


Ask the community...
One thing nobody's mentioned is that when your parents formed the LLC, did they elect S-Corporation taxation? Many small business owners switch from Schedule C filing to S-Corp status (which requires forming an entity like an LLC first) to save on self-employment taxes. If they did this, the big difference you're seeing might be because with an S-Corp, your parents should be paying themselves a "reasonable salary" which is subject to payroll taxes, with the remaining profit distributed as "distributions" that aren't subject to self-employment tax. This completely changes how income and expenses flow through to the tax return. Ask your parents if they're filing Form 1120-S rather than Schedule C now. That would explain the major differences you're seeing.
Thank you for this explanation! I just checked and it looks like they ARE filing something called an 1120-S now instead of the Schedule C. So does this mean we're actually making the same amount of money but it just looks different on paper? Could this hurt my chances for need-based scholarships?
Yes, that's exactly what's happening! With an S-Corporation (Form 1120-S), the income gets reported differently even if the actual money coming in is the same. The business income flows through to your parents' personal return on Schedule E rather than Schedule C. This could definitely impact your need-based scholarships because the FAFSA and many scholarship programs look at adjusted gross income. With an S-Corp structure, sometimes more of the business income flows to the personal return because expenses get handled differently. Your parents should talk to their tax preparer about optimizing their S-Corp approach for both tax savings and financial aid purposes. There are legitimate strategies to properly categorize business expenses on the 1120-S that might help reduce the reported income while still following tax laws correctly.
Just to add something nobody mentioned - when your parents switched to an LLC and possibly S-Corp taxation, did they start taking inventory into account differently? This could explain the weird cost of goods sold numbers. With a Schedule C, some small business owners are more casual about inventory tracking. But with an LLC, especially if they've switched to accrual accounting, the timing of when inventory is purchased versus when it's sold can cause huge swings in reported income from year to year.
Another strategy you might consider is timing your deductions. You could potentially still take the deductions but spread them out differently. Maybe take fewer deductions in the year before applying for your mortgage, then take more the following year to balance things out. That way you show higher income for the mortgage qualification but don't completely give up the tax benefits long-term.
Does this actually work with mortgage lenders though? Don't they usually look at 2 years of tax returns? I wonder if they'd notice the pattern and question it.
It can work depending on the lender and your specific situation. You're right that they typically look at 2 years, but many put more emphasis on the most recent year, especially if your income is trending upward. The key is to be strategic and consistent. Don't make it look like you're manipulating numbers - instead, make legitimate business decisions about when to make major purchases or when to defer income. For example, delaying some business purchases until after you close on the home is completely legitimate. Lenders understand that self-employed income fluctuates naturally.
Don't forget about self-employment taxes! If you choose not to take deductions, you'll pay more in income tax AND self-employment tax. For every $1000 in additional profit you show, you'll pay an extra $153 in SE tax (15.3%) plus whatever your income tax rate is. For most people that's at least another $120-220 per $1000 depending on your tax bracket. It adds up fast!
This is a really good point. When I did this last year, I was surprised how much extra I ended up paying because I forgot about the self-employment tax part. Definitely do the math carefully!
We had something similar happen a few years back. If you want to avoid having your refund taken again this year, you might want to adjust your withholding so you don't overpay throughout the year. That way, you won't have a refund for them to take! My husband and I changed our W-4s after this happened to us, and now we either break even or owe a small amount at tax time. Then we just make a payment for exactly what we owe. This gave us more money in our paychecks throughout the year AND prevented the IRS from automatically taking a big chunk for past debts. We set up a payment plan for the old debt instead.
Doesn't that strategy risk owing penalties if you end up owing too much at tax time? I thought there were rules about having to pay enough throughout the year.
You're right to be concerned about that! You do need to be careful not to underwithhold too much. The general rule is you need to pay at least 90% of your current year tax liability OR 100% of last year's tax liability (110% if your income is over $150,000) through withholding and estimated payments to avoid underpayment penalties. What we did was calculate it pretty closely so we'd either get a very small refund or owe just a little bit. This way we avoided the penalties while also preventing large refunds that would be automatically applied to old debts. It takes a bit more planning, but the IRS has a good withholding calculator on their website that helps make sure you're still meeting the requirements.
Has anyone figured out if the statute of limitations applies to these shared responsibility payments? I thought most IRS debts had a 10-year collection period. Since this is from 2016, would they only be able to collect until 2026?
Yes, the standard 10-year statute of limitations for IRS collections does apply to shared responsibility payments. The clock starts ticking from the date the tax was assessed, not the tax year itself. So if the assessment happened in 2017 for a 2016 tax issue, the IRS would have until 2027 to collect. Keep in mind that certain actions can extend this timeline, like if the taxpayer requests a payment plan or submits an offer in compromise. But barring any extensions, the IRS generally has 10 years to collect on this type of debt.
Something else to consider - you might need to make quarterly estimated tax payments going forward. When you're self-employed, you're supposed to pay taxes throughout the year (similar to withholding for W-2 employees). If you wait until tax time to pay everything, you might get hit with underpayment penalties on top of your tax bill. The IRS generally wants you to pay at least 90% of your current year's taxes or 100% of last year's tax liability through estimated payments to avoid penalties. I learned this the hard way my first year freelancing. Got hit with an extra $300 in penalties because I didn't know about quarterly payments. Just something to keep in mind for next year!
Oh no, I had no idea about quarterly payments! How do you even calculate how much to pay each quarter when freelance income is so unpredictable? Do you just guess?
You don't have to guess exactly. The IRS allows you to use the "annualized income installment method" for irregular income. Basically, you calculate your tax based on what you've earned so far in each quarter. Most tax software can help you calculate this, or you can use the IRS Form 1040-ES worksheet. Another approach is to set aside a percentage of each payment you receive (maybe 25-30%) in a separate savings account. Then use that to make your quarterly payments as best you can estimate.
Have you looked into whether you qualify for the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC)? At your income level, especially if you have any dependents, this could make a big difference. It's a refundable tax credit designed for lower to moderate income workers. Also, don't forget to check if your state has additional self-employment taxes or potentially tax credits that might help offset some of the federal burden. Some states are much more friendly to small business owners and freelancers than others.
Yuki Tanaka
Don't feel bad - this is literally the most common mistake for first-time business owners. The tax software takes you through a linear process, so until you get to the expenses section, it looks terrifying! Make sure you're tracking ALL legitimate business expenses: - Cost of goods/inventory - Shipping supplies - Software subscriptions - Advertising/marketing - Website hosting - Payment processing fees - Home office (if you have dedicated space) - Business percentage of internet/phone - Professional services (accountant, lawyer) - Business insurance You'll enter these on Schedule C, and they'll directly reduce your taxable income. The difference between $120k in revenue and maybe $50k in actual taxable profit is HUGE for your tax bill!
0 coins
StarStrider
ā¢Thanks for the detailed list! I didn't realize payment processing fees were deductible - that's actually a significant amount for my business. Is there a good rule of thumb for determining what percentage of my internet and phone to deduct? I use both for business but obviously personal use too.
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
ā¢For internet and phone, you need to determine a reasonable business-use percentage. If you use your cell phone 70% for business and 30% personal, you can deduct 70% of those costs. Just make sure you can justify the percentage if asked. For payment processing fees, absolutely deduct them all! Those PayPal/Stripe/credit card fees add up quickly and are 100% legitimate business expenses. Don't forget the monthly fees plus the per-transaction percentages. Many new business owners miss these, but they can easily add up to thousands of dollars in deductions over a year.
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
Have you considered hiring a CPA? I know it seems like an unnecessary expense, but when I started my business I tried doing it myself and missed so many deductions. I paid $350 for a CPA who specializes in small business taxes and she saved me over $8,000 in taxes my first year! She knew exactly what was deductible and what wasn't for my industry, plus gave me a system for tracking expenses throughout the year that made the next tax season super easy.
0 coins
Andre Laurent
ā¢I second this. Using a tax professional my first 2 years taught me how to properly do my taxes. Now I use TurboTax but actually understand what I'm doing. The education alone was worth the fee, and they likely will save you more than their cost.
0 coins