


Ask the community...
Has anyone used any specific tax software that handles household employee situations well? I tried using [popular tax software] last year for my mother's caregiver and it was a nightmare trying to figure out the Schedule H and W-2 generation.
TurboTax Home & Business handles Schedule H pretty well. Not perfect, but it walks you through the questions. For generating the actual W-2 forms though, I used the SSA's Business Services Online website. It's free and lets you create and file W-2s electronically. It's a bit clunky but gets the job done.
I went through this exact same situation with my grandmother's caregiver two years ago and learned some hard lessons. First, the IRS classification really does depend on the degree of control you have over the work, not just whether they work for other families. If you're directing what tasks need to be done, when they need to be at your home, and how the care should be provided, you're likely an employer regardless of their other clients. One thing I wish someone had told me earlier: even if you determine she should get a 1099-NEC as an independent contractor, you still need her Social Security Number or Individual Taxpayer Identification Number (ITIN), her full legal name, and address before you can file anything. The deadline for giving her the form is January 31st, and you need to file it with the IRS by the end of February (or March 31st if filing electronically). But honestly, given that you're paying her $26,000+ annually for regular ongoing care work in your home, this sounds like a textbook household employee situation to me. I'd strongly recommend getting professional help to sort this out properly - the penalties for misclassification can be significant, especially when you're dealing with this much money.
This is really helpful, Dylan! I'm in a similar situation with my elderly aunt's caregiver and I've been putting off dealing with the tax implications. Your point about the degree of control is eye-opening - we do tell her caregiver what medications to give, when meals should be prepared, and which activities to focus on with my aunt. One question - you mentioned penalties for misclassification can be significant. Do you know roughly what kind of penalties we might be looking at? I'm trying to figure out if it's worth hiring a tax professional or if I can handle this myself. We've been paying our caregiver about $1,800/month since January, so we're definitely over that $2,400 threshold you and others have mentioned.
Has anyone here actually gone through an IRS audit over gifted stocks? I'm worried because I did something similar last year but don't have great records of my original purchase from like 15 years ago. What happens if you can't prove the original cost basis?
You might also want to try contacting the company directly if it was a stock purchase through a dividend reinvestment plan (DRIP) or employee stock purchase plan. Many companies maintain records going back decades and can provide cost basis information even when brokers can't. Also, if you have old tax returns, sometimes the dividend income reported can help reconstruct the original purchase information. The IRS is surprisingly reasonable about accepting reasonable estimates if you can show good faith effort to determine the actual basis, but you definitely want to avoid that $0 basis assumption!
I went through something similar a few years back. If you really can't find the original cost basis, there are a few other options before you get stuck with the $0 basis default. You can try reconstructing it using old bank statements showing the purchase, old brokerage statements (even if they don't show basis), or any dividend reinvestment records. The IRS Publication 551 actually has guidelines for estimating basis when records are incomplete. Also, if the stock split or paid stock dividends over the years, that complicates the basis calculation but your broker should be able to help with the adjustment factors. Don't panic yet - most people can dig up enough documentation to avoid the worst-case scenario!
I went through almost this exact scenario with my mom last year when she gifted me some Apple stock she'd held since 2010. What everyone's saying about inheriting the cost basis is absolutely correct - I had to use her original purchase price from over a decade ago to calculate my capital gains, not the value when she gave it to me. One thing I'd add that hasn't been mentioned yet: make sure your daughter gets the holding period too. Since you held the stock for several years, she automatically qualifies for long-term capital gains treatment (even though she only held it briefly), which means lower tax rates. This is actually a nice benefit of receiving gifted stock versus inherited stock. Also, don't forget that your daughter will need to report this on Schedule D of her tax return, and possibly Form 8949 if her broker doesn't have the correct cost basis information. My broker initially showed the wrong basis (the value when gifted rather than mom's original purchase price), so I had to make an adjustment on Form 8949. It's worth double-checking what your daughter's brokerage reports to avoid any confusion when she files.
