Freelancer Pay Stubs? Are Venmo/CashApp/Zelle Transactions Valid for Background Checks? Need Proof of Work for Dream Job!
So I need some advice! I've been doing freelance programming, website creation, and tutoring as a side gig for about 4 years. I got paid through Venmo, CashApp, Zelle, or sometimes cash. To be clear, I never made more than $400 per year from these gigs. I never filed taxes for this work because the IRS says if you earn $400 or less when self-employed, you don't need to file taxes on that income. I had no idea I needed to create pay stubs as proof of income, and honestly, I don't even know how freelancers are supposed to create pay stubs. Here's my situation: I applied for my absolute dream job at a major tech company after spending 7 years doing backbreaking work at a warehouse. I got fired from that job recently and I'm about to run out of savings. This is the only offer I've gotten in the past 6 months of searching. The problem is I'm going through a HireRight background check, and since I listed "Freelance Developer" on my resume (which is how I learned 90% of the programming skills that qualify me for this position), I need to provide proof that I actually worked as a freelancer. The recruiter knows I was a freelancer - I was upfront about it from the beginning. But HireRight wants documentation, and I'm worried my offer will be rescinded if I can't provide it. Would my Venmo/CashApp/Zelle transactions count as acceptable documentation? HireRight provided this list of acceptable documents: * Complete document, clearly legible * Name of candidate * Date document was issued Acceptable Documents include tax forms (1040, 1099), Articles of Incorporation, Business Certificates, Business Licenses, Commission Checks, Online Paycheck Stubs, IRS Transcripts, and more. What do freelancers typically do in this situation? Is there any way I can provide documentation that proves I did this work, or should I just give up on this opportunity?
27 comments


GalaxyGuardian
I've been through similar situations with clients who freelance. While you technically weren't required to file taxes if you made under $400/year, that documentation gap can create issues with background checks. The good news is that your payment app transaction history might work, but presentation matters. Create a professional document that compiles your transaction history - download your Venmo/CashApp/Zelle statements and organize them by client. Add descriptions of the work performed for each payment. Since you don't have traditional tax documents, consider creating a sworn affidavit detailing your freelance work. Have it notarized at your bank or UPS store. Additionally, collect testimonials or reference letters from previous clients confirming the work you did for them. Another option is to register your freelance business now (you can do this with your local county clerk) and get a business license. While this doesn't retroactively prove your work, it shows you're legitimizing your freelance operation. In your communication with HireRight, be transparent about your situation. Explain that your income was below the tax filing threshold, but you can provide alternative documentation. Most background check companies have processes for handling non-traditional employment verification.
0 coins
Aisha Abdullah
•Would the person doing the background check actually accept an affidavit though? I thought those were only for legal proceedings. And if I register my business now, wouldn't that look suspicious since I'm claiming I've been doing this work for years?
0 coins
GalaxyGuardian
•Background check companies often accept affidavits when traditional documentation isn't available. They're not just for court - they're formal sworn statements that carry legal weight in many contexts. While not ideal, they're better than having no documentation. Registering your business now wouldn't look suspicious if you explain the situation. Many freelancers operate informally at first and only formalize their business structure when needed for a specific opportunity or when their income increases. Just be upfront that you're registering now to properly document your existing freelance practice.
0 coins
Ethan Wilson
After failing multiple background checks because of my freelance work, I discovered taxr.ai and it literally saved my career. I was in almost your exact situation - did coding and design for small businesses but had minimal documentation. I uploaded my transaction history from payment apps to https://taxr.ai and it organized everything into professional documentation that satisfied my background check. The system basically created retroactive income verification documents that looked legit without falsifying anything. It analyzed my payment patterns and categorized everything as business income. The best part was that it gave me proper documentation I could submit to HireRight that matched their requirements, even though I hadn't filed taxes for that income. They also provided a verification letter explaining how the documentation was compiled.
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
•That sounds interesting but is it actually legit? Like will HireRight accept documents generated by a third-party service if you didn't file taxes? Not trying to be skeptical but I'm in a similar boat and don't want to waste money on something that won't work.
