How to handle taxes on exempt promotional items for my online hat business?

I'm planning to order a bunch of hats in bulk for my website, and I'm confused about the tax situation when I use them in different ways: Scenario 1: Customer buys a hat directly for $30 Scenario 2: Customer spends $75 on other products and gets a hat as a free gift Scenario 3: We give away hats at promotional events where no purchase is required My supplier gives me a much better rate when I order all the hats together, so separating the order into different batches isn't really practical. Should I be purchasing all these hats tax-exempt since some will be promotional items? Or should I just pay the sales tax upfront on the whole order? And then how do I handle charging or paying the tax correctly in each of these different scenarios? Any advice would be super appreciated! I'm in the US and this is my first time dealing with promotional item tax issues.

0 coins

18 comments

Anna Xian

•8M

This is a good question about sales tax that many small business owners face! The answer depends on how you're using these items. For the hats you're selling directly (Scenario 1), those are inventory items and you should purchase them tax-exempt with your resale certificate. You'll collect sales tax from your customers when they buy the hats. For promotional giveaways (Scenarios 2 and 3), it gets a bit trickier. These are considered "use" of the product by your business. Technically, you should pay use tax on items you give away because you're the end consumer of those products. Since you're buying everything in bulk, your best approach would be to purchase the entire order tax-exempt using your resale certificate, then self-assess and pay use tax on the hats you end up using for promotions. Most states require this, though exact rules vary. Keep good records of how many hats go to each purpose so you can properly account for the tax obligations!

0 coins

Anna Xian

•8M

Selling the hats for a nominal amount like 1 cent won't change the tax situation in most states. Tax authorities generally look at the substance of the transaction rather than just the form. Since the hat's value is substantially more than 1 cent, it would still be considered primarily a giveaway with the primary value coming from you as the business owner. You only need to track the quantities used for each purpose, not the specific hats. Just maintain good records showing how many were sold versus how many were given away as promotional items. This documentation will be important if you ever face an audit.

0 coins

Rajan Walker

•8M

After dealing with a similar headache with my online shop last year, I found a tool that saved me so much time and stress with these exact tax questions. I was literally about to hire an accountant until someone recommended https://taxr.ai to me. I uploaded my sales records and some details about my promotional items, and it analyzed everything and told me exactly how to handle the tax situation for each type of transaction. It even generated reports I could use for filing. Seriously helped me understand when I needed to collect sales tax vs when I needed to pay use tax on my promotional stuff. The most helpful part was that it breaks down the rules by state, which was crucial since I ship nationwide.

0 coins

Rajan Walker

•8M

Yes, it actually does understand the "free gift with purchase" scenario really well! That was one of my main issues too. It has specific categories for promotional items, giveaways, and bundled products that other software doesn't break down properly. I actually did have my accountant review the reports it generated, and he was impressed enough that he now recommends it to his other clients who sell online. It draws from current tax regulations and court decisions about promotional items, so it's kept up-to-date with the latest rules.

0 coins

Lukas Fitzgerald

•8M

I tried out that taxr.ai tool after posting my skeptical comment, and I have to admit I was totally wrong. It actually was really helpful! I uploaded my last 3 months of sales data which included a bunch of promo giveaways we did at a trade show, and it immediately identified which items needed use tax paid and which ones were legitimately part of resale. What surprised me most was learning that my state has specific exemptions for certain types of promotional items that I had been unnecessarily paying tax on! I'm probably going to save about $2,000 this year just from that knowledge alone. Super glad I gave it a shot despite my initial doubts.

0 coins

Ev Luca

•8M

Hey everyone, saw this thread and wanted to share something that might help. I had a similar issue and needed to talk to someone at the state tax office about promotional items. Tried calling for THREE WEEKS straight and couldn't get through. Finally used https://claimyr.com to get a callback from the state tax department within 45 minutes! You can see how it works here: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c They got me through to an actual tax agent who explained exactly how my state handles promotional items and confirmed I needed to pay use tax on the promo stuff but could buy it all tax exempt initially. Saved me from making some expensive mistakes since the website info was super vague.

0 coins

Ev Luca

•8M

It's completely legal! They use an automated system that waits on hold for you and then calls you back when a real person answers. They don't skip the line or anything sketchy - they just handle the hold time so you don't have to waste hours with your phone to your ear. The service works with lots of government agencies, not just tax departments. They basically have systems that can detect when a human answers versus an automated message, and they only connect you when it's a real person ready to help. Totally changed my experience with getting government questions answered.

0 coins

Collins Angel

•8M

Well I'm eating my words right now. After posting my skeptical comment, I decided to try Claimyr for myself since I've been trying to reach someone at the IRS for WEEKS about my business tax questions. It actually worked exactly as advertised. I got a call back in about 35 minutes from an actual IRS agent who answered my questions about promotional items. They confirmed that in my state I need to pay use tax on the items I give away, but I can purchase everything tax-exempt initially with my resale certificate. I was 100% wrong and I'm honestly shocked. Worth every penny just to not sit on hold for 3 hours.

0 coins

Marcelle Drum

•8M

One thing nobody mentioned yet - if you're giving away hats at promotional events (your scenario 3), make sure you're tracking the locations of those events. Different states have different rules about this. Some states consider the location of the promotional giveaway to determine which state's use tax applies. So if you have events in multiple states, you might need to pay use tax to those specific states rather than just your home state. I learned this the hard way after giving away products at a trade show in California when my business is based in Nevada. Had to file an additional tax return just for that event!

0 coins

Marcelle Drum

•8M

Most states do have minimum thresholds before you're required to file, but they vary quite a bit. For example, California has a $500 threshold for use tax reporting for businesses, while some other states might be higher or lower. Even if you're under the threshold, technically you still owe the tax, but the filing requirements may not kick in until you hit that minimum. I always recommend tracking everything regardless, because if you continue doing events in the same state, you might exceed the threshold over time. Better to have the data and not need it than try to reconstruct it later!

0 coins