


Ask the community...
In my experience as someone who's worked in tax prep before, I can tell you that many tax preparers at the chain locations are seasonal employees who've taken a basic tax course. They're trained to handle common scenarios but often miss specialized rules like the married filing separately Roth IRA limitation. If you're dealing with something like retirement account contribution issues, you really need either a CPA or an Enrolled Agent who specializes in that area. The difference in knowledge and expertise is huge. For fixing your previous years, I'd recommend: 1) Determine which tax years you need to address (generally the last 3 years can be amended) 2) Calculate the excess contributions for each year 3) Contact your IRA custodian about removing excess contributions 4) File Form 5329 for each year to report the excess contributions 5) Consider whether filing amended returns to change from MFS to MFJ makes sense
This is really helpful, thank you! Do you think it's better to amend the returns to married filing jointly or just remove the excess contributions? We've been filing separately because my spouse has an income-based student loan repayment plan, so filing jointly would increase those payments. But maybe the Roth IRA penalties would be worse?
Whether to amend to MFJ or remove excess contributions depends on your complete financial picture. You need to calculate both scenarios to see which costs less overall. For the student loan consideration, calculate how much the income-based payments would increase if filing jointly versus the cost of Roth IRA penalties (6% per year on excess contributions) plus any potential tax benefits lost by filing separately. Sometimes it's cheaper to pay higher student loan payments for a year than pay IRS penalties and miss out on tax credits only available to joint filers. This is definitely a situation where running the numbers both ways is essential before deciding.
Has anyone actually received a penalty notice from the IRS specifically for excess Roth contributions while married filing separately? I've been doing this for 3 years not knowing about the limit, and now I'm worried but haven't received any notices.
Yes, I got hit with this exact situation last year. The IRS sent me a CP2000 notice about unreported income, and during that review, they flagged my Roth contributions while I was MFS with income over $10k. Ended up with penalties for 3 years of contributions plus interest. It was a mess to clean up, so I recommend being proactive before they find it.
22 A lot of insurance agents don't fully understand the tax implications of their products. When I surrendered my policy, the agent told me "you might have to pay taxes on it" but couldn't explain how much would be taxable. Quick rule of thumb: you pay taxes on (what you get) minus (what you put in). The insurance company should send you a 1099-R form that will show the taxable amount, but it's good to understand how it's calculated so you can verify it's correct. Sometimes insurance companies make mistakes too.
10 Is there any way to reduce the tax hit? I'm thinking about surrendering a policy but worried about having to pay a lot in taxes. Can I roll it over into something else tax-free?
22 Yes, you have a couple options to potentially reduce or defer the tax impact. If your policy qualifies, you could do what's called a 1035 exchange into an annuity or another life insurance policy. This allows you to transfer the cash value without triggering immediate taxation. Another option is to see if your policy allows for partial surrenders over multiple tax years instead of taking all the money at once. This can spread the tax liability across different years and potentially keep you in a lower tax bracket. Just be aware that each partial surrender can affect your overall basis calculation in complex ways.
15 Has anyone ever dealt with surrender fees when cancelling a whole life policy? I'm in a similar situation but my policy shows I'll lose about 12% of the value to surrender charges. Wondering if those fees are tax deductible since they reduce what I actually receive.
Does anyone know if TurboTax lets you track both your federal and state refunds in one place? I filed through them last year but had to use separate websites to check my refund statuses. Just wanting to know before I submit this year.
TurboTax does show the status of your federal refund in your account dashboard. For state refunds, it depends on which state you're in. Some states are integrated in the TurboTax tracking system, but for others, you'll still need to go to your state's tax department website to check. I'm in Texas so no state income tax to worry about, but when I lived in Illinois I had to check separately.
Is the free version of TurboTax actually free or do they make you upgrade halfway through? I've been using FreeTaxUSA but considering switching this year.
In my experience, TurboTax "Free Edition" usually tries to upsell you if you have anything beyond the most basic return. If you have any deductions, credits, self-employment income, etc., they'll tell you that you need to upgrade to Deluxe or higher. I switched to FreeTaxUSA a couple years ago and haven't looked back - much more straightforward pricing.
