


Ask the community...
I just want to point out that for the 2025 filing season (for 2024 tax year), there's a slightly higher threshold for long-term capital gains tax rates. For single filers, the 0% rate applies up to $47,025 of taxable income and the 15% rate applies up to $518,900. So depending on your income level, this could affect how you fill out the Capital Gain Tax Worksheet. The Qualified Dividends and Capital Gain Tax Worksheet is critical because if you don't use it, you might massively overpay your taxes. FreeFileFillableForms won't catch this - it just takes whatever numbers you input.
Those thresholds don't sound right. I thought the capital gains brackets were lower than that. Can anyone confirm these numbers?
Those numbers look correct for the 2024 tax year (2025 filing season). The 0% long-term capital gains rate does apply up to $47,025 for single filers, and the 15% rate goes up to $518,900. These thresholds are adjusted annually for inflation. You can verify these on the IRS website under Publication 550 or the current year's tax tables. It's definitely worth double-checking since these brackets change each year, but Keisha's numbers are accurate for returns being filed now.
Just to add another perspective here - I've been using FreeFileFillableForms for several years with investment income, and the key thing to remember is that it's really just a digital version of the paper forms. You're still responsible for all the calculations that would normally be done on supporting worksheets. For the Qualified Dividends and Capital Gain Tax Worksheet specifically, I usually download the PDF from irs.gov, work through it step by step, and keep a copy with my tax records even though it doesn't get submitted. The most important thing is making sure you use the correct tax year's version - don't accidentally grab last year's worksheet since the income thresholds and rates change annually. One tip that's helped me: after completing the worksheet, I always cross-reference my final tax calculation with the tax tables to make sure everything looks reasonable. FreeFileFillableForms won't catch computational errors in your supporting worksheets, so that sanity check has saved me from mistakes more than once.
This is really helpful advice! I'm new to investment income and wasn't sure about keeping copies of worksheets that don't get submitted. Quick question - when you do that sanity check against the tax tables, are you comparing your total tax amount or just the capital gains portion? Also, do you have any recommendations for organizing all these supporting documents? I feel like I'm going to end up with a mess of PDFs and calculations that I won't be able to make sense of later.
This is a bit off-topic but make sure whatever brokerage you're using actually allows non-resident aliens if that's your status! I had a friend who was on F-1, started trading with a popular app, then found out later they weren't supposed to be using it as a non-resident. Caused all kinds of headaches at tax time.
Thanks for the warning! I hadn't even considered that some brokerages might not accept non-residents. Do you know which brokerages are better for international students in my situation?
I've had good experiences with Charles Schwab International and Interactive Brokers - both are pretty accommodating for non-resident aliens and have clear processes for tax reporting. Fidelity is also solid if you end up being classified as a resident alien. The key is being upfront about your visa status during account opening. Most major brokerages will ask about your tax residency status and some will even help you figure it out. Just avoid the newer app-based brokers that might not have the infrastructure to handle international tax situations properly. Also, whatever you choose, make sure they can issue the proper tax forms (like 1042-S for non-residents) at year-end!
Just wanted to add another perspective here - I went through a similar visa transition (F-2 to F-1) a couple years ago. One thing that really helped me was getting a copy of my complete I-94 travel history from the CBP website before trying to figure out my residency status. The substantial presence test calculations can get really complex with visa changes, especially when you're trying to figure out which days count as "exempt" vs "non-exempt." Having the exact entry/exit dates made it much easier to work through the math. Also, since you mentioned you've been here since December 2019, you're probably still within the 5-year exempt period for F-1 students (which started when you switched to F-1 in March 2024). But the F-2 time might have different rules depending on your spouse's/parent's visa status during that period. Given the amount of money you're planning to invest, it's probably worth getting professional advice from a tax attorney or CPA who specializes in international tax issues. The wrong classification could cost you way more in taxes than the consultation fee, especially with the dividend withholding differences others mentioned.
This is really helpful advice! I didn't know about the CBP website for getting I-94 travel history. That sounds like it would make the calculations much more straightforward than trying to remember all my entry/exit dates. You're right about the professional consultation being worth it given the investment amount. I'm realizing there are so many nuances I hadn't considered - like how my F-2 status might be tied to my spouse's/parent's visa situation during that time period. Do you happen to know if the 5-year F-1 exempt period calculation starts fresh when you switch from F-2 to F-1, or if there's some overlap/carryover? I'm trying to figure out if I'm close to the end of my exempt status or if I have more time before my days start counting toward the substantial presence test.
The F-1 exempt period calculation is a bit tricky when transitioning from F-2. Generally, the 5-year exemption for F-1 students starts from when you first entered the US in F-1 status (March 2024 in your case), not when you were on F-2. However, if you were previously in the US as an F-1 student before switching to F-2, those earlier F-1 years would count toward your 5-year limit. Since you went directly from F-2 to F-1, you should have the full 5-year exemption period starting from March 2024. This means you'd be exempt from the substantial presence test until approximately March 2029, assuming you maintain F-1 status. The F-2 period (December 2019 - March 2024) would have its own exemption rules that typically follow the primary visa holder's status. Those days likely don't count toward your substantial presence test either, but for different reasons. I'd definitely recommend getting that I-94 history and consulting with a tax professional to confirm these calculations for your specific situation. The CBP website (i94.cbp.dhs.gov) makes it easy to get your complete travel history, which will be invaluable for any professional review.
I've been following this thread closely because I'm dealing with the same frustrating situation - mailed my return to the Philadelphia processing center on January 15th and still nothing showing up in the IRS system. After reading everyone's experiences, I decided to try Claimyr yesterday and I'm happy to report it actually worked! Got connected to an IRS agent after about 35 minutes of waiting. The agent confirmed they received my return on January 20th but said Philadelphia is currently running 8-10 weeks just to enter paper returns into their computer system. She explained that even though they physically have my return, it won't show up on "Where's My Refund" until it's been digitally processed. The relief of just knowing it's not lost somewhere was incredible. The agent also mentioned that sending a duplicate return would actually slow things down further because they'd have to manually resolve the duplication. So glad I found this thread before making that mistake! For anyone still waiting - hang in there. The paper filing system is definitely broken, but your returns are likely just sitting in processing queues, not lost. Getting that confirmation from an actual IRS person made all the difference for my peace of mind.
This is so helpful to hear! I'm dealing with the exact same timeline - mailed mine on January 18th and have been checking the IRS website obsessively with no luck. Your experience with Claimyr gives me hope that I can at least get confirmation they received it. It's really frustrating that the IRS can't even update their system to show "received but not processed" versus "not received at all." The uncertainty is honestly the worst part of this whole process. I've been losing sleep wondering if my return got lost in the mail or is sitting in some processing center. Did the agent give you any sense of when yours might actually be processed, or just that it would take 8-10 weeks to show up in the system? I'm trying to figure out if I should expect my refund sometime in April or if it could be even longer than that.
I'm in a very similar situation and this thread has been incredibly helpful! Mailed my return to the Kansas City processing center on February 8th and have been anxiously checking the IRS website daily with no results. Reading about everyone's experiences with both taxr.ai and Claimyr, I think I'm going to try Claimyr first to get confirmation that my return was actually received. The peace of mind aspect that several people mentioned is exactly what I need right now - the not knowing is causing me way more stress than just waiting would if I had a timeline. It's really eye-opening to learn about the different processing speeds between IRS centers. I had no idea Kansas City was potentially faster than Austin or Philadelphia. Does anyone know if there's a comprehensive list somewhere of current processing times by center? It would be helpful for planning purposes and managing expectations. Thanks to everyone for sharing their experiences - this community thread has been more informative than hours of trying to navigate the official IRS resources!
I'm in the exact same boat - mailed my return to Kansas City on February 12th and the waiting without any confirmation is honestly making me more anxious than I expected. This thread has been a lifesaver for understanding what's actually happening behind the scenes. Based on what everyone's shared, it sounds like Kansas City might be one of the better options, but even "faster" still means 6-8 weeks just to show up in their system. I'm definitely going to try Claimyr today - just getting confirmation that they actually received my return would eliminate so much stress. Has anyone found a reliable source for current processing times by center? It seems like this information would be really valuable for people trying to figure out realistic timelines, but the IRS website is basically useless for this kind of detail.
I'm a tax attorney who specializes in small business compliance, and I want to emphasize something that hasn't been fully addressed: the legal distinction between information reporting and income reporting. Your obligation to issue 1099-NECs stems from IRC Section 6041, which requires businesses to report payments of $600+ for services regardless of payment method. This is information reporting - you're telling the IRS "I paid this person this amount." How you paid them (Venmo, check, cash, cryptocurrency) is legally irrelevant. The 1099-K that Venmo might issue is under IRC Section 6050W, which reports payment card and third-party network transactions. This serves a completely different purpose and doesn't replace your Section 6041 obligation. Here's what many people miss: your contractor's tax liability doesn't change based on which forms they receive. They owe tax on income received, period. Whether they get a 1099-NEC from you, a 1099-K from Venmo, both, or neither doesn't change their underlying tax obligation. The forms are just information reports to help the IRS match income. For your resistant contractor, send a formal backup withholding notice citing Treas. Reg. 31.3406(d)-5. If they continue refusing after proper notice, you're required to withhold 24% under IRC Section 3406. Document everything - the regulation provides safe harbor if you can demonstrate reasonable efforts to obtain the TIN. With $145k in contractor payments, non-compliance isn't worth the risk. The penalties under IRC Section 6721 can reach $290 per missing form, and that's before considering potential audit exposure on your expense deductions.
