NY unemployment payment suddenly dropped by $120 and says 'offset' instead of direct deposit - what's going on?
I've been receiving unemployment since October after my tech startup laid off half the company. For the past 4 months, my weekly payment was $504 after taxes. Everything was going smoothly until yesterday when I checked my payment history and noticed my last payment was only $384! And instead of showing 'direct deposit' like usual, it now says 'offset' next to the payment. Nothing changed on my end - I'm still certifying the same way each week, haven't started working, and haven't received any notices or emails from unemployment. I checked my bank account and confirmed I only received the reduced amount. Has anyone dealt with this before? Do I need to call them to figure out what's happening? I'm worried they'll keep reducing my payments for some reason and I really need the full amount to cover rent.
45 comments
Andre Laurent
This happened to me last summer. The 'offset' means they're taking money out to pay a debt you owe. In my case, they started taking $137 out each week because of an overpayment from 2019 I didnt even know about! You need to call them asap to find out what debt they think you have. Could be old taxes, child support, or another government debt.
0 coins
MidnightRider
Crap, I had no idea. I don't have any kids and my taxes are paid. Could it be student loans maybe? I thought those were still paused...
0 coins
28d
Andre Laurent
Could be federal student loans if you defaulted before the pause. Or maybe an old overpayment from a previous UI claim? Literally the only way to know is to call them and ask specifically about the offset.
0 coins
26d
Zoe Papadopoulos
They could also be recouping money if you made a mistake on a previous weekly certification. Happened to me when I accidentally reported the wrong amount of hours one week.
0 coins
25d
MidnightRider
UGH I've been trying to call for 2 days with no luck. Just endless busy signals and disconnects. So frustrating!
0 coins
23d
Write a comment...
Jamal Washington
After 3 months of getting nowhere with NY unemployment, I finally used a service called Claimyr (claimyr.com) and actually got through to a real person! They called repeatedly for me and when an agent finally picked up, they connected the call to my phone. Talking to the agent got my payments fixed that same day. It was the only way I could talk to a live agent after weeks of failed attempts. Here's a video showing how it works: https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE
0 coins
Mei Wong
is this for real? ive been calling them for literally weeks straight and cant get anyone on the line ever š¤¬
0 coins
27d
Jamal Washington
Yes! It works. I was skeptical at first too, but I was desperate after trying for weeks. They basically auto-dial the dept for you and when they get through, you get a call on your phone connecting you with the agent. saved me so much time and frustration
0 coins
26d
Liam Fitzgerald
another miracle solution? yeah right... how much does this cost? there's always a catch with these services š
0 coins
24d
Jamal Washington
Honestly whatever it cost was worth every penny to fix my claim. I was missing like $2800 in backpay that I got resolved in one call. Do the math lol
0 coins
23d
PixelWarrior
wait I've actually heard of this from my cousin. She swears by it. said it saved her literal days of being on hold and getting disconnected
0 coins
22d
Write a comment...
Amara Adebayo
Check your email and physical mail ASAP! When they start an offset they're supposed to send you a notice explaining why. If you're in the online system, also check your message inbox there. They might have sent something you missed.
0 coins
Write a comment...
Giovanni Rossi
100% this is an offset for some kind of debt collection. I'm dealing with the SAME EXACT THING right now! In my case, its child support from another state. They take 25% of my benefits which is probably close to what they're taking from yours. The fact it literally says "offset" confirms it. You NEED to talk to someone at NY unemployment to find out exactly what its for.
0 coins
MidnightRider
Thanks for confirming. It is almost exactly 25% they're taking. I've been checking my mail obsessively the last few days but nothing from them explaining the change.
0 coins
22d
Giovanni Rossi
Yeh they're supposed to notify you but NY unemployment and proper notification dont exactly go hand in hand lol. Best of luck getting through on the phone!
0 coins
22d
Write a comment...
Fatima Al-Mansour
This right here is why the NY unemployment system is completely BROKEN. They just take money without proper notification and expect us to figure it out. Meanwhile we can't reach a human to save our lives. š¤¬ The whole system needs to be rebuilt from scratch.
0 coins
Dylan Evans
PREACH. I spent 3 months trying to resolve a simple issue that should have taken 5 minutes. šÆ
0 coins
22d
Sofia Gomez
I honestly think they make it impossible to contact them on purpose so they don't have to pay people. Been saying this for years.
0 coins
22d
Write a comment...
StormChaser
Hey, Unemployment Section Chief here. When you see an "offset" notation on your payment history, it means funds are being withheld due to a debt collection process. Common reasons include: ā¢ Tax debts (federal or state) ā¢ Child support obligations ā¢ Previous benefit overpayments ā¢ Defaulted student loans (in some cases) ā¢ Court-ordered restitution By law, they can withhold up to 25% of your weekly benefit amount. What you're describing ($120 reduction from $504) is almost exactly 24% which aligns with standard offset percentages. You have two options: 1. Call NY Unemployment directly at 888-209-8124 (good luck getting through) 2. Use a service like claimyr.com that will wait on hold for you and connect you when a representative is available Once you reach someone, ask specifically: - What type of offset is being applied - Which agency is collecting the debt - How to contest it if you believe it's in error - How long the offset will continue They are required by law to provide this information. If the debt isn't yours or you believe it's in error, you have rights to dispute it, but you must act quickly.
0 coins
MidnightRider
Thank you for this detailed info!! Do you know if there's a way to look up what the offset is for online somewhere? I really don't want to spend days trying to call if there's another way to find out.
0 coins
22d
StormChaser
Unfortunately, the specific reason for the offset isn't available in the online portal. You really need to speak with a representative. If calling is difficult, I strongly recommend using a service to connect with them. Whatever debt this is, addressing it promptly is important as interest and penalties can continue to accrue.
0 coins
22d
Dmitry Petrov
I have a question - if its federal student loans can they still offset even with the current pause on collections?
0 coins
22d
StormChaser
Great question! During the federal student loan payment pause, collections through the Treasury Offset Program (including from unemployment benefits) should be suspended for federal student loans. If you're experiencing offsets for federal student loans during this period, that would be something to contest immediately.
0 coins
22d
Write a comment...
Ava Williams
try claimyr.com to reach someone. Only way I got through after 2 weeks of calling. Not cheap but beats the alternative of never getting answers.
0 coins
Write a comment...
Miguel Castro
Okay so I literally just fixed this EXACT problem yesterday. It was a nightmare but here's what happened: turns out I had an overpayment from 2 years ago that I never knew about (they claimed I reported my income wrong on ONE certification). Called for 3 days straight, finally got through and found out what it was. Had to file an appeal because I never received any notice. They're still taking the money while my appeal is pending tho. š¤
0 coins
MidnightRider
OMG this sounds exactly like what might be happening to me. Was your reduction also around $120? And did they say they sent you any notices before starting to take the money?
0 coins
22d
Miguel Castro
Mine was $132 but yeh pretty close. They CLAIMED they sent a letter in January but I never got it. Make sure when you call you ask for the appeal form for overpayment. Don't let them tell you it's too late to appeal!
0 coins
22d
Write a comment...
Zainab Ibrahim
Ok I worked at the NY DOL call center during covid. An offset usually means there's a legal garnishment happening. Double check that you didn't accidentally certify that you were working or had other income - that trips a lot of people up. If you made a mistake on a weekly cert, call and explain the mistake. If it's a garnishment for a debt, you'll need to address it with whatever agency is collecting (usually by calling UI first to find out who that is). The phone lines are horrendous - I suggest using claimyr.com to get through since they'll wait on hold for you and call when an agent is available.
0 coins
MidnightRider
Thanks for the insider perspective! I definitely didn't report any income on my certifications. I'm still completely unemployed. Will try calling tomorrow.
0 coins
22d
Connor O'Neill
I keep seeing people recommend this claimyr service... does it actually work? I've been trying to reach ny unemployment for 3 weeks now š©
0 coins
22d
Zainab Ibrahim
Yes it works. We (the agents) don't care how you get through to us - we just answer the calls that come in. Claimyr basically handles the frustrating hold process for you. Worth every penny IMO.
0 coins
22d
Write a comment...
LunarEclipse
Does your payment history show only the reduced amount, or does it show the full amount and then a separate line for the offset? That might give you a clue about what's happening.
0 coins
MidnightRider
Just one line with the reduced amount ($384) and then under the payment method it says 'offset' where it normally says 'direct deposit'
0 coins
22d
LunarEclipse
Hmm that's different from what I experienced. When I had an offset for child support, it showed both amounts separately. You definitely need to call.
0 coins
22d
Write a comment...
Yara Khalil
Call your bank first to check that they didnt put a garnishment on your account. Sometimes banks will implement garnishments without telling you and it has nothing to do with unemployment.
0 coins
Write a comment...
Keisha Brown
Had this happen to my wife. The DOL was taking $ out of her unemployment because she supposedly had an overpayment from like 7 years ago during a previous claim. We had to file an appeal and fought it for months. Turns out they were wrong and had to repay everything they took! Make sure you appeal!!!! The system is designed to hope you don't fight back.
0 coins
MidnightRider
That's encouraging to hear! Did you have to hire a lawyer for the appeal or did you handle it yourselves?
0 coins
22d
Keisha Brown
We did it ourselves. It was a pain but not complicated - mostly just paperwork and one phone hearing. The most important part was gathering evidence (old pay stubs, tax forms, etc) to prove their calculation was wrong.
0 coins
22d
Write a comment...
Paolo Esposito
This happened to me. I used claimyr.com to finally get ahold of them after days of trying. Found out it was for an old school loan I defaulted on years ago that I completely forgot about. At least knowing was better than wondering wtf was happening to my money.
0 coins
Write a comment...
Amina Toure
i swear ny unemployment exists just to torture us š¤” they pull this kinda crap all the time. take ur money first, explain never
0 coins
Oliver Weber
seriously!!! and then they act like YOU did something wrong when you finally reach them after 75 attempts š
0 coins
22d
FireflyDreams
NY unemployment is the literal worst. NJ and CT systems are SO much better.
0 coins
22d
Write a comment...
Natasha Kuznetsova
Sounds like you're dealing with the Treasury Offset Program. They can take up to 25% of your benefits to pay federal debts. The most common reasons are tax debts, defaulted student loans, or child support. Call the Treasury Offset Program directly at 1-800-304-3107 to find out what debt they're collecting. It's usually faster than trying to reach unemployment.
0 coins
MidnightRider
THANK YOU for this number! I'll try calling them tomorrow. Had no idea there was a separate line for this.
0 coins
22d
Natasha Kuznetsova
No problem! Just make sure you have your SSN ready when you call. They'll tell you which agency is collecting the debt and how much is owed. Good luck!
0 coins
22d
Write a comment...