
IRS
CommunityGovernment Services


Ask the community...
I started an LLC doing home renovations about 7 months ago and things are going pretty well. Right now I'm working with independent contractors for most jobs, but I'm thinking about bringing on a dedicated crew through actual payroll instead. I've got 3-4 guys who have been really reliable and I'd like to keep them around more permanently. My question is - are there any tax advantages for me as the business owner if I switch to payroll? Or am I just creating more headaches and expenses compared to keeping them as 1099 contractors? I'm trying to understand what this would mean for my business taxes overall. I know I'd have to deal with withholding, unemployment taxes and all that, but wondering if there are offsetting benefits I should consider. Thanks!
So this is new territory for me. Just checked my mail today and found a 1099-MISC form that I've literally never seen before in my life. The form is mostly blank except for a few fields filled in. I usually just go to H&R Block every year to handle my taxes and have always just had W-2s. Never dealt with this 1099-MISC thing before. Do I need to do anything different this year? Is this going to complicate my filing? I'm kinda freaking out because tax season is already stressful enough without random new forms showing up.
If it's your first 1099-MISC, keep in mind you might need to pay quarterly estimated taxes next year if you continue getting this kind of income. The IRS expects you to pay taxes throughout the year, not just at filing time. I learned this the hard way and got hit with underpayment penalties my first year with freelance income.
So I'd have to make tax payments four times a year instead of just filing once? How do I even figure out how much to pay if I don't know how much I'll make?
Yes, you make four payments throughout the year (usually April, June, September, and January). To figure out how much to pay, you can either pay 100% of last year's tax liability divided into four payments (safest method to avoid penalties), or estimate what you'll make this year and calculate your tax payments based on that. If your income varies, you can adjust each quarterly payment based on what you've earned so far. There's a form called 1040-ES that helps you calculate this. H&R Block can help set this up for you too - just make sure to ask them about estimated tax payments if you expect to receive more 1099 income this year.
Does the 1099-MISC have any numbers in Box 3 (Other Income)? If that's the only place with a number, you report it on Schedule 1, line 8 of your 1040. If Box 7 (Nonemployee Compensation) has an amount, that's self-employment income and goes on Schedule C. You'll also need to fill out Schedule SE to calculate self-employment tax if you have Box 7 income over $400.
I've been working in Malaysia for about 3 months this year (US resident with green card for tax purposes) and I'm trying to figure out how to file properly with the IRS. The situation is complicated because the Malaysian company I worked for has me on what feels like an employee contract, but they don't issue any W-2 or 1099 forms (they say they can't). They're not withholding any Social Security tax, and I'm personally covering all expenses - flights, hotel, meals, even my work phone. I know I'm not eligible for Foreign Earned Income Exclusion (less than 330 days abroad), but should qualify for Foreign Tax Credit. My main question is: How should I report this income? Just on Form 1040? Can I classify myself as self-employed during this period? That way I could deduct all those business expenses and then pay the 15.3% self-employment tax on what's left. Does anyone know if the IRS would have issues with this approach? I'm familiar with the IRS 20-factor test for employee vs contractor status, but I'm confused because if the foreign employer isn't issuing any tax forms, isn't paying the employer portion of FICA, and I'm covering all my own expenses... how could I possibly be considered an employee? I really don't want to be stuck in a situation where I'm categorized as an employee, can't deduct any business expenses, and have to pay 15.3% tax on the entire amount.
I went through this exact situation when working in Germany last year. Here's what I learned: The substance of your work relationship matters more than the paperwork. Since you're bearing all the costs and they're not withholding anything, you have a strong case for self-employment status. I filed Schedule C as self-employed, deducted legitimate business expenses (saved about $7,000 in taxes), and carefully documented everything. I also kept a copy of my contract showing I was responsible for my own expenses. One tip: make sure you're tracking any foreign taxes paid in Malaysia so you can claim the Foreign Tax Credit properly. Form 1116 is your friend here. If you're really concerned, consider getting a written statement from the Malaysian company describing your working relationship that emphasizes the independent contractor aspects of your arrangement.
Thanks for sharing your experience! Do you think it matters that my contract with the Malaysian company says "employment agreement" in the title, even though the substance of the relationship is more like self-employment? Did you have a similar issue with your German contract?
The title of the contract isn't as important as the actual terms within it. My German agreement also said "employment contract" but the IRS looks at the substance of the arrangement more than the labels. Make sure you highlight aspects of your arrangement that support self-employment: you paying your own expenses, setting your own schedule when possible, using your own equipment, and the lack of typical employee benefits. In my case, I included a memo with my tax return briefly explaining why I was filing as self-employed despite the contract title, focusing on these substantive factors. The key is being consistent and having documentation to back up your position if questioned.
Has anyone used TurboTax for this kind of situation? I'm in a similar boat (working for a company in Singapore for 4 months) and wondering if the software can handle this complexity or if I need to find a tax professional.
I used TurboTax last year for a similar situation working in Thailand. It does handle Schedule C for self-employment and Form 1116 for Foreign Tax Credit, but honestly the questionnaire was confusing for international situations. I ended up having to manually override some things and do quite a bit of research on my own. If your situation is straightforward self-employment, it might work fine, but if there are complexities, you might want a professional who specializes in expat taxes.
I've been searching everywhere and getting confused. Currently using TurboTax for my taxes this year. I received a 1099-NEC for some side work I did. Initially, I was planning to report it as hobby income, but I decided to experiment with different options in TurboTax. I tried filing it as hobby income, then as Schedule C business income, and just for comparison, I entered the same amount as if it were W-2 wages (with no withholding). The results were HUGELY different! TurboTax only gave me the additional child tax credits and earned income tax credit when I entered it as W-2 income. When I entered the exact same amount as 1099-NEC or Schedule C, those credits disappeared. My total income from all sources is definitely under $40k for the year. I thought income from 1099-NEC and Schedule C was considered earned income just like W-2 wages? Are they somehow treated differently when calculating refundable credits? This makes a big difference in my refund amount and I'm super confused!!
I had this same issue last year! The problem might be that you need to make sure your Schedule C shows an actual profit after expenses. If your expenses cancel out all your income (or most of it), then there's no earned income to qualify for the credits. Also check if you're filing as "single" vs "head of household" - that makes a huge difference for these credits too! And make sure your kids are entered as qualifying dependents with all their info correct.
I checked and I'm definitely showing a profit on Schedule C - about $24k after expenses. And I'm filing as head of household with two qualifying children (ages 5 and 8). All their info including SSNs is entered correctly. That's why I'm so puzzled about why TurboTax treats the income differently.
That's definitely strange then! With $24k profit on Schedule C filing as head of household with two young kids, you should absolutely qualify for both EITC and the Additional Child Tax Credit. Maybe try deleting that section completely and re-entering it from scratch? Sometimes TurboTax gets stuck with certain calculations. Another thing to check is if you've got any investment income. If you have more than $10,300 in investment income for 2024, that can disqualify you from EITC. Also double-check if you accidentally clicked something that indicates the income isn't subject to self-employment tax, which might mess up how TurboTax treats it for credit purposes.
Just as an fyi, I'm a private tutor and get a mix of 1099-NEC and cash payments every year. One thing I learned the hard way: if you choose "hobby" for reporting your 1099-NEC, you LOSE all your earned income credits because hobby income isn't considered earned income! But if you file a Schedule C, it IS earned income and counts toward EITC and Child Tax Credit.
I've been steadily putting money into this cryptocurrency throughout the year, about $1350 total so far. My average cost per coin has been around $1.95, but right now the coin is trading below $1.30, which obviously puts me at a loss. From my research, it looks like you can write off up to $3000 per year of realized capital losses after you sell your investments. I'm still bullish on this crypto long-term and want to keep investing in it. Would it be smart to sell all my tokens at the end of the year, take the loss, claim it on my taxes, and then just buy back in? Or would this cause problems? I'm trying to at least get some tax benefit while I wait for my investment to hopefully recover. Has anyone done this with crypto before?
Important distinction on the $3000 limit - that's only for deducting capital losses against ordinary income. If you have capital gains from other investments (stocks, property, other crypto), you can offset those completely before hitting the $3000 limit. For example, if you had: - $5000 in stock gains this year - $7000 in crypto losses You could offset the entire $5000 in gains, plus deduct $2000 from your ordinary income. The remaining $2000 in losses would carry forward to next year.
Do you know if I have to specify which coins I'm selling for the tax loss? Like if I have 3 different cryptocurrencies all at a loss, can I pick which ones to realize losses on and keep holding the others?
Yes, you can absolutely specify which coins you're selling for tax loss harvesting. You're not required to sell all your underwater positions - you can strategically choose which specific coins and even which specific lots if you've bought the same coin at different times. If you have three different cryptocurrencies at a loss, you can choose to sell just one or two and keep holding the other. You might base this decision on which coins you're least confident about long-term or which would give you the biggest tax benefit. Some tax software lets you optimize this by showing which sales would be most beneficial.
Anyone know how to report the crypto losses properly on tax forms? Is it just Schedule D and Form 8949, like with stocks?
Yep, same forms as stock trades. Form 8949 is where you'll list all your crypto transactions, and then the totals carry over to Schedule D. Make sure you check the correct box at the top of Form 8949 depending on whether the transactions were reported on a 1099-B. For most crypto exchanges in 2025, you'll likely check box C since many still don't issue 1099-Bs (though this is changing). Keep all your transaction records because the burden of proof is on you!
Nina Chan
Something nobody mentioned yet - if you pay employees instead of contractors, you can take advantage of the Section 199A qualified business income deduction more effectively. With contractors, their fees aren't considered part of your qualified business income, but with employees, their wages reduce your QBI but can result in a higher overall deduction depending on your income level. Also, with employees, you have more flexibility with reimbursement plans like an accountable plan that lets you reimburse business expenses tax-free to employees without it counting as income to them. This can be huge for things like vehicle usage, tools, and certifications in construction!
0 coins
Ruby Knight
Can you explain more about this accountable plan thing? I've never heard of it and I'm currently paying my workers extra to cover their gas when they drive between job sites, which I know isn't ideal tax-wise.
0 coins
Nina Chan
An accountable plan is basically a formal arrangement where your business reimburses employees for business expenses without that reimbursement counting as taxable income to them. To qualify, you need three things: business connection (expenses must be job-related), adequate accounting (employees must provide documentation like receipts), and return of excess payments (employees must return any excess reimbursements). For your situation with gas between job sites, instead of paying extra taxable income, you could reimburse actual mileage at the IRS rate (currently 67 cents per mile for 2023). The employee doesn't pay tax on this reimbursement, and you still get the deduction. You'll need employees to track their mileage and submit documentation, but there are easy apps for this. Much better than grossing up wages to cover gas which creates additional payroll taxes for both you and the worker.
0 coins
Diego Castillo
Has anyone used Gusto or QuickBooks payroll for a small construction crew? I'm in the same boat, considering switching my 5 contractors to employees and wondering which payroll system handles construction-specific things like prevailing wage jobs and certified payroll reports. Also concerned about how to transition without making the guys feel like they're losing freedom.
0 coins
Logan Stewart
I use QuickBooks Payroll for my remodeling business with 7 employees. It's decent for basic payroll but struggles with complex construction-specific reporting. For certified payroll on government jobs, I ended up using an add-on called LCPtracker. The main benefit is how it ties directly to my accounting, but the reporting for construction specifically is mediocre.
0 coins
Diego Castillo
Thanks for the insight on QuickBooks. Good to know about the limitations with construction reporting. Does it at least handle job costing well? I need to track labor costs per project really carefully.
0 coins