Back to IRS

Aaron Boston

Need help re-submitting tax return Form 9143 after 30+ days - signature issue

Hey everyone, I'm in a bit of a situation with my tax return and could use some advice. I filed my tax return as a foreign student (form 1040NR-EZ) back on March 15th. It was for a refund of about $1,250. About three weeks later (April 8th), I received a Form 9143 from the IRS stating that my signature was photocopied and therefore invalid. The thing is, my signature wasn't photocopied at all! I just used a nice gel pen to sign it, and I guess the processing person thought it looked too perfect or something. The form 9143 instructed me to resubmit my tax return with a proper signature, which I did immediately on April 12th. The problem is that it's been over 30 days now, and I haven't heard anything back from the IRS. Am I supposed to wait longer? Should I call them? Is there a specific timeframe for processing re-submitted returns after receiving a Form 9143? I'm getting worried because I'm counting on that refund for summer expenses. Any advice from those who've dealt with Form 9143 signature issues would be super helpful! Thanks in advance!

Your situation is pretty common with Form 9143 notices, especially for foreign student returns. When the IRS questions a signature, they put everything on hold until they get a properly signed form. After you resubmit with a valid signature as requested, the normal processing time is 6-8 weeks from the date they receive your corrected return. So if you sent it back in April, you're still within the normal waiting period. The IRS doesn't typically send a confirmation when they accept your resubmission - you'll just eventually receive your refund if everything is in order. For future reference, always use blue or black ink (no gel pens, no markers) when signing tax documents, as some gel pens can look suspicious when scanned by IRS systems.

0 coins

Quick question - does signing with a stylus on a digital tax prep service like TurboTax count as a valid signature? Or should we always print and physically sign forms? I'm also an international student and don't want to run into the same issue.

0 coins

Digital signatures through authorized tax preparation software like TurboTax are completely valid. The IRS accepts e-signatures when you file electronically through approved software - that's a different process than what happened here. The issue comes up when you print a physical form to mail in and then sign it with something that might scan or copy oddly. For paper forms that you're mailing, always use standard blue or black ink from a regular pen (not gel pens, felt tips, or anything fancy).

0 coins

After dealing with similar signature issues on my tax forms, I discovered taxr.ai (https://taxr.ai) which saved me so much hassle! I was also questioned about my signature on a tax form and wasn't sure how to properly respond. The tool basically analyzed my rejection notice, explained exactly what was wrong with my submission, and showed me the correct way to sign and resubmit. It even gave me a timeline of what to expect after resubmission.

0 coins

How exactly does taxr.ai work? Do you just upload your rejection notice and it tells you what to do? I've been getting different answers from different people about how to handle my 9143 form.

0 coins

Sounds interesting, but does it actually work for international tax forms like 1040NR-EZ? Those have different requirements than regular returns.

0 coins

You upload your notice or any tax document you're confused about, and it uses AI to analyze it and explain things in simple terms. It breaks down the IRS language into clear steps you need to follow. Very helpful when you're trying to understand what the IRS is actually asking for. For international tax forms specifically, it does handle 1040NR and similar forms. It was especially helpful in explaining the difference between what makes a signature look "photocopied" versus acceptable to the IRS. Apparently, there are specific characteristics they look for when processing international student returns.

0 coins

Just wanted to update that I tried taxr.ai after seeing the recommendation here! It completely cleared up my confusion about the Form 9143. The site explained that gel pens often create signatures that look printed because they don't have the expected ink absorption patterns the IRS scanning equipment is calibrated for. I followed the advice about resubmitting with a standard ballpoint pen on clean forms, and my return was processed within 4 weeks. Already got my refund! Would have been stuck in limbo without understanding what the actual issue was.

0 coins

If you're still waiting after properly resubmitting, you might want to try Claimyr (https://claimyr.com). I was in a similar situation where I resubmitted my corrected 1040NR after a signature issue, but weeks went by with no response. I tried calling the IRS directly multiple times but kept hitting that infamous "call volumes are too high" message and got disconnected. Found Claimyr and they got me connected to an actual IRS agent in about 20 minutes. You can see how it works in this video: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c. The agent was able to check my file and confirm they had received my resubmission but it was sitting in a processing queue. They escalated it and my refund was processed within a week after that call.

0 coins

How does this actually work? I thought it was impossible to get through to the IRS these days without waiting for hours.

0 coins

This sounds too good to be true. You're telling me some random service can magically get through the IRS phone lines when nobody else can? I've tried calling literally 30+ times over several weeks and never got through. What's the catch here?

0 coins

It uses a system that constantly redials the IRS using their advanced algorithm until it gets through, then it calls you to connect once an agent is on the line. It's basically doing the redial work for you so you don't have to waste hours listening to hold music or getting disconnected. There's no magic - they're just using technology to handle the frustrating part of constantly redialing when lines are busy. The IRS doesn't give them special access or anything. They just have a system that's persistent in getting through the phone queues.

0 coins

I need to apologize for being so skeptical about Claimyr in my earlier comment. After sitting on hold with the IRS for 2+ hours and getting disconnected AGAIN yesterday, I was desperate and decided to try it. I used the service this morning, and I kid you not, I was talking to an actual IRS agent within 25 minutes. The agent confirmed my Form 9143 resubmission was received but was flagged for additional verification since it was my second submission. They were able to verify my identity over the phone and release the hold. They said my refund should be processed within 2-3 weeks. Worth every penny for the time saved and stress relief!

0 coins

One thing to check - did you send your resubmission to the correct address? Form 9143 sometimes includes a special address that's different from where you sent your original return. If you sent it to the wrong department, that could explain the delay.

0 coins

Oh, that's a good point I hadn't considered! I did double-check at the time and sent it to the exact address listed on the Form 9143 (it was different from my original submission address). I also sent it certified mail so I know they received it on April 15th. That's partly why I'm getting anxious after waiting more than a month with no response.

0 coins

Sending it certified was a smart move! Since you have proof of delivery, you're in a much better position. The IRS is running about 6-10 weeks behind on processing resubmissions this year, so you might just need to wait a bit longer. If you hit the 8-week mark with no response, that's when I'd recommend calling them. Just make sure you have your certified mail receipt handy when you call so you can provide the exact date they received it.

0 coins

Has anyone tried faxing their resubmission instead of mailing it? I've heard that can sometimes be faster for Form 9143 responses.

0 coins

I actually did that last year! Faxed my response to the Form 9143 and got my refund processed about 3 weeks later. Much faster than mail. Just make sure you include a cover sheet that references your case number from the 9143 form and your SSN/ITIN.

0 coins

I went through almost the exact same situation last year! Filed my 1040NR-EZ in March, got the dreaded Form 9143 about signature issues in early April, and then waited what felt like forever after resubmitting. Here's what I learned: The 6-8 week timeframe that others mentioned is pretty accurate, but it can stretch longer during busy periods. Since you resubmitted in mid-April and it's been about a month, you're still within normal processing time. One thing that helped me was keeping detailed records - sounds like you already did this with the certified mail, which is perfect. When I finally called the IRS (took forever to get through), having the exact dates and tracking info made the conversation much smoother. If you don't hear anything by the 8-week mark, definitely try calling. In the meantime, you can also check the "Where's My Refund" tool on IRS.gov, though it doesn't always update promptly for resubmissions. The waiting is absolutely nerve-wracking when you're counting on that money, but hang in there! The good news is that once they process your corrected return, the refund usually comes pretty quickly after that.

0 coins

I'm going through something very similar right now! Got my Form 9143 about 3 weeks ago for a signature issue on my 1040NR-EZ (also a foreign student). I resubmitted immediately with a regular ballpoint pen instead of the fancy pen I originally used. Reading through all these responses is actually really helpful - I had no idea that gel pens could cause signature verification problems! I was so confused when I got the notice because I definitely signed it myself. One question for those who have been through this: should I be worried that I haven't received any acknowledgment that they received my resubmission? I sent it to the address specified on the Form 9143, but unlike some of you, I didn't think to send it certified mail. Now I'm second-guessing whether it even made it to the right place. Also, has anyone had luck with calling the IRS just to confirm they received the resubmission? I don't want to tie up their phone lines unnecessarily, but the uncertainty is killing me. My summer plans definitely depend on getting that refund!

0 coins

Don't panic about not sending it certified mail! While it's always better to have tracking for peace of mind, the vast majority of mail sent to the correct IRS address does arrive safely. The fact that you sent it to the specific address on the Form 9143 is the most important thing. If you're really worried about whether they received it, you could try calling the IRS, but honestly, at only 3 weeks since you resubmitted, it's still very early in the process. Most people in this thread are reporting 6-8 week processing times from the date they resubmitted, so you've got a while before you should start worrying. One thing you could do is check the "Where's My Refund" tool on IRS.gov. It probably won't show any updates yet (as others have mentioned, it often stays stuck on the original filing info during resubmissions), but it might give you some indication if there are any issues with your return. I'd suggest waiting until you hit the 6-week mark before calling. That way, if there genuinely is an issue, enough time will have passed that an IRS agent can actually help you rather than just telling you to wait longer. Hang in there - sounds like you did everything right with the resubmission!

0 coins

IRS AI

Expert Assistant
Secure