Are you eligible for unemployment if you get fired? My NYSDOL situation
So I got let go from my warehouse job last month and I'm honestly not sure where I stand. My manager called me in and said they were terminating me for 'performance issues' but honestly the whole thing felt like it came out of nowhere - I'd never had a written warning or anything documented. I filed for UI through NYSDOL right after and now my claim has been sitting in adjudication for over two weeks with no movement. I keep seeing conflicting stuff online about whether being fired automatically disqualifies you or not. Some sites say you're fine if it wasn't serious misconduct, other sites say any firing is a disqualification. I work in a warehouse and have been there for about 3 years so the wages are definitely there to qualify. Can anyone who's actually been through this explain how NYSDOL treats terminations vs. layoffs? I'm starting to panic a little.
79 comments

Andre Rousseau
My first job out of college I got fired and I was terrified I'd get nothing. The key distinction NYSDOL makes isn't just 'fired vs. laid off' - it's about whether you were terminated for what they call disqualifying misconduct. Basically if your employer can show you intentionally violated a rule or behaved in a way that a reasonable person would know could get them fired, that's where you can run into trouble. But poor performance, downsizing, or personality clashes? Those usually don't meet that bar. NYSDOL will reach out to your former employer to get their side, and then an adjudicator reviews both accounts. The adjudication period you're seeing is exactly that review happening. You should still file your weekly claims during this whole wait even though you won't get paid yet - those weeks are protected and if you're approved they'll pay them all out.
0 coins
Carmen Ortiz
AuthorMy weekly claims are filed, I've been doing those. What I'm wondering is whether 'performance issues' as a reason counts as misconduct in their eyes or if it falls into the other category.
0 coins
Andre Rousseau
Performance-based stuff almost never qualifies as disqualifying misconduct under how NYSDOL interprets it. Misconduct is more like showing up drunk repeatedly, stealing, or deliberately ignoring safety rules after being warned. If they just said you weren't meeting targets or weren't a good fit, that works in your favor in adjudication.
0 coins
Zoe Papadakis
This is accurate. My termination letter said 'failure to meet performance benchmarks' and I still got approved after a 3-week adjudication. NYSDOL interpreted it as not rising to the level of misconduct.
0 coins
Jamal Carter
Two weeks of adjudication and no way to get a straight answer from NYSDOL is genuinely brutal. I was in the same boat earlier this year - fired for 'attitude issues' which my employer tried to frame as gross misconduct. I needed to actually speak with someone at NYSDOL to understand what was happening with my case. I'd tried phoning for days and kept getting the busy signal or the system dropping me after 40 minutes on hold. A friend mentioned Claimyr - it basically sits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up talking to a live agent without spending your whole day on the phone. You can check it out at claimyr.com and there's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. Once I got an agent on the line she explained exactly where my adjudication was and what documentation they still needed. Got approved about a week after that.
0 coins
Carmen Ortiz
AuthorI've been trying the phone route and it's been useless. Getting dropped after a long wait is so demoralizing. I'll look into Claimyr for sure, thanks.
0 coins
AstroAdventurer
My situation was almost identical - fired for something vague and adjudication just sitting there. I tried Claimyr after seeing it mentioned somewhere else and finally talked to an actual person at NYSDOL who could look at my file. It made a huge difference just knowing what was actually happening.
0 coins
Mei Liu
Does talking to an agent actually speed anything up though? I always assumed adjudication just runs its own timeline regardless.
0 coins
Jamal Carter
In my experience the agent flagged that they were waiting on a document from me that I didn't even know they needed. So it wasn't that the agent rushed anything, it was that I found out there was a blockage I could actually fix.
0 coins
Liam O'Sullivan
The thing nobody prepares you for when you get fired is that NYSDOL essentially runs a mini-investigation. I was terminated from a retail management job about a year ago and I went into it thinking I'd just get denied because I was fired. What actually happens is they send your former employer a questionnaire asking them to describe the circumstances of the separation. If the employer claims misconduct, NYSDOL looks at whether it was a one-time thing or a pattern, whether you were warned, and whether the punishment fits what happened. In my case my employer said I had 'repeated attendance issues' but I had documentation showing approved FMLA-related absences. I submitted that and was approved.
0 coins
Carmen Ortiz
AuthorMy employer never gave me written warnings so I don't have much documentation from their side. Would it help to write out my own account of what happened?
0 coins
Liam O'Sullivan
Absolutely yes. NYSDOL gives you an opportunity to submit a statement from your perspective during adjudication. Write out the timeline - when you were hired, what your performance reviews said historically, that there were no written warnings, and your understanding of why you were let go. The more specific the better.
0 coins
Amara Chukwu
I submitted a statement with dates and my old performance reviews from the previous year and it really seemed to help my case. Keep it factual, not emotional.
0 coins
Giovanni Conti
they also look at whether you were given a chance to improve right?? like a PIP or something before being fired
0 coins
Fatima Al-Hashimi
FIRED FOR PERFORMANCE after 3 years with no warnings and you're worried about being denied?? I'll be honest that makes me so frustrated on your behalf. The bar for disqualifying misconduct is genuinely high - we're talking about egregious stuff, not 'this person wasn't hitting numbers.' NYSDOL isn't just going to take your former employer's word for it either. They assess both sides. I've seen people get approved after being fired for all kinds of things that sounded bad on paper. The adjudication process exists specifically for situations like yours where the reason for termination is disputed or vague.
0 coins
Carmen Ortiz
AuthorYeah the lack of any prior warnings is what I keep coming back to. It really did feel sudden and unjustified.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Hashimi
DOCUMENT THAT. Write it all down now while it's fresh. No written warnings, no formal disciplinary process, no PIP. That's your case right there.
0 coins
NeonNova
Agreed this situation sounds like a strong case for approval. The vagueness of 'performance issues' without documented steps taken by the employer is very hard for them to use as a disqualification argument at NYSDOL.
0 coins
Dylan Campbell
My layoff happened in a weird way where my company told me it was 'restructuring' but then filed the separation paperwork as a voluntary quit which threw everything into chaos. So I ended up in a much messier situation than a standard firing case, but I learned a ton about how NYSDOL handles these things. The separation reason on the employer's paperwork matters a lot. If they filed yours as misconduct termination vs. simple termination without cause, that changes what adjudication looks like. You can actually ask NYSDOL what reason code your former employer submitted. That was huge information for me once I finally got an agent on the phone.
0 coins
Carmen Ortiz
AuthorI had no idea you could ask what reason code the employer filed. That's actually really helpful - would an agent be able to just tell you that over the phone?
0 coins
Dylan Campbell
Yes, any NYSDOL agent can pull up your claim and see the employer-submitted separation reason. It's not hidden from you. That was the piece of info that unlocked my whole situation.
0 coins
Sofia Hernandez
My employer filed my termination incorrectly too and it caused a 5-week adjudication delay. Getting that clarified with an agent was the only way I got it sorted.
0 coins
Dmitry Kuznetsov
wait so employers can basically say whatever they want on that form and NYSDOL just believes them first?
0 coins
Dylan Campbell
Not exactly - NYSDOL contacts the employer separately too and cross-references. But if the employer's initial filing says 'voluntary quit' when you were actually fired, that discrepancy has to get resolved in adjudication which is why it takes longer.
0 coins
Ava Thompson
I lost a customer service job two years ago under pretty similar circumstances - fired for 'unprofessional conduct' but I'd never been written up. At that point I had zero idea how the whole misconduct determination worked. Turns out the distinction NYSDOL draws is between ordinary workplace mistakes or disagreements versus intentional, knowing violations of a reasonable rule. If someone gets fired for something a normal person couldn't have known would get them fired, that usually doesn't count as disqualifying misconduct either. My case went through adjudication and came out approved.
0 coins
Carmen Ortiz
AuthorHow long did your adjudication take, and did you have to do anything during it or just wait?
0 coins
Ava Thompson
Mine took 19 days total. I didn't have to do anything active during it but I did make sure my weekly claims were filed on time throughout. When the decision came it was mailed to me and also showed up in my Unemployment Services portal.
0 coins
Miguel Ramos
My adjudication was 23 days. I was going out of my mind but the payment for all those pending weeks came through at once after approval which was a relief at least.
0 coins
Zainab Ibrahim
My whole situation dragged on partly because I couldn't get any information about where my adjudication actually stood. I tried phoning NYSDOL every single morning for a week and a half and either got a busy signal immediately or sat on hold until the system eventually dropped me. What ended up working was using Claimyr - it took care of the hold time for me and I ended up speaking directly with a NYSDOL agent who could actually see my file. She told me my former employer had submitted documentation I hadn't responded to, which I didn't even know existed. Once I submitted my response the adjudication wrapped up in about 4 days.
0 coins
Carmen Ortiz
AuthorThis is the second mention of Claimyr in this thread and honestly I'm going to try it today. The phone situation has been incredibly frustrating.
0 coins
Zainab Ibrahim
The piece I didn't expect was that the agent could see everything in my file - including employer submissions I didn't know about. Without that conversation I might have just kept waiting indefinitely.
0 coins
StarSailor
my brother went through something similar last spring, could not get through to anyone at nysdol for weeks, eventually someone he knew suggested a third party service for the hold issue and once he talked to an agent his claim moved within days. the hold time is genuinely the biggest obstacle
0 coins
Connor O'Brien
My firing came with the words 'we're letting you go, effective immediately' and absolutely nothing else. No paperwork given to me that day, no specific reason stated. I was terrified that NYSDOL would just deny me because I couldn't provide a reason for the termination. What actually happened is NYSDOL contacted my employer who also couldn't provide specifics, and I got approved. If your employer can't document actual misconduct, they're going to have a hard time making that case to the adjudicator. The burden isn't really on you to prove you weren't guilty of misconduct - it shifts to them to prove you were.
0 coins
Carmen Ortiz
AuthorThat framing really helps - I've been thinking about it backwards, like I need to prove my innocence.
0 coins
Connor O'Brien
That's exactly the trap. The default in New York is that a fired worker is eligible unless the employer can demonstrate disqualifying misconduct. It's not on you to prove a negative.
0 coins
Yara Sabbagh
I wish someone had told me this before my first unemployment claim after being fired. I basically apologized in my statement to NYSDOL which probably looked weird. Still got approved but I definitely undermined myself.
0 coins
Keisha Johnson
this is a really important point that i don't see explained clearly anywhere on the NYSDOL website either
0 coins
Paolo Rizzo
My termination happened at a small company where the owner basically made up reasons after the fact. The employer told NYSDOL I was fired for insubordination but I had texts showing my manager had asked me to do something I did do. What helped me was that NYSDOL adjudicators are used to employer-employee disputes and they're not automatically on either side. They're looking for documented, verifiable evidence. Personal grudges and vague claims without records don't hold up well. If your employer is claiming performance issues but can't show a documented performance improvement plan or formal warnings, their case is weak.
0 coins
Carmen Ortiz
AuthorMy employer definitely cannot show any of that because none of it existed. I appreciate hearing these real examples so much.
0 coins
Paolo Rizzo
Keep all your own records too - old emails, any performance reviews you were given, anything that shows the company's characterization of your work doesn't match reality.
0 coins
QuantumQuest
Yep this matches what I've seen. After my own adjudication mess I ended up learning a lot about how NYSDOL evaluates employer documentation vs. employee statements. For anyone struggling to actually reach NYSDOL during their adjudication - Claimyr is worth knowing about, it handles the hold time so you get to an actual live agent at NYSDOL. The agent I spoke with walked me through exactly what my file showed and what I could submit to help my case.
0 coins
Amina Sy
My girlfriend got fired last year from a nursing home for supposedly being rude to a patient but there was zero written complaint and the nursing home couldn't produce any incident reports. NYSDOL approved her UI claim after a 2.5 week adjudication. The nursing home tried to fight it and lost at that stage too. The adjudication system really does function as a filter for bad-faith employer claims.
0 coins
Carmen Ortiz
AuthorHearing real approval stories is genuinely helping my anxiety about this. Thank you.
0 coins
Amina Sy
The wait is brutal but the system is more claimant-friendly than it seems from the outside when the employer doesn't have documentation to back up their claims.
0 coins
Oliver Fischer
my experience was similar, employer claimed gross misconduct but had literally no paper trail and I was approved in under 3 weeks
0 coins
Natasha Petrova
I had my claim stuck in adjudication after a firing last year and was going absolutely insane trying to figure out what was happening. What really freaked me out was seeing 'pending adjudication' for so long with no status change - I thought it meant I was going to be denied. Actually it just means they haven't made a decision yet, not that it's going badly. Approved AND denied both look like 'pending adjudication' right up until the determination letter goes out.
0 coins
Carmen Ortiz
AuthorOh wow I did not know that. I've been reading 'pending adjudication' as like a warning sign.
0 coins
Natasha Petrova
No it just means it's in the queue being reviewed. The status doesn't distinguish between 'leaning toward approved' and 'leaning toward denied' - you won't know until the letter comes.
0 coins
Andre Rousseau
This is true and an important clarification. The portal status is very minimal in the information it gives you, which is why talking to an actual NYSDOL agent can be so valuable during this period.
0 coins
Javier Morales
Three weeks into my own adjudication I genuinely thought I was done. I had been fired from a food distribution job and my employer told NYSDOL I had falsified delivery records which I absolutely had not done. I had to submit counter-documentation including route logs and supervisor messages. The process was stressful but once I submitted everything the adjudicator actually weighed it carefully. The determination came down in my favor. What I want anyone reading this to understand is that adjudication is a real process with real review - it's not just a rubber stamp on whatever the employer says.
0 coins
Carmen Ortiz
AuthorThis gives me hope. I think my employer's claim is weak and I'm going to submit a detailed statement today.
0 coins
Javier Morales
Do it now while the details are freshest. Be specific about dates, any performance conversations that were informal and undocumented, your tenure and what your reviews historically showed.
0 coins
NeonNova
My former employer also tried to overstate what happened and I was really worried the adjudicator would just believe them. But the lack of documentation on the employer's side is legitimately weighty in NYSDOL's evaluation. The adjudicators do scrutinize the employer's submission, not just take it at face value.
0 coins
Liam O'Sullivan
My determination letter actually cited the absence of prior written warnings as a significant factor in the decision to approve my claim. So the documentation gap works in your favor when it's the employer who failed to document a disciplinary process.
0 coins
Emma Davis
I know someone who thought getting fired for 'policy violation' would automatically disqualify them because it sounded official. NYSDOL still approved the claim because the policy violation was something minor like wearing the wrong shirt, which no reasonable person would know was a fireable offense. The specifics of what the alleged violation was matter a lot - vague labels like 'performance issues' or 'policy violation' don't tell NYSDOL anything on their own.
0 coins
Carmen Ortiz
AuthorThe vagueness of my situation might actually be helping me here then. 'Performance issues' is about as vague as it gets.
0 coins
Emma Davis
Exactly. NYSDOL adjudicators are looking for specifics. What rule was broken, was it known to the employee, was there a pattern or was it isolated. 'Performance issues' doesn't answer any of those questions from the employer's side.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Hashimi
This is why employers who fire people without documentation tend to lose at adjudication AND at appeals. They haven't built a defensible record.
0 coins
GalaxyGlider
My first week after being fired I was on the NYSDOL website for hours trying to understand whether I'd even qualify. The information is kind of buried and not super clearly written. What I eventually pieced together: NY unemployment eligibility after firing basically comes down to whether your employer can prove you intentionally did something you knew could get you fired. Things like theft, violence, deliberate sabotage - those are the clearest cases of disqualifying misconduct. Someone just not hitting metrics or having a rough patch? Almost never disqualifying.
0 coins
Carmen Ortiz
AuthorI remember reading those pages too and not being able to get a clear answer. The plain-language version you wrote is actually easier to understand.
0 coins
GalaxyGlider
The official language is really opaque. 'Misconduct' sounds scary but the legal definition NYSDOL applies is quite specific and excludes most of what employees actually get fired for in everyday situations.
0 coins
Miguel Ramos
My HR person tried to tell me I'd definitely be denied because I was fired. That was completely wrong. HR people at companies aren't always accurate about what NYSDOL will actually determine.
0 coins
Malik Robinson
The adjudication period for me was actually useful even though it felt like purgatory. Because I had to gather documentation for my statement I ended up organizing everything - old emails, performance reviews, offer letter, anything showing my history at the company. That stuff ended up being useful when I also filed a complaint with the labor board separately for unpaid expenses. If you're in adjudication right now, use the waiting time to get your records together even if you end up not needing all of it.
0 coins
Carmen Ortiz
AuthorI've been doing exactly that actually - pulling together old emails and reviews. It feels productive at least.
0 coins
Malik Robinson
That's the right instinct. Your old performance reviews especially - if they were positive and your employer is now claiming you were a performance problem, that's a direct contradiction they'll have to explain.
0 coins
Yara Sabbagh
I compiled a full timeline document with dates and bullet points and I think it made my statement to NYSDOL much clearer than if I'd just written a paragraph.
0 coins
Isabella Silva
My claim was approved after I was fired for allegedly missing too many shifts, but what actually happened was my schedule kept getting changed without notice and I was showing up for the shifts I had been told about. I submitted a text thread with my manager that showed the last-minute changes and that was enough. The adjudicator's written determination said the absences were not willful or intentional. If you have any kind of documentation that tells a different story than what your employer is claiming, submit it. You don't need a lawyer to participate in NYSDOL adjudication.
0 coins
Carmen Ortiz
AuthorI keep wondering if I need to get a lawyer involved. Sounds like for adjudication that's not necessary?
0 coins
Isabella Silva
For the initial adjudication you really don't. It's essentially an administrative review of documents. Lawyers come into play more if you end up at a formal appeal hearing before an administrative law judge, which is a whole separate process if you're denied.
0 coins
Amara Chukwu
I went through adjudication without any legal help and was fine. The appeal hearing is a different level of formality where having some representation can be more helpful, but initial adjudication is designed to be accessible without it.
0 coins
Giovanni Conti
agreed adjudication is not like court at all, it's more like submitting your side of the story and letting the administrator sort it out
0 coins
Ravi Choudhury
My adjudication wrapped up with an approval and then about two months later I got a notice saying my former employer was appealing the decision. I had no idea employers could do that. They can. So even if you get approved at adjudication, your employer might take it to an appeal hearing. If that happens you do get to participate and present your case again. I ended up winning that too but it was an extra few stressful months.
0 coins
Carmen Ortiz
AuthorI had no idea employers could appeal an approval. How much notice do you get if that happens?
0 coins
Ravi Choudhury
You get a formal notice by mail from NYSDOL with the hearing date, and you have time to prepare. The whole process has deadlines and you do get advance notice. It was stressful but survivable.
0 coins
NeonNova
Employer appeals after a claimant approval aren't that common in ordinary termination cases. They happen more when the employer genuinely disputes facts and believes they can win at a hearing. If your employer doesn't have strong documentation their incentive to appeal is lower.
0 coins
Freya Andersen
I read this whole thread because I'm dealing with something adjacent - I resigned but my employer is claiming I was fired. So the direction of the dispute is reversed for me. What I gathered from reading everyone here is that NYSDOL is going to look for documented evidence from both sides and that neither the employer nor the employee gets automatic credibility. My situation is different from a fired-with-no-misconduct case but the underlying principle seems the same.
0 coins
Carmen Ortiz
AuthorYour situation sounds genuinely complicated. I hope adjudication goes well for you.
0 coins
Andre Rousseau
Separation disputes where both parties characterize it differently are common. NYSDOL adjudicators deal with that frequently. Submit everything you have that speaks to whether you resigned or were fired - texts, emails, termination paperwork if any.
0 coins
Freya Andersen
My biggest piece of evidence is an email from my manager that says 'we're terminating your employment' in writing so I feel okay about where I stand. Just waiting through the process like everyone else.
0 coins