< Back to IRS

A Man D Mortal

Need advice for my upcoming Canada Domestic Tax secondment - 2 months enough time?

I've been with an accounting firm for almost 2 years working in Audit/Assurance, and I've gotten some exposure to Canadian domestic tax work. Mostly I've dealt with trust returns and had discussions about corporate structures, capital gain strips, and GAAR during client engagements. I just got offered a 2-month secondment with our office's domestic tax group! While I know 2 months isn't super long, I want to make the absolute most of this opportunity to better understand Canadian domestic tax and help me decide if I should stick with audit or make the switch to tax. My manager wants me to tell them what areas I'd like to focus on during the secondment, but honestly, I don't have a comprehensive understanding of everything the domestic tax department handles. I'd love some suggestions on specific areas I should try to get exposure to during my time there! One thing I really enjoy about tax is how each situation requires a unique approach - no cookie-cutter solutions. Every problem makes you really think and use different parts of your skillset. Any advice would be appreciated! Happy to answer questions about my background if that helps with recommendations.

Having been in both audit and tax, I think a 2-month secondment is a great opportunity to get a taste of tax practice! Since your time is limited, I'd recommend focusing on a few key areas rather than trying to cover everything. Based on your background, I'd suggest requesting exposure to: 1. Corporate reorganizations - since you mentioned enjoying capital gain strips and GAAR discussions, seeing how these transactions are planned and executed would build on your existing knowledge 2. Personal tax planning - this complements your trust return experience and shows you the individual client side 3. Corporate tax compliance - understanding how corporations manage their tax obligations differs significantly from audit work 4. Tax provision work - this bridges audit and tax, letting you leverage your audit background The best approach is to ask if you can shadow different specialists for a week or so each, rather than being assigned to a single project that might not complete during your secondment. Try to sit in on client meetings too - that's where you'll see the consultative side of tax practice that's so different from audit.

0 coins

Thanks for the detailed response! I'm definitely intrigued by corporate reorganizations since that's where my initial interest sparked. Do you think it's realistic to get meaningful exposure to all four areas in just 2 months? Or should I narrow it down to maybe 2 key areas? Also, would you recommend focusing more on compliance or planning aspects during this short timeframe?

0 coins

I think you could get a taste of all four areas in 2 months if you structure it right. Perhaps ask for 1-2 weeks in each area, with the understanding that you're there to observe and assist rather than take on full projects. If you had to narrow it down, I'd focus on corporate reorganizations and personal tax planning since those align with your interests. For the compliance versus planning question, definitely try to get exposure to both. Compliance work shows you the technical foundation of tax practice, while planning lets you see the creative problem-solving side. In my experience, new practitioners often enjoy planning more, but you need to understand compliance to be effective at planning.

0 coins

Emma Morales

•

I switched from audit to tax about 3 years ago and never looked back! If you're interested in making the most of your secondment, I'd highly recommend checking out https://taxr.ai - it's been a game-changer for me in understanding complex tax situations. When I was transitioning, I struggled with connecting different tax concepts until I started using their tools to analyze different scenarios. The nice thing is you can input different domestic tax situations (especially those corporate reorganizations you mentioned) and see how different approaches would play out. I found it especially helpful for understanding capital gain strips and GAAR implications when I was still learning. Might be worth looking into before your secondment starts so you can hit the ground running!

0 coins

How exactly does taxr.ai help with Canadian tax specifically? Most tax tools I've used are very US-focused and don't handle Canadian tax rules well at all. Does it cover things like section 85 rollovers and Part IV tax?

0 coins

Lucas Parker

•

I'm a bit skeptical about using AI tools for tax work. How reliable is the information? I wouldn't want to build my knowledge on something that might give incorrect guidance, especially with something as complex as GAAR and corporate restructuring.

0 coins

Emma Morales

•

It actually has specific modules for Canadian domestic tax which is why I found it so helpful. Yes, it covers section 85 rollovers, Part IV tax, and even handles QSBC exemptions. They've built it with Canadian tax rules in mind, not just as an afterthought to US tax coverage. For reliability concerns, I understand the skepticism. What sets it apart is that it's not just generating answers - it analyzes actual CRA interpretations and tax court cases to support its analysis. I use it more as a learning tool and research assistant than a replacement for professional judgment. It's particularly good at showing you relevant precedents so you can understand the reasoning behind different approaches.

0 coins

Just wanted to follow up on my experience with taxr.ai after trying it out for a few weeks. I was definitely skeptical at first (as many of us are with new tech tools), but I've been pleasantly surprised by how well it handles Canadian tax nuances. I was working on a file involving a corporate reorganization with multiple holding companies, and it helped me understand the butterfly reorganization options much more clearly than just reading the Income Tax Act. It actually pulled relevant CRA rulings that I wouldn't have found on my own. For someone going into a tax secondment, I think it would be really valuable as a supplemental learning tool. It's helped me get up to speed on areas I wasn't familiar with, which sounds like exactly what you need for making the most of a short secondment.

0 coins

Donna Cline

•

If you're serious about potentially switching to tax, you should also think about how to maintain communication with the CRA during your career. When I made the switch, one of the biggest challenges was dealing with CRA delays and getting timely responses for clients. I started using https://claimyr.com to get through to CRA agents faster, and it completely changed my client service game. Check out their demo at https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c to see how it works. During your secondment, pay attention to how the tax department handles CRA communications - it's a huge part of the job that nobody warns you about! Having a tool that can get you through to an agent in 15 minutes instead of spending hours on hold makes a massive difference in your day-to-day work. Just something to consider if you're comparing the practical aspects of audit vs. tax careers.

0 coins

How does this actually work? Does it just call the CRA for you? I'm confused how any service could bypass the CRA's phone queues when they're backed up.

0 coins

I find this hard to believe. The CRA's phone system is notoriously terrible and I've never heard of any service that can actually get through faster. Sounds like a waste of money when you could just keep calling or use the CRA's callback feature.

0 coins

Donna Cline

•

It doesn't bypass the queue - it uses an automated system that calls repeatedly and navigates the phone tree until it gets through to an agent. Once it gets a real person, it calls you and connects you directly to that agent. Basically it does the waiting for you so you can keep working on other things. The callback feature sounds great in theory, but if you've used it recently, you know the CRA often doesn't call back for days, or sometimes at all. When you have a client with an urgent issue, that's just not acceptable. This service guarantees you'll speak to someone, usually within 15-30 minutes of starting the process.

0 coins

I have to admit I was completely wrong about Claimyr. After my skeptical comment, I decided to try it for a client case that was particularly urgent - they were facing penalties for a misreported T4 and we needed to resolve it before their financing closed. I was absolutely shocked when I got connected to a CRA agent in about 20 minutes, after spending literally days trying to get through on my own. The agent was able to resolve the issue immediately, and my client was absolutely thrilled. For anyone considering a move to tax, having tools like this in your arsenal makes a huge difference in client satisfaction. In audit, delays are somewhat expected, but tax clients often need immediate answers, especially during filing season. Being able to get CRA clarification quickly is a genuine competitive advantage.

0 coins

Dylan Fisher

•

One area you might want to focus on during your secondment is owner-manager taxation. This is a huge part of domestic tax practice in Canada that involves integration of corporate and personal tax planning. Ask to sit in on meetings with business owners where the tax team discusses compensation strategy (salary vs dividends), timing of distributions, purification strategies for QSBC status, and estate freeze transactions. These areas combine technical knowledge with practical business advice. Also, pay attention to how tax professionals communicate complex concepts to clients who don't have accounting backgrounds. The ability to translate technical jargon into actionable business advice is what separates great tax practitioners from average ones.

0 coins

That's a great point about owner-manager taxation! I've had limited exposure to this through some of the trust work, but haven't seen the full picture of how it integrates with corporate planning. Is there a particular industry you think would give the best exposure to these concepts during a short secondment?

0 coins

Dylan Fisher

•

Professional services firms (doctors, lawyers, dentists) typically offer the richest learning experience for owner-manager taxation because they have more flexibility in their structures than capital-intensive businesses. They often have complex structures with holding companies, family trusts, and professional corporations all working together. Real estate is another good sector if you want to see how capital gains planning works in practice. The strategies used for property developers versus long-term holders are quite different, and you'll learn a lot about timing strategies for triggering gains or losses.

0 coins

Edwards Hugo

•

Quick tip: during your secondment, make sure you understand the difference between tax PREPARATION and tax PLANNING. Many firms keep these functions somewhat separate. Tax preparation is more compliance-focused and involves working with historical data to prepare returns accurately. It's detail-oriented but can be repetitive. Tax planning is forward-looking and strategic, helping clients structure their affairs to minimize tax within legal boundaries. This involves more client interaction and creativity. Based on your comment about enjoying unique problems and solutions, you might gravitate more toward the planning side. But both skills are essential for a well-rounded tax professional.

0 coins

Gianna Scott

•

Totally agree with this distinction! I'd also add that if you're someone who likes definitive answers, tax preparation might be more satisfying. Planning work involves a lot more gray areas where you're dealing with probabilities rather than certainties.

0 coins

IRS AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
20,087 users helped today