


Ask the community...
The unemployment website says average wait time is 12 minutes LMAOOOOO what a joke. I've never waited less than an hour and that's IF I can even get in the queue. Who comes up with these fake stats?
12 MINUTES??!?! 😂😂😂 maybe in some parallel universe where NY unemployment is functional
they count all the people who get instant disconnects as '0 minute wait times' to bring down the average 🤡
I feel your pain - went through this exact nightmare last year. After 6 weeks of getting nowhere with the regular phone line, I finally got connected using a callback service called Claimyr. They handle all the calling and waiting for you, then connect you when they reach an actual human. Cost me like $20 but saved literally weeks of my life sitting on hold. Got my whole claim sorted in one 15-minute call once I had an agent. The NY system is completely broken - they know people will give up if it's hard enough. Don't let them win, your benefits are money YOU paid into the system!
This is so frustrating to read about everyone going through the same thing! I'm new to this whole unemployment process and honestly didn't realize it would be this broken. It's crazy that we have to pay for third-party services just to access benefits we're entitled to. The fact that so many people are recommending the same service makes me think it might actually work though. At this point I'm willing to try anything - the stress of not being able to complete my claim is worse than any fee. Thanks for sharing your experience!
UPDATE: I got it fixed!!! It WAS the address mismatch between my license and unemployment account. I contacted ID.me support directly like @HelpfulCareerPro suggested and they told me exactly what was wrong. Had to upload additional proof of address (utility bill) but finally got verified! Already completed my recertification for this week. Thank you everyone for your help!!!
So glad you got it resolved! I'm dealing with a similar issue right now and this thread has been super helpful. Going to try contacting ID.me support directly first before going through the NYSDOL phone nightmare. Thanks for sharing the update - gives me hope!
@Zadie Patel Good luck with your verification! One tip I d'add - when you contact ID.me support, have your failed verification attempt confirmation numbers ready if you have them. They can look up your specific case faster that way. Also, if you end up needing to upload additional documents like I did, make sure they re'clear, high-resolution scans or photos. Blurry documents will just cause more delays.
I had trouble reaching NYS Department of Labor when I had questions about a similar situation. If you need to speak with someone directly about your specific circumstances, I found claimyr.com really helpful. They have a service that connects you with actual agents and there's a video demo at https://youtu.be/qyftW-mnTNI that explains how it works. Sometimes these situations have nuances that only an agent can clarify.
The whole system is frustrating when you're in a bind like this. Have you considered talking to your employer about whether they could treat this as a temporary layoff instead of FMLA? Some companies are flexible if they understand your financial situation.
That's actually a really smart suggestion @Paloma Clark. I hadn't thought about asking to convert FMLA to a temporary layoff. Would that even be legal though? I'm worried about losing my job protection if I give up the FMLA status. But you're right that I'm in a real financial bind here.
@Alice Pierce You raise a good point about the job protection risk. Converting from FMLA to layoff would mean losing that guarantee to get your position back. It s'definitely a trade-off between immediate financial relief and long-term job security. Maybe worth discussing with HR about what options exist, but I d'be really careful about giving up FMLA protections unless you re'sure about the arrangement.
If you're having trouble getting through to NYS Department of Labor to ask questions about your claim timing, I used this service called Claimyr (claimyr.com) that helped me reach an actual agent. They have a video demo at https://youtu.be/qyftW-mnTNI showing how it works. Was way easier than sitting on hold for hours just to ask about filing deadlines and claim status.
The bigger issue is people not knowing they should file immediately. The unemployment system really doesn't do a good job of communicating these basic rules. Half the people I know who got laid off during my company's downsizing waited weeks to apply thinking they had some grace period.
Just file online at my.ny.gov ASAP. Don't overthink it. You need your social security number, employment history for the last 18 months, and your employer's info. The whole process takes maybe 20-30 minutes and then you'll start getting weekly claim forms. The longer you wait the more money you're throwing away.
This is really helpful info, thanks! Just to clarify - when you say employment history for the last 18 months, does that include all jobs even if they were part-time or temporary? I had a few different gig jobs before my warehouse position and I'm not sure if I need to include all of them or just my most recent full-time employer.
Yes, include ALL employment from the last 18 months - full-time, part-time, temporary, gig work, everything. NYS DOL uses this to calculate your benefit amount based on your earnings history. Even if a job was just a few weeks, include it. Better to over-report than miss something and have delays in processing your claim. They'll verify with all employers anyway, so being thorough upfront saves time later.
Aisha Rahman
Yeah my cousin works at one of the NYS Department of Labor offices and she says they're constantly backlogged. Even when unemployment rates look good on paper there's still tons of people cycling through the system - seasonal workers, people between jobs, folks dealing with reduced hours. The numbers you see publicly are just a snapshot.
0 coins
Sean Murphy
•That makes me feel a bit better about my situation. I was starting to think I'd done something wrong with my application.
0 coins
Hassan Khoury
If you want more detailed breakdowns, the NYS Department of Labor also publishes their Unemployment Insurance Trust Fund reports quarterly which show total benefit payments and recipient counts by region. You can find these buried in their "Data & Statistics" section. The winter months typically see the highest claims due to construction and hospitality layoffs. What's frustrating is they don't publish real-time adjudication queue numbers, so there's no way to know if you're number 100 or 10,000 in line for review.
0 coins