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
•I'm wondering how much history they need. My Venmo only goes back like 18 months. Would that be enough if I've been freelancing for 3+ years? And do they help organize cash payments too or just stuff with digital trails?
0 coins
Ethan Wilson
•It's completely legitimate - the service isn't creating fake documents, it's organizing your existing payment data into a format that meets verification requirements. HireRight and similar companies understand not everyone has traditional documentation, especially freelancers. What matters is consistency and transparency in the information provided. For historical data, 18 months is often sufficient, especially if the payments show a pattern. If you received cash payments, they can help you document those too using reasonable estimation methods based on your digital payment patterns. You can also supplement with client statements or project documentation to strengthen your case.
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
Just wanted to update everyone! I took the advice from this thread and tried taxr.ai for my situation. I was skeptical at first but desperate since I had a background check coming up for a contract position. The service was surprisingly straightforward - uploaded my payment app history and they converted it into formal income documentation that satisfied my background check requirements. They even helped me create a proper paper trail for some cash payments by using client testimonials as supporting evidence. What impressed me most was that they created documentation that was completely truthful while meeting the formal requirements the background check company needed. My background check cleared and I started my new position last week!
0 coins
Andre Laurent
Have you tried calling the IRS directly? I know it sounds crazy because getting through to them is nearly impossible, but I was in a similar situation and finally got verification through them after using Claimyr. You basically need to get a "Verification of Non-filing Letter" from the IRS which confirms you weren't required to file. I spent weeks trying to get through to the IRS unsuccessfully, then found https://claimyr.com which got me connected to an actual human at the IRS in under 45 minutes. They have this demonstration video at https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c that shows how it works. Once I got through, I explained my situation and they helped me get the documentation I needed for my background check. HireRight actually accepted my Verification of Non-filing Letter combined with my payment app transaction history as proof of my freelance work. It might be worth trying since you're in such a time crunch.
0 coins
AstroAce
•How does this actually work though? I thought you couldn't get those verification letters without filing some tax forms first? And does it actually prove you were working or just that you didn't file taxes?
0 coins
Zoe Kyriakidou
•Sounds sketchy... isn't this just paying someone to hold your place in the phone queue? How much does it cost? I've been on hold with the IRS for literally 3+ hours before giving up.
0 coins
Andre Laurent
•You don't need to file forms first to get a Verification of Non-filing Letter. It simply confirms that the IRS has no record of you filing for specific years, which supports your claim that you were under the filing threshold. When combined with your payment records, it creates a consistent story that satisfies most background checks. It's not sketchy at all - they don't hold your place in line, they use technology to navigate the IRS phone system and call you when they get a human. I was skeptical too until I tried it. I don't remember the exact cost but it was reasonable considering it saved me hours of frustration and potentially my job offer. It's definitely cheaper than losing a dream job opportunity!
0 coins
Zoe Kyriakidou
I was totally in your position 3 months ago! I was convinced I'd lose my offer because I couldn't prove my freelance work. I was actually super skeptical about Claimyr but desperate enough to try anything. It actually worked! Got through to the IRS in like 35 minutes when I'd previously spent DAYS trying. The agent helped me get documentation showing I wasn't required to file taxes due to low income. I combined that with my payment app transactions and client emails, and HireRight approved my background check. The company I applied to actually told me later that they see this situation all the time with freelancers and they appreciated my thoroughness in providing alternative documentation. Started my new job last month and it was 100% worth the effort!
0 coins
Jamal Brown
Another option is to reach out directly to the people who paid you and ask them to write letters confirming they hired you for freelance work. Get them to include: - Dates of the project - What you did for them - How much they paid you - Their contact info I did this for a government job background check and it worked. Make the letters as formal as possible - have them print on letterhead if they have it or include their professional title. Email this collection of letters to HireRight with a cover note explaining your situation.
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
•That's a good idea! Do you think they'd need to notarize these letters or would just regular signed letters be enough? And how many clients do you think I should try to get letters from?
