Back to New York Unemployment

Omar Hassan

Can u collect unemployment if you quit? NYSDOL rules explained

So I walked off my job at a warehouse distribution center about three weeks ago. It wasn't a snap decision — my supervisor had been cutting my hours from 40 down to like 18-19 a week for two months straight and refused to give me any reason why. I finally hit a breaking point and told them I was done. Now I'm sitting here trying to figure out if I can even file a UI claim or if quitting just automatically disqualifies me. I went ahead and filed anyway but I'm honestly expecting the worst. The NYSDOL site says something about 'good cause' for leaving but I can't figure out if my situation counts. Anyone been through something similar where you quit but still got approved?

My hours got slashed the same way before I finally left a job, and yes — I did get approved. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) while I was waiting to sort out my adjudication because I needed to talk to an actual NYSDOL agent and couldn't get anyone on the phone after trying for days. There's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE — basically it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up on the phone with a live agent. Turned out my adjudication was flagged because I quit, but once I explained the hour reduction to the agent, they noted it on my file and things moved forward pretty quickly.

0 coins

Hours getting cut from 40 to under 20 — that's exactly what happened to me. How long did your adjudication take after you talked to the agent?

0 coins

Claimyr actually worked for you? I've been skeptical but I literally cannot get anyone at NYSDOL on the phone no matter what time I try.

0 coins

Took about 10 days after I spoke with the agent. Way faster than it was moving before.

0 coins

Your situation with the hours is actually really important here. NYSDOL has a concept where if your employer significantly changes the conditions of your job — including cutting your pay or hours by a substantial amount — that can count as 'good cause' for leaving. You didn't just walk out randomly; your employer basically changed the job on you. Document everything: old pay stubs showing full hours, recent ones showing the cuts, any texts or emails where you asked about it. That paper trail is what adjudication reviewers are going to look at.

0 coins

Pay stubs I have. What about texts — do I need to submit those when I file or only if they ask?

0 coins

Your best move is to have them ready but wait until NYSDOL specifically requests documentation during adjudication. Submitting stuff they didn't ask for can sometimes slow things down.

0 coins

This matches what I was told when I went through something similar. The hour reduction was the key factor in my approval.

0 coins

wait does it have to be a certain percentage cut or any reduction counts

0 coins

Quitting on its own doesn't automatically kill your claim — a lot of people think it does and don't even bother filing. The key thing NYSDOL looks at is whether you had what they'd call a compelling reason tied to work conditions, not just personal preference. A 50%-plus reduction in your weekly hours over two months is pretty much exactly the kind of thing that can clear the bar. File, go through adjudication, and be honest and specific about the timeline.

0 coins

50% reduction is wild, I didn't know NYSDOL even considered that as good cause I always thought quitting was an instant no

0 coins

Most people assume that, which is why a lot of valid claims never get filed. The rule is way more nuanced than 'quit equals disqualified.

0 coins

Timeline I have down cold — it started mid-December, dropped to 18-19 hours by February. That's documented on every pay stub.

0 coins

Also important: when you're in adjudication after quitting, NYSDOL will likely reach out to your former employer to get their side. Make sure what you tell NYSDOL matches what actually happened, because if your employer says the hours were cut for performance reasons or something, that creates a conflict they'll have to sort out. Not saying that's your situation, just flagging it because it can drag out the process significantly.

0 coins

My employer never gave me any explanation for the cuts, verbal or written. That actually works in my favor, right?

0 coins

Your lack of any documented reason from them is actually useful. If they can't explain the reduction either, it's harder for them to argue it wasn't a material change to your job.

0 coins

This is real. My former employer lied to NYSDOL during my adjudication and I had to appeal. Whole thing took like three extra months.

0 coins

Ended up winning the appeal but it was exhausting. Keep records of everything.

0 coins

My cousin went through this and I want to say something that might be obvious but — keep filing your weekly claims even while you're in adjudication. I see people stop because they think it's pointless while everything is on hold. If you end up getting approved, those weeks you certified for are what determines how much back pay you get. Don't skip a single week.

0 coins

Weekly claims I've been doing every Sunday, wasn't sure if I should keep going. Good to know.

0 coins

This is SO important and completely overlooked. I lost weeks of back pay because nobody told me this.

0 coins

same happened to me i stopped filing for 6 weeks thinking it was frozen and lost all of it

0 coins

Three months ago I was in almost your exact position after leaving a retail management job where they kept changing my schedule at the last minute and cutting my base hours. Ended up spending two weeks trying to reach NYSDOL to understand my adjudication status and couldn't get through. Someone here mentioned Claimyr and I tried it — ended up speaking directly with a NYSDOL agent who walked me through exactly what my adjudication was flagged for. Knowing what the specific issue was let me gather the right documentation instead of just guessing.

0 coins

Two weeks of trying to reach NYSDOL sounds about right unfortunately. What documentation did you end up needing?

0 coins

Pay stubs showing the schedule changes over time and a written statement I prepared explaining the timeline of events. The agent told me exactly what format to send it in.

0 coins

Having an agent tell you specifically what they need is so much more useful than just submitting a pile of stuff and hoping

0 coins

Did Claimyr work pretty fast? I've been trying to reach NYSDOL for a totally different issue and I'm going on week two of no luck.

0 coins

okay genuine question — how does the job search requirement work while you're in adjudication after quitting? Like do you still have to do 3 job search activities a week even though your claim isn't approved yet? I always get confused about this part

0 coins

Your job search requirements kick in from the moment you're certifying weekly claims, regardless of adjudication status. Three work search activities per week in New York — you need to log them and have them ready if NYSDOL ever audits your records. Don't wait until you're approved to start tracking.

0 coins

oh wow I didn't realize I had to do that during adjudication too, I've been skipping weeks because I figured why bother

0 coins

That's a really common mistake and it can cause problems if you get approved retroactively and they check your work search logs for those weeks.

0 coins

NYSDOL adjudication after a voluntary quit is basically its own little investigation. They're going to look at your separation reason, talk to your employer, potentially ask you for a written statement. It drags. Mine took 7 weeks because my former employer disputed everything I said even though I had the receipts. Honestly the most stressful period of my life financially. I'd say give it at least 4-5 weeks before you start really worrying, but stay on top of your Unemployment Services account for any new notices.

0 coins

7 weeks is rough — was there anything you wish you'd done differently to speed it up?

0 coins

My biggest regret was not getting an agent on the phone earlier to understand what was actually being disputed. I was just waiting and refreshing my portal.

0 coins

Adjudication timelines for quit cases really do vary wildly depending on how quickly your former employer responds to NYSDOL's request for information.

0 coins

The portal is kind of useless for understanding what's actually happening with your claim during adjudication. All it says is 'pending' or 'under review' which tells you absolutely nothing. The only way to really know where things stand is to talk to an actual NYSDOL agent. Easier said than done obviously but that's the reality.

0 coins

Portal has been showing 'in progress' since day one, nothing more specific than that. Super frustrating.

0 coins

In progress for a quit case is basically just 'we haven't decided yet.' Unfortunately normal.

0 coins

The portal is designed for straightforward claims where everything is automatic. The second anything is complicated it tells you nothing useful.

0 coins

i quit a job last year and got denied at first but then appealed and won so dont give up if u get a denial. the appeals process takes forever but it does work if u actually had a good reason

0 coins

Appeals timeline — how long did yours take start to finish?

0 coins

like 11 weeks from when i filed the appeal to when i got the decision letter. then another week or two for payments to start coming

0 coins

11 weeks is a long time but winning on appeal is definitely possible for quit cases with good cause documentation

0 coins

My hours were reduced significantly before I left my last job and I want to offer one thing nobody mentioned yet: when you fill out the separation information section of your NYSDOL claim, don't just put 'quit' and leave it at that. Write a specific, factual description of the hour reduction — exact numbers, dates, and that you raised the issue with your employer. Adjudication reviewers are reading those initial statements and a vague separation reason slows everything down.

0 coins

Mine said something like 'hours were significantly reduced' — should I contact NYSDOL to add more detail to that statement?

0 coins

Your initial statement can sometimes be amended or supplemented. Worth asking about if you get an agent on the phone — they can note additional details on your file.

0 coins

Specific dates and numbers matter a lot here. 'Hours reduced from 40 to 18 starting December 15' is way more useful to a reviewer than 'hours were cut.

0 coins

Went through adjudication last spring for a quit case and kept hitting walls trying to reach NYSDOL. A friend suggested Claimyr and I ended up speaking with an actual live agent at NYSDOL after weeks of getting nowhere on my own. The agent pulled up my file and told me my former employer had submitted a response that conflicted with my statement — I never would have known that just refreshing my portal. Got to respond to their claims directly because I knew what was in the file.

0 coins

Wait your employer submitted something that conflicted with your statement and NYSDOL didn't tell you that through the portal?

0 coins

Nothing showed up in my Unemployment Services account about the employer dispute. The agent is the one who told me what was in my file.

0 coins

This is one of the most useful things about actually reaching an agent — they can tell you what's actually in your claim file, not just what the portal status says.

0 coins

That's honestly alarming. I had no idea employers can submit responses that you don't get notified about.

0 coins

Hour reduction cases like yours aren't super common so adjudication reviewers sometimes have to do more research before making a call. That's part of why these cases can take longer than a standard layoff claim. The good news is 'good cause' jurisprudence in New York is actually fairly employee-friendly when you can show the job changed materially from what you were hired for.

