
IRS
CommunityGovernment Services


Ask the community...
So I recently discovered that the IRS apparently lets you e-file your 1040-X amended returns for 2019 tax year electronically now. This is a huge relief since I realized I forgot to claim some major deductions on my 2019 return that would get me back around $2,300. I've been putting off filing an amendment because I hate dealing with paper forms and the mail (plus waiting forever for processing). I tried looking at TurboTax, H&R Block, and even asked a friend who does taxes, but nobody seems to give me a straight answer about which software actually supports e-filing for 1040-X forms specifically for 2019 returns. The IRS website just says "it's possible" but doesn't list specific software. Has anyone successfully e-filed a 1040-X for 2019? Which tax software did you use? I'm hoping to get this done this week since I'm worried about how far back I can still claim refunds. Thanks!
I had to tap into my retirement accounts last year when I lost my job and got into some financial trouble. I ended up taking two separate distributions - first pulled out $8,250 from my 401k to cover my mortgage and health insurance, and had them withhold 30% for taxes (about $2,475). Then around July, I had to take another distribution from my IRA for $3,890 and only withheld 12% for taxes (approximately $467). Both were early withdrawals, so I know I'm getting hit with the 10% penalty on top of regular income tax. Since I was unemployed the entire year, I won't be receiving any W-2 forms - these two 1099-Rs are my only income for the tax year. I'm using TurboTax but struggling to figure out how to correctly enter just these 1099-Rs without any W-2. Will TurboTax automatically calculate the 10% penalty? And more importantly, with the amount I already had withheld, will I end up owing more or possibly getting some refund? Anyone gone through something similar who can walk me through this?
Just an FYI - when entering multiple 1099-Rs in TurboTax, make sure you enter them one at a time completely. Don't try to combine them, even if they're from the same financial institution. Each form needs to be entered separately because they'll have different distribution codes, different withholding amounts, and possibly different exception qualifications. Also, check if you qualify for the "medical insurance premiums for unemployed individuals" exception to the 10% penalty. Since you mentioned being unemployed and paying for insurance, you might qualify for this exception on at least part of your distributions.
Thanks for the tip about entering them separately! Do you know if TurboTax will automatically ask me about the medical insurance exception, or do I need to look for that specifically somewhere?
TurboTax should ask you about exceptions after you enter each 1099-R form. When it asks about the distribution code (Box 7), it will then follow up with questions about your situation. If you indicate you were unemployed, it should specifically ask if you used any of the money for health insurance premiums. If it doesn't automatically prompt you, look for a section called "Exceptions to Tax Penalties" or something similar after entering your 1099-R information. Make sure you have documentation of your insurance premium payments during your unemployment period, as you'll need this if you're audited.
Has anyone used TurboTax's live expert feature for this kind of situation? I'm wondering if it's worth paying extra to have a tax expert review this.
I used it last year for a similar retirement withdrawal situation. The expert was helpful in confirming I qualified for an exception to the penalty since I was using the money for health insurance during unemployment. For complex situations like multiple 1099-Rs with no W-2s, I'd say it's worth the extra cost for the peace of mind.
I've accumulated back taxes that I honestly don't think I can repay. The last few years have been a complete financial nightmare - lost my job, eventually found a new one but at like 40% less pay, plus been taking care of my sick mom, and even had to file bankruptcy last year. Just one disaster after another. Now I'm trying to get my life back on track. My long-term goal is buying a house someday, and I know I need to clean up my credit to get a decent interest rate. My tax situation is this huge cloud hanging over everything. Planning to reach out to the IRS within the next month or so, but I keep hearing about this "Fresh Start Program" and wondering if it might help someone in my situation. Does anyone have experience with this or know how it actually works? I'm pretty overwhelmed with all the tax terminology and options.
Something important nobody's mentioned yet - if you've filed for bankruptcy, there's a waiting period before the IRS will consider an Offer in Compromise. I think it's around 12 months after your bankruptcy is discharged, but double-check that. Also, before approaching the IRS, make sure ALL your tax returns are filed, even if you can't pay what you owe. The Fresh Start Program won't even be an option if you have unfiled returns. They'll just tell you to file first before discussing any payment options.
That's really good to know - my bankruptcy was discharged about 14 months ago, so sounds like I should be past that waiting period. I do have one tax return I haven't filed yet because I knew I'd owe and couldn't pay. Should I get that filed ASAP before contacting them about the Fresh Start options?
Yes, absolutely file that outstanding return immediately. The IRS won't even discuss resolution options until you're in compliance with all filing requirements. Even if you can't pay what you owe, getting the return filed is the necessary first step. Think of it this way - the IRS sees unfiled returns as someone trying to hide or avoid their obligations entirely, while someone who files but can't pay is at least being transparent about their situation. Once you've filed everything, then you can approach them about payment options through the Fresh Start program with a much better chance of success.