Has anyone else noticed that the withholding calculators seem to be way off for people with multiple jobs? I work a full-time job plus a weekend gig, and none of the calculators seem to handle this correctly. I always end up owing even when I follow their recommendations.
Thanks for that tip! I didn't realize there was a specific checkbox for multiple jobs. Does it matter which employer's W4 I check this box on? Or should I do it for both?
You should only check the multiple jobs box on ONE of your W4s, typically the one for your higher-paying job. If you check it on both, you'll end up with too much withheld. The IRS worksheet helps you figure out which job should have the box checked and if you need any additional withholding amount on line 4(c). The key is that your combined income from both jobs might push you into a higher tax bracket than either job alone would suggest.
I've been dealing with this exact same frustration! What I discovered is that many calculators don't properly account for the timing of when you make the withholding changes during the year. If you're adjusting your W4 in April versus January, the calculations should be different because you've already had several months of potentially incorrect withholding. The IRS calculator is generally most accurate, but make sure you're entering your year-to-date withholding amounts correctly from your most recent pay stub. Also, if you have any life changes planned (like getting married, having a baby, buying a house), factor those into your calculations since they'll affect your tax situation. One trick I learned from my CPA is to aim for owing between $0-$100 at tax time rather than getting a big refund. That way you're not giving the government an interest-free loan, but you're also not hit with underpayment penalties. It takes some trial and error to dial it in perfectly, but it's worth the effort!
That's a really smart approach about aiming for $0-$100 owed rather than a big refund! I never thought about it that way. Quick question - when you mention entering year-to-date withholding amounts, should I be looking at just federal withholding or does it include state and other deductions too? I want to make sure I'm inputting the right numbers into the IRS calculator.
I just went through this exact situation with a CP22A notice a few weeks ago! Everyone's advice about selecting "Notice" in DirectPay is absolutely correct - that's definitely the right option for your CP22A payment. One thing I'd add that really helped me is to have a backup payment method ready, just in case there are any technical issues with your primary bank account. I ran into a temporary problem with my bank's online system during the payment process, and having my debit card information ready as a backup saved me from missing my deadline. Also, when you're entering your information, take your time and double-check everything before hitting submit. The system is pretty forgiving, but it's better to get it right the first time than to have to deal with payment corrections later. The whole process from start to finish took me about 15 minutes, and I got my confirmation immediately. Make sure to save that confirmation number - you'll want it for your records. The $825 will likely show up as pending in your bank account within 24-48 hours. Good luck with your payment!
Thanks for the backup payment method tip! That's really smart thinking ahead. I'm definitely going to have my debit card info ready just in case something goes wrong with the bank transfer. Quick question about the timeline - when you say the $825 shows up as pending in 24-48 hours, is that when the IRS actually receives credit for the payment, or is that just when it shows as processing on the bank side? I want to make sure I understand the timing correctly since my due date is coming up soon. Also, did you happen to get any follow-up correspondence from the IRS after making your payment to confirm they received and applied it correctly? I'm trying to plan out what to expect in the coming weeks. Thanks for sharing your recent experience!
I actually work in tax resolution and deal with CP22A notices regularly, so I can definitely help clarify a few things! You're absolutely right to select "Notice" as your payment type in DirectPay - that's the correct option for any IRS notice payment. Here are the key pieces of information you'll need to have ready: - Your Social Security Number (primary taxpayer if married filing jointly) - The notice number (should be clearly marked on your CP22A) - The notice date (exactly as printed on the letter) - Tax year the notice relates to - Your bank account and routing number (if paying by bank transfer - no fees vs. debit card fees) One thing many people miss: make sure you're paying the correct amount! If your notice is more than 2-3 weeks old, additional interest may have accrued since it was issued. You might want to add an extra $10-20 to cover any additional interest, or call the number on your notice to get the exact current balance. The DirectPay system will credit your payment on the date you submit it (if done before 8 PM ET), which is what matters for avoiding additional penalties. Just make sure to save/print your confirmation page - that's your proof of payment if any issues arise later. The whole process typically takes 10-15 minutes once you have everything organized. You've got this!
This is incredibly helpful professional insight! I really appreciate you breaking down exactly what information I need to have ready before starting the DirectPay process. The tip about potentially adding an extra $10-20 for accrued interest is something I wouldn't have thought of but makes total sense given that my notice is about 3 weeks old now. Your point about the payment being credited on the date of submission (before 8 PM ET) is really reassuring since I was worried about processing delays affecting my due date. Quick question - when you mention that people should call the number on their notice to get the exact current balance, do you find that clients actually get through to someone relatively quickly, or is it typically a long wait? I'm trying to decide whether it's worth the potential hold time or if adding that small buffer amount is the safer bet. Thanks so much for sharing your professional expertise - it's exactly the kind of authoritative guidance that makes me feel confident about tackling this payment!
Sarah Ali
Just a heads up on those cutting machines - I made the mistake of putting similar equipment ($250 range) under Section 179 last year, and my tax preparer said it created unnecessary complication. She had to go back and reclassify them as simple expenses under the de minimis rule, which apparently is much cleaner for audit purposes. For the utilities question, I use a Kill-A-Watt meter to track exactly how much electricity my craft equipment uses. I can literally show the difference in usage between when my machines are running vs not. My accountant said this is perfect documentation to justify claiming more than just the square footage percentage for electricity.
0 coins
Zoe Wang
ā¢That Kill-A-Watt meter idea is brilliant! I'm going to get one. Did your accountant have you put the extra electricity usage under Operations Expenses - Utilities, or somewhere else? And did they have you document specific times/dates when you were using the equipment?
0 coins
Sarah Ali
ā¢My accountant had me list the extra electricity under Operations Expenses - Utilities. I kept a simple log of when I ran production batches (dates and hours), and I had measurement readings of how much power the machines used during operation. I also took baseline readings of normal household usage for comparison. She said the key is being reasonable and having documentation. I didn't try to claim every tiny increase, just the significant electricity used directly by the business equipment. She also suggested taking photos of the meter readings occasionally as additional proof. The IRS generally won't question well-documented business expenses that make logical sense.
0 coins
Keisha Taylor
Great questions about Schedule C categorization! As someone who's been through this confusion before, here's my take based on experience and professional guidance: Your vinyl sheets are definitely COGS Materials and Supplies since they directly become part of your finished product. This is the clearest categorization you have. For those $230 cutting machines, you're overthinking it! Since they're under the $2,500 de minimis threshold and have short useful lives, just expense them immediately under Operations Expenses - Supplies. No need for Section 179 or depreciation headaches for relatively inexpensive equipment. Packaging materials should go under COGS Materials and Supplies too - they're essential for delivering your finished product to customers, so they're part of your cost of goods sold. For utilities, if you track actual usage (like with a power meter), you can definitely claim more than just the standard home office percentage. Document your machine usage patterns and put the business portion under Operations Expenses - Utilities. Phone/internet business usage goes under Operations Expenses - Utilities at whatever reasonable percentage you can document. Those Costco storage bins are definitely just Operations Expenses - Supplies. At $12, they're way below any capitalization threshold. The key is reasonable documentation and consistency in your categorization approach!
0 coins
CosmicCadet
ā¢This is such helpful advice! I'm new to running a small business and the Schedule C categories have been really overwhelming. Your explanation about the de minimis threshold is especially useful - I had no idea there was a $2,500 rule that could simplify things so much. One question: when you say "reasonable documentation" for the utilities, what does that actually look like in practice? I'm worried about keeping too little documentation and getting in trouble, but also don't want to go overboard with record-keeping if it's not necessary. Also, is there a specific form or statement you need to file to elect the de minimis safe harbor treatment, or do you just categorize the expenses that way on your Schedule C?
0 coins