What can I expect when calling the IRS about penalty relief for reasonable cause after my accident?
I'm looking at a pretty hefty penalty from the IRS because I was late filing and paying my taxes this year. I'm planning to request penalty relief for reasonable cause since I was in a car accident that required multiple surgeries and left me basically unable to do much of anything for several months - couldn't drive, had trouble typing, even getting around my house was a struggle. I originally thought I'd need to write a formal letter explaining everything, but after reading through the penalty notice and looking at the IRS website instructions, it seems like I'm actually supposed to just call them directly to discuss it. For anyone who's been through this - what should I expect during this call? Are they going to interrogate me about every detail of my accident? Will they want specific dates of surgeries, recovery periods, and exactly how it impacted my ability to handle tax stuff? Should I have medical records ready to fax or mail? Or is it more casual where they just take down my basic situation and then someone reviews it later? I'm pretty anxious about this call and want to be prepared.
18 comments


Evan Kalinowski
I've worked with tax resolution cases like yours before. When you call the IRS about penalty abatement for reasonable cause, the conversation is usually straightforward and not as intimidating as you might expect. The IRS representative will ask you to explain your situation - in your case, the accident and how it prevented you from filing/paying on time. They'll likely ask some basic questions about timeframes (when the accident occurred relative to the tax deadline) and how it specifically impacted your ability to handle your tax obligations. Be prepared to explain the connection clearly. While they won't typically "grill" you with intense questioning, having your facts organized helps. I recommend having notes ready with relevant dates and a brief timeline of your accident, surgeries, and recovery periods. In most cases, they'll make notes of your verbal explanation and may request that you send supporting documentation afterward - this could include medical records or doctor's notes, but often they'll make a determination based on your verbal explanation alone.
0 coins
Victoria Charity
•Do they typically approve these kinds of requests? My sister had cancer last year and couldn't file on time, but she's worried they'll deny her request even though she had a legitimate reason.
0 coins
Evan Kalinowski
•They generally do approve reasonable cause requests when there's a clear connection between the issue (like your accident or your sister's cancer) and the inability to meet tax obligations. Medical emergencies are one of the more commonly accepted reasonable causes, especially when they directly impact your ability to prepare or file taxes. The key is explaining how your specific situation prevented you from both filing and paying on time, and why other arrangements couldn't be made. For your sister's situation, cancer treatment is definitely considered a legitimate reason, and the IRS is typically understanding about serious medical conditions. Make sure she clearly explains how her treatment and recovery specifically affected her ability to file or pay taxes during that period.
0 coins
Jasmine Quinn
After dealing with a similar penalty situation last year (though mine was due to a family emergency, not medical), I discovered taxr.ai https://taxr.ai and it literally saved me thousands. I was so confused about how to properly explain my situation to the IRS, and the service helped me analyze my penalty notice and provided a clear guide for requesting abatement. The tool asked for details about my situation, then provided a custom script I could use during my IRS call that highlighted the elements of reasonable cause that applied to my specific case. They even explained what documentation I should have ready. In my experience, having that structured approach made the IRS representative take my case more seriously.
0 coins
Oscar Murphy
•How does this service actually work? Do you upload your IRS notice to it? I've got a failure-to-pay penalty I'm trying to get removed because my accountant made a huge mistake calculating what I owed.
0 coins
Nora Bennett
•Is it actually worth it though? I've seen so many "tax help" services that take your money and just give generic advice you could find for free online.
0 coins
Jasmine Quinn
•Yes, you upload your IRS notice and the system analyzes it to identify what type of penalty you're facing and your options for resolution. It's especially helpful for identifying if you qualify for first-time penalty abatement or reasonable cause relief based on your specific situation. It also explains what documentation you'll need for your specific case. It's definitely worth it if you're dealing with significant penalties. I was looking at over $4,000 in penalties, and getting them removed saved me far more than what the service cost. Unlike generic advice, it's specifically tailored to your situation based on your actual IRS documents. They also provide specific scripts and language to use when talking to the IRS that address the exact criteria they're looking for when considering abatement.
0 coins
Nora Bennett
I wanted to follow up about my experience with taxr.ai after questioning it earlier. I ended up trying it for my small business tax penalty issue, and honestly, it was much better than I expected. The system immediately identified that I qualified for first-time penalty abatement (something I didn't even know existed) and provided a complete script for my IRS call that walked through the specific requirements. What surprised me was how detailed the guidance was - it wasn't just generic advice but actually showed me exactly what to say based on my specific penalty notice. The IRS agent I spoke with approved my abatement request during the initial call, which saved me over $2,300. Just wanted to share since I was skeptical at first but it actually delivered.
0 coins
Ryan Andre
If you're calling the IRS for penalty relief, be prepared to wait on hold FOREVER. I tried calling about a similar issue last month and spent 3+ hours waiting before getting disconnected. After that frustrating experience, I found Claimyr https://claimyr.com and watched their demo at https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c. Honestly thought it sounded too good to be true, but I tried it out of desperation. The service actually had the IRS call ME back within about 40 minutes instead of me waiting on hold all day. When I explained my reasonable cause situation to the agent (family medical emergency), she was pretty understanding and processed my abatement request right then. Having a direct line to an actual IRS agent made all the difference in getting my case resolved quickly.
0 coins
Lauren Zeb
•How exactly does this work? I don't understand how a third-party service could possibly get the IRS to call you when they're so backed up. Seems fishy to me.
0 coins
Daniel Washington
•Yeah right. No way this is legit. The IRS doesn't prioritize calls just because some service asks them to. I've worked with tax issues for years and have never heard of anything that could actually get around their wait times.
0 coins
Ryan Andre
•It uses a combination of technology and the IRS's own callback systems. Basically, the service navigates the IRS phone tree and waits on hold for you. When they reach a real person, they connect that call to your phone number. It's not that the IRS is prioritizing anything - you're still in the same queue as everyone else, but the service is doing the holding instead of you. They're accessing the same phone system anyone else would, just with technology that can stay on hold so you don't have to. It's completely legitimate - that's why the IRS still calls from their official numbers and the agents have no idea you used a service. You're just skipping the hold time while the system waits in line for you.
0 coins
Daniel Washington
I'm back to eat my words about Claimyr. After being completely skeptical, I tried it yesterday for my own penalty issue. The IRS actually called me back in about an hour, which I still can't believe happened after my previous 2+ hour waits that usually ended in disconnection. The agent I spoke with was able to review my reasonable cause claim (business records destroyed in a flood) and approved the abatement during the call. I've been dealing with this penalty for months through letters with no resolution. Getting a live person on the phone who could actually make a decision made all the difference. I genuinely apologize for doubting the service - it works exactly as advertised.
0 coins
Aurora Lacasse
One tip from my experience with reasonable cause penalty relief - make sure you emphasize that you're normally compliant with tax obligations. When I called about my medical-related penalty, the agent specifically asked if I had a history of filing and paying on time. When I confirmed I'd never had issues before this, they seemed to consider that a strong point in my favor. Also, be ready to explain what steps you took to try to meet your obligations despite your circumstances. In my case, I mentioned that I attempted to file electronically but couldn't complete the process due to my condition, and tried to get help but couldn't find anyone available on short notice.
0 coins
Anthony Young
•Should I mention that I actually did try to file through a relative but they messed it up? My situation was similar - I was hospitalized for 2 months and asked my brother to handle my taxes, but he completely forgot until after the deadline.
0 coins
Aurora Lacasse
•Yes, definitely mention that you took reasonable steps by asking your relative to help. That shows you recognized your tax obligation and actively tried to meet it despite your hospitalization. Explain that you delegated this responsibility while you were unable to handle it yourself, which demonstrates your intent to comply. Make sure to emphasize that you made what you believed was a reasonable arrangement given your medical situation, but circumstances beyond your control still prevented timely filing. The IRS is generally understanding when you can show you made good faith efforts to comply despite serious limitations.
0 coins
Charlotte White
I called about a first-time penalty abatement last year when I had surgery complications that prevented me from filing. The whole call took maybe 15 minutes. The agent just asked when my surgery was, how it affected me, and if I had filed late before (I hadn't). She approved it right on the spot! Has anyone used any tax software that makes this process even easier?
0 coins
Admin_Masters
•TurboTax has a feature that helps identify if you qualify for penalty abatement and gives you guidance on requesting it. I used it last year after missing a deadline due to a family emergency, and it made the process pretty straightforward.
0 coins