Back to New York Unemployment

Logan Stewart

Can business owner file unemployment in NY? What I found out from NYSDOL

So I ran a small landscaping company for about six years, three employees at peak, did decent work. Last fall the contracts dried up and I had to wind everything down. I dissolved the LLC formally in February, laid off my last worker, and now I'm sitting here with no income and genuinely wondering if there's any path to unemployment benefits for me personally. I paid into the system through payroll taxes on my own W-2 wages the whole time I was running things — I was actually on payroll as an employee of my own LLC. My accountant is the one who suggested I look into this. Has anyone actually navigated this? I keep getting conflicting information from random google searches and I need to know if can business owner file unemployment is even a real possibility in New York or if I'm completely out of luck here.

Week two of my own situation and I'm watching this thread closely because my partnership dissolved in March and I'm in almost the same boat. Filed two weeks ago and it's sitting in adjudication with zero explanation. Following every word here.

0 coins

Adjudication at week two is actually kind of normal from what I've read, though that doesn't make it less stressful. What type of entity was your partnership — did you have W-2 wages through it or were you taking draws?

0 coins

My claim sat in adjudication for 19 days before anything moved. Turned out there was a flag on the account because I was listed as an officer of the company. Had to explain the ownership percentage situation in writing.

0 coins

Checked my Unemployment Services portal just now and there's a new message asking for my ownership documentation. So that's what triggered the hold. At least now I know what they want.

0 coins

The core rule here surprised me when I first looked into it — NYSDOL doesn't disqualify you just because you owned the business. What actually matters is whether you were on the payroll drawing W-2 wages and paying into unemployment insurance through your employer account. If your LLC had an employer registration and was withholding and remitting UI taxes on wages paid to you as an employee-officer, you built up a wage base that can support a claim. The disqualifying part is usually when someone is STILL operating the business or still has the ability to call it back into operation. Formally dissolved changes the picture significantly.

0 coins

That tracks with what my accountant said. The LLC is fully dissolved — articles of dissolution filed with the state, EIN closed, the whole thing. The question is whether NYSDOL will accept my W-2 wages from the LLC as valid base period wages or flag them because of the ownership.

0 coins

they look at your base period wages same as any other employee tbh. the ownership thing complicates it but dissolved means dissolved in their eyes usually

0 coins

My first week looking into this and I found a NYSDOL fact sheet that specifically addresses officer-employees. It says officer status alone doesn't disqualify you but they do scrutinize whether the separation was truly involuntary. Dissolution qualifies as an involuntary separation in most cases.

0 coins

The 10% ownership threshold comes up in some states but New York focuses more on the nature of the separation and whether UI taxes were actually paid on your wages. Your Form NYS-45 filings from the business will be key evidence here.

0 coins

Submitting week four of weekly certifications right now and still no determination on my officer-employee claim. The phone situation at NYSDOL is genuinely brutal — I spent parts of three different days trying to reach someone before I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com). The way it works is it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so that you end up talking directly with a live agent. There's a video walkthrough at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE if you want to see it before trying. I finally got an agent on the line and she confirmed my wages were showing in the system and explained exactly what documentation they needed to move my claim forward. Worth every minute not spent on hold.

0 coins

Four weeks of weekly certifications with no determination yet — that sounds exhausting. What documentation did the agent say they needed from you specifically?

0 coins

My phone situation was identical. Tried for days. The hold music alone was making me anxious about the whole process. Good to know there are workarounds.

0 coins

Pulled up my portal messages after reading this and there's actually a document request I somehow missed from ten days ago. No wonder nothing has moved. Going to upload everything today and probably also try to reach someone by phone to confirm receipt.

0 coins

four weeks is a long time to be in limbo especially when bills are piling up. hope the agent was actually helpful and not just reading from a script

0 coins

DISSOLVED THE BUSINESS AND STILL GOT DENIED ON FIRST PASS. That was me eight months ago. They coded my separation as 'voluntary quit' because I was listed as 100% owner. Had to file an appeal and submit the dissolution documents, the final tax return, the letter to my last client explaining we were closing — basically a whole packet proving this wasn't me choosing to leave a job, it was the business ceasing to exist. Appeal was decided in my favor after about six weeks. The system is NOT set up to handle business owners at all, you basically have to explain your entire situation from scratch.

0 coins

This is exactly what I was afraid of. Did you file the initial claim before or after the formal dissolution was complete?

0 coins

Filed about three weeks after dissolution was final. The agent at my appeal hearing actually said the timing was good because it showed I didn't just walk away — the entity didn't exist anymore when I filed.

0 coins

voluntary quit coding is so annoying because the system cant tell the difference between someone quitting a job and an entire company shutting down. they really should have a separate category for this

0 coins

My appeal on a similar issue took nine weeks not six so your mileage may vary. But it did get resolved correctly eventually. Keep every piece of paper from the dissolution process.

0 coins

The base period question matters a lot here. NYSDOL looks at wages earned in roughly the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters before you file. If your LLC was paying you W-2 wages during that window and remitting UI taxes on those wages, those wages count toward your benefit rate calculation the same as any other employer's payroll. The issue that trips up business owners specifically is when they were taking owner draws or distributions instead of salary — those don't count. But if you were genuinely on payroll with proper withholding, you should have a solid wage base.

0 coins

My wages were always through payroll with proper W-2 and withholding. The LLC filed NYS-45 every quarter. So in theory the wage base should be there — it's the ownership flag I'm worried about triggering a denial.

0 coins

The NYS-45 filings are your strongest evidence. If the wages are in the NYSDOL wage records system they're harder to dispute. The ownership percentage question is separate from whether the wages count.

0 coins

wait so if you were paying yourself a salary through payroll this whole time you actually might be in a decent position? i assumed all business owners were just automatically excluded

0 coins

My situation was a bit different — I was a 50% partner in an S-corp that closed. Week three after filing I got a letter asking me to explain my separation. The letter asked specifically whether I retained any ownership or control over business assets after the closure date. They wanted a signed statement. What caught me off guard was the phrasing — it asked if I had 'ability to resume business operations' not just whether I currently was operating. So even if everything is dissolved you need to affirmatively state that resuming is not possible.

0 coins

The 'ability to resume' framing is really useful to know. I should probably get a statement from my attorney confirming the dissolution is complete and the business cannot be restarted under the same entity.

0 coins

My attorney's letter was literally what turned my claim around. One page on letterhead stating the dissolution was final and the entity has no remaining assets, obligations, or ability to conduct business. Cost me about $150 for that letter and probably saved weeks of back-and-forth.

0 coins

Looked through my own dissolution paperwork after reading this and I do have a certificate of dissolution from the state. Going to include that with my document upload tonight along with a written statement about the ability to resume question.

0 coins

The 'ability to resume' thing is real and they do ask it at the hearing level too if it goes to appeal. Good to address it proactively in the initial claim.

0 coins

My claim got to week six before I finally talked to an agent who actually knew the officer-employee rules. The stuff I'm reading in this thread tracks with what I learned. One thing that helped me was specifically asking the agent to note in my file that the dissolution was involuntary — meaning market conditions and not a personal choice drove the closure. That language 'involuntary business cessation' apparently means something specific in how they categorize the separation. I'd been trying to reach someone for weeks before I finally used Claimyr to get through. Once I had an agent on the phone it was a completely different experience than dealing with the portal alone.

0 coins

Involuntary business' cessation — writing that phrase down right now. Did the agent give you that term or did you come in knowingit?

0 coins

The agent used it first and I asked her to repeat it. She said it distinguishes owners who actively chose to close from those forced to close by circumstances outside their control. NYSDOL treats them differently in the adjudication process.

0 coins

interesting that the portal and the phone experience are so different. like the portal gives you no information at all and apparently just calling gets you actual useful answers

0 coins

week six sounds terrible but at least you got there. i gave up at week three and just found other work. probably left money on the table looking back

0 coins

The ownership percentage thing genuinely matters in ways I didn't expect. Mine was an S-corp where I owned 55%. NYSDOL's review process flagged me because majority owners get extra scrutiny — their logic being that a majority owner theoretically has the power to reopen the business. I had to document not just that I dissolved it but that there was no customer base, no equipment, no contracts — basically nothing to reopen with even if I wanted to. The adjudication examiner was actually pretty reasonable once I got my documents in. Took about five weeks from submission to determination.

0 coins

Five weeks from document submission to determination feels long but honestly at this point I'd take a known timeline over open-ended waiting. What did you submit — just the dissolution docs or more than that?

0 coins

Dissolution certificate, final quarter NYS-45, a letter from my accountant confirming the business accounts were closed, and a brief written statement I drafted myself explaining the circumstances. The examiner actually emailed to say the accountant letter was helpful.

0 coins

Reviewed the NYSDOL website this morning looking for a checklist of what to submit and couldn't find one for officer-employee situations specifically. It's like they want you to guess.

0 coins

There's no checklist because they evaluate these case by case. That's both the annoying and potentially helpful part — a good adjudicator who understands your specific situation can rule in your favor even if the initial system flags you.

0 coins

just chiming in because i went through something similar two years ago with a sole prop not an llc. sole prop is completely different rules fyi — no W-2 wages, no employer registration, so there's basically nothing to claim from. the LLC with payroll situation the OP describes is actually a much stronger position than what i had. i got denied outright because there was no employer account and no wage records in the system at all. nothing to base benefits on.

0 coins

That's an important distinction — sole prop vs. LLC with payroll are genuinely different situations. Good to hear the LLC with proper payroll is a stronger position.

0 coins

yeah sole props dont pay into UI so there's nothing to draw from. that makes sense even if its frustrating for people in that situation

0 coins

the worst part was i HAD been contributing to the system through a previous employer job before i started the sole prop. but those wages were too old to be in the base period by the time i filed. terrible timing.

0 coins

My question landing here week one of researching this before I even file — if the LLC had employees other than you and was filing NYS-45 and paying UI taxes on all their wages including yours, does NYSDOL have all that in their system already or do you have to provide it yourself?

0 coins

The wage records submitted on your NYS-45 filings go into NYSDOL's employer wage records database. When you file a UI claim they pull your Social Security number and check what wages are on record for you. If your LLC properly reported your wages each quarter it should show up. That said, you can and should still provide your W-2 as documentation.

0 coins

My wages showed up correctly in the system from the quarterly filings. The W-2 I uploaded was more of a belt-and-suspenders move but the examiner said the wage records were already there. The documentation I needed was about the nature of my separation, not the wages themselves.

0 coins

Checked my portal after getting here and I can see the wage records are showing from the LLC employer account. So that part at least is already handled. The separation documentation is what I need to put together.

0 coins

kinda surprised nobody mentioned the job search requirements yet. even if you get approved you still have to do 3 job search activities per week and report them on your weekly certification. as a business owner thats a weird adjustment because you're used to creating your own work. but NYSDOL still requires you to actively apply for jobs and log the activities. applying to jobs you're qualified for not just random stuff.

0 coins

Three activities per week — what counts as an activity? Just submitting applications or does networking and attending job fairs count?

0 coins

applications, interviews, resume submissions, registering with a job site, going to a career center event, networking contacts if you document them properly. all count. you log them in your weekly certification and need to be able to prove them if audited

0 coins

The job search requirement caught me off guard too. After running my own business I hadn't thought about updating a resume in years. But it's a real requirement and they do spot-check. Keep records of everything — confirmation emails from applications, LinkedIn messages, whatever.

0 coins

My examiner mentioned that business owners who claim they're 'available for work' sometimes get scrutinized extra on this because NYSDOL wants to verify you're genuinely pursuing employment not just trying to draw benefits while you figure out your next business venture.

0 coins

Month two of my claim approval and I want to offer some hope here — I owned 40% of an LLC that dissolved and I successfully collected unemployment. The process was not smooth, there was a long adjudication period and a request for documents, but it resolved in my favor. The key for me was getting on the phone with someone who understood the officer-employee rules rather than just the standard agent reading from a screen. I'd tried to get through on my own for a long time before a friend mentioned Claimyr. Got an actual live NYSDOL agent on the phone and walked through my whole situation with her. That conversation shaped how I framed my written response to the examiner.

0 coins

Month two and already past the hard part — that's genuinely good to hear. The 40% ownership making it through suggests majority ownership isn't automatically fatal to the claim either.

0 coins

The examiner's focus was entirely on whether the dissolution was genuine and whether I retained any ability to continue operating. Percentage mattered less than the finality of closure.

0 coins

The portal just updated with a new status on my claim — it moved out of adjudication and into 'pending determination'. Something actually shifted. Not sure what triggered it but progress is progress.

0 coins

Pending determination is usually a good sign — it typically means an examiner has picked it up and is actively working on it rather than it sitting in a queue.

0 coins

My determination letter came last Thursday — approved. 38% owner of a dissolved LLC with W-2 wages through the whole life of the business. Weekly benefit rate based on my highest quarters. I want to add one practical note: the letter specifically said my separation was classified as a 'layoff due to lack of work' which is wild because I was both the person who laid off the last employee AND the person who got laid off in a sense. But that classification is what you want — it's the cleanest path to approval. If anyone is still trying to navigate the phone situation, Claimyr was how I eventually got proper guidance before my determination came through. The agent I spoke with was the one who told me to request that specific classification language in my written statement.

0 coins

Approved with 38% ownership — this is the most directly relevant outcome I've seen in this thread to my own situation. The 'layoff due to lack of work' classification is exactly what I want to push for. Thank you for coming back to share this.

0 coins

My determination came through with the same classification language. I think the examiner defaults to it when the dissolution is well-documented and genuinely involuntary.

0 coins

Just got off a long hold session with NYSDOL and finally reached someone who confirmed my wages are in the system. The agent was helpful once I got through. Now I need to put the separation documentation together.

0 coins

congrats on the approval. the system can work for business owners it just takes way more effort than it should. glad you got it sorted

0 coins

The appeals process deserves its own mention because even if you get denied initially the case isn't over. The Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board has a pretty good track record of correcting erroneous officer-employee denials when the facts support approval. You file within 30 days of the determination notice, there's a hearing before an administrative law judge, and you can present documentation and testimony. I went through the whole thing and the judge was much more willing to engage with the nuances of my situation than the initial adjudicator was. My benefits were backdated to my original filing date once the appeal succeeded.

0 coins

Backdated to the original filing date is key — so even if there's a long delay or an appeal process, you don't necessarily lose those weeks of benefits?

0 coins

Correct, as long as you filed your weekly certifications for each week even during the appeal period. That's essential — you have to keep certifying every week or you lose those weeks even if the appeal succeeds.

0 coins

The 'keep certifying while appealing' advice is so important. I almost stopped because I figured why bother if I'm denied. My attorney told me to keep certifying no matter what. Good thing I did.

0 coins

The 30-day appeal window is firm so do not sleep on it if you get a denial. The appeal form is on the NYSDOL website and can be submitted online or by mail but confirm receipt either way.

0 coins

Pulling the thread together on the practical steps for officer-employee UI claims in New York: gather your base period W-2s from the business, confirm your NYS-45 filings are complete for all quarters, prepare a written statement explaining the nature of the dissolution and your lack of ability to resume operations, and get documentation from your attorney or accountant confirming finality of dissolution. File the claim, then immediately prepare to respond to the adjudication request that will almost certainly follow. The portal is where you'll upload documents when asked. Phone access to an agent is valuable for understanding exactly what an examiner needs — that part is harder to manage than the document gathering.

0 coins

This is the clearest summary I've seen. Printing this out. The phone access point is real — everything I've learned that's actually useful has come from people who managed to reach a live agent.

0 coins

The written statement piece is underrated. Mine was three paragraphs explaining my role in the company, how the dissolution happened, and why resumption of operations wasn't possible. The examiner quoted it in my determination letter.

0 coins

i feel like the portal should tell you all this but it really just says adjudication in progress and nothing else. all the useful information lives outside the portal somehow

0 coins

Two weeks into my adjudication period and my portal just changed to show a document request for the first time. They want proof of dissolution and a statement about my separation. I've been preparing these since I read this thread so I'm actually ready to respond within a day or two instead of scrambling. Sometimes reading ahead actually pays off.

0 coins

Responding quickly to document requests is supposed to help move things along. I read that delays in responding can extend the adjudication by weeks.

0 coins

My examiner confirmed that over the phone — they work requests in batches and if yours comes in before the next batch cutoff it moves faster. Fast response genuinely matters.

0 coins

Uploaded everything this afternoon. Dissolution certificate, my W-2 from the LLC for the base period year, and a two-page written statement. Now back to waiting but at least I did my part quickly.

0 coins

The weekly certification piece is worth emphasizing. During adjudication you still have to file your weekly certification every single week even though nothing seems to be moving. If you miss a week it creates a gap in your claim that you typically cannot go back and fill. I missed week three because I assumed the whole claim was on hold during adjudication. Had to call and get that sorted out and it added more time to my resolution.

0 coins

Filing weekly even during adjudication — noted. I haven't missed any but good to know missing one creates problems that aren't automatically fixable.

0 coins

Checked my certification history on the portal just now and I have all weeks logged. Good to have confirmation that piece is handled even while everything else is uncertain.

0 coins

i forgot a week during my adjudication too. they were actually pretty understanding about it once i explained but it did require a phone call to sort out and the system definitely didn't fix it on its own

0 coins

The certification question employers answer also matters for officer-employees. After you file, NYSDOL sends a notice to your former employer — which in this case is your dissolved LLC — asking them to confirm or contest the separation. With a dissolved LLC there's obviously no one to respond, which actually works in your favor. No employer response typically results in the claim proceeding. But make sure your registered agent or dissolution paperwork doesn't create a situation where someone responds on behalf of the entity incorrectly.

0 coins

Hadn't thought about the employer notice side of this. The LLC is fully dissolved so there shouldn't be anyone to receive or respond to that notice, which sounds like it should be fine.

0 coins

The dissolution means no active registered agent in most cases. The notice goes unanswered and that's standard. It's when a partially-active entity or a spouse who's still associated with the business receives and responds to that notice that complications arise.

0 coins

My dissolved entity had a registered agent who had already filed cessation paperwork so there was truly no one to respond. Exactly as described — the absence of an employer response moved things along.

0 coins

update from my situation that sort of mirrors this thread even though mine is different — former employee of a small company here not an owner, but I got caught in adjudication for weeks because my employer filed something incorrectly in their separation paperwork. made me realize how much the employer-side of the process matters and how little control you have over it once you file. the NYSDOL just waits for responses and you're stuck waiting too.

0 coins

employer filing errors causing claimant delays is infuriating because you did everything right and still get held up by someone else's mistake

0 coins

exactly. i had to reach an agent to find out what was wrong because the portal just said pending with no detail at all. once i understood what had happened the fix was relatively quick but finding out what the problem was took forever

0 coins

The portal really does tell you almost nothing. It's like a progress bar that never moves and never tells you why.

0 coins

Checking back in here with my own update — I filed the claim formally three days ago after putting together all the documentation this thread helped me understand I'd need. Already preparing my written statement about involuntary business cessation and the inability to resume operations. The adjudication notice showed up on the portal within 24 hours of filing which I'm told is pretty standard. I'll keep updating here as things develop. This thread has been more useful than anything else I found researching this question.

0 coins

Adjudication notice within 24 hours just means your claim type triggered the standard officer-employee review. It's not a bad sign at all — it means someone has to look at it, not that it's going to be denied.

0 coins

Having your documents ready before they even ask is a good position to be in. Some people get the document request and then scramble for weeks to gather everything. You're ahead of that curve.

0 coins

My initial adjudication was resolved much faster than I expected once I uploaded a complete document set on the first request. The examiners apparently appreciate not having to send multiple follow-up requests.

0 coins

Came back to check the thread and glad to see you filed. My own claim moved to determination this week — still waiting on the actual decision but the fact that it progressed at all felt like a small victory.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure