


Ask the community...
MBA tax deductions are complicated! I got my MBA while working full-time in finance, and the IRS questioned my deduction too. Here's what my tax attorney told me - the key is whether your MBA qualifies you for a "new trade or business" vs. improving skills in your existing one. For example, if you were a marketing specialist before your MBA and continued as a marketing specialist (even with promotion), you have a stronger case than if you were in marketing before and moved to finance after. The IRS often argues that an MBA with a general business curriculum inherently qualifies you for new types of jobs, even if you personally didn't change careers. If you haven't already, check out Tax Court case Galligan v. Commissioner which specifically deals with MBA deductions. Might give you some ammunition.
I went through a similar MBA audit situation two years ago and ended up winning my case. The key thing that saved me was being extremely specific about how each course directly improved my performance in my existing role rather than qualifying me for new positions. What really helped was getting documentation from my employer before, during, and after my MBA showing that: 1) My job title and core responsibilities remained the same, 2) The company encouraged (but didn't require) the MBA for my current role, and 3) My performance reviews specifically mentioned how MBA coursework was improving my existing job functions. I also kept detailed records of how I applied concepts from each class to actual work projects. For instance, I documented how the financial analysis course helped me better evaluate marketing campaign ROI - something I was already responsible for but doing less effectively before the MBA. The $10,500 they're asking for is definitely worth fighting if you can build a solid case showing the MBA enhanced rather than replaced your existing skill set. Don't give up without a proper appeal!
Just to add another perspective, I formed an LLC for my freelance design business last year, and here's what I learned: it's absolutely NOT a free-for-all for deductions. I tried deducting my new laptop at 100% and got destroyed in an audit because I couldn't prove it was exclusively for business. Now I keep a separate credit card for business purchases, log work vs personal use for mixed items, and maintain a mileage log for my car. My tax guy says the key isn't the LLC - it's having a legitimate business with actual income and keeping meticulous records for anything you deduct.
What tax software do you use that helps with this? I'm trying to track everything but its getting overwhelming.
I switched to QuickBooks Self-Employed after my audit nightmare, and it's been a game-changer. The automatic expense categorization and mileage tracking have saved me hours of work each month. For receipts and documentation, I use their built-in receipt scanner plus a backup in Google Drive with folders for each expense category. My accountant recommended this double-system approach after seeing how badly I got hammered in my audit. The key is consistency - spend 15 minutes each week categorizing transactions while they're fresh in your memory, rather than trying to reconstruct everything at tax time.
Your friend's cousin is basically committing tax fraud, and it's only a matter of time before the IRS catches up. I see this all the time - people think forming an LLC gives them some magical shield to deduct personal expenses, but it doesn't work that way. The IRS has specific tests for business deductions: they must be ordinary, necessary, and directly related to your business activities. That truck? Only deductible if it's primarily used for the landscaping business. Personal vacations disguised as "business trips"? That's fraud. Electronics for personal use claimed as business equipment? Also fraud. What really gets people caught is the pattern - claiming tons of deductions with little to no business income, year after year. The IRS calls these "hobby businesses" and they have specific rules to prevent exactly what your friend's cousin is doing. When (not if) he gets audited, he'll face back taxes, penalties, interest, and potentially criminal charges. If you want to start a legitimate business, absolutely do it - but do it right. Keep separate accounts, maintain detailed records, and only deduct expenses that genuinely benefit your business operations.
Another thing to consider - if you're using the cash method of accounting for your business (which most small Schedule C filers do), you would only deduct expenses when you actually pay them. So the store credit approach mentioned above makes sense from that perspective too. If you're using accrual method (rare for small businesses), it gets more complicated and you'd need to properly account for when the expense was incurred vs when the credit was applied.
How do I know which accounting method I'm using? This is my first year filing Schedule C and I don't remember choosing anything specific. I just track my income when I get paid and expenses when I pay them.
You're using the cash method. That's the default for most small businesses and exactly what you described - recording income when you receive it and expenses when you pay them. The accrual method is more complex and involves recording transactions when they're earned or incurred, regardless of when money changes hands. Most Schedule C filers use cash method unless they specifically elected otherwise or have inventory that requires accrual accounting.
Wait I'm confused. If Amazon gives me a $10 promotional credit just for being a Prime member and I use it for a business purchase, is that considered a discount (deduct only what I paid) or is it considered income (deduct full amount but report the $10 as income)?
It's considered a discount, not income. You would deduct only what you actually paid out of pocket after applying the promotional credit. The IRS generally views promotional credits and coupons as price reductions rather than income. You don't need to report the $10 credit as income, and you should only deduct the reduced amount you actually paid for the business item.
I went in person for a different issue (identity verification) and they were super helpful, but for reviews/audits they probably won't be able to do much on the spot. Still, they can see notes in your file that you can't see online, so it might give you more info at least. Make sure to schedule an appointment tho - they don't take walk-ins anymore at most locations.
AaliyahAli
Compared to other verification situations I've seen, yours seems to be moving along the standard path. When verification happens on weekends versus weekdays, there's typically a slight difference in processing speed - weekend verifications often take about 1-2 days longer than weekday ones because the actual processing doesn't begin until Monday. Also, if you're comparing your timeline to pre-2023 experiences, keep in mind that the current IRS systems have been updated and generally process verified returns about 20% faster than in previous years, assuming all other factors are equal.
0 coins
Miguel Castro
I went through this exact same process about 3 weeks ago and can share my timeline. I verified my identity on a Tuesday evening, called to confirm the next day, and the verification notice disappeared from my account within 24 hours. My direct deposit hit my bank account exactly 11 days later on a Saturday morning. One thing I noticed is that my transcript updated with a 846 refund issued code about 2 days before the actual deposit appeared in my account. So if you're checking your transcript regularly (which you can do on the IRS website), that code will give you a heads up that your deposit is coming soon. The waiting is definitely nerve-wracking, but based on what I'm seeing from others this season, your timeline sounds very normal.
0 coins