Thank you for this incredibly detailed legal breakdown! As someone new to this community and dealing with contractor payments for the first time, the distinction between IRC Section 6041 and 6050W really clarifies why I've been seeing so much conflicting information online. Your explanation about information reporting vs. income reporting is particularly helpful - I was getting confused thinking that different forms somehow created different tax obligations for my contractors, when really they're just different ways of reporting the same underlying income to the IRS. The specific regulatory citations you provided (especially Treas. Reg. 31.3406(d)-5 for backup withholding) give me exactly the kind of authoritative guidance I need to handle my resistant contractor situation professionally and legally. I really appreciate you taking the time to cut through all the confusion with actual tax code references. It's clear that regardless of all the noise about payment apps, the fundamental reporting requirements haven't changed. I'm going to stop second-guessing myself and get those 1099-NECs issued immediately.
This has been an incredibly thorough discussion that really cleared up my confusion about Venmo payments and 1099 requirements. As a newcomer to this community dealing with my first year managing contractors, I was getting completely overwhelmed by conflicting advice online. The key insight that finally clicked for me was understanding that my obligation as a business paying for services is completely separate from whatever reporting Venmo might do. Whether I pay by check, wire transfer, or Venmo doesn't change the fundamental requirement to issue 1099-NECs for services over $600. For anyone else in a similar situation, I found the combination of tools mentioned here really helpful - taxr.ai for analyzing my payment obligations and Claimyr for getting direct IRS confirmation when I had specific questions. Having that official guidance documented gave me confidence to move forward despite pushback from contractors. The backup withholding approach for resistant contractors also makes complete sense now. I was being too accommodating when I should have been protecting my business interests. A formal notice explaining 24% withholding on future payments tends to resolve W9 issues quickly. Thanks to everyone who shared their experiences and expertise. The consensus is crystal clear - issue those 1099-NECs regardless of payment method and protect your business!
Amara Torres
I just went through this exact same situation about a month ago! Got my CP24 letter and was immediately stressed about when the money would actually arrive. Like everyone else has mentioned here, the IRS's 4-6 week estimate is definitely overly conservative. My refund hit my account in exactly 19 days from when I received the CP24 letter. The adjustment was actually in my favor - they caught that I had missed claiming the Premium Tax Credit properly, which added an extra $320 to my refund. Here's what I learned that might help: The CP24 notice means they've already completed the heavy lifting of processing your return. The August 25th date on your letter indicates they finished their review by then, so you're actually further along than it might seem. I'd strongly recommend using the IRS2Go app with notifications enabled - it updated me automatically when my status changed from "processing" to "approved" about 8 days after I got the letter. Make sure you're checking with your new adjusted refund amount from the CP24, not your original filing amount. Based on all the timelines people are sharing here, you should definitely have your car repair money well before October - probably by early to mid-September. The CP24 is actually good news since these adjustments are usually in the taxpayer's favor!
0 coins
Henry Delgado
ā¢This thread has been so incredibly helpful! As someone who just received my first CP24 notice, I was really panicking about the timeline and what it all meant. Reading everyone's actual experiences - with refunds arriving in 13-19 days instead of the 4-6 weeks quoted - is such a huge relief. It's amazing how the IRS gives such conservative estimates when the reality seems to be much faster. I'm definitely downloading the IRS2Go app right now and will make sure to check with my adjusted amount. The fact that most people are reporting positive adjustments with additional credits they missed gives me hope that this might actually work out better than my original filing. Thanks everyone for sharing your real timelines and practical tips - this community is so much more helpful than trying to navigate the IRS website alone!
0 coins
Hannah Flores
I'm also dealing with a CP24 situation right now and this thread has been incredibly reassuring! Got my notice about a week ago and was really worried about the 4-6 week timeline, but seeing everyone's actual experiences of 13-19 days is such a relief. One thing I wanted to add that I haven't seen mentioned yet - if you're really anxious about the timeline like I was, you can also set up account alerts through your bank's mobile app. That way you'll get notified immediately when any deposit hits your account, even if the IRS systems haven't updated yet. I've been checking "Where's My Refund" daily with my new adjusted amount (thanks for that tip everyone!), but knowing I'll get a bank notification the moment the money arrives gives me extra peace of mind. Based on all these positive experiences, it sounds like your car repairs should definitely be covered by mid-September rather than October. The CP24 really does seem to be good news rather than something to stress about!
0 coins