
IRS
CommunityGovernment Services


Ask the community...
I've been pulling my hair out trying to get this situation entered correctly into tax software, and I'm hoping someone can check if I did it right. **The Situation** In 2022, my income unexpectedly went over the Roth IRA limit. So in January 2023, I had to recharacterize about $390 of my Roth contribution and basically do a backdoor Roth conversion. Got some great advice here last year! Then in 2023, I did a standard backdoor Roth conversion of $8,500 (no gains before conversion). Now for my 2023 taxes, I have two 1099-Rs from my Roth provider: - 1099-R #1: $9,058.00 - 1099-R #2: $390.00 - Total: $9,448.00 **2022 Form 5329** - Line 24 (Total excess contributions): $390 - Line 25 (Additional tax): $23 **2022 Form 8606** - Line 16 (net converted from traditional IRAs to Roth IRAs): $390 - Line 17 (basis in amount on line 16): $390 - Line 18 (Taxable amount): $0 **2023 Form 5329** - Line 22 (Prior year excess contributions): $390 - Line 24 (Total excess contributions): $390 - Line 25 (Additional tax): $23 **2023 Form 8606** - Line 16 (amount converted from traditional IRAs to Roths): $9,448 - Line 17 (basis in amount on line 16): $9,448 - Line 18 (Taxable amount): $0 - Line 25c (Taxable amount to include on Form 1040): $0 I'm confused about the $9,058 1099-R, but I think the math is: 1. Amount recharacterized from 2022: $390 2. Amount from standard backdoor conversion in 2023: $8,500 3. And line 25 ($23) of my 2023 Form 5329 is the additional tax from 2022. I had to do some weird workarounds in both cash app and TurboTax, but I think this is correct? Also, why am I paying this $23 tax again? Do I need to take additional steps with my Roth to finally close this out?
I bought Treasuries last year and paid for ACCRUED INTEREST at purchase (first time doing this, think I messed up). The whole experience was confusing since the broker's website didn't clearly explain the accrued interest situation, and I ended up buying Treasuries that were expiring within days. The crazy part is I actually paid slightly MORE than what I got back at maturity! Like, I literally lost money on what should be a guaranteed return treasury bond. The whole point was to get something safe and I still managed to lose money lol. Now my broker sent me a 1099-INT showing a large interest amount in field #3. I'm confused about how to report this on my taxes. Should the 1099-INT/B be showing the ACCRUED interest that I PAID when purchasing the Treasury bonds? Is this normal or did my broker mess up the form? I don't want to get in trouble with the IRS for something that doesn't seem right to me.
One other option: if your tax software allows it, you can adjust the amount reported in Box 3 directly rather than adding a separate line item. I use TurboTax and they have a section for adjusting 1099-INT amounts specifically for accrued interest purchased.
I've been dealing with treasury bonds for years and want to clarify something important that might help avoid future confusion. When you buy treasuries in the secondary market, always check the "accrued interest" line on your purchase confirmation BEFORE completing the transaction. The accrued interest is essentially paying the previous bondholder for the interest they earned while holding the security. When the next interest payment comes, you'll receive the full amount even though you only earned part of it - that's why you need to deduct what you paid upfront. For tax reporting, yes your 1099-INT will show the full interest payment in Box 3, but you absolutely should deduct the accrued interest you paid at purchase. List it on Schedule B as "Accrued Interest Paid on Treasury Securities" with the amount as a negative number. Also, losing money on a treasury isn't that uncommon if you buy at a premium in the secondary market. The capital loss (difference between what you paid excluding accrued interest and what you received at maturity) goes on Schedule D and can offset other gains or up to $3,000 of ordinary income. Pro tip: if you want guaranteed returns, consider buying treasuries directly from TreasuryDirect.gov at auction to avoid paying premiums and accrued interest complications.
You can use "non-competitive bidding" at TreasuryDirect auctions, which means you agree to accept whatever yield is determined at the auction. You don't have to compete or guess rates - you just submit your order and you'll get the average yield of all accepted competitive bids. It's perfect for exactly what you want: simple, safe returns without the secondary market complications. The minimum purchase is usually $100 and you can set up automatic reinvestment too.
Great question! When you buy through TreasuryDirect auctions, you can submit either a "competitive" or "non-competitive" bid. For most individual investors, you'll want to submit a non-competitive bid, which means you agree to accept whatever interest rate is determined at auction. You're guaranteed to get your securities at the auction price without having to guess what rate to bid. Non-competitive bids are accepted up to $5 million per auction, so unless you're investing huge amounts, you don't need to worry about competing with other bidders. You just specify how much you want to buy and you'll get it at the final auction rate. Much simpler than dealing with the secondary market premiums and accrued interest complications!
I was doing a routine transfer between my WellsFargo accounts when I noticed a new account option I've never seen before - Higher One First Carolina Bank. I've never opened an account with them and wondering if this could be related to my tax refund somehow?
This is a major red flag! Higher One banks are frequently used in tax refund fraud schemes. Here's what you need to do immediately: 1) Call Wells Fargo fraud department and ask them to explain why this account appeared, 2) Log into your IRS account online and check if your direct deposit info has been changed, 3) Call the IRS Identity Protection Unit at 800-908-4490. Don't wait - these scammers work fast once they've compromised your info. Also freeze your credit reports just to be safe!
@85ecf604042e Yes, freeze all three bureaus (Experian, Equifax, TransUnion) - it's free and you can do it online! Just go to each bureau's website and set up the freeze. You'll get a PIN to unfreeze when needed. Takes like 10 minutes total and gives you peace of mind. Also make sure to file Form 14039 (Identity Theft Affidavit) with the IRS if you suspect your info was compromised!
@85ecf604042e Yes, freeze all three bureaus (Experian, Equifax, TransUnion). Credit freezes are free by law! You can do it online at each bureau's website. Takes like 10 minutes total and gives you peace of mind. Also consider signing up for IRS IP PIN if you haven't already - it's free protection that requires a special code to file your taxes.
So frustrated right now! I just checked the status of my tax refund on the IRS "Where's My Refund" tool and it's showing that my refund was MAILED as a paper check. But I definitely selected direct deposit when I filed my taxes back in February! I triple-checked my return before submitting and all my banking info was 100% correct (account number, routing number, everything). I've been getting direct deposits from the IRS for years without any issues. The weird thing is that I haven't hit any of the thresholds that would force them to mail a check instead (like the limit on refund advances or something). My refund is only about $2,870 which isn't even that large. Has anyone else experienced this? Is there any way to change it back to direct deposit before they mail the check? I'm worried about mail theft in my neighborhood and really needed that money to hit my account ASAP for some bills coming up.
I work as a tax preparer and see this issue frequently during tax season. One additional cause that hasn't been mentioned is if there were any math errors or discrepancies on your return that required IRS adjustment. Even minor corrections (like a calculation error that changes your refund by just a few dollars) can trigger the system to switch from direct deposit to paper check. The IRS does this as a safety measure - if they had to make any changes to your return, they want to make sure you receive proper documentation with the check showing what was adjusted. This is different from the situations others mentioned and wouldn't show up in the typical verification issues. You can check if this happened by requesting your tax transcript from the IRS website (irs.gov) and looking for any adjustment codes. If you see codes like 290, 300, or 570, that indicates they made changes to your return which would explain the switch to paper check.
This has been such an informative thread! I'm dealing with this exact situation too and was getting really stressed about it until I found all these explanations. One thing I wanted to add that might help others - if you're worried about mail theft like Victoria mentioned, you can also have the check sent to a different address by calling the IRS and requesting an address change specifically for the refund mailing. I had to do this last year when I was traveling and didn't want the check sitting in my mailbox for days. Also, for anyone using the services mentioned here (taxr.ai, Claimyr), just make sure you're going to the legitimate websites. I've noticed scammers sometimes create similar-sounding domain names during tax season to try to steal people's information when they're desperate for help with IRS issues. The address mismatch issue that Andre mentioned is so important - I'm definitely going to double-check that my bank has my current address on file. It's crazy how many small things can trigger these switches to paper checks when the IRS could just tell us what the actual problem is!
Great point about the address change option for refund mailing - I had no idea the IRS would let you do that! That's really helpful for people who might be traveling or have concerns about mail security. And thanks for the warning about scam websites. With so many people desperate for answers about their refunds, it makes sense that scammers would try to take advantage. I'll definitely make sure I'm on the official sites if I decide to try any of these services. This whole thread has been like a crash course in IRS refund processing that I wish I had known about years ago. It's honestly ridiculous that we all have to become detectives to figure out why our refunds got switched to paper checks when the IRS obviously has this information in their systems. They could save everyone so much stress by just being more transparent about what triggers these changes. I'm going to call both my bank and the IRS this week to get to the bottom of my situation. At least now I have a whole list of questions to ask instead of just being confused and frustrated!
I've been using TurboTax for years but I always double check my return with Taxslayer just to be safe. Our situation is pretty straightforward - married filing jointly, both of us are W2 employees, and we own a home. Nothing complicated. So I just entered our identical W2s into both systems and I'm totally confused... TurboTax is saying we OWE $10,500 while Taxslayer shows we're getting a $2,700 REFUND for federal. That's a $13k swing between the two!! I've triple-checked that I entered our income exactly the same in both programs. Same W2 numbers, same filing status, same home info. How can there possibly be such a massive difference between TurboTax and Taxslayer? Has anyone else experienced this kind of discrepancy between tax software? I'm freaking out a little because that's a huge amount of money difference.
Which version of TurboTax are you using? Their free version often misses deductions that their paid versions catch. I've seen the Deluxe version find thousands in deductions that the free version missed.
Glad you got it sorted out! Missing withholding entries is probably the #1 cause of major discrepancies between tax software. It's such an easy thing to overlook but creates massive differences in your final calculation. For future reference, when comparing tax software, I always recommend doing a quick sanity check on the key numbers first - total income, total withholding, and filing status - before diving into the more complex deduction comparisons. Those three fields alone determine most of your tax liability. The remaining $200 difference you're seeing is totally normal. Different programs handle rounding and certain calculations slightly differently, but both should be acceptable for filing. You can pick whichever interface you prefer at this point.
Tami Morgan
Question for people who've dealt with this: Does tax software automatically handle these forms correctly or do we need to manually override things? I'm using H&R Block software and it seems confused by my recharacterization.
0 coins
Rami Samuels
In my experience, NO tax software handles Roth recharacterizations correctly, especially when they span multiple tax years. I had to manually override several fields in TurboTax last year. The biggest issue is that the tax software interview questions don't properly distinguish between recharacterization vs conversion, and they don't track your basis correctly across tax years. I'd strongly recommend either getting professional help or at minimum running your completed forms by a tool that specializes in these situations before filing.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
Thank you! That's really helpful. I think I'll have to do some manual overrides then. I was worried I was doing something wrong but it sounds like the software itself just doesn't handle these complex situations well.
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
Based on your forms and the discussion here, it looks like you're on the right track but there's one key step missing to stop that $23 penalty cycle. Your Form 8606 entries look correct - you're properly reporting the $9,448 total conversion amount with full basis, so no additional taxable income. The two 1099-Rs make sense: $390 from your 2022 recharacterization done in 2023, and $9,058 from your regular 2023 backdoor conversion. The ongoing $23 penalty on Form 5329 is happening because the IRS still considers you to have an "unused" excess contribution of $390 from 2022. Recharacterization moved the money from Roth to traditional (then back to Roth via conversion), but didn't eliminate the excess contribution itself. To stop the penalty for 2024 and beyond, you need to "apply" that $390 excess to a future year's contribution. The easiest way is to contribute $390 less to your Roth IRA in 2024. So if the limit is $7,000 for 2024, only contribute $6,610. This effectively uses up your excess contribution and should eliminate the penalty going forward. On your 2024 Form 5329, you'll report the prior year excess of $390 on line 22, but then show it as "applied to current year" which should zero out the penalty calculation. The math all checks out otherwise - you've handled a complex situation pretty well!
0 coins