent you if you want though most people don't for straightforward cases.

0 coins

The doctor visit you mentioned — even without a formal diagnosis, your doctor noting 'reduce stress' in your medical records is actually something. You could request those visit notes and include them. It won't be as strong as a letter that explicitly says the job was harmful, but it corroborates your account that you were experiencing real health effects, not just saying you were stressed.

0 coins

Hadn't thought about the medical records angle. Can I request those visit notes myself or does it have to go through NYSDOL?

0 coins

You request them yourself directly from your doctor's office. HIPAA gives you the right to your own records. Then you include them voluntarily in your documentation package when you submit your statement. NYSDOL doesn't go get them on your behalf.

0 coins

This is a solid point. Even circumstantial medical evidence helps paint a fuller picture for the adjudicator. It shows you weren't just dissatisfied with the job — you were experiencing actual health impacts.

0 coins

Are you sure your situation doesn't count as being fired? Like if they were making conditions terrible on purpose to force you out that's not really quitting, the company was pushing you toward the door. Sometimes HR does that intentionally to avoid having to lay someone off.

0 coins

This is actually the constructive discharge question raised earlier in the thread. If you can show the employer deliberately made conditions intolerable to pressure you to leave, it changes the nature of the separation in NYSDOL's eyes.

0 coins

oh wait i didn't see that part. yeah same thing i was getting at. the 'you chose to leave' framing falls apart when the company engineered the situation.

0 coins

Went through adjudication after a voluntary quit and the thing that helped me most was sending a detailed timeline in writing directly to NYSDOL before they even asked for it. Didn't wait for a request — just mailed a written statement with dates, specifics, and copies of my emails to HR. Got a determination letter about ten days after that saying I was approved. Proactive documentation moves things along.

0 coins

Did you send it to a specific office or is there a general address for adjudication submissions?

0 coins

My determination notice had the specific adjudication unit contact info on it. If you haven't received that yet, your Unemployment Services account under 'claim details' should show a contact for the adjudication. If it doesn't, that's when calling becomes necessary.

0 coins

The mailing address route is slow though. If you can figure out the fax number for the adjudication unit that processes your claim, faxing is faster and you get a confirmation that it arrived.

0 coins

I got denied for a voluntary quit a couple years back and I want to be really honest with this person — please prepare yourself for the possibility that you get denied on the first determination. That's very common. What matters is that you understand an appeal is available and you have 30 days from the determination date to file it. Missing that window is what actually kills the claim for most people, not the initial denial.

0 coins

30 days from the determination date — writing that down right now. How do I even know what date the clock starts from if the letter takes a few days to arrive?

0 coins

The determination letter itself will have an issued date on it, and that's the date NYSDOL uses, not the date you receive it. So don't sit on the letter if you're going to appeal. File as soon as you've read it and decided.

0 coins

This almost cost me my appeal. My letter sat in my mailbox for three days because I didn't check and I nearly burned through most of my window before I even knew there was a determination.

0 coins

Does anyone know if the stress has to be work-related stress specifically or if personal stuff bleeding into work counts? My situation is a bit different from OP's but I'm curious where NYSDOL draws the line.

0 coins

NYSDOL looks at whether the conditions at the workplace itself caused the situation that led to quitting. Personal stress that affects your work performance isn't the same thing as the employer creating or tolerating conditions that caused your health to suffer. The source of the stress matters.

0 coins

that makes sense thanks. in my case it's definitely the job itself not outside stuff so good to know

0 coins

My adjudication dragged on so long that I genuinely couldn't afford to wait anymore. Tried phoning NYSDOL every morning for two weeks and kept getting the high-volume message and getting cut off. Someone in another forum mentioned Claimyr and I figured I had nothing to lose at that point. Used it, wound up speaking with an NYSDOL agent within the same day. She pulled up my claim right there and told me it was sitting waiting for me to submit a form I'd never received notice about. Got that in the same day and my claim resolved about a week later.

0 coins

A form you never got notice about — that is exactly my fear. How common is it that NYSDOL needs something from you but doesn't actually tell you?

0 coins

More common than it should be. The agent I spoke with said notices sometimes go to spam or get lost, and the portal often doesn't flag what's pending on their end. That's why getting a human on the phone matters — they can actually see what's sitting in your file.

0 coins

Two weeks of morning calls before trying something different — I feel that so much. The 8am rush is brutal, everyone figures calling right when they open is the trick but everyone else thought the same thing.

0 coins

The form-you-didn't-know-about situation is incredibly common in adjudication cases. The adjudicator often sends something to your Unemployment Services message inbox rather than mailing it and claimants miss it entirely.

0 coins

Used Claimyr when my voluntary quit claim got stuck and I ended up talking to someone in the adjudication unit directly, not just a general rep. That was a huge difference — she actually knew the status of my specific case rather than reading me generic information.

0 coins

Getting routed to someone who could actually see your case rather than a general line sounds like exactly what I need. My biggest frustration right now is not knowing if there's even anything pending on NYSDOL's end or if they're just slow.

0 coins

That not-knowing is the worst part. At least once you're talking to someone you can get a real status update and know what step you're actually on.

0 coins

The difference between a tier-one rep who reads scripts and someone who can actually pull up your adjudication file is enormous. The first few times I phoned I'd get information that turned out to be totally generic.

0 coins

The job search log is something a lot of people in adjudication overlook — keep it detailed. Record the company name, position title, how you applied, and the date for every activity. NYSDOL can and does audit job search logs, especially in cases where they're already scrutinizing the claim for other reasons like a voluntary quit. A sloppy log gives them another reason to deny a week.

0 coins

My current log is kind of bare bones — company, date, that's about it. Should I go back and fill in more detail on my previous weeks' logs?

0 coins

You can't retroactively change certified weeks, but start doing it thoroughly from this week forward. And honestly, include every activity — a LinkedIn message to a recruiter counts, a job fair counts, a networking call with a former colleague about opportunities counts. Document everything.

0 coins

Using the NYSDOL job search log template they provide is also helpful — it shows you exactly what fields they care about and formats your entries in a way that's already familiar to whoever reviews it.

0 coins

been following this thread because im in almost the exact same boat — quit a retail management job after my store manager started publicly humiliating employees in team meetings, myself included. Filed three weeks ago and sitting in adjudication. Have the determination letters from NYSDOL come in the mail or through the portal?

0 coins

My determination arrived both ways — showed up in my Unemployment Services message inbox first, then the physical letter came in the mail a few days later. Watch the portal inbox more closely, it's faster.

0 coins

ok checking the portal now. nothing yet but at least I know where to look

0 coins

Public humiliation in a workplace setting has actually been cited as a hostile work environment issue in NYSDOL cases. Document every incident you can remember with dates. That kind of conduct pattern is exactly what 'good cause' cases are built on.

0 coins

What about giving notice — does quitting with two weeks notice versus walking out the same day affect your claim differently? OP mentioned giving notice which I think actually works in their favor but I've heard conflicting things.

0 coins

Giving two weeks notice generally helps your case because it shows you weren't just impulsively walking out — you followed proper professional procedure even under difficult circumstances. It supports the argument that you tried to handle the situation responsibly.

0 coins

That's what I figured. I quit without notice from my last job and that definitely came up in my adjudication. Ended up getting approved but had to explain the circumstances in writing.

0 coins

The notice piece shows up in the initial claim interview sometimes too. When you filed, NYSDOL would have asked you about how you separated. If you said you gave two weeks, that's already in your file as a data point in your favor.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure