Back to New York Unemployment

Keisha Brown

Can teachers collect unemployment during the summer in NY? NYSDOL rules explained

So I've been a paraprofessional at a NYC public school for going on six years and every summer I go through the same anxiety spiral wondering if I'm going to be okay financially until September. This year I actually tried to file for UI benefits between the school years and my claim got flagged almost immediately. The NYSDOL system is showing something about 'reasonable assurance' but nobody at the school district told me anything about what that means or whether I actually have a job waiting for me in the fall. My contract situation is a little complicated — I was told verbally that I'd be brought back but I haven't received anything in writing. Has anyone else dealt with this? I'm a school employee trying to figure out if I even qualify to collect during the summer months or if the state just automatically blocks all education workers from getting UI benefits between terms.

The 'reasonable assurance' thing tripped me up too when I first tried filing after my school year ended. What it basically means is that if your employer has told you — even informally — that you have a position lined up for next term, NYSDOL treats that as a signal you're not truly unemployed. The tricky part is that 'reasonable assurance' doesn't require a written contract. A verbal offer, a letter of intent, even just being listed on next year's staffing plan can count. If that assurance falls through — meaning you show up in September and there's no job — you can go back and claim benefits for the whole summer period retroactively.

0 coins

The retroactive part is what I keep hearing about but I'm nervous about it. Like if I end up not having a job in September I'd have to prove the assurance wasn't real?

0 coins

Exactly right on the retroactive piece. My sister-in-law is a school aide and that's exactly what happened to her a few years back — no position materialized and she filed after Labor Day and got paid for the whole gap. The key is documenting everything the school tells you between now and then.

0 coins

verbal offer absolutely counts, schools use this all the time to block summer claims even when there's nothing solid lined up. its kind of a gray area that benefits the districts more than workers imo

0 coins

Teachers and school employees are in a weird spot with UI that most people don't realize until they're stuck in it. NYSDOL has specific rules for 'between-term' periods — basically summers and holiday breaks — and educational workers get treated differently than regular claimants. The reasonable assurance disqualification is real but it's not automatic. You have to actually have been given that assurance to be blocked. If your situation is genuinely unclear, you should be in adjudication while they sort it out, not just auto-denied.

0 coins

Mine IS in adjudication right now, which is why I'm stressed. I don't know if that means they're seriously reviewing it or just delaying.

0 coins

adjudication just means a human has to look at it rather than the system auto-approving. for school employees that's pretty common, doesn't necessarily mean bad news

0 coins

My claim was in adjudication for almost five weeks last summer before they ruled on it. During that whole time I had no idea what was happening and couldn't get anyone on the phone to tell me anything.

0 coins

Five weeks with no information is brutal and I went through something similar. Couldn't get through on the NYSDOL phone lines no matter what I tried — I'd hold for 45 minutes and the system would just dump the call. A friend told me about Claimyr (claimyr.com) and I was skeptical but I tried it — it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up talking to a live agent yourself. There's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. I actually got to speak to someone at NYSDOL who explained exactly where my claim stood and what the adjudicator was looking at. For a between-term school employee claim specifically, talking to an agent made a huge difference because there were details they needed that weren't obvious from the online portal.

0 coins

45 minutes and then dropped — that's the NYSDOL phone experience in a nutshell. I'll check out Claimyr because at this point I'd try anything to get a straight answer.

0 coins

I've tried calling at like 7:58am thinking I'd beat the rush and still get put on hold forever. Does Claimyr work for school-employee specific questions or is it just general claim status stuff?

0 coins

the hold times are genuinely insane. i sat on hold for over an hour twice last week and both times it cut off before anyone answered

0 coins

I used something similar before and ended up talking to an agent who actually knew the between-term rules for school employees really well. Having a live person walk through the specifics of your situation is way more useful than trying to interpret the website.

0 coins

Here's what confused me when I first filed as a teaching assistant — there's a difference between summer break and being actually laid off. If your school is closed for summer that's a 'between academic terms' period under state law, and that triggers the reasonable assurance rules. But if your position was cut, your hours were reduced permanently, or the program you worked in was eliminated, that's a different situation entirely and the between-term rules may not apply the same way.

0 coins

My situation is somewhere in the middle which is why I think it went to adjudication. The program I work in had budget issues and I genuinely don't know if it's continuing.

0 coins

Budget uncertainty is actually a decent argument against reasonable assurance. If the school itself can't confirm the program is funded, how can they have given you real assurance of return?

0 coins

this is where you need everything documented. emails, any letters, text messages from supervisors, all of it. adjudicators want paper trails

0 coins

My experience as a per diem school worker was that NYSDOL basically assumed I had reasonable assurance even when I didn't have a guaranteed schedule. Per diem and substitute workers sometimes fall into a gray zone — the school might 'expect' to use you but that's not really the same as assurance of continued work. I had to appeal before anyone actually looked at my specific arrangement carefully.

0 coins

Per diem workers have stronger arguments than full-time staff in a lot of these situations because the nature of the work itself implies no guaranteed continuation. The appeal process can work in your favor there.

0 coins

My appeal took about two months from filing to hearing but I won and got everything I was owed going back to the first week of summer. Worth the wait even though it was stressful.

0 coins

two months for an appeal hearing is actually pretty fast from what i hear, some people wait way longer

0 coins

If it comes to it I'll appeal but I really want to avoid that if adjudication resolves it first

0 coins

The 30-day window to file your initial claim from the week you become unemployed is something a lot of school employees miss. They wait to see if the summer job or contract comes through, then realize they should have filed weeks earlier. Even if you're uncertain about your status, filing while your claim is being sorted out is better than waiting and potentially losing weeks of benefits you'd otherwise be entitled to.

0 coins

I did file right away — the last day of my contract I submitted the application. So at least I did that part right.

0 coins

Filing immediately is the move every time. You can always withdraw if you end up not needing it but you can't recover weeks you didn't file for.

0 coins

also dont forget the weekly certifications!! even while in adjudication you still need to certify each week or you can lose those benefit weeks even if the claim is eventually approved

0 coins

WAIT. i just want to make sure i understand — so teachers and school workers CAN file for unemployment in the summer, it just might get denied if the school says they're coming back?? i always thought education workers were just flat out not eligible during summer breaks. been leaving money on the table for YEARS if that's not true

0 coins

You were probably getting reasonable assurance from your employer each year without realizing it. If you have a teaching contract that renews automatically you'd likely have been disqualified even if you filed. But it depends on your specific situation.

0 coins

The blanket 'teachers can't get unemployment' thing is a myth that's been around forever. The actual rule is more nuanced — it's about whether you have that assurance of return, not about being an educator specifically.

0 coins

ok so I should actually look into this for real. i have a year to year contract and sometimes they don't confirm my assignment until literally August

0 coins

My NYSDOL adjudication for a between-term claim dragged on so long that by the time they ruled on it, September had already arrived and I was back at work. Never got an explanation, never got paid for a single week. I'm still not sure if I was disqualified or if it just fell through the cracks. The online portal never showed a clear determination, it just eventually stopped showing my claim as active.

0 coins

That sounds like a nightmare. If you never got an official written determination you might actually still be able to request one and appeal if necessary. Claims don't just disappear without a formal ruling.

0 coins

Someone told me the same thing but at that point I was back at work and just mentally couldn't deal with fighting it. I regret not pushing harder.

0 coins

the portal being unclear is such a common complaint. 'pending' forever and then nothing. they should be required to send a letter or something

0 coins

After weeks of getting nowhere with the phones, I finally had a real conversation with a NYSDOL agent about my summer school claim — Claimyr was what made that happen, it sat on hold so I didn't have to and I ended up speaking directly with someone at the agency. The agent told me the adjudicator had actually already made a note on my file that my employer's statement was inconsistent, which was information I never would have gotten from the portal alone. For school-employee claims especially, knowing what's actually in your file changes everything.

0 coins

Knowing what's in the file is huge. The portal just says 'in review' and gives you nothing to work with.

0 coins

inconsistent employer statements are actually really useful for the claimant. if the school told NYSDOL one thing and you something else, that works in your favor in adjudication

0 coins

Employer statements being reviewed is standard in these between-term cases. The school district reports to NYSDOL when you file and what they say about 'reasonable assurance' is a big factor in the determination.

0 coins

The districts are very practiced at filling out those employer responses in a way that triggers the disqualification. Knowing exactly what they said gives you a chance to counter it.

0 coins

I work in a charter school and found out that charter school employees aren't always covered the same way as traditional public school employees under these between-term rules. My claim got processed differently and I ended up getting approved for summer benefits my colleagues at the district school were denied. Worth looking into which type of institution you work for and how NYSDOL categorizes it.

0 coins

Charter school vs. traditional public school is actually a real distinction in some cases. Private school employees also have different treatment in some situations. The 'educational institution' definition in the UI rules isn't always as broad as people assume.

0 coins

My HR department had no idea about the distinction either, which made it extra confusing. I sort of stumbled into the approval by just filing and letting it play out.

0 coins

Private nonprofit educational institutions are generally covered but the specifics of the reasonable assurance rules can apply differently. Worth getting an actual determination rather than assuming you're disqualified.

0 coins

My friend works at a school and was in adjudication for summer benefits last year — she mentioned Claimyr after I told her I was having phone access issues with NYSDOL for a totally unrelated claim. Ended up with a live agent who could see what stage the review was at and what documents were still needed. Saved her from missing a submission deadline she didn't even know existed.

0 coins

Missing deadlines you don't know exist is the scariest part of this whole thing. The portal doesn't warn you, the letters sometimes arrive late, and then you're just out of luck.

0 coins

My determination letter arrived like nine days after it was dated. Barely had time to appeal within the window. I wish I'd had someone looking at my file earlier in the process.

0 coins

The job search requirement during summer adjudication is something that trips people up. While your claim is pending you technically still need to be doing your three job search activities per week and logging them. If your claim is eventually approved and they audit your certifications, missing job search entries can cost you benefit weeks even after the fact.

0 coins

Three activities per week — is that standard or does it vary? And do I need to be looking for work outside education or can I log education-adjacent jobs?

0 coins

Three per week is the standard requirement. The jobs don't have to be in a totally different field — applying to summer programs, tutoring positions, education coordinator roles, all of that counts. Just keep your log detailed with dates and employer contact info.

0 coins

You also don't have to actually want the jobs you apply to in order to log them, just saying. Keep records of everything regardless.

0 coins

This is so important and I see people get tripped up on it constantly. Certifying that you did job searches when you didn't is worse than just doing the searches — that's potential fraud territory.

0 coins

Does anyone know if the summer rules are different for teachers at year-round schools? My cousin works at one of those schools that only closes for two weeks in December and a week in spring but runs all summer. She filed and got approved with no issue but I want to understand if that's because the between-term rules just didn't apply or something else.

0 coins

Year-round school employees don't have the same 'between academic terms' gap that triggers the special rules, at least not for summer. If your cousin's school operates continuously and her position was just cut or her hours reduced, that's a standard UI claim, not a between-term situation.

0 coins

The between-term rule specifically requires there to be an actual term break for it to apply. Continuous operation changes the analysis pretty significantly.

0 coins

Three weeks into adjudication with no word is honestly not that unusual for school-employee claims — these tend to get more scrutiny because NYSDOL has to verify what the employer reported. Where it gets concerning is if you hit the 6-week mark with nothing, because at that point you should definitely be trying to reach someone who can tell you whether additional information is needed.

0 coins

Week four starts Monday for me. So I should start being more aggressive about reaching out?

0 coins

Week four I'd be making serious efforts to get a human on the phone. The portal info is limited and adjudicators sometimes need something from you that never got communicated clearly.

0 coins

My experience was that by week five they were waiting on something from me and I had no idea. Getting a live agent to look at the notes in the file would have saved me at least a week of delay.

0 coins

The employer response in between-term school cases often uses very specific language that NYSDOL interprets as reasonable assurance even when the actual situation is ambiguous. Phrases like 'we anticipate the employee will return' or 'position is expected to continue pending funding' have been treated as sufficient assurance in some determinations. If your school used language like that and you feel it misrepresents your actual situation, that's something worth addressing in adjudication or on appeal.

0 coins

Pending' funding is exactly the kind of language that applies to my program. How do I make clear to the adjudicator that pending funding'isn t the same as actualassurance?

0 coins

You can submit a written statement through your Unemployment Services account explaining the specifics — that the program's funding was uncertain, you had no written confirmation, and that you reasonably did not have assured return. Specific dates of when you asked about your status and got non-committal answers help a lot.

0 coins

Budget contingency language is genuinely a contested area. Some adjudicators treat it as assurance, others don't. The appeal level is where you might get a more consistent ruling if the adjudicator rules against you.

0 coins

Went through almost this exact situation two summers ago — program I worked in had uncertain funding, got flagged for the between-term disqualification, and was completely lost trying to understand what NYSDOL actually needed from me. The online portal told me basically nothing. Someone I know suggested Claimyr and I ended up on the phone with a NYSDOL agent who walked me through exactly what the adjudicator's notes said and what I could submit to support my case. I sent in a statement the same day and my claim was approved within ten days.

0 coins

Ten days after submitting a statement — that's actually really encouraging. I didn't even know I could submit additional information proactively.

0 coins

You can absolutely upload documents and written statements through the portal. The agent I spoke to told me exactly where to submit and what specifically to address. Without that conversation I would have had no idea.

0 coins

I keep hearing that talking to an actual agent makes this process so much more manageable. The website is basically useless for understanding where things actually stand.

0 coins

The retroactive benefit period if your assurance falls through is worth understanding before September hits. If you go back for fall term and there genuinely is no position — program cut, school closes, enrollment drops, whatever — you need to report that immediately and file for the summer period. There are deadlines for how far back you can claim and you don't want to let weeks slip by while you figure out next steps.

0 coins

How quickly do I need to report back if the fall position doesn't come through? Is there a specific deadline from when school starts?

0 coins

File as soon as you know the position won't be there — don't wait for formal paperwork. NYSDOL is going to look at whether you were actively trying to maintain your claim. If you've been certifying through the summer that helps.

0 coins

The certification piece is critical here. Even if your claim is in adjudication, weekly certifications establish the week-by-week record of your unemployment. No certifications, no benefits for those weeks even retroactively.

0 coins

i waited two weeks after my program was cut to file and lost those weeks. file immediately when anything changes dont sit on it

0 coins

Reading everything in this thread I realize I made every mistake possible last summer. Didn't file immediately, stopped certifying when adjudication went on too long, never submitted any additional statement, and never got through to a live agent. Lost probably six weeks of benefits I might have been entitled to. If you're in this situation right now please learn from my mess and stay on top of every piece of it.

0 coins

Honestly your post is making me feel better about having asked this question before giving up. I'm going to stay on this.

0 coins

Please do. I genuinely wish I'd found a thread like this before it was too late for my situation. The school between-term rules are complicated enough that most people don't understand what they're dealing with until they've already made mistakes.

0 coins

the system is designed in a way that makes it easy to unknowingly disqualify yourself. it shouldn't be this hard to understand what you're supposed to do

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure