Can't reach IRS? Claimyr connects you to a live IRS agent in minutes.
Claimyr is a pay-as-you-go service. We do not charge a recurring subscription.
Using Claimyr will:
- Connect you to a human agent at the IRS
- Skip the long phone menu
- Call the correct department
- Redial until on hold
- Forward a call to your phone with reduced hold time
- Give you free callbacks if the IRS drops your call
If I could give 10 stars I would
If I could give 10 stars I would If I could give 10 stars I would Such an amazing service so needed during the times when EDD almost never picks up Claimyr gets me on the phone with EDD every time without fail faster. A much needed service without Claimyr I would have never received the payment I needed to support me during my postpartum recovery. Thank you so much Claimyr!
Really made a difference
Really made a difference, save me time and energy from going to a local office for making the call.
Worth not wasting your time calling for hours.
Was a bit nervous or untrusting at first, but my calls went thru. First time the wait was a bit long but their customer chat line on their page was helpful and put me at ease that I would receive my call. Today my call dropped because of EDD and Claimyr heard my concern on the same chat and another call was made within the hour.
An incredibly helpful service
An incredibly helpful service! Got me connected to a CA EDD agent without major hassle (outside of EDD's agents dropping calls – which Claimyr has free protection for). If you need to file a new claim and can't do it online, pay the $ to Claimyr to get the process started. Absolutely worth it!
Consistent,frustration free, quality Service.
Used this service a couple times now. Before I'd call 200 times in less than a weak frustrated as can be. But using claimyr with a couple hours of waiting i was on the line with an representative or on hold. Dropped a couple times but each reconnected not long after and was mission accomplished, thanks to Claimyr.
IT WORKS!! Not a scam!
I tried for weeks to get thru to EDD PFL program with no luck. I gave this a try thinking it may be a scam. OMG! It worked and They got thru within an hour and my claim is going to finally get paid!! I upgraded to the $60 call. Best $60 spent!
Ask the community...
- DO post questions about your issues.
- DO answer questions and support each other.
- DO post tips & tricks to help folks.
- DO NOT post call problems here - there is a support tab at the top for that :)
Join the conversation
Join the conversation
This thread has been absolutely invaluable! I'm on an H1B visa planning to return to Taiwan in about 2-3 years, and I've been contributing to my Roth IRA for the past 2 years. After reading everyone's experiences, I'm realizing there are several Taiwan-specific considerations I need to research that I hadn't even thought about: 1) Taiwan's Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT) system has specific rules for overseas income that might affect how Roth distributions are treated, even if the US-Taiwan tax agreement generally covers retirement income. 2) Taiwan's Central Bank has foreign exchange controls that could complicate receiving large USD distributions - there are annual limits on how much foreign currency individuals can bring into Taiwan without special approval. 3) The recent changes to Taiwan's tax residency rules (the 183-day test vs. domicile test) could affect when these rules start applying, similar to what @Maya Patel mentioned about Australia's tie-breaker provisions. What's particularly concerning is that Taiwan doesn't have a comprehensive tax treaty with the US - just a more limited tax agreement that might not cover all the retirement account scenarios discussed here. This could mean fewer protections than what others have described for countries with full treaties. @Liam McConnell - your cost-benefit analysis approach is really smart. For those of us from countries without comprehensive US tax treaties, the ongoing complexity might be even higher, making the simple approach of withdrawing contributions before leaving more attractive. Has anyone dealt with jurisdictions that only have limited tax agreements rather than full treaties with the US? I'm curious how much this affects the practical treatment of retirement account distributions.
@Angelica Smith - your situation with Taiwan s'limited tax agreement rather than a full treaty is really important to highlight! This is a crucial distinction that could significantly impact the treatment of US retirement accounts. The Taiwan-US tax agreement primarily covers withholding taxes and information sharing, but doesn t'have the comprehensive retirement income provisions that full treaties typically include. This means you might not get the same protections that others in this thread have mentioned for countries with full treaties. Your point about Taiwan s'AMT system is particularly concerning - if Roth distributions are treated as overseas income subject to AMT calculations, you could face unexpected tax liabilities even if the distributions are tax-free in the US. The foreign exchange controls you mentioned add another layer of practical complexity that could affect both the timing and cost of accessing your funds. Given Taiwan s'183-day residency test, you might have some flexibility in timing your transition to Taiwan tax residency, but the limited agreement means you d'have fewer treaty benefits to rely on during that transition period. For jurisdictions with limited agreements rather than full treaties, I d'strongly recommend getting a formal tax opinion from professionals familiar with both US and Taiwan tax law before making any major decisions. The stakes are higher when you don t'have comprehensive treaty protections. Your situation really reinforces @Liam McConnell s cost-benefit'analysis approach - with limited treaty protections and additional compliance complexity, the simple strategy of withdrawing contributions before leaving might make even more sense for Taiwan-bound expats than for those going to countries with full treaty coverage.
