


Ask the community...
I've been dealing with a similar situation for about 3 years now, and what finally saved me was setting up automatic ACH payments directly through my city's online portal. Most people don't realize that many cities now offer this option - you can schedule recurring payments that automatically deduct from your checking account. I calculate my annual liability at the beginning of the year (1.5% of expected income), divide by 12, and have that amount automatically withdrawn monthly. It's like having your own withholding system. The monthly approach works better for me than quarterly because smaller amounts are less noticeable in my budget. One tip that really helped: I set the monthly amount slightly higher than needed (maybe $5-10 extra per month) so I end up with a small refund rather than owing more. That extra cushion gives me peace of mind, especially if I get unexpected income during the year. Check your city's website under "Online Services" or "Tax Payments" - the automatic payment setup is usually buried in there but it's a game changer once you find it.
This monthly automatic payment approach sounds brilliant! I never thought about breaking it down into 12 payments instead of 4 quarterly ones. The smaller amounts would definitely be easier to absorb into my monthly budget without feeling the pinch. I'm curious about the "small cushion" strategy you mentioned - do you just let that extra amount build up as a credit with the city, or do you request a refund each year? I'm wondering if there are any benefits to keeping a credit balance on file versus getting the money back. Also, when you say you set this up through the city's online portal, were you able to do it entirely online or did you need to mail in any forms first? My city's website is pretty basic, so I'm hoping I don't have to deal with paper forms and waiting periods to get the automatic payments started.
I've been lurking on this thread because I'm dealing with almost the exact same situation - living in one city with local tax requirements but working somewhere else. What really struck me from reading all these responses is how many different approaches there are to solve this problem. For anyone still reading through all these options and feeling overwhelmed (like I was), here's what I'm taking away as the key decision points: 1. Do you want to handle it yourself or use a service? The manual approaches (quarterly payments, automatic bank transfers, separate savings account) are definitely doable but require discipline. Services like taxr.ai seem helpful if you're willing to pay for automation and convenience. 2. Monthly vs quarterly payments - I hadn't considered monthly payments before reading Miguel's response, but breaking it down into 12 smaller chunks instead of 4 larger ones makes a lot of psychological sense for budgeting. 3. Where to get help when needed - The Claimyr service sounds useful for actually reaching someone at your city tax office without the endless hold times. I think I'm going to start with Sofia Morales' approach (separate savings account + monthly transfers) since it's simple and free, then explore the automatic ACH setup Miguel mentioned if my city offers it. If I run into roadblocks getting information from my city, I'll try that call service. Thanks everyone for sharing your experiences - this thread has been incredibly helpful for understanding all the options available!
This is such a helpful summary! I was getting a bit lost in all the different options too, so having them broken down into those key decision points really clarifies things. I'm leaning toward the same approach you mentioned - starting simple with the separate savings account and monthly transfers, then building from there if needed. It seems like the lowest-risk way to get started without committing to any paid services upfront. One thing that's making me feel more confident about tackling this is seeing how many people in this thread have successfully solved the same problem. Before reading all these responses, I thought I was stuck with just accepting that annual surprise tax bill, but clearly there are plenty of workable solutions. Has anyone who tried the manual approach (savings account + transfers) ever had issues with discipline or forgetting to make the transfers? I'm wondering if I should set up automatic transfers right from the start or try to build the habit manually first.
The codes on your transcript tell the whole story! Code 971 entries from March and July show you had amended returns being processed, which probably contributed to the complexity. When you requested the trace on 10/07 (another Code 971), the IRS had to cancel your original 09/16 refund (Code 841) and remove the interest (Code 777). The September codes 290/291 show some tax adjustments happened right before your original refund too. November 4th shows your fresh refund (Code 846) with new interest (Code 776). The 7-week gap is typical - they need time to verify the original check wasn't deposited before issuing a replacement. Your account balance is clean at $0 so you should be all set once that November check arrives!
This is super helpful! I'm new to reading transcripts and was totally confused by all these codes. It's reassuring to know that the 7-week wait is normal for traces and not just the IRS being inefficient. Really appreciate you breaking down what each code means - makes me feel way less anxious about the whole process!
I went through something similar last year! The transcript codes can be overwhelming but they actually tell a clear story once you understand them. Your Code 971 entries show you had amended returns in March and July, which definitely complicates processing. When you requested the trace in October, the IRS had to go through their standard verification process - they can't just reissue immediately because they need Treasury to confirm the original check wasn't cashed somewhere. The 7-week gap between cancellation and reissue is actually on the faster side from what I've seen. Some people wait 3+ months! The good news is your account shows a clean $0 balance with no penalties, and the November 4th codes (846 and 776) show everything processed correctly. Make sure your address is current in their system and consider setting up informed delivery with USPS to track when it actually arrives. You should be getting that check soon!
