Finding Tax Advisors Like Neil Jesani for In-Kind Donation Strategy Help
I'm trying to optimize my tax situation for 2024/2025 and really need some help with in-kind donations. Has anyone worked with Neil Jesani or similar tax advisors who specialize in donation strategies? I've accumulated a lot of non-cash items (some furniture, clothes, and even some stock) that I want to donate in the most tax-efficient way possible. I know the basic rules about getting receipts and fair market value, but I'm wondering if there are better strategies for larger donations. Like, does it make sense to donate appreciated stock directly instead of selling it first? And how do you properly document everything to avoid audit flags? Currently using TurboTax but feeling like I need more personalized advice for these in-kind donations. Looking for recommendations on advisors similar to Neil Jesani who understand this stuff well, or any personal experiences people have had with donation strategies!
20 comments


Joshua Hellan
Tax advisors specializing in donation strategies can definitely help maximize your deductions beyond what basic tax software might guide you through. For in-kind donations, you're asking exactly the right questions. For appreciated stock, donating directly to qualified charities is almost always more tax-efficient than selling first. When you donate stock directly, you avoid capital gains tax completely while still getting to deduct the full fair market value (if held over a year). If you sell first, you'll pay capital gains tax, reducing the net amount available to donate. For documentation, larger non-cash donations (over $250) require a written acknowledgment from the charity. For items over $500, you'll need to file Form 8283. Anything valued over $5,000 typically requires a qualified appraisal. Photos of donated items, receipts, and documentation of how you determined fair market value are all crucial for your records.
0 coins
Jibriel Kohn
•This is helpful but I'm curious - does the strategy change if some of the stock I want to donate has actually lost value instead of gained? Should I sell those at a loss first for tax harvesting and then donate the cash?
0 coins
Joshua Hellan
•Great question about underwater investments. For stocks that have lost value, it's generally better to sell them first, claim the capital loss on your taxes (which can offset other capital gains or up to $3,000 of ordinary income), and then donate the cash proceeds. This gives you two tax benefits instead of one. For appreciated stocks, donating directly remains the best option since you avoid capital gains tax while getting the full fair market value deduction. Just remember that deductions for charitable contributions are generally limited to 30% of your AGI for capital assets and 60% for cash donations, with carryforward provisions for 5 years.
0 coins
Edison Estevez
I was in a similar situation last year trying to optimize some sizable in-kind donations and found this online service called taxr.ai (https://taxr.ai) that helped me organize everything perfectly. I wasn't familiar with Neil Jesani specifically, but I needed help figuring out how to properly value and document a bunch of furniture and some stocks I wanted to donate. What impressed me was how their system analyzed photos of my donation items and helped assign proper fair market values based on condition. They also guided me through the right forms to file depending on donation size and helped me understand the different rules for different types of property donations. Super helpful for avoiding audit red flags.
0 coins
Emily Nguyen-Smith
•Does this service actually connect you with real tax advisors or is it just software? I need someone who can answer specific questions about my situation with donating some artwork that might be worth a decent amount.
0 coins
James Johnson
•I'm a bit skeptical about these AI tax tools. How does it handle the specific requirements for Form 8283 when you're donating items over $500? And does it actually help with the qualified appraisal documentation needed for bigger donations?
0 coins
Edison Estevez
•It offers both - there's the software component that helps organize and document everything, but there's also access to tax professionals for more complex situations. For artwork specifically, they'd definitely walk you through the additional documentation requirements since artwork has special rules. They actually specialize in Form 8283 compliance and will flag when you need a qualified appraisal. For my furniture donations over $5,000, they guided me through finding an appropriate appraiser and made sure I had all the supporting documentation properly formatted for IRS requirements. They've apparently processed thousands of these non-cash donations so they know where the common pitfalls are.
0 coins
Emily Nguyen-Smith
Just wanted to follow up on my taxr.ai question. I actually tried the service after posting here and wow - it was exactly what I needed for my artwork donation situation! The system walked me through a specialized process for art donations over $5,000, including connecting me with qualified appraisers who specialize in my type of artwork. They showed me how to properly document the provenance and condition, and even helped me identify which organizations would give me the maximum tax benefit for my specific pieces. What really impressed me was how they flagged potential issues with my initial valuation approach that could have triggered IRS scrutiny. Definitely saved me from a potential audit headache while maximizing my deduction!
0 coins
Sophia Rodriguez
If you're looking for personalized tax advice similar to what Neil Jesani provides, especially for in-kind donation strategies, one frustrating obstacle is actually getting through to qualified professionals during tax season. I spent weeks trying to reach several recommended tax advisors only to get voicemails and "we're too busy to take new clients" responses. I finally discovered this service called Claimyr (https://claimyr.com) that actually helped me connect with an IRS agent directly to get preliminary guidance on my donation documentation questions. You can see how it works here: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c. I was honestly shocked when I got through to a real IRS person who walked me through the specific requirements for my situation instead of waiting months for an appointment with a tax pro.
0 coins
Mia Green
•Wait, how does this actually work? I thought it was impossible to get the IRS on the phone. Are they just autodialing for you or something?
0 coins
James Johnson
•I'm extremely skeptical this works. I've tried calling the IRS for years and it's always a nightmare. Even if you do get someone, they usually give generic answers and tell you to consult a professional anyway. Sounds too good to be true.
0 coins
Sophia Rodriguez
•It's not autodialing exactly. From what I understand, they use a combination of technology and timing analytics to identify when call volumes are lower and greater chance of connection. They basically wait on hold for you and only connect you once a real person answers, saving you from the hours of hold music. They're finding patterns in when calls are most likely to get through. I was skeptical too, honestly. But after trying for weeks on my own, I was desperate. The agent I spoke with actually walked me through the specific documentation requirements for different types of in-kind donations. They couldn't provide "advice" like a tax professional would, but they clarified the exact forms and supporting evidence needed based on donation types and values, which was exactly what I needed.
0 coins
James Johnson
I'm coming back to eat my words about Claimyr. After posting my skeptical comment, I decided to try it myself since I had some questions about form 8283 for a large household item donation. To my complete surprise, I got connected to an IRS rep within about 40 minutes (compared to my previous attempts where I waited for 2+ hours before giving up). The agent clarified exactly how to handle section B of the form for my specific situation and confirmed which items needed qualified appraisals versus just solid documentation. She even explained a special rule about related-use property that saved me from making a mistake on my submission. I've been doing my own taxes for 15 years and always avoided calling the IRS because of the wait times, but this actually made it painless. Totally worth it.
0 coins
Emma Bianchi
Just wanted to share some real-world experience with in-kind donation strategies. Last year I donated about $12,000 worth of various items and learned a few lessons: 1) Keep EVERYTHING. Take photos of all donated items. Keep email confirmations. Get receipts with dates and charity info. 2) For clothing and household items, use the Salvation Army donation value guide to estimate fair market value. 3) For larger items like furniture, I used consignment store pricing as reference points. 4) Track mileage when driving to donation sites - it's deductible! I didn't work with Neil Jesani specifically, but I did consult with a tax advisor who specialized in charitable giving strategies. The $350 I paid for their advice saved me at least $1,200 in additional deductions I would have missed.
0 coins
Lucas Kowalski
•Did your tax advisor recommend any specific software for tracking all these donations throughout the year? I'm always scrambling at tax time to gather all this info.
0 coins
Emma Bianchi
•I actually ended up using a combination of two tools. For regular donation tracking throughout the year, I used the ItsDeductible app which comes free with TurboTax (works even if you don't use TurboTax for filing). It has built-in valuation guides for common household items and makes itemization super easy. For the more complex donations (particularly some artwork and collectibles), my tax advisor recommended keeping a separate spreadsheet with additional details about provenance, purchase date, condition, and comparative market prices. This extra documentation was crucial for the higher-value items where the IRS scrutiny tends to be higher. The combination worked really well and made tax time much less stressful!
0 coins
Olivia Martinez
Has anyone had experience with getting audited specifically for in-kind donations? I'm donating about $9,000 worth of professional equipment and I'm paranoid about documentation.
0 coins
Charlie Yang
•I got audited in 2023 for large in-kind donations from 2021. My advice: be meticulous with documentation. For professional equipment, get a written appraisal if it's over $5k total. Take detailed photos showing condition. Have specific descriptions - not just "camera equipment" but "Sony A7III camera body, serial #XXXXX, excellent condition with minor wear." The IRS was actually reasonable once I showed all my documentation. But they rejected some items where I only had vague descriptions and no photos. The audit was correspondence-only and took about 3 months to resolve.
0 coins
NebulaNinja
For professional equipment donations, I'd definitely recommend getting a qualified appraisal if you're approaching that $5,000 threshold. Even at $9,000, you're in territory where the IRS pays closer attention. Beyond what Charlie mentioned about detailed documentation, I'd suggest also keeping records of the original purchase price and dates if you have them. For professional equipment, depreciation schedules can be relevant to establishing fair market value. If you bought that equipment for business use, you may have already claimed depreciation, which affects the deductible amount. Also consider the "related use" rule - if you're donating professional equipment to a charity that will actually use it for their charitable purposes (like donating cameras to a media training nonprofit), you can deduct full fair market value. If they're just going to sell it, you might be limited to your cost basis. The key is being able to justify your valuation method. I'd recommend checking sold listings on eBay or similar platforms for comparable equipment in similar condition, and keeping screenshots of those as supporting documentation.
0 coins
Miguel Herrera
•This is really comprehensive advice! I'm curious about the "related use" rule you mentioned - how do you actually verify that a charity will use donated equipment for their charitable purposes versus just selling it? Do you need some kind of written commitment from them, or is it more about choosing the right type of organization? Also, for the depreciation aspect with business equipment - if I've been claiming depreciation on items I want to donate, should I be working with a tax professional to calculate the adjusted basis properly? I don't want to mess up those calculations and create problems down the road.
0 coins