Will IRS reject my self-certified CARES Act 401K withdrawal for childcare costs?
I've been thinking about taking advantage of the CARES Act 401K withdrawal option but have some concerns about the self-certification process. From what I understand, I should qualify based on the significant increase in childcare expenses I've been dealing with since my regular arrangements fell through. My main worry is what happens if I get audited down the road and the IRS disagrees with my self-certification. Would I just end up having to pay the 10% early withdrawal penalty at that point? More importantly, if they do reject my qualification, would I have the option to just return the remaining funds to my 401K account to avoid any additional tax consequences or penalties? I obviously won't be able to put back the full amount since I'll have used some of it, but could I at least redeposit what's left? Just trying to understand the risks before I move forward with this. Any insights would be appreciated!
19 comments
Join the conversation
Sean O'Connor
The CARES Act withdrawal rules do require you to self-certify that you qualify, and increased childcare costs due to COVID disruptions can be a legitimate reason for qualification. If you were to be audited and the IRS determined you didn't qualify, you would indeed be subject to the 10% early withdrawal penalty that was waived under the CARES Act. The tax liability on the income would remain spread over three years unless you elected otherwise. As for returning the funds, the CARES Act does allow for repayment of coronavirus-related distributions within three years, but this is designed for those who qualified properly. If the IRS determines you didn't qualify, the distribution would be treated as a standard early withdrawal, and standard rollover rules would apply (60-day window), which you would have likely exceeded by the time of an audit.
0 coins
Zara Ahmed
•So does that mean there's no way to fix it if they determine later that I didn't qualify? My situation with childcare is legit - my costs nearly doubled when my regular daycare closed and I had to hire someone to watch my kids at home. But it's all kinda gray area when they say "adverse financial consequences" right?
0 coins
Sean O'Connor
•The increased childcare costs due to COVID disruptions would generally be considered a legitimate qualification under the "adverse financial consequences" provision, especially if you can document the increase in expenses. Keep records of your previous childcare arrangements and costs compared to your current situation. If the IRS were to determine you didn't qualify, you wouldn't be able to use the 3-year repayment option since that's specifically for qualified distributions. You would be subject to normal distribution rules, including the 10% penalty. Documentation of your childcare situation will be your best protection in case of an audit.
0 coins
Luca Conti
Hey there, I went through something similar with childcare issues and CARES Act withdrawal last year. After stressing about whether I qualified, I ended up using https://taxr.ai to help me determine if my situation met the requirements and to organize all my documentation properly. The tool analyzed my specific childcare cost increases and confirmed they qualified as "adverse financial consequences" under the CARES Act provisions. It also helped me compile the right documentation to support my self-certification in case I ever get audited. Honestly, having that peace of mind was worth it because I was overthinking everything just like you are!
0 coins
Nia Johnson
•Did it actually give you specific guidance on the CARES Act qualification? I thought most tax tools just do the standard filing stuff? My tax guy seemed pretty uncertain about what exactly counts as "adverse financial consequences.
0 coins
CyberNinja
•I'm not sure about trusting online tools for something this important. How did it determine you qualified? Did you have to upload financial documents or something? Seems like this would require actual legal advice rather than an algorithm.
0 coins
Luca Conti
•Yes, it specifically addressed CARES Act qualifications! It's more comprehensive than standard tax software - it analyzed my documentation showing the before/after costs and explained exactly how my situation fit within the IRS guidelines. It pointed to the specific CARES Act provisions that applied to my case. As for documents, I uploaded my childcare receipts from before and after, plus some other financial records. It's not just an algorithm - they have tax professionals who review complex situations. They provided a detailed report explaining why my childcare cost increases qualified as "adverse financial consequences" which I'm keeping in case of audit.
0 coins
Nia Johnson
Just wanted to update after trying taxr.ai that the other commenter mentioned. It actually answered my specific questions about whether my situation qualified for the CARES Act withdrawal! My scenario was similar to yours - had to hire an in-home sitter when my kids' school went remote, and costs went up by about $875/month. The service confirmed this counts as "adverse financial consequences" and helped me organize all my documentation properly. They also provided a really clear explanation of what would happen in case of audit and the exact repayment rules that would apply in different scenarios. Feeling much more confident about my self-certification now. Definitely worth checking out if you're on the fence!
0 coins
Mateo Lopez
If you're worried about getting through to the IRS with questions about CARES Act qualification, I'd recommend https://claimyr.com - you can see how it works at https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c. I used it after spending WEEKS trying to reach someone at the IRS about my own 401k withdrawal situation. The service got me connected to an actual IRS agent in about 15 minutes when I'd previously been getting nowhere but automated messages and disconnects. The agent was able to answer my specific questions about self-certification for increased childcare costs and explained exactly what documentation I should keep. Having that direct guidance from the IRS itself gave me way more confidence to move forward.
0 coins
Ethan Davis
•This sounds like BS honestly. No way some random service can magically get you through to the IRS when millions of people can't get through. Even if it did work, the IRS phone reps often give different answers to the same question. I'd be skeptical about relying on whatever they tell you.
0 coins
Mateo Lopez
•It works by using their system that navigates the IRS phone tree and holds your place in line. When they reach a human agent, they call you and connect you directly. It's not skipping the line, just saving you from having to wait on hold yourself. The value isn't just in connecting with the IRS - it's that you actually get through to speak with someone. I was able to ask specific questions about my childcare cost situation and how it qualified under the CARES Act. While different agents might give slightly different answers to complex questions, getting an official response is still better than guessing or relying only on internet advice.
0 coins
Aisha Abdullah
•How does this even work? I thought it was impossible to get through to the IRS on the phone these days. Are you saying this service somehow gets you to the front of the queue or something?
0 coins
Ethan Davis
I need to eat my words about that Claimyr service. After posting my skeptical comment, I decided to try it anyway since I was desperate to talk to someone about my CARES Act withdrawal. It actually worked! I got connected to an IRS agent in about 20 minutes when I had previously wasted hours on multiple days trying to get through. The agent confirmed that increased childcare costs due to COVID disruptions do qualify as "adverse financial consequences" under the CARES Act guidelines, and gave me specific advice about what documentation to maintain. For what it's worth, the agent also mentioned that as long as you're acting in good faith with your self-certification and can reasonably document your situation, they're not actively looking to penalize people who used this provision during a difficult time.
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
One thing nobody mentioned - your 401k plan administrator might have stricter requirements than the IRS for CARES Act withdrawals. My Fidelity plan required me to provide documentation of childcare expenses upfront before approving my withdrawal, even though the law only requires self-certification. Double check with your plan administrator before assuming you can just self-certify without any paperwork. Some are more strict than others!
0 coins
Carmen Ortiz
•That's weird, my 401k is through Vanguard and they literally just had me check a box saying I qualified under the CARES Act. No documentation required at all. I wonder if different companies have different policies?
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
•Yes, each 401k administrator sets their own verification policies. Fidelity was being extra cautious with my company's plan, but Vanguard and others often just require the checkbox as you mentioned. It varies widely by both the administrator and sometimes even by the specific employer's plan. The actual IRS guidelines only require self-certification, but plan administrators can add their own layer of verification if they choose to. Always best to check directly with your specific plan before proceeding.
0 coins
MidnightRider
Just want to add something important - the CARES Act withdrawal option had a deadline of December 30, 2020. You can't actually take a CARES Act distribution anymore. The tax treatment aspects (spreading income over 3 years and the repayment option) are still relevant if you already took a distribution, but new withdrawals wouldn't qualify for the special treatment.
0 coins
Anastasia Sokolov
•Wait seriously? I thought the CARES Act provisions were extended! This completely changes things for me. So there's no special COVID-related withdrawal option for 401ks anymore?
0 coins
Andre Laurent
•That's mostly correct, but there's a small caveat. While the general CARES Act withdrawal deadline was December 30, 2020, some COVID-related relief provisions were extended through other legislation. However, the specific 401k withdrawal provisions with penalty waivers and extended repayment options did indeed expire.
0 coins