Has anyone tried negotiating an Offer in Compromise for gambling tax debt? I heard they might settle for less than you owe if you can prove financial hardship, which seems relevant in OP's case making only $35k with a $25k tax bill.

I went through something very similar a couple years ago - $18k gambling tax bill on a $42k salary. Here's what worked for me: First, definitely file that amended return (Form 1040-X) ASAP to claim your losses. Even with imperfect records, bank statements showing deposits/withdrawals to gambling sites are usually sufficient. The IRS accepts "reasonable documentation" - you don't need a bet-by-bet log. Second, request an installment agreement immediately using Form 9465. With your income level, you'll likely qualify for a low monthly payment plan. I got approved for $180/month on a similar situation. Third, look into penalty abatement. If this is your first major tax issue, you have a good shot at getting penalties removed through First Time Penalty Abatement. This alone saved me about $3k. Don't panic - the IRS actually wants to work with people who are trying to resolve their debt. The key is being proactive and communicating with them rather than ignoring the notices. You've got options, and $25k isn't insurmountable with the right approach.

Someone told me you could get in big trouble for having the wrong filing status on your W-4. Is this true or just another tax myth??

This is actually a really common mistake, and you're definitely not alone in dealing with this! I went through something similar when I switched jobs a few years ago. The good news is that everyone here is right - you won't get in trouble with the IRS, and you'll likely get a nice refund since they've been overwithholding from your paychecks. One thing I'd suggest is to document all your attempts to get HR to fix this. Keep emails, notes from phone calls, etc. While it shouldn't be necessary, having a paper trail can be helpful if there are any delays or complications down the road. Also, once they do fix your W-4, you might want to use the IRS withholding calculator (on their official website) to double-check that your new withholding amount looks reasonable for the rest of the year. Since you've already had extra taxes taken out for several months, you might want to adjust your withholding to account for that so you don't end up with an enormous refund (some people prefer getting their money throughout the year rather than waiting for tax season). Hang in there - this will get sorted out and you'll get that money back!

Can someone clarify the consequences if you're past the statute of limitations but you OWED money to the IRS? I'm in a similar situation where I made mistakes on older returns, but in my case I underreported some income. Getting nervous about what happens now.

I've been following this thread closely since I'm dealing with a similar situation with my 2019 and 2020 returns. One thing I want to add that hasn't been mentioned yet is the importance of checking if you qualify for any penalty relief programs. Even if you're within the statute of limitations and need to pay additional tax, the IRS has first-time penalty abatement and reasonable cause relief options that can waive penalties for honest mistakes. I discovered this when I had to amend my 2020 return - while I did owe additional tax, they waived all the penalties because I had a clean compliance history and could demonstrate reasonable cause for the error. Also, if anyone is still unsure about their specific situation, I'd recommend getting your tax transcripts from the IRS website first. They show exactly when your returns were filed and processed, which helps you calculate the exact statute of limitations dates for your amendments. It's free and gives you all the key dates you need to know.

I work at a bank and see this kind of thing all the time with government payments. What likely happened is the IRS check processing system initially recorded your payment (code 613) but then during reconciliation, something didn't match up so they reversed it (code 612). The most important thing: your check was actually cashed, so your money is sitting SOMEWHERE in the Treasury's account. It's not lost, just misallocated. The IRS can absolutely track where every dollar goes - they just need to trace it. Pro tip: when you call, ask for the "IDRS check payment trace" specifically. That's their internal system for tracking payments. And definitely call from a landline if possible - their system disconnects cell phones more frequently for some reason.

This is exactly what happened to me in 2018! The sequence of codes 613 followed by 612 is frustrating but actually gives you valuable information - it proves the IRS received and initially processed your payment before something went wrong. In my case, I had written the wrong tax year on my payment voucher (wrote 2017 instead of 2018), so they applied it to the wrong year initially, then reversed it when they couldn't match it to a return. The money sat in a suspense account for months while I was getting notices about unpaid taxes. When I finally got through to the IRS, they found my payment within 10 minutes using the check number and amount. They transferred it to the correct year and refunded the penalties they had charged me. The whole thing was resolved in one phone call once I reached the right person. Don't panic - your money is definitely in their system somewhere. Bring your bank statement, the check number, and those transaction codes when you call. Ask specifically for a payment trace and mention you can see codes 613/612 on your transcript. This will help the agent understand exactly what happened.

Anyone know if you can get in trouble for deliberately overpaying? Like could the IRS see it as some kind of weird fraud attempt? I did it last year and my refund has been "under review" for 9 months!!!

I used to think the same way - just overpay and avoid the stress! But after learning more about taxes, I realize this approach actually costs you money in multiple ways. The biggest issue is opportunity cost. When you overpay by thousands of dollars, you're essentially giving the government a free loan for months while waiting for your refund. That money could be earning interest in a high-yield savings account, paying down credit card debt, or invested in your retirement account. Also, contrary to what many people think, the IRS doesn't actually know your complete tax picture. They receive your W-2s and 1099s, but they don't know about: - Charitable donations you made - Medical expenses that might be deductible - Education credits you qualify for - Child tax credits or dependent care expenses - Business expenses if you're self-employed - State and local tax deductions By just overpaying without filing properly, you could be missing out on legitimate deductions and credits worth hundreds or thousands of dollars. The tax code is complex, but that complexity often includes benefits designed to help taxpayers - you just have to claim them properly. A better approach is to adjust your withholdings throughout the year to get as close to your actual tax liability as possible, then file accurately to claim all the deductions and credits you're entitled to.