


Ask the community...
A little warning from someone who messed this up before - make absolutely sure your total family contributions don't exceed the correct limit! I incorrectly thought my wife and I could each contribute the family maximum to our separate HSAs, and ended up with an excess contribution. The IRS charged me a 6% excise tax on the excess amount for each year it remained in the account. Had to file Form 5329 and everything. What a nightmare! To recap what others have said: - Family limit for 2025: $9,750 - Catch-up contribution if 55+: $1,000 per eligible person - Each catch-up must go to separate HSA owned by that person - Total max for married couple both 55+: $11,750
That 6% excess contribution penalty is no joke! Thanks for the warning. Did you have to withdraw the excess amount too or just pay the penalty?
Yes, I had to both withdraw the excess contribution AND pay the 6% penalty tax. You can avoid the penalty if you withdraw the excess contributions (and associated earnings) before your tax filing deadline including extensions. If you don't withdraw the excess, you'll pay the 6% penalty every year the excess remains in your account. I didn't catch my mistake right away so I ended up paying the penalty for two years before finally fixing it. Definitely learn from my mistake!
Great question! I went through this exact same confusion last year. Yes, you can absolutely add both catch-up contributions for a total of $11,750 since you're both over 55. However, there's one critical detail that trips up a lot of people (including me initially): your wife will need her own separate HSA account for her $1,000 catch-up contribution. Here's how it breaks down: - Base family contribution: $9,750 (can go into either HSA or split between them) - Your catch-up: $1,000 (must go into your HSA) - Wife's catch-up: $1,000 (must go into an HSA in her name) The catch-up contributions are tied to the individual, not the family plan. So even though you have family coverage, each person's catch-up must go into their own HSA account. If your current HSA is only in your name, you'll need to open a second HSA for your wife to receive her catch-up contribution. This is actually a pretty common misconception, so don't feel bad about being confused! The important thing is getting it right before you make the contributions to avoid any excess contribution penalties.
This is really helpful! I'm new to HSAs and had no idea about the separate account requirement for catch-up contributions. Just to make sure I understand correctly - if my spouse and I are both over 55 with family coverage, we'd need two separate HSA accounts even though we're on the same insurance plan? And the $9,750 base contribution can be split however we want between the two accounts, but each $1,000 catch-up has to go specifically into the account of the person who's eligible for it? I'm wondering if there are any other HSA rules like this that aren't obvious to newcomers. Are there any other common mistakes people make with HSA contributions that I should watch out for?
Did you check your transcript on the IRS website? Sometimes that gives more detailed info than the "Where's My Refund" tool. You might see codes there that explain why your TAX refund is delayed. You'll need to create an account if you don't already have one.
I tried that but couldn't get verified online to create an account. Something about my phone not being in my name or something. Is there another way to check my transcript?
You can request a transcript by mail using Form 4506-T. It takes about 5-10 business days to arrive. But honestly, at this point you're probably better off just waiting a few more days or trying one of the methods others suggested to contact the IRS directly about your TAX refund status.
I'm dealing with the exact same situation! Filed on January 20th and still showing "being processed" after almost a month. What's really frustrating is that I have friends who filed later than me and already got their TAX refunds. One thing I learned from calling my tax preparer is that even though we think our returns are "simple," sometimes there are automatic reviews that we don't know about. For example, if your refund amount is significantly different from last year, or if there are any slight mismatches in the data the IRS has on file vs what you reported, it can trigger a review. The good news is that February is historically the worst month for processing times. Once we get into March, things typically speed up a lot. I'm trying to be patient but it's hard when you're counting on that money!
I'm going through the exact same thing! Filed on January 18th and it's been over a month now with just "still processing." It's so frustrating seeing people who filed after us getting their refunds already. I didn't realize that even small differences from last year could trigger reviews - that's probably what's happening since I changed jobs mid-year and my income is quite different from 2024. Thanks for sharing that insight about February being the worst processing month. I guess we just have to hang in there until March and hope things speed up. At least we're not alone in this waiting game!
Something else to consider - if you revert back to LLC status, make sure you understand how it affects your self-employment taxes. When you had S-Corp status, you were probably taking a reasonable salary and then distributions that weren't subject to SE tax. Once you switch back to partnership taxation (assuming multi-member LLC), all your distributive share of income will typically be subject to self-employment tax, not just the salary portion. This can be a significant increase in your overall tax burden depending on your income levels. We made this switch last year and our overall tax bill went up about $12,000 because of the SE tax difference, even though it was still the right move for other reasons.
This is a great point about SE taxes. One option to consider is making an election to be treated as a limited partnership for certain members under IRC 1402(a)(13). Not all accountants are familiar with this strategy, but it can help reduce SE taxes on passive members while maintaining partnership taxation. Has anyone here successfully implemented this approach?
I just went through this exact process last month and wanted to share some key timing considerations that weren't mentioned yet. When you file your S-Corp revocation letter, make sure to specify that it's effective as of January 1, 2025 (beginning of the tax year) rather than the date you submit the letter. This ensures clean tax reporting for the entire year. Also, don't forget about estimated tax payments. Since you'll be switching from corporate taxation back to pass-through taxation, your quarterly estimated tax obligations will change significantly. We had to recalculate our safe harbor payments and adjust our Q1 2025 estimated taxes to account for the different tax structure. One more thing - if you have any outstanding payroll liabilities or employment tax deposits as an S-Corp, make sure those are fully resolved before making the switch. The IRS can get confused about which entity is responsible for what if there are any loose ends during the transition period.
Great advice on the timing! I'm new to this community but dealing with a similar S-Corp to LLC transition situation. Quick question - when you mention specifying January 1, 2025 as the effective date, does that create any complications if you're filing the revocation letter partway through 2025? I'm worried about potential issues with quarterly filings or payroll that have already been processed under S-Corp status this year.
I appreciate all the detailed responses here! This is exactly the kind of guidance I was hoping for. It sounds like the consensus is that gift cards will be taxable regardless of how we structure it. I'm leaning toward the suggestion to redeem points for actual merchandise instead of gift cards to potentially qualify for de minimis treatment. I'll check our credit card portal to see what options are available under $75 per person. The board approval point is really important too - I hadn't thought about the private benefit implications. I'll make sure we document everything properly and get board approval before proceeding with any approach. Thanks everyone for helping me think through all these angles. Better to handle this correctly from the start than deal with IRS issues later!
Great decision! The merchandise route is definitely your safest bet for staying compliant. Just a heads up - when you're looking at your credit card portal, make sure the items don't have obvious cash values printed on them (like electronics with retail prices). The IRS looks more favorably on items where the value isn't immediately clear to the recipient. Also, since you mentioned you're new to this - keep receipts/documentation of what you redeemed and the point values used. You'll want this for your records in case anyone ever questions the valuation for tax purposes. Good luck with the board meeting!
Another approach to consider is timing the gift-giving strategically. If you're committed to using gift cards, you might want to spread them across tax years or combine them with other compensation adjustments. For instance, if you were planning year-end bonuses anyway, you could reduce the cash bonus slightly and add the gift card value, then gross up the total to cover taxes. This way employees still get the same net benefit, but you're being completely transparent about the tax treatment. Also worth noting - some credit cards allow you to transfer points to travel partners or other loyalty programs. If any of your employees travel for work, you might be able to redeem points for travel credits that could qualify as working condition fringe benefits rather than taxable income, though this gets pretty complex and would definitely need professional tax advice to structure properly. The key is being upfront with everyone about the tax implications rather than trying to find workarounds that might not hold up under IRS scrutiny.
That's a really thoughtful approach about timing and transparency. I hadn't considered the travel credits angle - that could actually be perfect for our ED since she does travel for conferences and donor meetings. Do you know if there are specific IRS guidelines about when travel credits qualify as working condition fringe benefits vs. taxable income? I'd want to research this thoroughly before suggesting it to our board, but it sounds like it could be a win-win if structured correctly.
Caesar Grant
Another option worth considering is the TaxAct DeductionPro feature, which I switched to after hearing about ItsDeductable's discontinuation. It's similar to what others mentioned about H&R Block and TaxSlayer, but I found their valuation database to be really comprehensive - especially for electronics and household appliances that can be tricky to value. The nice thing about TaxAct is that you can use their donation tracker year-round even if you don't file your taxes through them. They pull valuation data from multiple sources including thrift store guides, so the suggested values tend to be well within IRS-acceptable ranges. I've been testing it alongside the Salvation Army guide for the past month, and the values are usually within 10-15% of each other, which gives me confidence I'm in the right ballpark. Plus it has a mobile app that lets you scan receipts directly, though I still take photos of the actual items like some others mentioned here for my own records. For anyone donating regularly like the original poster, having a system that can handle both receipt scanning AND provide reliable valuations is really helpful for staying organized throughout the year.
0 coins
Demi Hall
ā¢This is really helpful! I hadn't heard of TaxAct's DeductionPro before. The fact that you can use their donation tracker year-round without committing to filing through them is exactly what I was looking for. How does their mobile receipt scanning compare to the other solutions mentioned here? I'm trying to decide between TaxAct, that taxr.ai service Jacob mentioned, or just going with the DIY spreadsheet approach. The 10-15% variance with Salvation Army values sounds pretty reasonable - that kind of consistency would definitely give me peace of mind. Also curious about the user interface - is it pretty intuitive to navigate, or does it feel clunky like some of the older tax software tools? With ItsDeductable, I really appreciated how clean and simple the interface was for quickly entering donations.
0 coins
Un Tyming
ā¢Some folks are REALLY misinformed. First of all, TaxAct's charitable deduction feature is called "Donation Assistant", not "DeductionPro". The latter is a feature of H&R Block's tax prep software. Next, TaxAct's Donation Assistant is not available in the Basic version.....you need to buy a higher, more expensive version to get that feature. Finally, I could find NO INDICATION that either Donation Assistant nor DeductionPro could be used through the year. For example, you enter your donated items for the tax year you're preparing the return for, not the current year's donations.
0 coins
Ravi Sharma
Thanks for the reality check @Un Tyming - you're absolutely right about those details. I got confused between the different tax software features and made some inaccurate claims about year-round access. This actually highlights why it's so frustrating that ItsDeductable is going away. Most of these tax software "solutions" are really just tools you can use during tax season when you're already committed to their platform, not the kind of ongoing donation tracking system that ItsDeductable provided throughout the year. It sounds like the standalone solutions (like that taxr.ai service Jacob mentioned, or the DIY spreadsheet approach with Salvation Army/Goodwill guides) might be the better alternatives for people who want to track donations as they happen rather than trying to reconstruct everything at tax time. Has anyone found other tools that actually work year-round for donation tracking without being tied to a specific tax prep service? The whole point was having something readily available whenever I'm dropping off donations, not just in March when I'm doing my taxes.
0 coins