Thanks for that tip! Do you know if using the FTA for an estimated tax penalty would prevent me from using it for other types of penalties in the future? Like if I somehow ended up with a late filing penalty next year?

Good question. The FTA policy is actually applied separately to different types of penalties. So using your FTA for an estimated tax penalty wouldn't prevent you from qualifying for an FTA on a late filing or late payment penalty in the future. The IRS treats each penalty type as its own category for FTA purposes. But you should still aim to avoid penalties altogether since FTAs aren't guaranteed and depend on your compliance history.

Isn't the Practitioner Priority Line only for tax professionals with CAF numbers? I don't think regular taxpayers can use that line - we're stuck with the normal IRS customer service line.

22 Is there a time limit for recharacterization though? I thought you had to do that by the tax filing deadline for the year of the contribution.

11 You're absolutely right about the time limit, and that's an important clarification. Recharacterization generally must be done by the tax filing deadline (including extensions) for the year of the contribution. Since the OP mentioned this was from "several years ago," recharacterization is unfortunately no longer an option. For anyone else reading this who recently made an excess contribution, recharacterization is a great option, but it has to be done quickly. For the OP, removal of the excess contribution (plus earnings) is likely the only remaining option to stop the ongoing 6% penalty.

1 Thanks for sharing your experience! Did you need to provide any specific documentation to your brokerage to prove the contribution was excess? Or did they just take your word for it and process the request?

6 They didn't require any documentation at all. I just had to tell them which contribution I wanted treated as excess (in my case it was the whole annual contribution). They have all the records of your contributions already in their system. They did warn me that the calculation of earnings might result in different numbers than I expected, especially if the market had gone up or down significantly since the contribution. In my case, the earnings portion was actually negative because the market had dropped after my contribution, which was actually better for tax purposes since I didn't have to pay tax on earnings that didn't exist.

Thanks for pointing that out. I held most of these coins for over a year, but some of the DeFi stuff was shorter term. Do I need to separate those out specifically on different forms, or just calculate different rates?

You'll report them separately on your Schedule D and Form 8949. You'll use different sections of Form 8949 - Part I for short-term transactions and Part II for long-term. Each transaction gets reported individually with its purchase date, sale date, proceeds, and cost basis. This is where good record keeping becomes really important, as you need to know the specific purchase and sale dates for each position. If you're using tax software, it will guide you through this process and calculate the appropriate tax for each category.

Using $0 cost basis is the nuclear option though - definitely a last resort! I'd exhaust every possible method to reconstruct your basis before going that route. Bank statements, credit card statements, emails from exchanges confirming purchases - anything can help establish at least some basis.

So does this mean your student's income DID count toward PTC household income once you filed their return? Or were they still exempt from household income because they were below the filing requirement threshold, even though you voluntarily filed? This distinction seems really important.

Their income remained exempt from the household income calculation for Premium Tax Credit purposes. The key is that they were below the filing requirement thresholds ($12,950 for earned income and $1,250 for unearned income), so even though we voluntarily filed a return, their income didn't have to be included in the PTC household calculation. The IRS looks at whether they were required to file, not whether they actually filed. This is an important distinction that many tax software programs don't explain well. So we got the benefit of claiming the American Opportunity Credit without any negative impact on our Premium Tax Credit.

Good question! For Additional Child Tax Credit purposes, earned income refers to wages, salaries, tips, self-employment income, and certain disability benefits. Work-study income does count as earned income because it's reported on a W-2 as wages. However, the confusion might be because you're thinking of the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC), which has its own specific definition of earned income. For the Additional Child Tax Credit, what matters is having at least $2,500 of earned income to begin qualifying, but the credit amount is based on your overall tax situation, not just earned income.

Thanks for clearing that up! I was totally mixing up ACTC requirements with EITC. That makes much more sense now. So if I understand right, the parent needs earned income to qualify for ACTC, but the scholarship question is more about how it affects household income for Premium Tax Credit, not whether it counts for the ACTC calculation itself?

Do you know if there's any difference in processing time between major banks and smaller credit unions? Mine sometimes takes longer for ACH transfers.

Yes, there can definitely be differences. Larger banks typically process ACH transfers (which is what IRS payments are) more quickly - usually within 24 hours of receiving them. Smaller credit unions sometimes batch their ACH processing and might only run them once per day, which can add a delay of up to 24 hours. If you're with a smaller credit union, I'd add an extra day to the expected processing time just to be safe. So if the IRS schedules the withdrawal for the 15th, it might not actually hit your account until the 17th or 18th at a smaller institution.

If your payment bounces, the IRS will send you a notice and charge you a penalty - usually about 2% of the payment amount. They'll also charge interest on the unpaid amount until you pay it. Plus your bank will probably charge you an NSF fee too.