
IRS
CommunityGovernment Services


Ask the community...
So I've been running my tabletop RPG business for about two years now (I host paid D&D sessions and design custom campaigns). After filing taxes this spring, I was shocked at how much I owed! Talking to my cousin who runs his own plumbing business, he asked if I was "paying myself" from my business income. I was confused because I just take whatever money comes in and use it personally after expenses. He insisted I could "pay myself" and somehow deduct that from my business taxes. Is this actually a legitimate thing for self-employed people? I'm not sure if he's confused or if I'm missing out on a huge tax benefit. How would this even work with a single-person business where all the money just goes into my personal account anyway?
I've been loyally using FreeTaxUSA for the past several years with no issues whatsoever. Well, this year I finished my entire return only to discover I need to MAIL it because of Form 7202 (sick leave credit). Super annoying! I did some digging and found out the IRS actually prefers and will accept e-filed returns with Form 7202 if the data is attached as an additional document. So now I'm wondering which tax preparation companies have actually implemented Form 7202 into their systems and can properly e-file it? Let me start a running list of what I've found so far: H&R Block: They can e-file with Form 7202, but it's pretty expensive starting at $149 TaxSlayer: They support it, but honestly their interface is terrible and not user-friendly at all. Instead of walking you through a simple step-by-step process, you have to hunt around for everything you need. Has anyone used other services that properly handle Form 7202 e-filing? I really don't want to mail in my return if I can avoid it!
I know this is a bit late to the party, but I just wanted to let everyone know that I just checked today and OnLine Taxes (OLT.com) also supports Form 7202 e-filing. It's only $49.95 for their premium version which is way cheaper than H&R Block or TurboTax. The interface isn't fancy but it gets the job done if you're primarily concerned about being able to e-file with Form 7202 without spending a fortune.
Have you actually used OLT yourself? I've never heard of them before and I'm worried about using some random tax site. Are they an authorized IRS e-file provider? And did they handle the rest of your taxes okay? I've got some investment stuff and a small business too.
Yes, I've used OLT for the past two years including this year with Form 7202. They are definitely an authorized IRS e-file provider - you can check the IRS website for their list of authorized providers and OLT is on there. For your investment and small business concerns, they handled my stock trades and side gig income without any problems. Their interface isn't as slick as TurboTax, but all the necessary forms and schedules are there. I found their small business section particularly good at walking through deductions many people miss. The $49.95 price includes all forms including Schedule C for business.
Any of you try using a tax professional instead of software? After struggling with Form 7202 last year trying to DIY with software, I broke down and hired an EA (Enrolled Agent) this year. Cost me $275 but she handled everything including Form 7202 and e-filed with no issues. Plus she found deductions I missed last year that more than paid for her fee.
Just got bumped up to 65k yearly and I'm kinda shocked at how much is coming out of each check. Looking at my paystubs, they're taking about $200 for Social Security and over $300 for federal taxes every paycheck (I get paid twice monthly). I mean, I understand taxes are unavoidable and necessary, but this feels like highway robbery! I'm a single guy in Texas with zero dependents, and I actually live pretty minimally compared to what I make. No fancy car, reasonable apartment, cook most meals at home. Is this normal or am I getting hit harder than I should be? Anyone else making around the same amount seeing similar withholdings? Are there any tax changes coming in 2025 that might help? Besides taking a pay cut ๐ what options do I have to keep more of what I earn? Any legit deductions or strategies I'm missing?
Something nobody mentioned yet - with your income level, you might look into contributing to a Roth IRA instead of a traditional IRA. At $65k, you're probably better off paying taxes now (while your rate is relatively low) than later in retirement when your rate might be higher. Max contribution is $7,000 for 2025 if you're under 50. While it won't reduce your current tax bill, the growth is tax-free when you withdraw in retirement, which is huge!
Wouldn't traditional IRA be better if they're trying to lower their current tax bill though? Roth doesn't help with that at all.
You're right that a traditional IRA would help lower the current tax bill, which is definitely an advantage if immediate cash flow is the primary concern. I suggested Roth because at $65k, OP is probably in the 22% tax bracket now, and many financial planners believe this is a relatively favorable rate to pay taxes at, especially for someone early in their career whose income (and potentially tax bracket) will likely increase. The long-term tax-free growth often outweighs the current tax deduction for younger earners. But it's definitely a personal decision that depends on individual circumstances and priorities.
Anybody have experience with adjusting their W-4 specifically? My pay is similar to OP's and I'm wondering how many allowances I should claim to get a more reasonable withholding without owing a bunch at tax time.
The new W-4 doesn't use allowances anymore (changed in 2020). You now have to specify actual dollar amounts for additional withholding or reduction. Bit more complicated but more accurate.
I just opened my mail yesterday and found a letter from the IRS saying I owe almost $40k in taxes and penalties from my 2022 tax return. I'm freaking out because they're clearly wrong about this, and I have the documents to prove it. The issue is they're counting all my stock sales as pure income without factoring in what I originally paid for the stocks (the cost basis). So they're basically treating it like I got all this free money when in reality, I barely broke even on some trades and lost money on others! I've got all my brokerage statements showing exactly what I paid for everything. What I'm trying to figure out now is who's the best person to help me respond to this mess? Should I just write back myself? Go to H&R Block? Hire an accountant? Or do I need a full-on tax attorney for this? I don't want to overspend if I can handle it myself, but I also don't want to screw this up and end up actually owing all that money because I responded the wrong way. Has anyone dealt with this kind of IRS letter before? Any advice on the most effective way to get them to correct their mistake?
One thing nobody's mentioned yet - check if your brokerage actually submitted a corrected 1099-B after you filed your taxes. This happened to me and was the source of the problem. I filed in February, then in March my brokerage sent a corrected form with updated cost basis info, but I never realized it. The IRS got the updated form which didn't match what I filed, and that triggered the notice. If this is what happened to you, the solution is pretty straightforward - you just need to show that you filed based on the information you had at the time, and provide the corrected information now.
That's a really good point I hadn't considered. I did file pretty early (mid-February) because I usually get a refund. I'm going to log into my brokerage account right now and see if they issued a corrected 1099-B that I missed. If they did, would I need to file an amended return or just respond to the notice with the updated information?
You typically don't need to file an amended return in this case. The response to the notice effectively serves as your correction. In your response letter, you should explain that you filed with the original information provided by your brokerage, and include copies of both the original and corrected 1099-B forms. Make sure to clearly reconcile the differences between what you reported and what the corrected form shows. The IRS mostly wants to see that you can account for the discrepancy and that you're not trying to hide income. They're generally reasonable when the error originated with the brokerage rather than you.
Has anyone mentioned CP2000 responses can be done online now? You don't always have to mail back paper forms. The IRS has a portal where you can respond to certain notices electronically. Check if your notice has an option for online response - it's WAY faster.
Online response is definitely better when available! But you still need to scan and upload all your supporting documents. I did mine online last year and still had to upload about 20 pages of stock transaction records. But processing time was only about 3 weeks versus the 2+ months it took when I mailed in a response the previous year.
You make a good point about still needing to provide all the documentation. I should have been clearer. The main advantage isn't reducing what you need to submit, but rather the processing time and confirmation. When you submit online, you get an immediate confirmation that they received your response, which gives peace of mind compared to wondering if your mail got lost. The other major advantage is that online responses typically get processed in the order received, while paper responses can get shuffled into various processing backlogs. This is especially important when responding to a notice with a deadline.
Just got my 1099-B for selling some Bitcoin last year. The total proceeds were only around $28. I plugged everything into TurboTax to see what an amendment would look like, and apparently I'd owe $4 in federal taxes. But here's the thing - filing an amendment would cost me $19.99 through the software. Is it even worth filing an amendment for such a small amount? Can I just send the IRS a check for $4 directly without going through the whole amendment process? Seems ridiculous to pay $20 to file something that only changes my tax by $4.
Former tax preparer here. For amounts this small, it's really not worth amending. The IRS computer systems have tolerance thresholds built in, and a $4 difference won't trigger any action. If you really want to be 100% by the book, you can file a paper amendment for free, but honestly, the postage stamp would cost almost as much as the tax owed. Most practitioners I know wouldn't bother with an amendment for anything under $50 in tax difference.
If they do have these threshold amounts, why doesn't the IRS just publish them? Seems like it would save everyone a lot of time and stress over tiny amounts.
They don't publish the exact thresholds for a strategic reason. If everyone knew precisely what amount they could "get away with" not reporting, many people would deliberately stay just under that threshold, and the cumulative effect across millions of taxpayers would be significant. The IRS wants everyone to report everything accurately, but they have to allocate their limited enforcement resources effectively. They keep these internal tolerance levels confidential and also change them periodically to prevent systematic abuse.
Quick question - if I'm in a similar situation but I OVERPAID by a small amount ($10-20) because I missed a deduction, is it worth amending to get that money back? Or is the same "too small to bother" rule apply?
For overpayments, the calculation is different. You're getting YOUR money back, so it depends on how much your time is worth. A refund of $20 might be worth the 30-45 minutes it takes to prepare and mail a paper amendment. Remember though, paper amendments can take 6-12 months to process currently, so you'll be waiting a while for that $20.
Noah Torres
Just to add another perspective: I run a TTRPGing business similar to yours, and I did actually set up an LLC taxed as an S-corp because my income got high enough. I pay myself a salary of $3,500/month which is "reasonable" for a TTRPG creator in my area, and then take distributions for the rest. The paperwork is a pain and I pay about $1,200/year for a bookkeeper to handle the quarterly filings, but I'm saving around $7,400/year in self-employment taxes. If you're making under $40k profit, stick with sole proprietor and focus on maximizing your deductions instead.
0 coins
Samantha Hall
How did you determine what's a "reasonable" salary for a DM? I didn't think there was enough data for that kind of job to establish market rates.
0 coins
Noah Torres
I researched what other professional DMs and TTRPG content creators charge hourly in my area and nationwide, then calculated what a full-time equivalent would earn. I also looked at similar creative professionals like game designers and tabletop gaming store managers. I documented all this research in case of an audit. The key is having a methodology that shows you didn't just pick a low number to avoid taxes. My CPA helped me gather comparable profession data that would stand up to scrutiny. With niche professions like ours, you need to get creative with finding salary comparisons, but there's actually more data out there than you might think now that professional DMing has grown as a career.
0 coins
Ryan Young
Don't forget about quarterly estimated tax payments if you're self-employed! I learned this the hard way with my editing business last year - got hit with a $420 penalty because I waited until April to pay everything.
0 coins
Sophia Clark
How do you even calculate how much to pay quarterly when your income fluctuates month to month? My crafting business is super seasonal and I have no idea what I'll make until I make it.
0 coins