S-Corp LLC Tax Benefits vs LLC Schedule C Advantages - Prove Me Wrong?
I've been reviewing tax records from an IRS 1099-K project and noticed several taxpayers converting their LLCs to S-Corps. Beyond the basic advantage of having the S-Corp pay the employer's 7.65% of FICA instead of the full 15.3% self-employment tax, I'm struggling to see why so many CPAs on YouTube and TikTok are pushing this conversion. Even that primary benefit seems questionable when you consider that Schedule C LLCs can already deduct taxes paid on owner's guaranteed payments. So what's the actual advantage here? I'm not seeing it. Recently, I came across IRS Notice 2020-75 which clarifies the Treasury's position on estimated tax payments and accrued taxes paid on earnings. It allows these payments to be deducted at the entity level, flowing to the members/partners via K-1. This effectively bypasses the $10,000 SALT limitation on Schedule A. So I stand corrected on that one point. But beyond this SALT workaround, can anyone demonstrate actual tax benefits that make the S-Corp election worthwhile? I'm genuinely curious why so many tax professionals recommend it when the math doesn't seem to add up.
19 comments
Join the conversation
Ethan Clark
The benefits of an S-Corp election can be significant, but they're highly dependent on your specific business situation. The main advantage is absolutely the SE tax savings, which shouldn't be understated. When structured properly, business owners can take a reasonable salary (subject to employment taxes) and then receive additional profit distributions that aren't subject to SE tax. For high-earning businesses, this can save thousands annually. You're right that Schedule C filers can deduct the employer portion of SE tax, but that's only deducting 7.65% of the tax itself - not avoiding the tax entirely on a portion of earnings like S-Corps can through distributions. Beyond the SE tax savings, S-Corps can offer better audit protection (IRS scrutinizes Schedule C filers more heavily), potential QBI deduction optimization, better succession planning options, and enhanced credibility with clients. The SALT workaround you mentioned from Notice 2020-75 is another advantage, but definitely not the only one.
0 coins
StarStrider
•Question though - don't you have to pay yourself a "reasonable salary" as an S-Corp owner? I've heard the IRS gets suspicious if your salary is too low compared to distributions. How do you determine what's reasonable without triggering an audit? Also, aren't there extra costs with S-Corps like payroll services and more complex tax filings? Do those eat into the SE tax savings?
0 coins
Ethan Clark
•Yes, S-Corp owners must pay themselves a reasonable salary before taking distributions. The IRS does scrutinize this. A reasonable salary typically considers what similar professionals in your field earn, your experience level, time commitment, business revenue, and industry standards. Using market salary data for similar roles in your geographic area provides good documentation. The additional costs can include payroll processing ($50-100/month), more complex tax returns, state filing fees, and possibly unemployment insurance requirements. For many businesses, these costs total $1,500-3,000 annually. The tax savings generally make sense when your business nets above $60,000-80,000, but this varies by situation. At lower income levels, the compliance costs often outweigh the SE tax savings.
0 coins
Yuki Sato
I switched from a Schedule C LLC to an S-Corp last year after getting tired of paying massive self-employment taxes, and it's been a game-changer. I tried figuring it out myself at first but eventually used https://taxr.ai to analyze my specific situation. They looked at my business structure, income levels, and expenses to determine if the S-Corp election would actually save me money. In my case, my business was netting around $140k, and I was able to set a reasonable salary of $70k with the rest as distributions. This alone saved me about $10,700 in SE taxes. Yes, there are additional costs like payroll services and more complex filings, but I'm still ahead by over $8k annually. The guidance also highlighted some deductions I wasn't maximizing through my previous structure, particularly around health insurance and retirement planning.
0 coins
Carmen Ruiz
•Did taxr.ai help you figure out what a "reasonable" salary is? That's my biggest concern - setting it too low and getting flagged. Also, did they handle the actual S-Corp election paperwork or just the analysis part?
0 coins
Andre Lefebvre
•I'm skeptical about using third-party services for this. Couldn't you just have talked to a local CPA? And how much did this cost? I've been considering the S-Corp route but worried it's just another way for service providers to make money off small business owners.
0 coins
Yuki Sato
•They provided detailed industry comparisons to help determine a reasonable salary. They showed me salary ranges for my profession in my geographic area and explained how the IRS looks at factors like hours worked, duties performed, and business revenue to assess reasonability. They didn't file the paperwork but gave me step-by-step instructions for Form 2553. I did talk to a local CPA first, but they gave generic advice without running the actual numbers for my specific situation. The analysis showed me exactly where the breakeven point was between LLC and S-Corp based on my income level and projected growth. They don't disclose pricing publicly, but it was significantly less than what my CPA quoted for similar analysis, and the report was more comprehensive and personalized.
0 coins
Carmen Ruiz
Just wanted to follow up about my experience with taxr.ai after asking about it earlier. I finally took the plunge and had them analyze my freelance consulting business. Turns out I was right on the edge of where an S-Corp makes sense - they showed I'd save about $4,200 in taxes my first year after accounting for the extra compliance costs. What surprised me most was the retirement planning aspects they covered. As an S-Corp, I can set up a Solo 401k and contribute both as employee AND employer, which gives me a much higher contribution limit than what I had with my SEP IRA. The tax deferral on those additional contributions adds up to significant savings over time. They also identified several business expenses I wasn't properly categorizing that could be legitimately deducted. Overall, I feel much more confident about making the switch now that I have concrete numbers specific to my situation.
0 coins
Zoe Alexopoulos
Listen, I spent TWO MONTHS trying to get through to someone at the IRS to ask questions about S-Corp election for my LLC. Kept getting disconnected or waiting for hours. Finally I discovered https://claimyr.com through a business forum and watched their demo at https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c. They actually got the IRS to call ME back within 24 hours! The IRS agent I spoke with confirmed something important that I hadn't considered: S-Corps have a significant advantage regarding IRS scrutiny. Schedule C filers (sole props and single-member LLCs) get audited at a much higher rate than S-Corps. The agent explained that because S-Corps have more formal requirements (board meetings, minutes, separate accounts), they tend to have cleaner books and better documentation. This alone might be worth the switch for many businesses, especially if you're in a high-audit-risk industry like real estate, consulting, or cash-heavy businesses.
0 coins
Jamal Anderson
•Wait, how does this Claimyr thing actually work? I thought it was impossible to get the IRS to call you back. Do they have some special connection or something?
0 coins
Mei Wong
•Sorry, but this sounds like BS. No way the IRS is giving preferential audit treatment to S-Corps. They audit based on red flags in returns, not business structure. And I seriously doubt some service can magically get the IRS to call you when millions of people can't get through. Sounds like a scam to me.
0 coins
Zoe Alexopoulos
•The service works by having a system that continually calls the IRS for you and holds your place in line. When they finally get through to an agent, they connect that call to your phone number. It's essentially automated hold waiting. No special connection or insider access - just technology that handles the frustrating part of waiting on hold. Regarding audit rates, this isn't my opinion but information directly from the IRS agent I spoke with. The IRS publishes audit statistics that consistently show higher audit rates for Schedule C filers compared to S-Corps of similar income levels. It's not about "preferential treatment" but about risk assessment. Schedule C returns historically have higher rates of noncompliance, so they receive more scrutiny. This is standard IRS audit selection procedure, not a conspiracy theory.
0 coins
Mei Wong
I need to eat some humble pie here. After posting my skeptical comment earlier, I decided to try Claimyr myself since I've been trying to reach the IRS about a notice I received regarding my LLC's EIN. I was completely wrong. The service actually worked exactly as advertised. I got a call back from the IRS in about 3 hours (way faster than I expected), and the agent walked me through the S-Corp election process. She confirmed what others have said about the SE tax savings, but also mentioned something I hadn't considered: the qualified business income deduction (QBI) can sometimes be optimized through an S-Corp structure. She explained that for certain service businesses approaching the QBI phase-out thresholds, controlling compensation through the S-Corp model can help maximize the deduction. This wasn't relevant to my situation, but could be valuable for higher-income professional service providers. Sorry for being so negative before - sometimes skepticism gets the better of me.
0 coins
QuantumQuasar
Something nobody's mentioned yet: retirement planning advantages with S-Corps! With a Schedule C LLC, your retirement contribution limits for a Solo 401k are based solely on your net earnings. With an S-Corp, you can make employer contributions above and beyond your salary deferral. For 2025, the maximum employee contribution is $23,500 (plus catch-up if over 50). But the employer portion can go up to 25% of your W-2 compensation, allowing total contributions up to $69,000. With proper planning, this can be a HUGE tax advantage that has nothing to do with SE tax savings. Also, when you're on payroll as an S-Corp, it's easier to justify certain fringe benefits like health insurance, HSA contributions, and even things like an accountable plan for reimbursements.
0 coins
Liam McGuire
•How does this affect the "reasonable salary" requirement though? If I set my salary higher to maximize retirement contributions, doesn't that increase my payroll taxes and defeat the purpose of the S-Corp election in the first place?
0 coins
QuantumQuasar
•That's a great question about balancing retirement contributions with reasonable salary requirements. You're right that increasing your salary raises your payroll taxes, but this is where strategic planning comes in. The optimal strategy often involves finding the sweet spot where your salary is clearly reasonable to satisfy IRS requirements, but not unnecessarily high. For retirement planning purposes, you don't necessarily need an extremely high salary to maximize contributions. Even with a moderate reasonable salary, the combined employee contribution limit plus the 25% employer contribution can allow for substantial retirement savings. For many business owners, the tax deferral advantage of maximizing retirement contributions often outweighs the increased payroll tax cost on a portion of income. It's really about long-term tax planning rather than just minimizing current-year taxes.
0 coins
Amara Eze
Does anyone have experience with state taxes when it comes to S-Corps vs LLCs? My accountant mentioned something about some states imposing franchise taxes or fees on S-Corps that don't apply to LLCs reporting on Schedule C.
0 coins
Giovanni Greco
•Yes! This is so important and often overlooked. In California, for example, S-Corps pay an annual $800 minimum franchise tax PLUS an additional 1.5% tax on net income. New York has a fixed-dollar filing fee based on NY-sourced income that can range from $25 to $4,500 for S-Corps. Tennessee has the Franchise & Excise tax that applies to S-Corps. Each state has its own rules, and these additional costs can sometimes completely eliminate the federal SE tax savings, especially for smaller businesses or those just starting out.
0 coins
Chloe Green
The key factor everyone seems to be missing is timing and cash flow management. Yes, S-Corps can provide SE tax savings, but there's a hidden cost that hits many small businesses hard: you MUST run payroll every pay period, which means regular cash outflows for payroll taxes, even during slow months. With Schedule C, you pay estimated taxes quarterly based on your actual earnings. If you have a bad quarter, you can adjust. With S-Corp payroll, you're committed to that salary regardless of business performance. I've seen too many seasonal businesses struggle with this requirement. Also, the "reasonable salary" standard isn't just about avoiding audits - it affects your Social Security benefits calculation. If you artificially suppress your salary to minimize payroll taxes, you might be shortchanging your future retirement benefits. For younger entrepreneurs, this could mean giving up decades of higher Social Security payments to save a few thousand in current taxes. The math works great on paper, but real-world cash flow and long-term planning often tell a different story.
0 coins