
IRS
CommunityGovernment Services


Ask the community...
Hey all, I'm in a bit of a tax situation and could use some help. I had a pretty good run at the casinos this year and won enough that I'll need to report it. Problem is, I also lost quite a bit (probably more than I won honestly). I know I can deduct gambling losses against winnings, but I'm not sure what documentation I need. The casino gave me a W-2G for one big jackpot, but nothing for my losses. I don't keep the most detailed records - I have some ATM receipts from the casino and credit card statements showing cash advances, but not much else. Does anyone know what the IRS will actually accept as proof of gambling losses? Do I need to have saved all those little ticket stubs? Will bank statements showing withdrawals at the casino be enough? I'm worried that if I get audited, I won't have enough to back up my deduction. Any advice from people who've dealt with this before?
Hey everyone! I have a situation with a business client that I'm advising. They're expecting to receive about $8 million in Employee Retention Credits over the next few months. The problem is, they currently have a $24 million judgment against them for unpaid rent to their commercial landlord. The client is... let's just say... not exactly eager to pay this judgment. They're under the impression that since ERC payments are technically tax credits rather than regular income, these funds might be protected or treated differently when it comes to collections and judgments. I need to understand whether the landlord can place a lien specifically on these incoming ERC funds. Does anyone know how the law treats Employee Retention Credits in cases like this? Are there special protections for tax credits versus regular income when it comes to judgments and collections? Or can creditors go after these funds just like any other asset? Really appreciate any insights you might have on this situation!
Just a word of caution - the IRS has been heavily scrutinizing ERC claims, especially large ones. With a claim size of $8 million, there's a very high likelihood of an audit. Has your client thoroughly documented their eligibility? Many businesses are finding their claims denied or having to return funds.
This is such an important point. My company had an ERC claim for much less (~$350K) and we're currently under audit. The documentation requirements are intense. They're questioning every aspect of how COVID impacted our operations.
That's a good point and adds another layer to the situation. The claim was prepared by a specialized ERC firm that assured us the documentation is thorough, but with $8 million at stake, I'm now wondering if we should have an independent review done. If the IRS denies the claim or reduces it substantially, the client's position with the judgment creditor becomes even more precarious. I'll definitely raise this concern with them and possibly suggest engaging a tax attorney to review the ERC claim documentation before they make any decisions about the funds.
Your client needs to understand that attempting to shield ERC funds from a valid $24 million judgment is not only unlikely to succeed, but could expose them to serious legal consequences. As others have mentioned, once ERC funds are received, they become regular business assets subject to collection. Given the size of both the judgment and the expected ERC payment, I'd strongly recommend your client consider a few key points: 1. **Immediate settlement negotiations**: Sofia's suggestion about offering the $8M ERC as settlement for the full judgment is probably their best option. A 33% recovery might be very attractive to the landlord versus the uncertainty of collecting the full amount. 2. **Timing is critical**: If the landlord's attorneys become aware of the incoming ERC funds, they'll likely file for garnishment before the money even reaches your client's accounts. The sooner settlement talks begin, the better. 3. **ERC audit risk**: Dmitry raised an excellent point about IRS scrutiny. An $8M claim will almost certainly trigger an audit, and if the claim is reduced or denied, your client loses their primary settlement leverage while still owing the full judgment. 4. **Asset protection alternatives**: Rather than trying to hide funds (which could constitute contempt of court), explore legitimate options like appealing the judgment or filing for bankruptcy protection if the business truly cannot pay. The reality is that $8M toward a $24M judgment is a significant payment that most creditors would seriously consider, especially given collection uncertainties.
I inherited a Roth IRA from a work colleague who passed away at 46 (non-spouse) back in 2018. When I first inherited it, I received: * A Roth IRA-BDA (Beneficiary Designated Account) * A separate individual brokerage account Both accounts stayed with Vanguard, along with my personal Roth IRA that I had established on my own, until recently. Last January, a financial advisor from Lincoln Financial was referred to me by a friend. Since I had some extra savings sitting around, I wanted advice on investments and trusted this person to handle everything properly. (I've since discovered Lincoln advisors mainly push insurance products for commissions - which I declined). The advisor suggested I consolidate my inherited Roth IRA and personal Roth IRA into one combined Roth IRA in my name at Lincoln Financial, and move my cash into a new brokerage account there too, so everything would be under one roof. I thought this made senseโuntil my tax preparer emailed me this week with alarming news. This sent me down a research rabbit hole, and I quickly realized the transfer was done completely wrong. According to the IRS website: * An inherited Roth IRA must be transferred directly into an inherited Roth IRA (titled with the deceased's name for the beneficiary's benefit). THIS DIDN'T HAPPEN - THEY LIQUIDATED IT TO MY CHECKING ACCOUNT THEN DEPOSITED INTO A NEW ROTH IRA IN MY NAME ONLY. * If an inherited Roth IRA is moved into a personal Roth IRA, it gets treated as a distribution, which becomes taxable. * Improper rollovers can also trigger excess IRA contribution penalties. Because my inherited Roth IRA was incorrectly transferred into my personal Roth IRA, I'm now facing almost $30K in taxes and penaltiesโinstead of just $260 if it had been done correctly. How this disaster unfolded: 1. Vanguard issued a 1099-R with Code T (early Roth distribution, exception unknown). 2. My financial advisor told me to move the inherited Roth IRA into my personal Roth IRA at Lincoln. I now know this isn't allowedโit should have gone into a properly designated inherited Roth IRA. 3. Since this wasn't a direct transfer (the money was liquidated and deposited into my checking account first), the IRS sees it as a full distributionโeven though I never intended to cash it out. 4. After my tax preparer flagged this, I called Vanguard. Two different reps confirmed the 1099-R can't be changed to Code Q (qualified distribution). Is there anything I can do to fix this mess? Can I go after the financial advisor for giving me terrible advice that's costing me $30K?
Important point that hasn't been mentioned yet - depending on when the original Roth IRA owner established their account and how long they had it, there might be a way to argue that some portion of the distribution should be considered qualified regardless. For Roth IRAs, the "five-year rule" can sometimes apply differently to inherited accounts. If the original owner had the Roth for more than 5 years before passing away, some of the earnings might still be considered qualified distributions. At minimum, your contributions portion should still be tax-free (just the earnings would be taxable), so make sure your tax professional is calculating this correctly. Don't just accept the full amount as taxable!
This is a really good point. I learned this the hard way too - there's actually a difference between the "principal" (original contributions) and the "earnings" in a Roth IRA for tax purposes. The principal should ALWAYS be tax-free when withdrawn, even if done incorrectly. Only the earnings would potentially be subject to tax and penalties.
Exactly! The 1099-R might show the full distribution amount, but you should only be taxed on the earnings portion if this was truly an inherited Roth IRA. The original contributions should remain tax-free regardless of how the transfer was handled. If the original Roth owner had their account for more than 5 years before passing away, the qualified earnings distribution rules might also apply, potentially making even more of the distribution tax-free. Your tax professional needs to dig into these details rather than just accepting the full amount as taxable.
This is an absolutely devastating situation, and I'm so sorry you're dealing with this. As someone who's worked with inherited retirement accounts, I can tell you that this type of advisor error is unfortunately more common than it should be. One additional avenue you might consider is checking if the advisor has Errors & Omissions (E&O) insurance through their firm. Most financial advisors are required to carry this type of professional liability insurance specifically for situations like this where their advice causes financial harm to clients. When you contact the compliance department at Lincoln Financial, specifically ask about their E&O coverage and whether this situation would qualify for a claim. Document that you explicitly relied on their advisor's expertise regarding inherited IRA rules, and that you would never have made this transfer without their professional recommendation. Also, make sure to request all recorded calls if any of your conversations with the advisor were recorded. Many firms record client interactions, and having the advisor's voice on tape recommending this incorrect transfer could be invaluable evidence. The combination of IRS relief requests, FINRA complaints, and potential insurance claims might help you recover most of this $30K mistake. Don't let them brush this off - this is a serious professional error that caused substantial financial damage.
I filed my taxes and waiting for my refund but my bank account just closed. Really worried about what happens to my refund money now. Anyone deal with this before? Need help figuring out what to do next.
Pro tip: sign up for informed delivery with USPS so you know exactly when that check hits your mailbox
Same thing happened to my friend - the IRS will automatically send a paper check to your last known address when the direct deposit gets rejected. Just make sure to keep checking your mail and maybe give it a few extra weeks. Also might want to call your old bank to see if they can tell you exactly when the account closed, that way you know if your refund got processed before or after the closure date.
I've been renting a room in a house for about 8 months now, and I'm starting to suspect my landlord isn't reporting the rental income on her taxes. When I asked her for a formal lease agreement (which I need to qualify for some medical assistance programs), she completely flipped out and got extremely hostile. She flat-out refused to provide any written documentation of our rental arrangement. The way she reacted was so over-the-top that it made me wonder why she's so against having anything in writing. My best guess is that she's collecting cash under the table and not declaring it as income to avoid paying taxes. I'm paying $950 monthly in cash with no receipt, and she's been increasingly aggressive anytime I bring up needing documentation. I'm in a tough spot because I really need this paperwork for my medical situation, but she doesn't seem to care at all about my circumstances. After living here for this long, I feel like I have a right to some kind of formal agreement. What are my options here? Can I legally demand a lease? And if I'm correct about her hiding rental income from the IRS, is there anything I should do about that, or should I just stay out of it?
Since nobody's mentioned it yet - check if your state has a Rent Relief program or tenant advocacy office. When my landlord refused to give me a lease, I contacted our state's housing department and they connected me with a free tenant advocate who helped me draft a letter to my landlord explaining the legal ramifications of not providing proper documentation. The letter mentioned potential tax implications without directly accusing them of tax evasion. Sometimes just showing you know your rights and the relevant tax laws is enough to get reluctant landlords to cooperate. The advocate also helped me create alternative documentation that satisfied my benefits application.
That's a really helpful suggestion - I hadn't thought about state-level resources. Did you have to provide any proof that you were actually paying rent when you contacted them?
I provided bank statements showing regular cash withdrawals that matched my rent amount and dates, plus photos I'd taken of my living space that showed it was clearly being used as a residence. I also had some text messages discussing rent payments. They told me that's usually enough to establish that you're in a landlord-tenant relationship even without formal documentation. The advocate said they see these situations all the time and most housing departments are familiar with off-the-books rentals. Good luck with your situation - document everything!
I've been following this thread and wanted to add something that might help - have you considered creating your own paper trail moving forward? Even if your landlord won't cooperate, you can still protect yourself legally. Start sending her texts or emails about rent payments (like "Hi, here's my $950 rent payment for [month]" with a photo of the cash). Even if she doesn't respond, you're creating timestamped evidence of your rental arrangement. Keep copies of everything. Also, many medical assistance programs accept what's called a "self-attestation" of housing costs along with supporting evidence. You might be able to submit bank withdrawal records, photos of your living space, and a written statement about your living arrangement. Contact the specific program you're applying to - they deal with situations like this more often than you'd think. The hostile reaction when you asked for documentation is definitely suspicious, but focus on protecting yourself first. Getting proper documentation for your medical needs is your priority, and there are usually workarounds even when landlords won't cooperate.
Noah huntAce420
One thing nobody's mentioned - if you itemize deductions to claim gambling losses, you might end up with LESS money than just taking the standard deduction and eating the gambling tax. Do the math before you decide! Last year I had about $8k in winnings and $7k in losses, but the standard deduction was way higher than my total itemized deductions would have been.
0 coins
Ana Rusula
That's a really good point. Also worth mentioning that if you're married filing jointly, the standard deduction is $27,700 for 2023 tax year. So unless you have a LOT of other itemized deductions besides gambling losses, you probably won't benefit from itemizing.
0 coins
Noah huntAce420
You're absolutely right about the standard deduction being substantial for married couples. For single filers it's $13,850 for 2023, which is still pretty significant. The other thing to consider is that even if you don't benefit from itemizing, you still need to report ALL gambling winnings as income on your 1040. The W-2G will be reported to the IRS regardless, so not reporting it will definitely trigger issues. It's just that you might not get the benefit of deducting the losses if the standard deduction is higher than your itemized total.
0 coins
AstroAce
Just wanted to add something important that I learned the hard way - if you're going to reconstruct gambling losses from bank statements and ATM receipts, make sure you can clearly distinguish gambling-related withdrawals from other cash needs. I had a situation where I withdrew cash at a casino ATM but then used some of it for dinner and tips, not just gambling. During my audit, the IRS agent was very thorough about this distinction. She explained that you can only deduct actual gambling losses, not ancillary expenses like meals, drinks, or entertainment. My advice is to be conservative in your estimates. If you withdrew $500 at a casino but aren't sure exactly how much went to gambling versus other expenses, it's better to claim a lower loss amount that you can reasonably defend. The IRS appreciates honesty and reasonable estimates over inflated claims that might not hold up under scrutiny. Also, keep any hotel receipts or restaurant receipts from casino visits - they help establish that you were actually there on the dates you're claiming losses, which strengthens your overall documentation.
0 coins