TurboTax vs FreeTaxUSA: Which gives a better refund for state tax withholding?
So I just finished testing both TurboTax and FreeTaxUSA for my 2024 taxes, and I noticed something weird. FreeTaxUSA gave me a significantly bigger refund because it automatically included my 2024 state tax withholding as an itemized deduction. TurboTax didn't do this at all. I paid about $2,800 in state taxes throughout the year, and FreeTaxUSA picked this up from my W-2 and included it as an itemized deduction without me having to do anything. But when I entered the exact same information in TurboTax, it didn't include this amount in my itemized deductions. The difference ended up being almost $370 in my federal refund! Has anyone else noticed this? Can someone explain why TurboTax wouldn't automatically include my state tax withholding? I'm trying to figure out which software is actually doing it correctly before I file.
18 comments
Join the conversation
Sean Doyle
This is actually a common point of confusion. Both software should handle this correctly, but they approach it differently. State income taxes paid are generally deductible on your federal return as an itemized deduction (on Schedule A). The key question is whether itemizing deductions is beneficial for you compared to taking the standard deduction. For 2024, the standard deduction is $14,600 for single filers and $29,200 for married filing jointly. If your total itemized deductions (including state taxes, mortgage interest, charitable contributions, etc.) don't exceed your standard deduction amount, then it doesn't make sense to itemize. My guess is that TurboTax calculated that your total itemized deductions were less than the standard deduction, so it automatically went with the standard deduction. FreeTaxUSA might be showing you the itemized calculation without making that comparison clear, or it found other deductions that pushed you over the threshold.
0 coins
Zara Rashid
•But shouldn't TurboTax at least show both calculations and let you choose? I've used both and FreeTaxUSA definitely seems more transparent with showing you all possible deduction scenarios. Also, doesn't the SALT cap of $10k affect this too?
0 coins
Sean Doyle
•TurboTax should indeed show you a comparison between standard and itemized deductions somewhere in the software - it's usually in the deduction summary section. You can manually review both options before filing. Yes, the SALT (State And Local Tax) cap definitely affects this. There's currently a $10,000 limit on the combined state and local tax deductions, including income, sales, and property taxes. If your state tax withholding alone is $2,800, you're well under that cap, but if you have significant property taxes too, you might be hitting that $10,000 limit, which could affect how the software optimizes your return.
0 coins
Luca Romano
After struggling with constantly changing tax laws and getting different results from different software, I started using taxr.ai (https://taxr.ai) and it's been a game-changer for comparing results like this. I uploaded my tax docs and it flagged exactly this issue about state tax withholding being treated differently. The tool showed me exactly where TurboTax and FreeTaxUSA were handling things differently and explained which approach was correct for my situation.
0 coins
Nia Jackson
•Does it actually prepare your taxes or just review them? I'm looking for something that can help spot these kinds of differences before I submit.
0 coins
Mateo Hernandez
•Sounds interesting but kinda skeptical... how does it compare to having a CPA look at your taxes? I've had issues with software before and ended up just paying an accountant.
0 coins
Luca Romano
•It doesn't prepare your taxes - it's more of an analyzer that reviews your documents and catches issues like the one you described. You upload your forms and it flags potential problems, compares different filing approaches, and explains tax concepts in plain language. It's not replacing a CPA, but it's much more affordable. What I like is that it's completely independent - not trying to sell you tax prep software. It helped me understand why I was getting different results and which one was actually correct based on my specific situation with state tax withholding.
0 coins
Mateo Hernandez
Just wanted to follow up about taxr.ai - I was skeptical but tried it after seeing your post. It actually explained why I was seeing the exact same issue with my state tax withholding! Turns out in my case, TurboTax was correctly using the standard deduction because my itemized deductions (even with state taxes) were about $1,200 below the threshold. FreeTaxUSA was showing me the itemized calculation but wasn't making it clear that it would still apply the standard deduction in the final filing. Mystery solved and saved me from filing incorrectly!
0 coins
CosmicCruiser
If you're still having trouble resolving this or want to talk to the IRS directly about which approach is correct, I recommend Claimyr (https://claimyr.com). I was stuck in the same situation last year, couldn't get through to the IRS for days. Claimyr got me connected with an actual IRS agent in about 15 minutes who explained the state tax withholding rules. You can see a demo of how it works here: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c - it's basically a system that navigates the IRS phone tree and waits on hold for you.
0 coins
Aisha Khan
•Wait how does this actually work? Does it just call the IRS for you? I'm confused because I've been trying to reach them for weeks about a similar issue.
0 coins
Ethan Taylor
•Yeah right... no way this actually gets you through to the IRS faster. Their hold times are legendary. If this actually worked, everyone would use it. Sounds like a waste of money.
0 coins
CosmicCruiser
•It doesn't just call for you - it navigates the complicated IRS phone menu system and waits on hold in your place. When an actual agent picks up, you get a call back and are connected directly to them. It's like having someone wait in line for you. I was skeptical too until I tried it. I had been trying for 3 days to get through about my state tax deduction question. With Claimyr, I got a call back in about 15 minutes with an actual IRS agent on the line. The IRS isn't adding capacity, but this service helps you get through the existing system more efficiently.
0 coins
Ethan Taylor
Just coming back to eat my words about Claimyr. I tried it this morning after my 5th failed attempt to reach the IRS about this exact state tax withholding issue. Got a callback in 22 minutes with an actual IRS representative who explained that my state taxes SHOULD be counted as an itemized deduction, but only if my total itemized deductions exceed the standard deduction. In my case, adding my $3,700 in state taxes still kept me below the standard deduction threshold, which is why TurboTax was correct in my situation. Worth every penny to finally get a clear answer!
0 coins
Yuki Ito
I'm a tax preparer and this is actually a common issue I see with various tax software. Here's the simple explanation: Both programs are technically doing it right, but FreeTaxUSA is showing you more of the calculation process. State taxes paid (whether through withholding or estimated payments) are deductible as itemized deductions on Schedule A. BUT, you only benefit from itemizing if your total itemized deductions exceed the standard deduction ($14,600 single, $29,200 married for 2024). TurboTax tends to hide the "losing" calculation from you if the standard deduction is clearly better. FreeTaxUSA shows you both calculations more transparently, which sometimes makes people think they're getting a bigger refund when actually both would give you the same amount in the end.
0 coins
Carmen Lopez
•Does this mean I should always double check if software is making the right choice between standard and itemized? I've just been accepting whatever the software recommends.
0 coins
Yuki Ito
•Yes, you should always verify which deduction method is better for your situation. Most software will choose correctly, but understanding why is important. The standard deduction is simple - a fixed amount based on filing status. Itemized deductions add up your qualifying expenses (state/local taxes up to $10K, mortgage interest, charitable donations, certain medical expenses, etc.). If itemized > standard, use itemized. If not, use standard. Both programs will ultimately pick the higher option, but they differ in how clearly they show you the "losing" calculation.
0 coins
Andre Dupont
Has anyone tried using Credit Karma Tax (now Cash App Taxes)? It's completely free and I've found it does a good job with state tax withholding deductions. I've compared it with both TurboTax and FreeTaxUSA.
0 coins
QuantumQuasar
•I used Cash App Taxes last year and liked it, but it doesn't support some forms I need this year like K-1s from partnerships. For simple returns it's great tho.
0 coins