


Ask the community...
3 When I was in a similar situation, I asked my preparer to walk me through each deduction and credit they were claiming. If they can't explain in plain English why you qualify for something, that's a huge red flag. A good preparer should be happy to educate you, not just expect blind trust. For what it's worth, some legitimate tax situations CAN result in unusually large refunds (first-time homebuyer credits, education credits, missed stimulus payments, earned income credit if your situation changed, etc). But you deserve to understand exactly where that money is coming from.
17 This is actually great advice. How detailed should their explanation be? My preparer just keeps saying "trust me, I know what I'm doing" without giving specifics.
3 They should be able to point to specific IRS rules or forms that apply to your situation. For instance, if they're claiming business expenses, they should explain which expenses qualify and how they determined the amounts. If they're claiming credits, they should walk you through the eligibility requirements and confirm you meet them. A good preparer will show you where on your tax documents (W-2s, 1099s, etc.) they're getting figures from, and explain any calculations. Vague answers or dismissing your questions with "trust me" is definitely concerning. Tax preparation isn't magic - it follows specific rules that can be explained clearly.
14 You don't need a reason to switch tax preparers! It's YOUR money and YOUR tax liability on the line. A $45k refund does sound suspiciously high unless you had some unusual circumstances this year (sold a business, major life changes, etc.). What tax software or service does she use? I switched from one major company to another last year and noticed a HUGE difference in how they approached deductions.
20 I'm not sure what software she uses, I just know she has her own office with her name on the door. Does the type of software make that big a difference in the final refund amount?
One thing to consider - you mentioned your employer is based in PA. If you were working remotely from Minnesota for those 7 months (rather than in a Minnesota office), some states have "convenience of employer" rules that could affect where you owe taxes. Pennsylvania doesn't have this rule, but it's something to be aware of when dealing with multi-state situations. For your specific situation, I'd recommend looking at when you officially changed your driver's license, voter registration, and other official documents. Having documentation of when you established Minnesota residency will be helpful if either state questions your allocation.
That's a good point about documentation. I got my MN driver's license in June and changed my voter registration right after moving. I was working fully remote during this time, but for the same PA-based company. Does that change the situation at all with how I should allocate income?
Working remotely actually simplifies your situation somewhat. Since Pennsylvania doesn't have a "convenience of employer" rule, your income is taxed based on where you physically performed the work. So for those 7 months you were working remotely from Minnesota, that income should be allocated to Minnesota regardless of where your employer is based. Your documentation of establishing Minnesota residency in June aligns with your move timeline, which is perfect. Just make sure to keep copies of your driver's license change, voter registration, lease/mortgage documents, and utility bills showing your Minnesota address. These will be your proof if either state ever questions your residency dates.
Has anyone used TurboTax for a situation like this? I'm wondering if it can handle multi-state returns with mismatched W2s properly or if I need to use a professional tax preparer.
I used TurboTax last year for a similar situation (moved from Washington to Oregon mid-year). It actually handles it pretty well! There's a section where you enter your residency information for each state, and it creates the proper part-year resident returns. For the W2 allocation, you'll need to do a bit of manual work. TurboTax will initially allocate your W2 income based on what's in the state boxes, but you can override this. There's a worksheet where you can adjust how much income goes to each state. Just make sure to keep good documentation of how you calculated everything.
Just an important note: if you're adjusting your withholding to have less taken out, make sure you're setting aside that extra money somewhere! I did this last year thinking "I'll just pay what I owe in April" but then spent the extra money and got hit with a $3800 tax bill I wasn't prepared for. Either build up savings throughout the year or make estimated quarterly payments to avoid a nasty surprise.
You can make estimated quarterly tax payments using Form 1040-ES. The easiest way is to use the IRS Direct Pay system on their website - just select "estimated tax payment" as the reason. You don't need to create an account, and you can pay directly from your bank account. The due dates are typically April 15, June 15, September 15, and January 15 (of the following year), though they can shift slightly if those dates fall on weekends or holidays.
Has anyone actually gotten in trouble with the IRS for adjusting their withholding too much? Im thinking of claiming 3 dependents even tho i dont have any just to get more money in my checks but worried about penalties??
This is definitely not recommended. The W-4 form contains a clear statement that you sign under penalty of perjury. Intentionally claiming dependents you don't have could be considered tax fraud. Instead, use the proper methods on the W-4 form to adjust your withholding. The "Additional withholding" line in Step 4(c) allows you to specify a negative amount that reduces your withholding without falsely claiming dependents. Much safer approach!
One thing nobody has mentioned yet - if your grandmother had any outstanding debts when she passed, the estate should pay those before distributing assets to beneficiaries. If the executor didn't handle this properly and creditors come after the estate later, beneficiaries can sometimes be asked to return distributed assets. Not trying to scare you, but it's something to check with the executor about. Did they publish notices to potential creditors and wait the required period before distributing assets?
Oh man, that's concerning. I have no idea if the executor did that. It's my uncle (dad's brother) handling everything. I'll definitely ask him about this. How long do they usually need to wait before distributing?
The waiting period varies by state, but it's typically between 3-6 months after publishing notices to creditors. In Texas, I believe it's 4 months. A properly handled estate administration should include this step, but family-member executors sometimes skip parts of the process if they're not working with an attorney. Just check that your uncle published the required notices and waited the appropriate time. If he worked with an estate attorney, they would have ensured this was done correctly.
I inherited money last year and completely forgot to mention it to my tax preparer. Should I be worried? Do I need to file an amended return?
You're most likely fine. If it was a straightforward inheritance (not from an IRA or retirement account), you typically don't need to report it on your tax return at all. Inheritances generally aren't considered taxable income to the beneficiary. The only exception would be if you inherited something that was generating income after the person died (like interest, dividends, rental income, etc.) - in that case, you would need to report that income, but not the inheritance itself.
Rita Jacobs
22 Have you considered switching accountants? Not all tax professionals have the same expertise with business taxes, especially with specialized credits like R&D. I switched to a CPA who specializes in small manufacturing businesses last year, and the difference was incredible. She found deductions my previous accountant missed for years and explained everything in terms I could understand. Ask potential accountants specifically about their experience with R&D credits and QBI deduction optimization. The right match can make a world of difference.
0 coins
Rita Jacobs
ā¢1 I've thought about switching, but I've been with my current guy for 5 years and I worry about starting fresh with someone new. How did you find your specialized CPA? Did you interview multiple people? Was the transition difficult with all your previous tax history?
0 coins
Rita Jacobs
ā¢22 I found my CPA through a manufacturing industry association, which was great because she already understood my business model. I interviewed three different CPAs and asked each the same questions about their experience with R&D credits and multi-state filing. The differences in their answers made the choice clear. The transition was actually smoother than I expected. I provided my new CPA with the last three years of returns, and she did a free initial review to identify opportunities before I fully committed. She found nearly $12,000 in missed deductions in just the previous year. We filed amendments and her fee was more than covered by the refunds. Most good accountants have systems for onboarding new clients effectively.
0 coins
Rita Jacobs
3 Anyone tried using a tax software specifically for business owners instead of relying completely on an accountant? I've been thinking about trying to do more of the work myself to at least understand what's happening before handing it off to a professional.
0 coins
Rita Jacobs
ā¢9 I've used QuickBooks Self-Employed for the last couple years and it's been pretty decent for tracking expenses and estimating quarterly payments. But once you get into R&D credits or multi-state filing, it falls short. I now use it alongside my accountant - I handle the bookkeeping and basic stuff, then let the pro deal with the complex credits and deductions.
0 coins