0 coins

Materially changed — does that have to be in writing from the employer or can it just be shown through pay stubs?

0 coins

Pay stubs, timesheets, or any scheduling system records work. You don't need written acknowledgment from the employer — the documented pattern is enough.

0 coins

Exactly. The pattern of records tells the story even without a memo from your boss saying 'we're cutting your hours.

0 coins

ugh I'm going through something kind of similar right now but slightly different — I didn't quit, I was let go, but my employer is claiming I quit voluntarily. So now I'm in adjudication fighting about what actually happened. This thread is making me realize I really need to get an agent on the phone to find out what my employer actually told NYSDOL.

0 coins

Your situation is actually a contested separation case which is a bit different from a true voluntary quit — NYSDOL has to determine what actually happened. You absolutely want an agent to tell you what's in your file.

0 coins

How do you even get anyone on the phone? I've tried three times this week and either get a busy signal or get disconnected after waiting 45 minutes.

0 coins

Claimyr is what finally got me talking to a NYSDOL agent after I'd spent a week getting nowhere. It waits on hold for you so you eventually end up with an actual person at NYSDOL — I explained my situation to the agent and found out things about my file I had no way of knowing otherwise. For a contested separation that information could be really important.

0 coins

Okay I will look into that because I genuinely cannot afford to wait months just refreshing my portal.

0 coins

Appeals after a quit denial are definitely survivable but I want to give realistic expectations — you need to show up to your hearing (usually by phone now) with organized documentation and a clear statement about why you left. The ALJ is basically going to ask you to prove the work conditions were bad enough that any reasonable person would have left. Hour reductions of 50%+ generally meet that bar but you have to present it clearly.

0 coins

ALJ hearings — are those scary? I've never done anything like that before.

0 coins

My hearing felt more like a formal phone meeting than a courtroom. The ALJ asked questions, I answered, they considered the documentation. It's intimidating but manageable.

0 coins

i was terrified of mine too but it was way less intense than i expected. just be organized and honest

0 coins

Three weeks into adjudication for a quit case is completely normal unfortunately. NYSDOL has to verify your separation reason, contact your employer, and have a reviewer actually make a determination. For voluntary separation cases that process can legitimately take 4-8 weeks depending on how quickly your employer responds and how backed up the adjudication queue is. Hang in there and keep certifying weekly.

0 coins

Every week I certify I report zero earnings since I haven't found anything yet — does that look bad or is that just what it is?

0 coins

Zero earnings during your claim is completely normal and expected while you're unemployed. That's what the benefit is for. Just make sure your job search activities are logged.

0 coins

wait you have to report even when you don't have any earnings? i thought you only certified if you had income to report lol

0 coins

Your weekly certification is how you tell NYSDOL you're still unemployed and still eligible — you do it every week regardless of whether you earned anything.

0 coins

My job dropped my hours for 'business reasons' they said, and I eventually quit. First I got denied, then I appealed, then I won. The whole thing from filing to getting that first payment was about 5 months. I know that sounds terrible but it did work out. The key was documenting everything obsessively and knowing what specifically NYSDOL was looking for in a good cause case.

0 coins

5 months is rough but good to hear it resolved. What would you tell yourself to do at the beginning that you didn't do?

0 coins

My biggest thing: get an agent on the phone early so you know what your file actually shows and what exactly is being questioned. I wasted two months reacting to things I guessed at instead of things I actually knew.

0 coins

5 months total is on the long end but honestly not unusual for a contested quit case that goes through appeal. The initial determination plus the appeals process adds up.

0 coins

Can I ask something about the monetary side — like even if you get approved after quitting, do you get paid for the weeks you were in adjudication? Or does the clock start from when they approve you?

0 coins

Your weekly certifications during adjudication are what create the back payment period. If you get approved, all those weeks you properly certified during adjudication should be paid out retroactively — which is exactly why you never skip weekly certification even when your claim is frozen.

0 coins

Oh that's actually really good to hear. I've been certifying every week even though nothing is happening.

0 coins

Every certification during adjudication is essentially banking a week of back pay if you get approved. It's worth doing every single week without fail.

0 coins

Former employer here — I actually process unemployment responses for my company and want to offer perspective from the other side. When NYSDOL contacts us about a quit, we have to submit a separation reason. For hour reduction cases, if the employer can't provide a documented business reason, it looks bad for us in the review. OP's situation with no explanation given for the cuts is actually a meaningful detail.

0 coins

From the employer side — does the employer always respond, or do they sometimes just not reply to NYSDOL?

0 coins

Employers don't always respond, especially smaller companies. If your former employer doesn't reply to NYSDOL's inquiry, that generally goes in your favor because they can't dispute your account of events.

0 coins

This is accurate. An employer who doesn't respond to NYSDOL's information request essentially leaves the claimant's statement as the only account on record.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure