Back to New York Unemployment

Lucas Parker

Alternate base period unemployment - did NYSDOL tell you about this option?

My standard base period claim got denied last month because I'd switched jobs twice in the past year and didn't have enough wages in those four calendar quarters. I was completely blindsided - I'd been working steadily, just not in the quarters NYSDOL was looking at. A coworker mentioned something called an alternate base period that uses more recent wages, and I had no idea this was even a thing. When I went back to look at my denial notice it didn't say anything about applying under a different base period. Had to dig through the NYSDOL website for 45 minutes before I found anything useful. Has anyone actually gone through the process of requesting an alternate base period review after getting denied? Do I have to file a whole new claim or is there a way to flag this within my existing case? I'm worried about the timeline because I've already lost three weeks of benefits while figuring this out.

Claimyr worked for me when I was stuck in exactly this kind of situation - couldn't get anyone at NYSDOL on the phone for days, and I needed answers about my base period wages fast. What it does is wait on hold with NYSDOL so you end up talking directly to a live agent. Took way less time than I'd burned trying on my own. Check out claimyr.com and there's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE - worth looking at before you spend another afternoon on hold.

0 coins

My hold attempts have been brutal so far - two hours yesterday before the line dropped. Going to look into this.

0 coins

Used it last spring for an adjudication question and had an agent on the line way faster than I expected. Definitely a real option when you're stuck.

0 coins

Sounds useful. My problem is I need the agent to actually understand alternate base period stuff, not just route me somewhere else.

0 coins

Wages from your most recent completed quarter - that's what the alternate base period adds in. The standard base period looks at the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters. When NYSDOL reviews under the alternate period, they shift the window to include your most recently completed quarter instead. So if you earned heavily in that quarter and it was being excluded before, you might clear the monetary threshold now. You do NOT have to file a brand new claim - you request an alternate base period reconsideration on your existing denial. The form you want is called the Monetary Determination request and you usually have 30 days from the denial date to submit it.

0 coins

Mine was actually about Q4 of last year where I had significant earnings - that quarter was sitting right outside my standard base period window. This sounds like exactly the fix.

0 coins

30 days goes fast though. OP has already lost three weeks so they need to move on this immediately.

0 coins

My denial letter said nothing about alternate base period as an option either. Had to find out from a friend who works in HR. NYSDOL really should include that information automatically.

0 coins

wait does this apply if you were self employed for part of the base period? asking for myself lol

0 coins

THREE WEEKS and they still haven't told you about the alternate base period option?? This is exactly the problem with NYSDOL - they deny claims and expect you to somehow know about every possible remedy on your own. The denial notices are written to be as unhelpful as possible. I had the same situation two years ago and spent weeks assuming I was just out of luck before someone on a forum like this told me about ABP. The system is designed to make you give up.

0 coins

Thinking it was just a hard denial with no path forward - that's where I was too before I learned ABP existed. These notices really do leave out critical info.

0 coins

Frustration is completely valid here. Mine had a boilerplate paragraph about appeal rights but nothing about alternate base period as a separate remedy. Those are two totally different things.

0 coins

yeah the letters are terrible. mine had a table with numbers i couldnt figure out and just said insufficient wages. thats it.

0 coins

My alternate base period request last year took about three weeks to process after I submitted the reconsideration paperwork. Here's how the wage threshold actually worked in my case: under the standard window I had something like $2,800 in covered wages, well under the minimum. Once they shifted to the alternate base period and included my Q4, that number jumped to over $6,500 and I qualified. The key thing to know is that NYSDOL has to offer you the alternate base period review if you don't qualify under the standard period - it's not optional on their end. If your denial didn't reflect that they ran the alternate calculation, that's worth raising explicitly when you request reconsideration.

0 coins

Mandatory on their end is news to me - I assumed it was something I had to know to ask for. That changes how I'm going to frame my reconsideration request.

0 coins

My agent confirmed this when I eventually got through to someone. They're supposed to run both calculations automatically. When they don't, reconsideration is the right path.

0 coins

Even if they're supposed to do it automatically, the reality is claims fall through the cracks all the time. Always worth checking your monetary determination letter carefully to see if ABP was even considered.

0 coins

Claimyr actually helped me get the alternate base period question resolved a lot faster. My situation was similar - denied on standard base period, needed to talk to someone who could actually pull up my wage record and confirm whether the alternate calculation would flip the outcome. Ended up with a live NYSDOL agent who walked me through exactly which quarters were in each window and what my wages looked like under both.

0 coins

That's the specific thing I need - an agent who can look at both base period windows side by side with my actual wage data. Good to know that's something they can do over the phone.

0 coins

did you have to give them your SS number on the call or does the agent already have your file?

0 coins

Having someone walk through both windows with the actual numbers sounds incredibly useful. That would have saved me a week of trying to calculate this myself from partial records.

0 coins

Your UI monetary determination letter should have a table showing covered wages by quarter. If you look at which quarters are listed and compare to the alternate base period window - which would include the most recently completed quarter - you can often do a rough check yourself before even calling. The minimum qualifying wage under New York UI is roughly 1.5 times the high quarter wages spread across at least two quarters, though NYSDOL runs the exact formula. If your recent quarter had high wages that aren't in the standard window, the alternate base period switch often makes a dramatic difference.

0 coins

NYSDOL's formula language is intentionally confusing though. 'High quarter' sounds straightforward but people get tripped up on what counts as covered wages vs total earnings.

0 coins

My determination letter had the quarterly breakdown but I had no idea what I was looking at without someone explaining it. The labels aren't intuitive at all.

0 coins

wait so freelance income doesn't count as covered wages?? i thought all income qualified

0 coins

Covered wages threw me off completely when I went through this. My assumption had been that any money I earned counted toward the base period - didn't realize W-2 employment wages and 1099 income are treated completely differently. NYSDOL only counts wages paid by employers who pay into the unemployment insurance system. So even if you earned a lot in the base period, if a chunk of it was freelance or gig work, it won't show up in your wage record at all.

0 coins

ugh that explains so much about my situation. i had a lot of doordash income mixed in and wondered why my wages looked wrong

0 coins

Exactly right on covered wages. The alternate base period doesn't fix the covered vs uncovered issue - it only helps if you have qualifying W-2 wages in a quarter that wasn't captured by the standard window.

0 coins

That's a really useful distinction. My situation is all W-2 from two traditional employers so I think I'm okay on the covered wages side, just the wrong quarters were being counted.

0 coins

My reconsideration request under alternate base period got approved but I want to flag that the backdating issue is real. When you get approved under ABP after an initial denial, your benefit start date typically goes back to your original claim date - you don't lose those weeks permanently. At least that's how mine worked out. Worth asking the agent specifically about the effective date when you get through to someone, because if they try to start benefits from the reconsideration approval date you'd be missing weeks you're owed.

0 coins

This is exactly what I was worried about. Three weeks in already, didn't want to find out later I'd lost them permanently. Good to hear the original claim date holds.

0 coins

My experience matched this. The effective date stayed tied to my original filing date and the weeks between denial and approval were paid out once the reconsideration came through. That said, you do still need to have been certifying weekly during that period.

0 coins

oh no did you have to keep filing weekly certifications even during the denial period? nobody told me to keep doing that

0 coins

Yes - keep certifying every week even if your claim shows denied. If you stop, you can lose credit for those weeks even after approval. This is one of the most common mistakes people make during reconsideration.

0 coins

Certifications during denial - completely missed that. My claim has been in denied status for two weeks and I stopped filing because I thought there was nothing to certify for. Is there any way to fix missed certifications retroactively or is that a separate battle?

0 coins

Backdating weekly certifications is possible but requires contacting NYSDOL directly. It's not guaranteed and the agent has discretion on whether to approve it. The sooner you file for those weeks the better chance you have.

0 coins

My missed certifications from a gap period got approved when I explained the situation - that I'd received a denial notice and genuinely didn't know to keep certifying. Having a clear reason helped. Document everything about when you got the denial and when you found out to continue.

0 coins

NYSDOL absolutely should send notice telling people to continue certifying during reconsideration. Instead they let people unknowingly forfeit weeks of benefits they'd otherwise be owed. It's infuriating.

0 coins

Claimyr is what finally got me an agent who could actually handle the backdating question on my missed certifications - same situation, denied, stopped filing, then found out I should have kept going. The agent I reached was able to look at my claim history and walk me through the process for requesting those weeks retroactively right on the call.