This thread has been incredibly comprehensive and exactly what I needed! I'm currently on an L1 visa planning to return to Brazil in about 4 years, and I've been contributing to my Roth IRA for the past 3 years. Reading through everyone's experiences, I'm realizing that Brazil presents some unique challenges that haven't been fully addressed yet. Brazil has very strict foreign asset reporting requirements under their "Declaração de Bens e Direitos no Exterior" (CBE), and all Brazilian tax residents must report foreign assets above R$1,000 annually - which would definitely include a Roth IRA. What's particularly complex about Brazil is their "come into compliance" (tributação universal) system - Brazilian tax residents are taxed on worldwide income, and while the US-Brazil tax treaty exists, Brazil's Receita Federal has been taking increasingly aggressive positions on foreign retirement accounts in recent years. I'm especially concerned because Brazil treats investment earnings differently than pension income, and I'm not sure which category Roth IRA distributions would fall under. If they're treated as investment income, they could be subject to Brazil's sliding scale tax rates (up to 22.5% for financial investments), potentially negating much of the US tax advantage. The practical banking side is also challenging - Brazilian banks have become very strict about documenting the source of foreign transfers due to anti-money laundering regulations. Large transfers from US retirement accounts might trigger additional scrutiny and documentation requirements. Has anyone dealt with Brazilian tax authorities specifically regarding US retirement accounts? The expat community in Brazil is smaller than in some other countries, so finding experienced cross-border advisors has been difficult.
Join the conversation
The bucket analogy from Chloe really resonated with me too! I've been helping friends and family with their taxes for years, and capital loss carryovers are always the trickiest part to explain. One additional tip that might help: when you're filling out line 1, always double-check that your Schedule D line 16 shows a LOSS (negative number). If line 16 shows a gain, you wouldn't use the Capital Loss Carryover Worksheet at all - it's only for when your losses exceed your gains. Also, don't forget that if you're married filing separately, your annual deduction limit is only $1,500 instead of $3,000. I've seen people miss that detail and wonder why their calculations don't match the worksheet. The IRS really should simplify these instructions, but understanding that you're essentially rationing your losses over multiple years (because of the annual limit) is the key concept that makes everything else fall into place.
Thank you Emma for that important clarification about Schedule D line 16 needing to show a loss! I actually made that mistake on my first attempt - I was trying to use the carryover worksheet when I had a small net gain, which obviously didn't make sense. The married filing separately limit is also something I completely overlooked. My spouse and I file separately due to some complicated business income situations, so I should be using $1,500 as my limit instead of $3,000. That changes my whole calculation! Between the bucket analogy from @fa0c4e8d1f86 and your reminder about the filing status limits, I think I finally have a clear picture of how to tackle this worksheet. It's frustrating that something so fundamental to tax planning is explained so poorly in the official instructions, but this community discussion has been incredibly helpful.
I went through this exact same struggle with the capital loss carryover worksheet last tax season! The "bucket with a drain" analogy that Chloe shared is spot on - it really helped me visualize what's happening. One thing that also helped me was creating a simple checklist to make sure I was doing line 1 correctly: 1. Check Schedule D line 16 - does it show a LOSS (negative number)? If not, you don't need this worksheet. 2. Enter that loss amount in line 1 first part (the "bucket") 3. For line 1 second part (the "drain"), enter the SMALLER of: your loss from step 2 OR your filing status limit ($3,000 for most people, $1,500 if married filing separately) 4. The difference between parts 1 and 2 is what carries forward to next year I also keep a simple spreadsheet tracking my carryover amounts from year to year, which makes it much easier when I have to deal with this worksheet again. The IRS instructions make this seem way more complicated than it actually is once you understand the basic concept of the annual deduction limit. Hope this helps anyone else wrestling with this confusing form!
This checklist approach is incredibly helpful! I'm definitely going to save this for when I tackle my taxes next month. The step-by-step breakdown makes it so much less intimidating than trying to decipher the IRS instructions. I especially appreciate the tip about keeping a spreadsheet to track carryover amounts year to year. I sold some investments at a loss this year and I know I'll have carryovers to deal with for the next few years, so having a simple tracking system will save me so much confusion down the road. It's amazing how much clearer this whole process becomes when people explain it in plain English instead of tax jargon. Between the bucket analogy, the checklist, and all the real examples everyone has shared, I actually feel confident about handling this worksheet now. Thank you for putting together such a practical guide!
Join the conversation
Quick question - my situation is different but related. My wife is not a US citizen yet (green card pending) but has an ITIN. Could I claim her as a dependent in this case? She made about $8k last year from a small business she runs.
No, you still cannot claim your spouse as a dependent even if they're not a US citizen. The same rule applies regardless of citizenship status - spouses are never dependents. However, you have a few options: you can file as Married Filing Jointly even if your spouse has an ITIN instead of a Social Security Number. Or you can file as Married Filing Separately. In some cases, you might qualify for Head of Household status if your spouse didn't live with you and meets certain other requirements.
I went through this exact same confusion when I first got married! The short answer everyone's given you is absolutely correct - you cannot claim your spouse as a dependent under any circumstances, regardless of income levels or who pays the bills. But here's what I wish someone had told me: before you commit to filing separately, make sure you're actually running real numbers. My husband and I were convinced filing separately would save us money our first year because he had student loans and I made significantly more. Turns out we were completely wrong! When filing separately, you lose access to so many tax benefits: - American Opportunity Tax Credit for education expenses - Lifetime Learning Credit - Child and Dependent Care Credit (if you have kids later) - Earned Income Credit - Student loan interest deduction (which sounds like it might apply to you) Plus the standard deduction rules can work against you. I'd strongly recommend using TurboTax to actually calculate both scenarios with your real numbers before deciding. The "common wisdom" about filing separately saving money for couples with different income levels is often wrong once you factor in all the lost credits and deductions. The tax code is designed to generally favor joint filing for married couples, which is why the spouse-as-dependent option doesn't exist - they assume you'll get better benefits filing together anyway.
This is really helpful advice! I'm also newly married and was leaning toward filing separately because my spouse makes way less than me. But reading about all these lost credits and deductions is making me reconsider. Quick question - when you say you were "completely wrong" about the savings, how much of a difference did it actually make? I'm trying to get a sense of whether we're talking about a few hundred dollars or something more significant. Also, did you end up using any of those online analysis tools people mentioned, or did you just run the numbers manually in your tax software? I'm definitely going to calculate both ways now before making a decision. Thanks for breaking down all those specific credits we might lose - I had no idea there were so many restrictions on married filing separately!
Join the conversation
This is absolutely ridiculous and unfortunately way too common with TurboTax. They've mastered the art of deceptive pricing - you start thinking you're filing for free or cheap, then somehow end up with hundreds in charges you never agreed to. The "Refund Processing Service Fee" is particularly insulting since you never even received the advance! They're literally charging you $40 for nothing. Here's what I'd do: 1. **Call TurboTax immediately** at 1-800-446-8848 and demand they show you exactly when/where you agreed to Live Premium services. Don't accept vague answers about "using premium features" - make them be specific since you did everything yourself. 2. **Ask for a supervisor** if the first rep won't help. I've seen people get partial refunds by being persistent. 3. **Dispute with your credit card company** if they refuse. You have a strong case since you never knowingly upgraded to premium. 4. **File a complaint with the FTC** - they've taken action against TurboTax for these deceptive practices before. The fact that your refund is also delayed makes this even more frustrating. At least you caught the charges before next tax season - now you know to avoid TurboTax completely. For what they're charging, you could get an actual CPA! Don't give up - you have every right to dispute charges you never authorized.
This is absolutely infuriating and I'm so sorry you're dealing with this! TurboTax has become incredibly predatory with their pricing tactics. The fact that they charged you $258 when you did all the work yourself is outrageous. A couple of things that might help: **Call them ASAP** - Their customer service number is 1-800-446-8848. When they inevitably say you "used premium features," demand they specify exactly which ones since you prepared everything yourself. Don't accept vague answers. **Document everything** - Take screenshots of your account showing the charges and any communication with them. This will help if you need to dispute with your credit card company. **The refund processing fee is a scam** - You're paying them $40 to take money out of your own refund! Especially ridiculous since you never even received the advance. **Be persistent** - Ask for supervisors if the first rep won't help. I've seen people successfully get partial refunds by not giving up. If TurboTax won't budge, definitely dispute the charges with your credit card company. You have a strong case since you never knowingly agreed to premium services. You can also file a complaint with the FTC at consumer.ftc.gov - they've taken action against TurboTax for these deceptive practices before. This whole situation is exactly why so many people are switching away from TurboTax. At these prices, you might as well use an actual CPA and get real professional service! Hope you can get some of your money back.
Ava Rodriguez
Has anybody tried the IRS Direct File beta this year? I heard they're testing a completely free filing system directly through the IRS, but I'm not sure if it handles education forms like 1098-T. Anybody have experience with it?
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
•I tried it! It does handle 1098-T forms and education credits, but there are some limitations. It only works for pretty simple tax situations and only certain states are eligible. I qualified in Arizona and it worked great for me with my 1098-T, but if you have anything complicated it'll tell you that you're not eligible. Worth checking if you qualify though!
0 coins
Amina Diop
Just wanted to add another free option that worked well for me - FreeTaxUSA. I used it through the IRS Free File portal and it handled my 1098-T without any upgrade fees. The interface isn't as polished as TurboTax, but it walked me through the American Opportunity Credit step-by-step and I got my full refund. One tip: make sure you have your 1098-T handy because you'll need to enter the amounts manually, but it's pretty straightforward. They also have good customer support if you get stuck on the education credit calculations. Definitely worth trying if the other options don't work out for you!
0 coins
Nathaniel Mikhaylov
•Thanks for mentioning FreeTaxUSA! I was actually looking at that one too but wasn't sure if it was trustworthy. Good to know it worked well for you with the 1098-T. Quick question - did you have to create an account or provide payment info upfront, or is it truly no-strings-attached free? I'm just paranoid after TurboTax immediately wanted my credit card info even for the "free" version.
0 coins