Wait, so if you work for a foreign mission but are a US citizen, do you have to follow the same process? My situation is different because I do owe income tax as a US citizen, but my employer doesn't withhold anything. Been doing quarterly payments but not sure if I file Schedule C or just regular W-2 income or what?
As a US citizen working for a foreign mission, your situation is actually a bit different. You DO owe both income tax and self-employment tax since US citizens are taxed on worldwide income. You wouldn't use Schedule C because you're an employee, not a business owner. Instead, you'd report your income on Line 1 of Form 1040 as wages, then complete Schedule SE to calculate your self-employment tax obligation. Make sure you're getting credit for those quarterly payments by reporting them on your return. And keep good records of everything because this situation often triggers questions from the IRS simply because it's less common.
Thanks for clearing that up! So basically treat it like regular wage income on the 1040, but also file Schedule SE for the self-employment portion? And I assume my quarterly payments go on the 1040-ES line? Do I need any special statement or form since my employer gave me their country's version of income documentation rather than a W-2?
I'm really late to this conversation, but I just wanted to say THANK YOU to everyone who contributed. I have this exact situation (working for foreign mission, exempt from income tax but not SE tax) and have been stressing about it for months. I ended up using the advice here about filing Form 1040 with an attached statement explaining the treaty exemption, along with Schedule SE. Filed it all last week and just got confirmation that it was accepted! One tip for anyone else in this situation: I called the Taxpayer Advocate Service and they were actually really helpful. They couldn't give specific tax advice but did confirm this was the correct approach and pointed me to the exact IRS publications that cover this scenario.
Do you mind sharing which publications they recommended? I'm in a similar situation but working for an international organization rather than a foreign mission, and I'm trying to understand if the rules are the same.
They pointed me to Publication 519 (U.S. Tax Guide for Aliens) which has a section on employees of foreign governments and international organizations. Also Publication 54 (Tax Guide for U.S. Citizens and Resident Aliens Abroad) had some relevant information. For international organizations, the rules are very similar but depend on whether your organization has specific tax privileges under International Organizations Immunities Act. The key thing is that while you might be exempt from income tax, you typically still owe self-employment tax unless covered by a totalization agreement with your home country.
Yuki Tanaka
One option nobody's mentioned is to just redesignate that transfer retroactively. I'm also an S-Corp owner and my accountant told me I can document that initial transfer as a "shareholder advance" that will be counted toward my reasonable salary when I run payroll. Basically, you're pre-paying yourself, and when you run payroll, you just need to account for taxes and issue yourself a smaller net paycheck since you've already received most of the money. Just make sure your payroll service knows how to handle this correctly, and you'll need good documentation. I do this regularly - take money when I need it, then formalize it through payroll later.
0 coins
Esmeralda GΓ³mez
β’Is this really legit though? Don't you have to run actual payroll with proper tax withholdings at the time you take the money? I've been stressing about making sure everything is by-the-book with my new S-Corp.
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
β’This is absolutely legitimate as long as you properly document and account for everything. When you run payroll, you'll calculate the full gross salary amount, withhold all required taxes, and then reduce the net check by the amount you already advanced yourself. For example, if your reasonable salary is $5,000 monthly and you already took $3,000 as an advance, when you run payroll, you'll still calculate taxes on the full $5,000, but the net check would only be around $2,000 (minus the taxes on the full amount). This ensures all proper employment taxes are paid on your full reasonable compensation. Just make sure your payroll system can handle this "adjustment" or "reimbursement" properly.
0 coins
Klaus Schmidt
My CPA told me this isn't actually as big a deal as people make it out to be for a new S-Corp with only a few months of operation. As long as you establish a reasonable salary before the end of the tax year and properly document everything, minor sequence mistakes in your first year typically won't trigger an audit. The reasonable compensation test is primarily looking at the entire tax year picture, not whether you took a specific distribution a few weeks before establishing payroll. Just don't make it a habit going forward!
0 coins
Aisha Patel
β’Agreed! I did something similar my first year and my accountant just had me document everything carefully. The important thing is the year-end picture looks right. S-Corps get in trouble when they take massive distributions and tiny salaries over the course of entire years, not when they make minor timing errors while learning the ropes.
0 coins