Back to New York Unemployment

Ryder Ross

Can I get unemployment if I was fired for stealing? NYSDOL situation

So I got terminated last month from my warehouse job and I'm trying to figure out where I stand with unemployment. The reason on my termination paperwork says 'theft of company property' but the actual situation is a lot more complicated than that sounds. I took home some damaged packaging material that was literally going to be thrown in the dumpster — stuff the floor supervisor had told us informally was fine to grab. Turns out there was a policy buried in the handbook against removing any company property regardless of condition, and when a new manager came in he made an example out of me. HR called it theft and that's what ended up on my separation notice. I filed a UI claim with NYSDOL two weeks ago and it's sitting there with no movement. I haven't gotten any determination letter or anything explaining what's happening. My question is whether this kind of firing automatically disqualifies me or if there's any chance NYSDOL looks at the actual circumstances? I have three kids and I'm already two weeks behind on bills. Really need to understand what I'm dealing with here.

Tried Claimyr for this exact frustration — when my own adjudication was dragging and I couldn't get anyone at NYSDOL on the phone, a friend told me about claimyr.com. It waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you actually end up talking to a live agent. There's a video demo at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE if you want to see how it works before trying it. I eventually got to speak with someone who pulled up my claim and explained exactly what was flagged. For your situation specifically, being able to ask an agent what the adjudicator is looking at could make a real difference in how you prepare your side of the story.

0 coins

My phone has been glued to my ear for days trying to get through to NYSDOL. I'll check out that video tonight. Did the agent you spoke with actually give you useful information or just read you what's on the screen?

0 coins

NYSDOL phone lines are brutal right now. Spent four hours on hold last Tuesday and got disconnected without ever reaching anyone. Anything that gets you talking to a real person is worth it.

0 coins

Claimyr worked for my neighbor who had an adjudication issue, she ended up speaking with an agent and got her claim sorted within a few days of that call. Worth trying when you can't get through on your own.

0 coins

Yours is exactly the kind of case that NYSDOL is supposed to investigate rather than auto-deny. Here's what I'd actually look at first if I were you: gather every piece of evidence that the packaging material was considered waste. If your former supervisor ever put anything in writing — even a text message saying that stuff was available to take — that's gold. NYSDOL adjudicators look at whether the misconduct was 'deliberate disregard' of company rules. If you genuinely didn't know the policy existed or were given permission by a supervisor, that works in your favor. The burden is partly on the employer to show you knew the rule and broke it intentionally.

0 coins

The supervisor who told us it was okay no longer works there. He left about a month before I got fired. Any way to use his word if he's not at the company anymore?

0 coins

Former coworkers who heard the same instruction from that supervisor could serve as witnesses for your statement to the adjudicator. Write down their names now before memories fade. NYSDOL can't subpoena anyone for the initial determination but you can reference witness accounts in your statement.

0 coins

Documentation is everything. Screenshots of any texts from that supervisor, emails, anything timestamped before the termination is huge.

0 coins

Wait so they actually wrote THEFT on your paperwork?? Because that word is gonna trigger a misconduct review for sure. NYSDOL doesn't just approve claims when the employer puts theft on the separation notice. I'm not saying you're definitely denied but you should prepare for a fight. The adjudicator is going to contact your former employer and they're going to repeat whatever HR put in the file.

0 coins

Yeah the word 'theft' is literally on the separation form they gave me. That's what I'm worried about. Does NYSDOL just take the employer's word or do they actually investigate?

0 coins

They do investigate — both sides get to submit information. Your former employer has to actually prove willful misconduct, not just allege it. The employer's version of events is not automatically accepted. Write your own detailed account of what happened and submit it to the adjudicator as soon as you can.

0 coins

my former job wrote misconduct on mine and I still got approved bc the adjudicator found their evidence lacking. dont panic yet

0 coins

Had a situation kind of similar — not theft but accused of policy violation — and the adjudicator actually called me to get my side before issuing a determination. When NYSDOL contacts you, answer every call even if it's an unknown number. Missing that call can delay your claim by weeks or even trigger a denial by default if you don't respond in time.

0 coins

How much notice do they give before that call? I work odd hours trying to pick up gig work while this is pending and I'm worried I'll miss it.

0 coins

My call came with zero advance warning — just an adjudicator leaving a voicemail one afternoon. I phoned them at the number they left and got through. Check your voicemail constantly and keep an eye on your Unemployment Services account for any new messages or document requests.

0 coins

They messaged me through the online portal AND left a voicemail. Check both places every single day during adjudication.

0 coins

Here's the thing NYSDOL looks at: intentionality. Taking something you genuinely believed was waste with supervisor approval is a very different legal picture than pocketing product you knew was valuable and prohibited. The question the adjudicator is essentially asking is whether you deliberately violated a rule you knew existed. If your answer is no — and you have anything backing that up — you have a real argument. That said, 'theft' as a stated reason does put you in the misconduct category which means you'll definitely go through adjudication rather than getting a quick approval.

0 coins

So adjudication is basically like a review process? I wasn't sure if that meant I was already being denied or if it's just standard for disputed separations.

0 coins

Adjudication just means your claim has a question that needs resolution before they can approve or deny it. It is not a denial. It's actually normal for any claim where the employer contests or where the reason for separation could potentially be misconduct. You're in the review phase, not the denied pile — yet.

0 coins

I thought adjudication meant automatic denial when I went through it and almost didn't even respond to their questionnaire. Please respond to everything they send you. That response is your chance to tell your side.

0 coins

My company did the same thing — changed management, new rules, fired half the warehouse crew over stuff the old management had let slide for years. It's really common and NYSDOL is familiar with this pattern. When you fill out whatever questionnaire they send, make sure you describe the management transition and that the rule was not enforced before the new manager arrived. That context matters.

0 coins

That's exactly what happened here. New regional manager came in around October and started cracking down. How do I make sure that context gets into my adjudication file?

0 coins

There's usually a section in the adjudication questionnaire where you explain the circumstances of your separation in your own words. Use all of it. Don't leave anything blank. Mention the management change, the informal practice, the supervisor who gave permission, and when that supervisor left. Be specific with dates if you can remember them.

0 coins

You can also upload additional documents to your Unemployment Services account to support your statement. Photos of the material being discarded, any written communications, even a written summary of what happened signed by you is better than nothing.

0 coins

Honestly I had no idea Claimyr was a thing until my brother mentioned it when I was going through my own adjudication nightmare. I ended up talking directly to an NYSDOL agent who could see my actual claim file — not just some FAQ-reading rep. If you want to know what specifically your adjudicator has flagged or what documents they're waiting on, that kind of direct conversation is worth a lot more than guessing from the outside.

0 coins

Two different people in this thread have mentioned Claimyr now. I'm going to try it tomorrow morning. Fingers crossed I actually get a live person.

0 coins

I keep seeing Claimyr mentioned whenever people are stuck with NYSDOL adjudication issues. Makes sense — waiting on the phone for hours is just not realistic for most people trying to find work at the same time.

0 coins

There's a thing people mix up here that's worth clearing up — a misconduct disqualification and a fraud/theft criminal matter are two separate things. NYSDOL can deny your UI claim for misconduct without that meaning you face any criminal exposure, and vice versa. Some people assume a UI denial means they're being reported for theft — usually not the case. NYSDOL is determining benefit eligibility, not filing a police report. Your employer could potentially file one separately but that has nothing to do with your UI claim determination.

0 coins

I hadn't even thought about that angle honestly. I'm not worried about criminal stuff since the material was literally trash but it's good to know those are separate processes.

0 coins

This is accurate. NYSDL disqualification and employer-filed theft charges are completely separate tracks. Most employers in warehouse situations don't bother pursuing criminal complaints over scrap material — it would cost them more in attorney time than the material was worth.

0 coins

My HR told me they were 'considering further action' when they fired me for a different policy thing. Nothing ever came of it. A lot of that language is just intimidation.

0 coins

If NYSDOL does deny your claim after adjudication, you have 30 days from the date on the determination letter to file an appeal. At the appeal stage you get an actual hearing with an Administrative Law Judge where you can present your evidence directly. The standard of proof at the ALJ level tends to be more favorable to claimants than the initial determination. So even if the first decision goes against you, the fight isn't over.

0 coins

30 days from the determination letter — noted. And do I keep filing weekly claims while the appeal is pending? I don't want to lose out on weeks if the appeal goes in my favor.

0 coins

Yes, keep filing every single week even if your claim is denied. If the appeal is decided in your favor, you can get paid for all the weeks you certified as long as you were filing. If you stop filing, you lose those weeks permanently. This is probably the most important practical thing in this whole thread.

0 coins

THIS. I didn't file for three weeks during my denial thinking it was pointless. When I won my appeal I lost those weeks forever. Don't make that mistake.

0 coins

How long have you been waiting so far? Two weeks in adjudication isn't that unusual for a contested separation — especially one with 'theft' listed. Some people wait six to eight weeks before getting a determination. I know that's brutal to hear when bills are due.

0 coins

Two weeks since I filed, so probably one to two weeks since it actually hit adjudication. How do I even know what stage it's at?

0 coins

Log into your Unemployment Services account and check the claim status page. It should show whether you're in adjudication or if a determination has been issued. Sometimes the letter arrives in your physical mail before the portal updates, so watch your mailbox too.

0 coins

The portal is frustratingly vague about what specifically is under review. That's exactly why talking to an actual agent through Claimyr helped me — the agent could read me exactly what the adjudicator's notes said was pending.

0 coins

People keep saying 'it depends on circumstances' and that's true, but let me be more direct about the range: if NYSDOL finds willful misconduct they can disqualify you for the full benefit year. If they find it was a good-faith misunderstanding or that you lacked notice of the rule, you can be fully approved. The difference between those two outcomes in your case is literally your ability to show you didn't knowingly break a known rule. That's your whole case right there.

0 coins

Putting it that way makes it clearer what I need to focus on. It's really about demonstrating I acted in good faith based on what I was told.

0 coins

Exactly right. Good faith reliance on supervisor instruction is a recognized defense in NYSDOL misconduct determinations. You're not inventing a loophole — you're describing a legally relevant factual circumstance.

0 coins

went thru this last year. fired for misconduct, waited 5 weeks, got approved because i showed the policy wasnt posted anywhere visible and HR couldn't prove i had ever seen it. sometimes the employer just cant back up their own claim.

0 coins

That's really encouraging. Did you have to do anything special to show the policy wasn't visible or did you just state that in your questionnaire?

0 coins

i just wrote it out in my own statement and said that in my years there i had never seen that policy in any training or posted anywhere. the burden to prove i knew it shifted to HR and they had nothing concrete.

0 coins

Employer can't just fire someone and say misconduct — they actually have to demonstrate you knew the rule existed. A lot of employers find out during the adjudication process that their documentation is weaker than they thought.

0 coins

My first instinct when I saw your post was to ask whether you kept any of the packaging material at home still — because if your employer asks NYSDOL to investigate further they sometimes get detailed. Not saying panic, just think through what a thorough review might look like from their angle and be prepared to answer questions honestly.

0 coins

The material was just cardboard and foam padding. I used some of it to pack some moving boxes. Nothing of any real value. I think any reasonable look at this would see it as de minimis.

0 coins

De minimis value is actually a relevant factor. NYSDOL has found in favor of claimants where the value of what was taken was negligible. Document what it was and approximate that it was going to be discarded — it strengthens the picture that this wasn't intentional theft of anything valuable.

0 coins

Had the same NYSDOL phone runaround for weeks on a misconduct adjudication. I ended up using Claimyr and finally had an actual conversation with an agent who walked me through what documentation would help my case. Got my determination about ten days after that call. I'm not saying it speeds up NYSDOL's process, but knowing exactly what they needed let me submit the right stuff immediately.

0 coins

Ten days after getting that information is a lot better than just waiting in the dark. I'm going to try this tomorrow.

0 coins

Having that targeted info about what the adjudicator needs is genuinely valuable. Otherwise you're guessing what to submit.

0 coins

Claimyr aside, make sure you're doing everything else right in parallel: filing your weekly certifications every week without missing one, logging your three job search activities per week as required, and keeping records of all of that. Some people get so focused on the adjudication that they forget to certify and then they have a whole separate issue to fix.

0 coins

Three job search activities per week — I've been doing two. I need to add one more. Thank you for that.

0 coins

The job search log needs to have the employer name, contact method, date, and position applied for. Keep a spreadsheet or document with that information in case you're ever audited on it.

0 coins

yes the job search audit is real. I know someone who had their benefits reviewed months later and had to produce logs for specific weeks. Keep records even after your claim resolves.

0 coins

Your case has some facts working against you on the surface — the word theft on the form — but also some real things working for you: supervisor verbal permission, the material was going to waste, it had no real value, and a management change that created a new enforcement environment. That's not a hopeless situation. I've seen worse cases get approved.

0 coins

Hearing that from people who've seen how these things go is genuinely helpful. I've been treating this as a lost cause and that framing isn't helping me prepare.

0 coins

Treat it as a winnable case because it may well be one. Write your statement carefully, gather what you can, respond to everything NYSDOL sends, and don't give up after a first denial if it comes to that.

0 coins

To answer your original question directly since I haven't seen anyone just say it plainly: getting fired for stealing doesn't automatically disqualify you from UI in New York. It triggers an adjudication review. Whether you're disqualified depends on what NYSDOL finds about whether it was intentional, whether you knew the rule, and whether the employer can prove it. You have a real chance here.

0 coins

Thank you. That's the clearest answer to my actual question and I really needed to hear it laid out that simply.

0 coins

The word theft on the form is the employer's characterization. NYSDOL makes their own determination about what happened. Those are two different things.

0 coins

Came here to say exactly what this person said. The employer's label doesn't decide your eligibility — the adjudicator's finding does.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure