Why is my friend's tax return so huge? Unusual refund amount
My friend just shared that she's getting a tax refund that seems way too big. She's a single mom with two kids and works as a nurse making around $62,000. Somehow her tax return is showing she's getting back over $9,700! I'm not trying to be negative, but that sounds like a red flag to me. I file single with no dependents and make about $58,000, and I only got back $1,200 this year. She mentioned something about claiming some education credits and child tax credits, but could those really add up to that much? She used some tax service I've never heard of that a coworker recommended. I'm worried she might get audited if there's a mistake, and I don't want her to count on money that might get taken back. Has anyone else seen legitimate refunds this large? What factors could make a tax return this big for someone in her situation? Should I suggest she get a second opinion before spending that money?
19 comments
Join the conversation
Felicity Bud
That refund amount actually could be legitimate for a single parent with two children. The Child Tax Credit alone is worth up to $2,000 per qualifying child. If she's also eligible for the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) as a single parent, that could add several thousand more depending on her income. Education credits are substantial too - the American Opportunity Credit can be up to $2,500 per eligible student, and the Lifetime Learning Credit can be up to $2,000. If she or her children are in college, these would apply. Also, if she's having too much withheld from each paycheck throughout the year, that overpayment comes back as part of her refund. Many people effectively use this as a forced savings method.
0 coins
Max Reyes
•But couldn't this mean she's just giving the government an interest-free loan all year? If her withholding is that high wouldn't it be better to adjust her W-4? Also I heard the EITC phases out pretty quickly once you hit $50k, especially with only two kids. Would she even qualify at $62k?
0 coins
Felicity Bud
•You're right that overwithholding is essentially giving the government an interest-free loan, and adjusting her W-4 could put more money in each paycheck instead. Some people prefer the "forced savings" method because they know they'd spend the smaller amounts throughout the year. For EITC with two qualifying children, the phase-out begins around $43,000 for a single filer or head of household, but doesn't completely phase out until about $53,000-$55,000 depending on the exact tax year. At $62,000 she might be past the EITC range, but if she has retirement contributions or other pre-tax deductions that lower her AGI, she could still qualify for a partial credit.
0 coins
Mikayla Davison
I was in a similar situation last year and couldn't believe my refund amount. I used https://taxr.ai to double-check my return because I was convinced there was a mistake. You upload your documents and it analyzes everything to make sure your preparer didn't miss anything or make errors. It actually found an additional education credit my preparer missed! Their system identified that as a single parent, I was eligible for Head of Household filing status which has better tax rates than filing Single. It also confirmed all my dependent-related credits were calculated correctly. Really gave me peace of mind knowing my unusually large refund was legitimate.
0 coins
Adrian Connor
•How does it work with the documents? Do you just take pictures or do you have to scan everything? My tax situation is complicated with rental properties and I'm always worried my preparer misses things.
0 coins
Aisha Jackson
•I'm kinda skeptical about these online services. How do you know they're not just telling you what you want to hear? And what credentials do they have to actually verify tax stuff? The IRS is the only one who can truly approve a return.
0 coins
Mikayla Davison
•You can either take clear photos with your phone or upload scanned documents - both work great. The system recognizes all the standard tax forms and organizes everything automatically. It's really user-friendly even with complicated situations like rental properties. The service uses certified tax professionals to review the AI analysis, so you're getting real expertise, not just an algorithm. They don't actually file for you - they just verify what you're already planning to file is correct and identify potential issues or missed opportunities before you submit to the IRS. That's what made me comfortable using it.
0 coins
Aisha Jackson
I tried taxr.ai after being skeptical in my previous comment, and I'm actually really impressed. I was sure my CPA had everything optimized, but the analysis found I was eligible for a home office deduction I hadn't claimed for my side business. The verification process was much more thorough than I expected. It flagged a potential issue with how my retirement contributions were reported that could have triggered an audit flag. My refund wasn't quite as large as your friend's, but it did increase by about $1,800 after making the corrections they suggested. The peace of mind knowing everything is properly documented was worth it alone.
0 coins
Ryder Everingham
If your friend is concerned about her refund being too good to be true, she should definitely try to speak with the IRS directly to confirm everything. Of course, that's easier said than done - I spent THREE DAYS trying to get through their phone lines recently about a similar situation. After all that frustration, I found https://claimyr.com which got me connected to an actual IRS agent in under 20 minutes. You can see how it works in this video: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c - they basically navigate the phone tree and wait on hold for you, then call you when an agent is actually on the line. The IRS agent was able to review my account and confirm that my large refund was actually correct based on my eligibility for several credits. Huge relief not having to wonder if I'd get an audit notice months later!
0 coins
Lilly Curtis
•Wait how is this even possible? The IRS phone system is completely broken. Are you saying this service somehow gets priority in the queue? That doesn't seem possible or fair.
0 coins
Leo Simmons
•This sounds like a scam. Why would I pay someone else to call the IRS for me? And how would they even have access to your personal tax info to discuss with the IRS? The IRS requires identity verification before they'll talk about your specific account.
0 coins
Ryder Everingham
•They don't get priority in the queue - they use technology to continuously redial and navigate the phone system automatically when lines are busy. It's the same process you'd go through manually, just automated. When they reach a human agent, they call you and connect you directly to that agent. You're right about identity verification - they don't access your personal information at all. They simply get you connected to an agent, then you handle all the verification and discuss your specific tax situation directly with the IRS agent yourself. They're just solving the "can't get through" problem, not acting as a representative.
0 coins
Leo Simmons
I need to eat my words from my previous comment. After continuing to fail getting through to the IRS for a week straight about my suspected identity theft issue, I broke down and tried Claimyr. I was connected to an IRS representative in about 35 minutes. The service just handles the frustrating hold process - once connected, I handled all my own identity verification and discussed my situation directly with the agent. The IRS confirmed someone had attempted to file a fraudulent return in my name but their security measures caught it. I was able to verify my legitimate return and confirm my actual refund amount right away instead of waiting for letters in the mail.
0 coins
Lindsey Fry
Your friend might also be getting a large refund because of pandemic-related tax credits that were extended. The Recovery Rebate Credit was available if she missed any stimulus payments, and there were expanded child credits for part of that period. Also, does she pay for childcare? The Child and Dependent Care Credit can be worth up to $4,000 for two or more children depending on her circumstances and income. That's separate from the regular Child Tax Credit.
0 coins
Saleem Vaziri
•The Recovery Rebate Credit was only for the 2021 tax year though, right? That wouldn't apply to this current filing season unless she filed an amended return. The expanded child tax credit also reverted back to the regular amount.
0 coins
Lindsey Fry
•You're absolutely right about the Recovery Rebate Credit - that was for 2021 returns and wouldn't apply to the current filing season. I was thinking of older returns when mentioning that. The Child Tax Credit did indeed revert to the previous amount of $2,000 per qualifying child after the temporary expansion ended. The Child and Dependent Care Credit is still quite substantial though, and if her children are young enough and she pays for childcare while she works, that could be a significant portion of her refund.
0 coins
Kayla Morgan
If she's getting $9,700 back, she should really update her W-4 with her employer. She's having waaaay too much withheld from each paycheck! That's over $800 a month she could be getting in her regular pay instead of waiting for a refund. I used to do the same thing until I realized I could be using that money throughout the year for my bills or putting it into investments instead of giving the government an interest-free loan.
0 coins
James Maki
•Some people use overwithholding as a forced savings method because they know they'd spend the extra money each month if it was in their regular paycheck. When they get the lump sum refund, they can use it for something important or put it straight into savings.
0 coins
Kayla Morgan
•That's a fair point. I just think there are better ways to save like setting up automatic transfers to a high-yield savings account or retirement fund. Those options would at least earn some interest throughout the year. But you're right that for some people, the psychology of not seeing the money until the refund works better for their financial habits. It's a personal choice, just not one I'd recommend from a purely financial optimization standpoint.
0 coins