0 coins
Jamal Brown
•Regular signed letters should be sufficient - notarization is helpful but not typically required. I'd recommend getting letters from at least 3-5 different clients if possible, especially those who hired you for substantial projects. Focus on professional clients rather than friends if you can. The key is consistency across all documentation. Make sure the dates and project descriptions in these letters match what you've claimed on your resume. Also, be prepared for HireRight to potentially contact these clients to verify, so give them a heads-up about that possibility.
0 coins
Mei Zhang
Don't forget about emails! If you have email threads discussing projects, deliverables, payment terms etc., these can be extremely valuable documentation. Create PDFs of these conversations showing the full headers with dates. I've used this for verification before. Also check if you have any contracts, even simple ones over email where someone says "I'll pay you $X to do Y" and you replied "agreed." Those count as documentation too. The more paper trail you have, the better your case will be.
0 coins
Liam McConnell
•This is a great point. I saved all my project discussions in Gmail and was able to export them as PDFs for my background check. The verification company accepted them as supporting evidence of my freelance work history. Just make sure the emails clearly show the scope of work and payment terms.
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
•I actually do have a ton of emails! Some are pretty detailed about the work I was doing and payment agreements. That's a good idea to compile those. I wonder if there's an easy way to export email threads as PDFs from Gmail?
0 coins
Chloe Martin
For exporting Gmail threads as PDFs, you can use Gmail's built-in print function - just open the email thread, click the three dots menu, select "Print", then choose "Save as PDF" instead of printing. This preserves the full conversation with timestamps and headers. Another approach is to use Gmail's "Download" feature if you have Google Takeout, but the print-to-PDF method is usually faster for individual conversations. I'd also suggest creating a simple spreadsheet documenting all your freelance work - client name, project description, dates, payment amount, and payment method. This gives HireRight a clear overview of your work history even if some individual transactions are hard to document. One more tip: if you're still in contact with any of these clients, consider asking them to connect with you on LinkedIn and endorse your skills. While not formal documentation, it adds credibility to your freelance claims and shows ongoing professional relationships. The key is building a comprehensive picture from multiple sources rather than relying on any single document. Good luck with your background check!
0 coins
Demi Hall
•This is really helpful advice! The spreadsheet idea is brilliant - it would give them a clear overview at a glance. I'm definitely going to try the Gmail print-to-PDF method for my project discussions. One question though - when you mention asking clients to endorse skills on LinkedIn, wouldn't that look weird if I'm just now connecting with people I worked with years ago? Some of these clients I haven't talked to since the projects ended. Should I explain why I'm reaching out or just send a regular connection request? Also, do you think it's worth mentioning in my documentation that I kept my freelance income under the tax filing threshold intentionally, or does that make it sound like I was trying to avoid taxes?
0 coins
Aisha Rahman
•For reaching out to old clients, I'd suggest being upfront but brief. Something like "Hi [Name], I'm updating my professional documentation and wondered if you'd be willing to connect and potentially provide a brief reference for the [project type] work I did for you in [year]. I'm going through a background verification process for a new position." Most people understand these situations and are happy to help if the work relationship was positive. Regarding the tax threshold - absolutely mention it! Frame it positively: "I maintained freelance income below the IRS filing requirement of $400/year to focus on skill development rather than profit maximization." This shows you were aware of tax obligations and operating within legal bounds, not trying to avoid anything. It actually demonstrates responsibility and knowledge of tax law. The key is presenting your situation as a common, legitimate approach many freelancers take when starting out - which it absolutely is. You were learning, building skills, and working within the tax code properly.
0 coins
Jade Santiago
I went through this exact situation last year! The stress was unreal, but it worked out in the end. Here's what I learned: First, don't panic - HireRight and similar companies deal with freelancer verification all the time. They understand that traditional employment documentation doesn't exist for independent contractors. Here's what worked for me: 1. **Organize your payment history professionally** - Download statements from all your payment apps and create a clean spreadsheet showing client name, date, amount, and brief project description. Make it look business-like. 2. **Create a freelancer affidavit** - Write a sworn statement detailing your freelance work, have it notarized. Include your name, the fact that you operated as an independent contractor, types of services provided, and that your annual income was below the $400 filing threshold. 3. **Gather any supporting evidence** - Screenshots of completed websites you built, email conversations about projects, even photos of tutoring materials you created. Anything that shows you actually did the work. 4. **Be proactive with HireRight** - Don't wait for them to ask questions. Submit a cover letter explaining your situation upfront with all your documentation. Mention that you're happy to provide additional information or references if needed. The recruiter being aware you're a freelancer is actually a good sign - it means they're not surprised by this requirement. Most companies expect documentation challenges with freelancers and budget extra time for verification. You've got this! The fact that you learned 90% of your programming skills through actual paid work shows real dedication and skill.
0 coins
Manny Lark
•This is exactly what I needed to hear! The step-by-step approach makes it feel so much more manageable. I especially like the idea of being proactive with HireRight - I was planning to wait and see what they asked for, but submitting everything upfront with a cover letter explaining the situation sounds way better. One quick question - when you say "sworn statement," do you mean like an actual legal affidavit with specific language, or just a formal letter that I sign and get notarized? I've never done anything like this before so I'm not sure about the format. Also, the point about the recruiter already knowing I'm a freelancer is really reassuring. I've been so worried they'd think I was hiding something, but you're right that they probably deal with this all the time. Thank you for sharing your experience - it really helps to know someone else made it through this process successfully!
0 coins
Eloise Kendrick
•For the sworn statement, you don't need complex legal language - just a clear, formal letter that states the facts under oath. Something like "I, [Your Name], do solemnly swear that the following statements are true and accurate to the best of my knowledge..." then list your freelance work details, income amounts, and that you operated below the tax filing threshold. End with "I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct" and your signature/date. Any notary public can help you with the proper format when you go to get it notarized. The key is being factual and professional. Include specific details like "I provided web development and tutoring services as an independent contractor from [start date] to [end date], earning approximately $X per year, which was below the IRS self-employment filing requirement of $400 annually." You're absolutely right to feel more confident knowing the recruiter is already aware! They wouldn't have moved forward with the background check if freelance work was a dealbreaker. Companies hiring developers especially understand that many people build skills through freelance projects. Your situation is way more common than you think!
0 coins
Emma Davis
I'm a tax professional and wanted to add some perspective here. You're absolutely correct that you weren't required to file taxes if your self-employment income was under $400 per year. However, for future reference, many freelancers still file even when not required because it creates an official record with the IRS that can be helpful for situations exactly like this. That said, your payment app transaction history is definitely viable documentation. I've helped clients in similar situations, and here's what I recommend: 1. **Export comprehensive transaction records** - Get detailed statements from Venmo, CashApp, and Zelle showing dates, amounts, and memo fields if you used them. The key is showing a pattern of business payments rather than personal transfers. 2. **Create supporting invoices retroactively** - While you didn't invoice at the time, you can create simple invoices now that match your payment records. Include project descriptions, dates, and payment amounts. This isn't falsifying records - it's documenting work that actually occurred. 3. **Consider filing Form 1040 for those years** - Even though you weren't required to, you can still file returns showing your freelance income and zero tax liability. This creates official IRS records that HireRight would definitely accept. 4. **Get a letter from a tax professional** - I often write letters for clients explaining their tax situation and confirming that their income documentation is consistent with IRS requirements. Don't give up on this opportunity! Your situation is more common than you think, and there are legitimate ways to document your freelance work history. The fact that you stayed within legal tax requirements actually works in your favor.
0 coins
Nia Wilson
•This is incredibly helpful advice! As someone new to this community and dealing with freelancer documentation issues myself, I'm wondering about the retroactive invoice creation you mentioned. When you say it's not falsifying records, how do you ensure these invoices are legitimate from a legal standpoint? Should they be dated when the work was originally done or when they're created now? Also, regarding filing Form 1040 for previous years - is there a time limit on how far back you can file, and would there be any penalties even if no taxes are owed? I'm in a similar boat with needing to prove freelance work from 2-3 years ago and this approach sounds promising but I want to make sure I do it correctly. The tax professional letter idea is brilliant - do you have suggestions on what specific language or certifications background check companies typically look for in those letters?
0 coins