


Ask the community...
I run into this all the time with clients. The real issue is that forms are designed by people who don't understand the distinction between legal entity type and tax status. Here's what I tell my clients: - Secretary of State filings: Always "LLC" - IRS filings: "S-Corporation" (Form 1120-S) - Loan applications: "LLC" with note about S-Corp election - Insurance applications: "LLC" - Contracts: "LLC" with full legal name including "LLC" What matters is understanding what the form is asking for and why they need to know.
This is really helpful! Does the same logic apply for an LLC being taxed as a C-Corp? I just made that election this year and I'm super confused about how to fill out forms now.
Yes, the same logic applies for LLC taxed as C-Corp! Your legal entity is still an LLC, so you'd follow the same pattern Carmen outlined. The key differences for C-Corp election: - IRS filings: You'd file Form 1120 (regular corporate tax return) instead of 1120-S - Same rules for everything else: LLC on state filings, contracts, insurance, etc. - Loan applications: Still "LLC" with a note about C-Corp tax election The C-Corp election is even less common than S-Corp, so you might get more confused looks from people, but the principle is identical - your tax status doesn't change your legal business structure.
This thread has been incredibly helpful! I'm dealing with a similar situation but with a twist - my LLC elected S-Corp status mid-year (July 2024) after starting as a regular LLC. Now I'm filling out a contractor application for a government project and I'm not sure how to handle the partial year situation. Should I select LLC since that's how I started the year, or S-Corp since that's my current status? The application asks about my "current business entity type" but also wants tax information from the full previous year when I was both. Has anyone dealt with mid-year elections and how they affect applications? I don't want to get rejected for inconsistent information between my current status and last year's tax filings.
14 Has your cousin considered filing for the Streamlined Domestic Offshore Procedures? With a foreign partner involved, there might be international reporting requirements they've missed too. When I had a similar situation with my small business that had a foreign partner, we had to deal with FBAR filings and other international information reporting requirements. The foreign partner should also check if they have any US tax filing requirements based on their interest in a US LLC, even if they've never been to the US.
25 The Streamlined Procedures are mostly for US taxpayers with unreported foreign assets, not really for this situation where the issue is a US business with a foreign partner. But you're right about the foreign partner potentially having US filing requirements.
This is a complex situation that requires immediate attention. Your cousin is looking at significant penalties - potentially over $25,000 just for the unfiled 1065s alone ($210 per month per partner for up to 12 months, multiplied by 10 years). Here's what I'd recommend: 1. **Get professional help immediately** - Find a tax attorney or CPA who specializes in partnership taxation and penalty abatement. The foreign partner aspect adds layers of complexity with potential withholding requirements. 2. **File all delinquent returns first** - Don't wait for penalty notices. Filing shows good faith effort to comply. 3. **Reasonable cause strategy** - For penalty abatement, your cousin will need to demonstrate reasonable cause for each unfiled year. Common arguments include: reliance on professional advice, serious illness, inability to obtain records, or other circumstances beyond their control. 4. **Consider installment agreements** - Even with abatement, there may still be substantial penalties. The IRS offers payment plans for situations like this. 5. **Foreign partner compliance** - The German partner likely has US tax obligations too and may need to file their own returns. The key is acting quickly and having a comprehensive strategy. Each day of delay potentially increases penalties. A qualified professional can help navigate the penalty abatement process and potentially save thousands in penalties.
This is incredibly helpful advice, thank you Connor! The $25,000+ penalty estimate really puts this in perspective - that's more than the business has made in several years combined. One quick follow-up question: when you mention filing all delinquent returns first to show good faith, should they file them all at once or space them out? I'm wondering if flooding the IRS with 10 years of returns simultaneously might trigger additional scrutiny or if it's better to get everything submitted quickly. Also, do you have any insight on how the IRS typically handles reasonable cause arguments for multi-year non-filing situations? Is it harder to prove reasonable cause when it's been going on for a decade versus just a year or two?
Just want to add my 2 cents as someone who works at a credit union. The W-9 process for most banks is super simple now - usually just entering your SSN and checking a box during the online application. If it makes you feel better, the bank already has your SSN and tax info if you have other accounts with them. The W-9 requirement is just a formality to make sure they have proper documentation for IRS compliance. Don't overthink it! High yield savings accounts are great for building money, and the tax stuff is actually pretty straightforward. You'll get a 1099-INT in January showing your interest earned, and you just enter that amount on your tax return. It literally takes 2 minutes.
Does it matter if the name on the W-9 matches exactly with my Social Security card? My SS card has my middle name but I don't use it on most accounts.
Yes, it's important that the name on your W-9 matches exactly with your Social Security card. The IRS uses name matching to verify tax documents, and mismatches can cause delays or issues with your tax reporting. If your Social Security card has your middle name, you should include it on the W-9 form. Most banks will also want your account name to match your tax name for consistency. You can always call the bank ahead of time to ask about their specific requirements for name formatting. It's better to be exact upfront than to deal with potential complications later when you receive your 1099-INT or if the IRS has questions about the reporting.
Thanks everyone for all the helpful responses! This has cleared up so much confusion for me. I was definitely overthinking the whole W-9 situation. @Malik Johnson - your explanation about the difference between W-9 and 1099 forms was super clear. I get it now - W-9 is what I fill out when opening the account, and 1099-INT is what I'll receive later showing my interest income. That makes perfect sense! @Anastasia Sokolov - I had no idea about the backup withholding thing! That's definitely motivation to make sure I fill out the W-9 correctly. 24% is a lot to have withheld, even if I'd get it back eventually. @Sean O'Connor - it's reassuring to hear from someone who works at a financial institution that this is all routine. You're right that I'm probably overthinking it. I think I'm ready to move forward with opening the Capital One HYSA now. I'll make sure to use my full name exactly as it appears on my Social Security card when filling out the W-9. Thanks again for all the guidance - this community is awesome!
@Miguel HernΓ‘ndez - Wait, I m'confused - are you the original poster? Your member ID is different from QuantumLeap who asked the original question. But regardless, this thread has been super helpful for me too! I ve'been putting off opening a HYSA because I was intimidated by all the tax forms, but now I realize it s'really not that complicated. The W-9 is just standard paperwork that every bank needs. One quick follow-up question for everyone - do you get the 1099-INT even if you only earn like $5 in interest for the year? Or is there a minimum threshold?
I'm confused by all this. So if I make $30k total but only have 1099s for $20k, I just put $30k on my Schedule C and that's it? I don't need to tell them which income came from where? I've been itemizing each client separately and its so time consuming!
That's correct! On Schedule C, you only need to report your total gross receipts on line 1. You don't need to itemize each 1099 or client on the form itself. The IRS's matching system just checks that your reported income is at least as much as the total of all 1099s they've received with your SSN/EIN. You should still keep records of who paid you what in your own bookkeeping (in case of an audit), but you don't need to attach or itemize that information on your tax return. This is why many sole proprietors find it easier to just report their total business income in one lump sum.
Just to add some reassurance from personal experience - I had this exact scenario happen to me two years ago. I was a freelance graphic designer reporting about $32,000 in total income, but I never received 1099s from three of my smaller clients (totaling around $5,500). I was really nervous about it too. I reported my full $32,000 on Schedule C anyway, and my return processed completely normally with no delays. The IRS received 1099s for about $26,500, so my reported income was higher than what they had on file. No red flags, no correspondence, nothing. The key thing to remember is that the IRS computer systems are looking for underreporting, not overreporting. When you report MORE than what's on the 1099s they received, it just means you had additional income sources (like cash payments) which is totally normal for sole proprietors. Your refund shouldn't be delayed at all since you're being conservative and reporting everything. The matching happens after your return is processed anyway, so it won't hold up your refund.
This is really helpful to hear from someone who actually went through it! I'm in almost the same boat - freelance work with some missing 1099s but reporting all my income anyway. Did you ever find out if those clients actually sent 1099s to the IRS even though you didn't receive them? I'm wondering if some of my smaller clients might not have filed them at all since they're not required to if they paid less than $600.
Evelyn Martinez
I went through this exact same situation last year and completely understand your stress! The 1099-K from PayPal is essentially just a transaction report - it's showing that $12,350 moved through their system, but it's not determining what's taxable income. Here's what really matters: your BetRivers win/loss statement. That's the document that shows your actual gambling activity for tax purposes. Since you had a net loss of $3,200, you're actually in a better position than you might think. The way it works is you report your gross winnings (from the BetRivers statement, not the PayPal amount) as gambling income. If you itemize deductions, you can then deduct losses up to the amount of your winnings. But if your standard deduction is higher than what you'd get from itemizing (including the gambling loss deduction), you're better off just taking the standard deduction. Keep all your documentation - the 1099-K, your BetRivers win/loss statement, and any transaction records. If the IRS ever questions why your reported income doesn't match the 1099-K amount, you'll have clear evidence that those PayPal transactions were deposits and withdrawals, not gambling winnings. Don't let the 1099-K amount scare you into thinking you owe taxes on $12,350. Focus on what your actual gambling results were according to BetRivers' records.
0 coins
Fiona Sand
β’This is incredibly helpful - thank you for sharing your experience! I've been panicking about this for weeks, thinking I somehow owed taxes on that massive PayPal 1099-K amount. Your explanation about it being just a transaction report versus actual taxable income makes so much sense. I was getting completely overwhelmed by TurboTax asking about the 1099-K and wasn't sure if I should report the full amount or ignore it completely. Now I understand I need to focus on my BetRivers win/loss statement for the actual tax reporting. It's such a relief to know this is a common issue and that the IRS understands these payment processors are just covering their reporting requirements. I'm definitely organizing all my documentation like you suggested - better to be over-prepared than caught off guard later. Really appreciate you taking the time to explain this so clearly!
0 coins
Charlee Coleman
I'm dealing with a very similar situation right now! Got a 1099-K from PayPal showing about $9,800 in transactions for my BetMGM deposits throughout the year, but like you, I actually ended up with a net loss when looking at my actual gambling results. What's been helpful for me is understanding that the 1099-K is basically PayPal's way of covering their bases with the IRS - they're required to report payment processing over $600 now, but that doesn't mean everything on there is taxable income. It's just showing money that moved through their system. Your BetRivers win/loss statement is definitely the key document here. That shows your real gambling activity for tax purposes. Even though you had a net loss of $3,200, you'll still need to report any gross winnings as income (from the BetRivers statement, not the PayPal amount), and then you can potentially deduct losses up to that amount if you itemize. The most important thing is keeping good records of everything - your PayPal 1099-K, the BetRivers win/loss statement, and any transaction histories. That way if there's ever a question about why your reported income doesn't match the 1099-K amount, you can show exactly what those transactions were for. It's definitely stressful when you first see that big number on the 1099-K, but you're on the right track questioning whether it's all actually taxable income. Focus on your real gambling results, not the payment processing total.
0 coins