0 coins

That's exactly the kind of agent access I need right now. Going to look into this today.

0 coins

Retroactive certification is the kind of thing that really does need a live agent, can't do it through the online system as far as I know.

0 coins

A live agent reviewing claim history in real time sounds way more useful than submitting a written request and waiting weeks for a response.

0 coins

Alternate base period requests that involve backdated certifications and wage adjustments - those are the ones that tend to get complicated in the NYSDOL system. The reconsideration itself might go smoothly but then the payment processing for those earlier weeks can stall. My approval came through in about three weeks but then it took another two for the payments to actually post. If you're watching your Unemployment Services account and the status flips to approved but no payment hits immediately, that lag is apparently normal even if annoying.

0 coins

Two more weeks after approval is a long wait when you're already this many weeks out. Good to know so I'm not panicking when the status changes but the money isn't there yet.

0 coins

mine took forever to post too. kept refreshing like every hour lol

0 coins

Does that payment delay also apply if the original claim had no wages posted yet and NYSDOL had to request wage records from employers?

0 coins

Employer wage records are another delay point nobody warns you about. My alternate base period reconsideration got held up because one of my employers hadn't reported my Q4 wages to NYSDOL yet - apparently there's a lag between when employers submit and when it shows in the system. NYSDOL sent a request to the employer to verify, and that added almost a month to my timeline.

0 coins

Wage reporting lag is real and it's one reason why claims filed shortly after a quarter ends can run into issues. The employer has a reporting deadline but NYSDOL's system doesn't always show those wages immediately.

0 coins

If you suspect this is your situation you can ask the agent to flag the claim for a wage audit request. Gets the employer verification process moving faster than just waiting.

0 coins

My Q4 wages are from a large company so hopefully their reporting is current, but I hadn't thought about that lag at all. Adding it to the list of things to verify when I get an agent on the line.

0 coins

Wage records I actually printed from my pay stubs helped move my reconsideration faster. When I submitted the reconsideration request I included a copy of my final pay stubs from the quarter in question along with a written explanation of why I believed the alternate base period should apply. The examiner noted in the approval letter that having wage documentation up front shortened the review. Might be worth gathering that before you even submit the form.

0 coins

Pay stubs are sitting in my email from both jobs - going to put together a packet before I file the reconsideration. That seems like a smart way to avoid back and forth.

0 coins

Does it have to be pay stubs or would a W-2 work? My last employer was slow getting paperwork out.

0 coins

W-2 works and so does a letter from the employer confirming wages paid in the quarter. The key is having something that shows the specific dollar amounts in the specific quarter you're claiming under the alternate period.

0 coins

its wild how much you have to know to navigate all this. i went through alternate base period stuff last year and had no idea until weeks in that i even had that option. they really should have like a checklist when you get denied that explains every possible next step. the fact that ppl are finding this out from random forum posts instead of from NYSDOL directly is a problem

0 coins

The denial letters are written by lawyers to limit NYSDOL's liability, not to actually inform you of your options. That's the cynical read but I believe it after what I went through.

0 coins

My denial letter had a URL to the appeals section of the website but the alternate base period reconsideration process is listed under a completely different section. Easy to miss if you don't know to look.

0 coins

Claimyr was the thing that broke my logjam on this exact issue. My alternate base period reconsideration had been sitting for three weeks with no update in my Unemployment Services account and I couldn't get through to anyone to find out if something was stuck. Once I had a live agent looking at my file, turns out there was a wage verification flag that nobody had acted on - the agent cleared it in about five minutes. Would have sat there indefinitely otherwise.

0 coins

Flags sitting unworked in the system is incredibly common from what I've heard. Without someone actively looking at your file, those things just age out.

0 coins

A five-minute fix for something that was silently blocking my claim for weeks - that's what terrifies me about this process. No way to know if something like that is happening unless you can reach an agent.

0 coins

This is why the online status alone isn't enough information. 'In progress' can mean actively being worked or it can mean sitting untouched with a flag nobody's looked at.

0 coins

My timeline summary for anyone going through this: filed original claim, standard base period denial came 10 days later, submitted alternate base period reconsideration request with wage documentation 5 days after that, approval came 18 days after submission. Total time from original filing to first payment was about 7 weeks including the two-week payment processing lag. Not fast but survivable once I understood the process. The key milestones to watch in your Unemployment Services account are the monetary determination update and then the payment schedule.

0 coins

Seven weeks total is sobering but at least it has an end. I'm already three weeks in so if the timeline holds I might be looking at four more weeks - that's manageable if I know to expect it.

0 coins

Does the clock restart at all if NYSDOL has to reach out to your employer for wage verification? Worried that could blow up the timeline significantly.

0 coins

Employer wage verification added about two weeks to a friend's reconsideration. Build that in as a contingency if your wages aren't already in the NYSDOL system.

0 coins

Appeals vs reconsideration - two completely different things and the confusion between them costs people weeks. Reconsideration under alternate base period is about whether you monetarily qualify and goes back to the claims examiner level. An appeal is a formal legal proceeding if you were denied for eligibility reasons like misconduct or quitting. If you got denied purely on monetary grounds and the alternate base period might fix it, you want reconsideration, not an appeal. Filing an appeal when you need a reconsideration will route you to the wrong place and waste time.

0 coins

Went through this mixup myself - filed an appeal when I should have filed for reconsideration and it set me back about three weeks while they redirected my paperwork.

0 coins

Worth reading the denial notice carefully to identify whether it's a monetary determination denial or an eligibility denial. The notice type tells you which remedy applies.

0 coins

i definitely mixed these up at first. thought i was appealing but i was actually just getting reconsideration lol. glad it worked out anyway

0 coins

My situation might be slightly different because my denial said both insufficient wages AND a question about whether I left my last job voluntarily. Does that mean I need to do both a reconsideration AND an appeal simultaneously? Or does one have to come first?

0 coins

Both can run in parallel and sometimes need to. The monetary reconsideration addresses whether you meet the wage threshold. The eligibility question about separation gets reviewed separately. Talk to an agent because these timelines can interact in ways that are hard to predict without seeing your actual file.

0 coins

My case had dual issues too. The examiner handling my reconsideration flagged the eligibility question to a separate reviewer automatically. Didn't have to manage two separate filings myself - but I'd verify that's how it works in your specific situation.

0 coins

NEVER assume NYSDOL automatically coordinates different issues on your claim. Confirm explicitly with an agent that both paths are being worked, because they absolutely can sit siloed from each other.

0 coins

My Unemployment Services account showed a different status update for the monetary determination than for the overall claim, which confused me for about a week. The claim said 'pending' but the monetary determination section said 'denied.' Once I understood those are tracked separately it made more sense. When an alternate base period reconsideration is approved, you should see the monetary determination status flip to something like 'monetary determination - eligible' even before the weekly payment statuses update.

0 coins

Had no idea those two sections update independently. Going to pay closer attention to the monetary determination section specifically since that's where the ABP change would show up first.

0 coins

the portal is so confusing. i had three different statuses showing different things at the same time and panicked thinking something was wrong with my claim

0 coins

Separating the monetary determination tracking from the overall claim status is actually useful when you're in reconsideration - it's the most direct indicator that the ABP review landed correctly.

0 coins

Updating in case this helps anyone in a similar spot: submitted my alternate base period reconsideration request today with the Q4 pay stubs attached. The NYSDOL examiner's office confirmed receipt by message in my Unemployment Services portal within about 2 hours which I did not expect. Status still shows denied at the claim level but I can see the monetary determination piece is now marked as 'under review.' Also resumed weekly certifications as advised in this thread. Going to give it the 2-3 week timeline before following up. Really grateful for everyone who responded - would have wasted another week trying to figure this out from NYSDOL's website alone.

0 coins

Receipt confirmation that fast is a good sign. Under review on the monetary determination is exactly what you want to see at this stage.

0 coins

Resuming certifications right away was the smart call. That protects those weeks regardless of how the reconsideration goes.

0 coins

Keep screenshots of everything - the receipt confirmation, the under review status, timestamps. If anything gets complicated later you'll want documentation of when things happened.

0 coins

This whole thread was incredibly helpful. Going to follow the same steps for my situation. Thanks everyone.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure