


Ask the community...
For your side hustle, I'd recommend starting as a sole proprietor until you have consistent income above $35-40K. The extra paperwork and fees for an LLC taxed as an S-Corp doesn't make financial sense below that threshold. When you do form an LLC, don't get too caught up in the Wyoming/Nevada/Delaware hype. If you're physically operating in another state, you'll likely need to register as a foreign LLC there anyway and be subject to that state's rules. Often better to form in your home state to avoid duplicate fees. One strategy people overlook: Qualified Business Income deduction (Section 199A). It can give you a 20% deduction on your business income if you qualify. Big tax saver!
Thanks for the practical advice! With the QBI deduction, are there income phaseouts I should be aware of? My wife and I have a combined W-2 income around $220k before any side hustle income.
Yes, there are phaseouts for the QBI deduction. For 2025, the phaseout begins at $364,200 for married filing jointly and completely phases out at $464,200. Since your combined income is $220k, you're safely below the threshold even with additional side hustle income. However, once your total taxable income approaches that phaseout range, you may want to increase retirement contributions or look into other strategies to keep below the threshold. Also, certain service businesses (like consulting) have stricter income limitations for QBI, so the type of side hustle matters. If your business isn't in a "specified service trade or business" category, you'll have more flexibility with the QBI deduction even at higher income levels.
Have you considered a Donor Advised Fund (DAF) as part of your tax strategy? If you're charitably inclined at all, it can be a huge tax advantage. We bunch several years of charitable contributions into a single tax year to exceed the standard deduction threshold, itemize that year, then take standard deduction in subsequent years. Also for the side hustle, look into whether your business could sponsor a Solo 401k. The contribution limits are WAY higher than a SEP IRA, especially if you're already maxing W-2 employer 401ks.
Make sure you respond by the deadline on the notice! The IRS automatically issues CP2000 notices when there's a mismatch between reported income and what financial institutions report. Banks report large deposits through currency transaction reports, but they don't indicate whether it's taxable income or not.
Is there a specific form the parents need to fill out to confirm this was a gift under the annual exclusion? I always thought there was paperwork for the giver.
The parents would only need to file Form 709 (Gift Tax Return) if their gift exceeded the annual exclusion amount per recipient. For 2022, that threshold was $16,000 per person. So if both parents contributed to the gift, each could give up to $16,000 (total $32,000) without any filing requirement. For responding to the IRS notice, there's no specific form the parents need to complete. A simple signed and dated statement explaining the gift (including amount, date, occasion, and relationship) should suffice. Including evidence like copies of checks, transfer receipts, or bank statements showing the source of funds would strengthen the case.
Have you checked if this is actually a legit IRS notice? There are tons of scams going around. A real IRS CP2000 notice always comes with your tax ID number and specific information about the discrepancy. The IRS also never asks for payment directly in their first notice about an issue.
This is an excellent point. I got a fake IRS letter once that looked really convincing! You can call the IRS directly (using the number from their official website, not the letter) to confirm if they actually sent you something.
When you do a conversion from traditional to Roth, you're taxed on any untaxed contributions and earnings. If you made a NON-deductible contribution (meaning you already paid tax on it) to your traditional IRA and then converted it, you should only be taxed on any earnings that happened between contribution and conversion. Since you converted just a few days after contributing, there were probably minimal earnings, so most of that conversion should be tax-free. As others have said, Form 8606 is key here - specifically parts I and II.
If there were literally no earnings between the contribution and conversion (like if the market was down those few days), would the taxable amount be zero? And does the 1099-R differentiate this or do you have to calculate it yourself?
If there were no earnings (or even if there was a loss), the taxable amount would indeed be zero. The 1099-R unfortunately doesn't differentiate this for you - it typically shows the full distribution amount in Box 1 and often shows the full amount as taxable in Box 2a as well, even when it's not. You have to calculate the non-taxable portion yourself using Form 8606. This is why it's so important to file this form - it's your documentation that establishes which portion of the conversion was after-tax money that shouldn't be taxed again.
Make sure you're entering everything in the right order in your tax software! I had this exact problem last year and realized I was entering my Roth conversion before establishing that I had made a non-deductible contribution. Try this sequence: 1) Enter the non-deductible Traditional IRA contribution first 2) Tell the software it was non-deductible 3) Then enter the 1099-R for the conversion In TurboTax, there's actually a specific section for IRA conversions that's separate from regular distributions. If you enter it as a regular distribution, it thinks the whole thing is taxable!
Thanks for the sequence tips! I think that's exactly what I did wrong - I just entered the 1099-R directly without establishing the non-deductible contribution first. I'm using TaxAct, not TurboTax, but I bet the principle is the same. I'll try re-doing it in that order and see if it fixes the calculation. Appreciate everyone's help on this!
Be careful about those free tax filing sites! They don't always include all the forms you need for education credits or server income without upgrading to their paid versions. I started with TurboTax Free and halfway through they told me I needed to pay $89 to add the education forms lol.
Don't forget about the Lifetime Learning Credit if you don't qualify for the American Opportunity Credit! It's worth up to 20% of your first $10,000 in education expenses. I missed out on this for two years before someone told me about it š
The American Opportunity Credit is usually better though if you qualify (up to $2,500 vs $2,000 for Lifetime Learning). Plus AOTC is partially refundable while LLC isn't. But yeah if you've used AOTC for 4 years already or don't meet other requirements, Lifetime Learning is a great backup!
Aurora Lacasse
Another option to consider - if you're eligible for any of the penalty exceptions for the 10% early withdrawal penalty, you might not owe as much as you think. Things like first-time home purchase (up to $10k), certain education expenses, birth/adoption expenses, etc. might apply. Worth checking if any of these fit your situation!
0 coins
Evan Kalinowski
ā¢Thank you for bringing this up! I'm actually using some of the money for education expenses this semester. How exactly do I document that to avoid the penalty on that portion?
0 coins
Aurora Lacasse
ā¢For qualified education expenses, keep detailed records of all tuition, required fees, books, and required supplies paid during the tax year. The expenses must be for yourself, your spouse, or your dependents at an eligible educational institution. You'll use Form 5329 to report the early distribution and claim the exception. On line 2 of the form, you'll enter exception code "08" and the amount that qualifies for the education expense exception. This amount won't be subject to the 10% penalty, though it will still be taxable income if it's coming from earnings in your Roth IRA.
0 coins
Anthony Young
Has anyone else here dealt with Roth IRA custodians refusing to do withholding above a certain percentage? Last year I tried to set withholding at 50% with Vanguard and they said their system maxed out at 37% for federal. Ended up having to make an estimated payment anyway.
0 coins
Charlotte White
ā¢Fidelity let me do 45% last year when I needed to. I've heard TD Ameritrade caps at 50%. Probably worth calling your specific custodian to ask before counting on the 90% withholding strategy.
0 coins