One thing to consider with the Fresh Start Program - if you go the Offer in Compromise route, they'll want to see that you've exhausted other options first. Like getting a loan from family, using available credit, or selling assets. I made the mistake of submitting an OIC without thoroughly documenting why I couldn't pay through other means. Got rejected and had to restart the whole process. Make sure you can clearly demonstrate financial hardship.
I've been financially supporting my disabled mom and younger brother who both live with me, and I'm trying to figure out the tax situation. My mom's health took a turn about 18 months ago, and she's currently in the process of applying for disability benefits. My teenage brother is also completely dependent on me financially. I'm covering all their living expenses - rent, food, medical bills, everything. This is the first complete tax year where I've been supporting both of them, and I'm confused about what I can claim on my taxes. Would I qualify to claim both my disabled parent and minor sibling as dependents on my tax return? What kind of tax credits would I be eligible for? Any help would be really appreciated since this is all new territory for me.
Don't forget to look into the Earned Income Tax Credit too! If your income is under certain limits and you qualify as Head of Household with dependents, the EITC can be substantial. The phase-out thresholds for 2025 are much higher than people realize. Also, if you're paying for any educational expenses for your brother, look into the American Opportunity Credit (if he's in college) or Lifetime Learning Credit. Education credits can be worth up to $2,500 in some cases.
Thank you! My income is around $48,000 - would I still qualify for EITC? And my brother is still in high school, but I am paying for some tutoring services. Would those count as educational expenses?
With $48,000 income and two dependents, you should still qualify for some EITC, though not the maximum amount. The phase-out for Head of Household with two qualifying dependents starts higher than your income, but you'll get a partial credit. Every bit helps! For educational expenses, unfortunately tutoring for high school generally doesn't qualify for the education credits. Those are primarily for post-secondary education (college, vocational schools, etc.). However, if the tutoring is related to a medical condition and prescribed by a doctor, you might be able to count it as a medical expense instead.
One thing I didn't see mentioned - if your mom gets approved for disability, be sure to check if she's eligible for Medicare. There's a specific timing when Medicare eligibility kicks in after SSDI approval (usually after 24 months of receiving benefits). This can affect your tax situation too since you might be paying for less medical expenses directly.
I just got the most confusing letter from the IRS asking me to provide "proof of Eligibility for claiming HCTC, Form 8885" on my 2020 tax return. I'm completely baffled because I definitely did NOT claim the Health Coverage Tax Credit on my return that year. I double-checked all my paperwork just to be sure I wasn't going crazy. The letter is requesting documentation within 30 days, but how do I prove I didn't claim something? I'm worried if I ignore this, they'll adjust my return and I'll end up owing money for something I never even claimed in the first place! Has anyone dealt with this kind of mix-up before? What's the best way to respond to the IRS when they're asking for proof of something that doesn't apply to me? Thanks for any help! This tax stuff makes my head spin.
Make sure you also check if you received any forms related to HCTC eligibility that might have been automatically reported to the IRS! My husband got a similar notice because his former employer sent him a PBGC (Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation) statement that triggered HCTC eligibility flags in the IRS system, even though we never claimed the credit.
Sophia Russo
Another option nobody mentioned is FreeTaxUSA. I used it to e-file my 2019 amended return last year and it worked great. Their interface for the 1040-X is actually clearer than TurboTax in my opinion, and it's WAY cheaper. The one drawback is you need to have your original return info handy and enter it manually - they don't import from PDFs like some of the other options mentioned. But if you're looking to save money and still want to e-file your 2019 amendment, it's worth checking out.
0 coins
Evelyn Xu
Do you remember approximately how long it took for the IRS to process your e-filed 1040-X through FreeTaxUSA? I've heard horror stories about paper amendments taking 6+ months, wondering if e-filing is significantly faster.
0 coins
Sophia Russo
It took about 7 weeks from submission to getting my refund, which was significantly faster than paper filing. The IRS sent an acknowledgment of receipt within 2 days of e-filing, which gave me peace of mind that they actually had my amendment. From what I've heard, paper amendments are taking 6-12 months right now, so e-filing is definitely the way to go if you qualify. Just make sure your changes are for forms that support e-filing - not all schedules can be e-filed for amendments even now.
0 coins
Dominic Green
Hate to be the bearer of bad news, but if you're trying to amend a 2019 return NOW for additional refund, you're probably out of luck. The deadline for claiming refunds from 2019 was generally April 18, 2023 (3 years from the original due date). I learned this the hard way when I tried to claim some missed education credits from 2019 earlier this year. Unless you have a special situation (military deployment, natural disaster victim, etc.), the IRS won't issue refunds for amendments filed after the 3-year window closes.
0 coins
Hannah Flores
Actually this isn't always true. If you've had tax payments applied to the year in question after filing (like estimated tax payments that were applied forward or carryforwards from other years), the deadline can be extended to 2 years from the date of the last payment rather than 3 years from filing. Worth checking if this applies to your situation OP.
0 coins
Kayla Jacobson
Quick question - does filing an extension for your original return extend the amendment deadline too? Like if someone filed a 2019 extension until October 2020, would they have until October 2023 to amend?
0 coins