This is exactly what I needed to hear! I was getting really worried that something was wrong with my case since it's been months since I filed. It's good to know that the 7-week timeline is actually pretty reasonable for a trace situation. I'll definitely set up that informed delivery - didn't even think of that. Thanks for taking the time to explain everything so clearly!
I'm dealing with this exact same situation! My wife and I got married in 2022 but I forgot to update my employer until this year. I've been paying taxes on about $8k in domestic partner imputed income that should have stopped after our marriage. I'm curious about the timing aspect - for the year you got married (2021 in your case), did you prorate the imputed income correction only for the months after your marriage date? Or did you remove the entire year's worth? I want to make sure I handle my 2022 amendment correctly since we got married in June of that year. Also, has anyone had success getting their employer to at least provide a letter or statement confirming the imputed income amounts and dates, even if they won't issue corrected W-2s? That might help strengthen the documentation package for the IRS.
For the year you got married, you should definitely prorate the correction based on your actual marriage date. So if you got married in June 2022, you'd only remove the imputed income from July through December 2022 on your amended return. The IRS will expect this level of precision since the tax treatment legitimately changed on your marriage date. Regarding employer documentation, I had good luck getting HR to provide a letter confirming the imputed income amounts and the period it was included in my pay, even though they refused to issue corrected W-2s. They framed it as "confirming payroll information" rather than admitting any error. This documentation definitely helped support my amended returns - the IRS agent I spoke with said having employer confirmation of the amounts makes the review process much smoother. You might also want to pull all your paystubs from the relevant periods to create a detailed timeline showing exactly when the imputed income appeared and in what amounts. This creates a clear paper trail that supports your correction calculations.
Just wanted to add another perspective on this issue - I work in HR and see this situation come up more often than you'd think. While your employer is technically not required to issue corrected W-2s for prior years (especially if they consider the reporting accurate based on their records at the time), they should definitely be willing to provide documentation supporting your amendment. One thing that might help with your employer: frame the request as needing "payroll verification" rather than asking them to admit an error. Most HR departments will provide a letter confirming what was included in your taxable wages and when, especially if you explain it's needed for tax compliance purposes. Also, don't forget to check if your employer has a flexible spending account or dependent care assistance program that might have been affected by this marital status change. Sometimes there are additional tax benefits you might have missed out on that could be recovered through the amendment process. The good news is the IRS sees domestic partner/spouse benefit corrections regularly, so your situation isn't unusual to them. Just make sure you have solid documentation of your marriage date and the imputed income timeline.
This is really helpful insight from the HR perspective! I'm wondering - when you mention framing it as "payroll verification," what specific language have you found works best when employees make these requests? I'm planning to approach my HR department next week about getting documentation for my situation, and I want to make sure I ask in a way that's most likely to get a positive response. Also, you mentioned flexible spending accounts - could you elaborate on how marriage might affect FSA eligibility or contribution limits? I hadn't considered that there might be other benefits beyond just the health insurance imputed income that could be affected by the marital status change.
As someone who's dealt with multiple IRS issues over the years, I can confirm that the mysterious "hold time" is often just agents struggling with their ancient computer systems. But here's something that's helped me get better results: Before calling, I always pull my own account transcript from the IRS website and write down ALL the transaction codes, dates, and dollar amounts I can see. When the agent puts me on hold to "research," I'm ready with specific codes to reference. For example, instead of saying "I'm missing my refund," I'll say "I see transaction code 846 for my refund date of X, but there's also a 570 freeze code from Y date - can you tell me what's causing this freeze?" This usually gets me past the generic responses because they realize I can see the same basic info they're looking at. The key is speaking their language with specific codes and dates rather than general complaints. It doesn't solve the underlying problem of their terrible systems, but it definitely gets you taken more seriously by the agents.
This is exactly the kind of preparation that makes a huge difference! I've been dealing with a complex issue involving multiple tax years, and I was getting nowhere until I started doing exactly what you described. One thing I'd add - if you're not sure what specific transaction codes mean, the IRS Publication 6209 (available online) has a comprehensive list. I spent an hour studying it before my last call, and when I mentioned that I had a 971 notice code with no corresponding resolution, the agent immediately knew I wasn't just another confused taxpayer calling blindly. Also, @f0a5c9e0aa63, have you found any particular time of day or day of the week when you get more knowledgeable agents? I've noticed Tuesday-Thursday mornings seem to connect me with agents who are more willing to dig deeper into the systems rather than just giving standard responses.
Having gone through this exact frustration myself, I can add a few insights from my recent experiences. The "mysterious hold time" often involves agents checking multiple disconnected systems that don't talk to each other well. But here's what I've learned works better: **Before calling, prepare like you're going to court:** - Pull your account transcript and wage & income transcript - Have your Social Security card, photo ID, and all relevant tax documents ready - Write down specific questions with transaction codes (not just "where's my refund") **During the call:** - Ask for the agent's SEID number (employee ID) - this shows you're serious about accountability - If they can't help, specifically request transfer to the "Technical Support" line rather than just asking for a supervisor - Always ask "What will show up in my account notes from this call?" and request they read it back **The game-changer:** If you have a complex issue, ask to speak with an "Accounts Management" representative directly rather than starting with customer service. They have broader system access and can often resolve things the front-line agents simply cannot touch. I've found that being prepared with specific codes and showing I understand the process gets me transferred to more knowledgeable agents much faster than starting with general complaints.
Issac Nightingale
As someone who's been doing gig work for a couple years now, I want to emphasize something that might not be obvious - even though you're currently under the $400 threshold at $342.50, it's really easy to accidentally cross that line without realizing it. Summer break isn't over yet, and those earnings can add up faster than you think, especially during busy periods like weekends or bad weather when demand spikes. I'd recommend setting up a simple tracking system now, even if you think you'll stay under $400. Use a spreadsheet or even just notes on your phone to track your daily earnings, and consider downloading a mileage tracking app like Stride or MileIQ. If you do cross the $400 threshold later, you'll be glad you have those records from day one. Also, don't forget that if you work for multiple gig apps (Uber Eats, Grubhub, etc.), you have to combine ALL your self-employment income when considering the $400 threshold. I learned this the hard way when I thought I was safe staying under $400 with each individual app, but together they put me over the limit. The good news is that with proper mileage tracking, you might actually get money back instead of owing taxes, even if you do go over $400. Last year I drove about 1,200 miles for gig work and the mileage deduction more than covered my tax liability from the earnings.
0 coins
Keisha Robinson
β’This is really solid advice! I'm also doing gig work as a student and didn't realize how quickly those small daily amounts could add up. I started with just weekend shifts thinking I'd make maybe $200 total, but I'm already at $180 after just three weeks. Your point about multiple apps is especially important - I was considering signing up for Grubhub too, but now I realize I need to factor that into my total when watching the $400 threshold. Quick question - when you mention the mileage deduction covering your tax liability, does that include both the regular income tax AND the self-employment tax? I keep seeing people mention self-employment tax as being around 15% which seems pretty steep for a college student just trying to make some spending money.
0 coins
Amina Sow
β’@Keisha Robinson Yes, the mileage deduction can help offset both regular income tax and self-employment tax! The self-employment tax is indeed around 15.3% covers (Social Security and Medicare ,)but here s'the thing - it s'calculated on your net profit after deductions, not your gross earnings. So if you earn $500 from gig work but have $400 in mileage deductions which (is totally realistic if you re'driving efficiently ,)you d'only pay self-employment tax on the remaining $100 of profit. That makes the actual tax burden much more manageable. The key is being diligent about tracking every single mile driven for work - from when you leave home to start your shift, all the miles between deliveries, and the trip back home when you re'done. I use Stride and just hit start "tracking when" I leave for work and stop "when" I get home. At 65.5 cents per mile, those deductions add up incredibly fast. Also don t'forget you can deduct other business expenses too - insulated delivery bags, phone mounts, even a portion of your phone bill based on business use. I keep all my receipts in a folder on my phone and it s'saved me hundreds in taxes.
0 coins
Juan Moreno
This thread has been incredibly helpful! As someone who just started doing gig work myself, I wanted to add one more resource that's been a lifesaver for me - the IRS Publication 334 (Tax Guide for Small Business). It's free on the IRS website and has a whole section specifically about self-employment income and deductions. What I found most useful is that it explains exactly what records you need to keep and for how long (spoiler: keep everything for at least 3 years). It also has examples of legitimate business deductions for delivery drivers that I hadn't thought of, like car washes if you clean your car specifically to maintain a professional appearance for customers. One thing I wish someone had told me earlier - consider opening a separate checking account just for your gig work earnings and expenses. It makes tracking so much easier come tax time, and if you ever get audited, having that clear separation between personal and business finances looks really professional to the IRS. Some banks even offer free business checking accounts for low-volume businesses. Also, for anyone worried about the complexity of filing taxes with gig income - TurboTax, FreeTaxUSA, and other tax software have specific sections for gig workers that walk you through everything step by step. You don't need to be a tax expert to get it right!
0 coins
Ravi Patel
β’This is such great advice about the separate checking account! I'm just getting started with Doordash and was wondering about the best way to keep everything organized. Opening a dedicated account for gig work makes total sense - it would definitely make it easier to see exactly how much I've earned and spent on business expenses. Quick question about the car wash deduction you mentioned - how often can you reasonably deduct that? I feel like if I claimed a car wash every week it might look suspicious, but my car definitely gets messier doing deliveries than it would from just personal driving. Also, do you happen to know if things like air fresheners or seat covers specifically for keeping the car clean/professional for customers would be deductible too? Thanks for mentioning Publication 334 - I'm definitely going to check that out. It's nice to have an official IRS source rather than just relying on random articles online that sometimes contradict each other!
0 coins