


Ask the community...
I have a sorta dumb question... if your daughter files taxes for her 1099 work, does that automatically disqualify her from being your dependent? My son insists he needs to file for his small gig income but I'm worried it'll mess up my ability to claim him.
No, her filing taxes doesn't automatically disqualify her as your dependent. As long as she meets all the tests (income under the limit, you providing more than half support, etc.), she can still be your dependent even while filing her own return. In fact, she SHOULD file for her 1099 work even if you claim her as a dependent - she's required to if her self-employment income is over $400 because of Social Security/Medicare taxes. She just needs to check the box that says "Someone can claim you as a dependent" on her return.
Don't overthink this one - your daughter clearly qualifies as your dependent under the qualifying relative rules. I went through this exact situation with my son. As long as you're paying for more than half her support (rent, food, utilities, etc.) and her income stays under that ~$4,700 limit, you're good to go. The student status only matters for the qualifying child test, which she aged out of at 19. This is a pretty straightforward case.
One thing nobody's mentioned is that personal vehicles usually don't generate taxable gains anyway. Cars almost always go down in value, not up. The only reason OP has a potential gain is because of the unique circumstances with the loan and inheritance timing. Most people who sell cars take a loss, which isn't tax deductible for personal vehicles.
Is that still true with used car prices being so crazy lately? I sold my 3-year-old Toyota last year for more than I paid for it new. Do I owe taxes on that?
You're right about the unusual market conditions affecting this. If you sold your personal vehicle for more than you originally paid, then technically yes, you do have a taxable capital gain. Even though it's unusual for cars, the IRS doesn't exempt vehicle gains from taxation. The gain would be calculated as the difference between your original purchase price (your basis) and the selling price. And since you mentioned selling after 3 years, that would be a long-term capital gain, which generally has more favorable tax rates than short-term gains. Make sure to report it on Schedule D of your tax return.
Don't forget to check if your state has any inheritance tax too! Federal and state tax treatments can be different. I'm in Pennsylvania and was surprised to learn we have an inheritance tax even when there's no federal estate tax due. Cars might be exempt depending on your state, but it's worth checking.
Does anyone know if there's a tax benefit to paying back a 401k loan early? Like can I deduct the interest or anything if I pay it back faster than the 5 year term?
Something that really bit me - I took a 401k loan and then my company got acquired 3 months later. The new company's plan didn't accept loan transfers, so I had to either repay the full amount within 30 days or have it treated as a distribution. I ended up with a huge tax bill because I couldn't come up with the cash that quickly. Just something to consider if there's any chance of company changes on the horizon!
Just wanted to add that this exact same thing happened to my son who's in a PhD program. The university financial aid office explained that they recently updated their accounting systems and now classify certain types of stipends differently for reporting purposes. But they confirmed it doesn't change the actual tax treatment - if the stipend was for services rendered (teaching or research work), it's still taxable income regardless of how it appears on the 1098-T. If your daughter has been reporting it correctly all along, she should be fine.
Thank you so much! Did your son end up owing more in taxes because of this change? That's my biggest worry right now. We're already struggling to help her make ends meet with that tiny stipend, and I'm afraid this change is going to mean she suddenly owes taxes that we didn't plan for.
He didn't end up owing more because the fundamental tax treatment of the stipend didn't change - just how the university reported it. Since he had already been reporting it as income all along (which was correct), there was no difference in his tax liability. If your daughter has been properly reporting her stipend as income on her tax returns in previous years, this reporting change shouldn't result in any additional tax burden. The key is that the tax treatment depends on the nature of the payment (compensation for services vs. scholarship), not on how the university chooses to report it on the 1098-T.
Has your daughter checked with other students in her program? I'm betting they all got the same change on their 1098-Ts this year. Universities sometimes make these reporting changes across the board due to updated interpretations of IRS guidelines or changes in their financial systems. My school did something similar last year and it freaked everyone out, but it turned out to be a non-issue tax-wise.
ThunderBolt7
I'm a little late to this discussion, but for what it's worth, I had this exact situation a few years ago. When I took my 1099-R with Code J to my tax preparer, she knew exactly what to do. She entered it as a rollover/transfer on Form 1040, which meant it showed up on the tax return but wasn't counted as taxable income. One thing to remember is to keep all your documentation for at least 3 years after filing. Even though the IRS systems usually match these things up correctly, having your merger paperwork and account statements showing the transfer can be important if there's ever a question.
0 coins
Mateo Gonzalez
ā¢Did your tax preparer need to see the 5498 form, or were they able to process everything with just the 1099-R and the documentation showing the transfer/merger?
0 coins
ThunderBolt7
ā¢My tax preparer didn't need the 5498 form at all. She was able to process everything correctly with just the 1099-R and my documentation showing the transfer happened because of the merger. She told me that tax preparers are very familiar with this situation and know exactly how to code it properly in the tax software. The 5498 forms are more for record-keeping and verification if the IRS has questions later, but they aren't necessary for preparing and filing an accurate return.
0 coins
Jamal Edwards
Quick question - does anyone know if TurboTax handles this situation well? I got a similar 1099-R with Code J for a rollover and want to make sure I'm doing it right.
0 coins
Mei Chen
ā¢I used TurboTax last year for this exact scenario. It definitely handles it, but you need to make sure you answer the questions correctly. When it asks about your 1099-R, there's a specific question about whether you rolled over the distribution into another qualified retirement account. Make sure you say YES to that question, and it'll treat it as non-taxable. It'll also ask you to enter the amount rolled over, which should be the full amount from the 1099-R in your case.
0 coins