


Ask the community...
I'm not a tax professional, but I went through this exact situation with my ex's daughter. Make sure you have documentation showing when the child lived with you - school records with your address, medical records showing you as the caregiver, even dated pictures or calendar entries of the time they spent with you. The IRS might not ask for this, but if the bio mom also tries to claim him, you'll need proof. My ex tried to claim her daughter even though she lived with me 9 months of the year, and I had to provide documentation to support my claim.
What tax software did you use that allowed you to claim a non-bio kid? I tried with TurboTax and it kept asking for adoption documentation or court papers.
I used H&R Block's online software. When it asked about the relationship, I selected "other eligible dependent" rather than "son/daughter" and then it walked me through the qualifying child tests. It asked if the child lived with me for more than half the year and if I provided more than half the support, both of which were true in my case. TurboTax should have a similar option. You might have been going down the wrong path in their question tree if it was asking for adoption papers. Try looking for the option about qualifying dependents rather than specifically entering the child as your son/daughter. The relationship test includes any child who lived with you in a parent-child relationship.
The key thing to remember is that the IRS qualifying child test is based on facts and circumstances, not just biology. Since you've had him living with you full-time since February (which is more than half the year) and you're providing his support, you very likely qualify to claim him. Just be prepared that if his mom tries to claim him too, you'll need to be able to prove the residency test - keep records of school enrollment, medical appointments, any official mail that comes to your address for him, etc. The IRS will look at where he actually lived, not what anyone claims. One thing to consider is having a conversation with his mom about this. Sometimes parents can agree on who claims the child each year, especially if it benefits the family overall. But if she's not cooperative and you meet the tests, you have every right to claim him based on the living situation you described.
This is really helpful advice about documentation. I'm new to this whole tax situation but I'm wondering - if the biological mom agrees to let him claim the child, do they need to put that agreement in writing somewhere? Or is it just understood that whoever files first gets to claim them? I've heard conflicting things about whether there needs to be a formal agreement between the parents.
I went through something very similar when I moved here from the UK in 2021. Had dividend income from British stocks that I completely missed reporting for two years. The anxiety was real! Here's what worked for me: I ended up using the Streamlined Filing Compliance Procedures that @Abigail Spencer mentioned. It was definitely the right path for someone in your situation. Since you genuinely didn't know about the reporting requirement (which is totally understandable as a new resident), this should qualify as non-willful non-compliance. The process was actually more straightforward than I expected. I filed amended returns for the missed years, included the required statement explaining my circumstances as a recent immigrant who wasn't aware of the foreign reporting requirements, and filed the missing FBARs. No penalties under the streamlined procedure. One tip: document everything about when you moved here, when you started working, and your genuine lack of knowledge about these requirements. The IRS wants to see that this was an honest mistake, not intentional tax avoidance. Your situation - small dividend amounts, proper W-2 reporting, coming forward voluntarily - checks all the boxes for non-willful behavior. Don't stress too much about this. The IRS actually handles these cases quite reasonably when people come forward voluntarily like you're doing.
This is really reassuring to hear from someone who went through the exact same situation! I'm definitely feeling less anxious about this after reading everyone's responses. The Streamlined Filing Compliance Procedures sound like exactly what I need. Quick question - when you filed your amended returns, did you need to pay any additional taxes on the dividend income? I'm wondering if the Foreign Tax Credit covered most of it since the dividends were likely already taxed in the UK. Also, how long did the whole process take from start to finish? I'm going to start gathering all my Canadian brokerage statements and tax documents this weekend. Better to get this sorted out properly now than worry about it later!
I just wanted to add one more perspective as someone who's helped several friends through similar foreign income reporting issues. The most important thing is that you're being proactive about this - the IRS really does appreciate voluntary disclosure. A few practical tips based on what I've seen work well: 1. Gather all your Canadian brokerage statements for the past 3 years showing the dividend payments and any Canadian taxes withheld 2. Create a simple spreadsheet tracking the dividend amounts by year - this will make the amended return process much smoother 3. If you have any documentation showing when you moved to the US and started working (like your visa approval, employment start date, etc.), keep that handy as it supports your "non-willful" status The Foreign Tax Credit will likely cover most or all of any additional US tax liability on those dividends, especially since Canada and the US have a good tax treaty. And honestly, with dividend amounts under $2500 per year, even without the credit, your additional tax liability would probably be pretty minimal. The key is just getting everything properly reported going forward. Once you're caught up with the Streamlined procedures, this becomes a non-issue for future years.
This is such helpful advice! I really appreciate everyone sharing their experiences - it's making this whole situation feel much more manageable. The spreadsheet idea is brilliant - I was dreading trying to organize all those statements but breaking it down by year makes total sense. And you're right about the Foreign Tax Credit likely covering most of the liability. I just checked and Canada did withhold taxes on those dividends, so that should work in my favor. I'm feeling much more confident about moving forward with the Streamlined Filing Compliance Procedures. It's reassuring to know that so many people have gone through similar situations successfully. Thanks to everyone for the detailed responses and practical tips - this community is amazing!
Thanks everyone for sharing your experiences! This is my first time dealing with a 570 code and honestly, I was starting to panic a bit. Reading through all these timelines is really reassuring - it sounds like most people do eventually get the 571 release code. I'm at about day 12 since mine appeared, so based on what @Christian Burns and @Noland Curtis shared, I'm probably still within the normal timeframe. Going to try to be patient for another week or two before calling. The airport security checkpoint analogy really helps put this in perspective @Isabel Vega! Fingers crossed mine resolves soon.
Welcome to the 570 club! š I just got mine a few days ago and was totally confused at first. This thread has been a lifesaver - everyone here really knows their stuff. It's comforting to see so many people going through the same thing. Hopefully we'll both be posting our success stories with 571 codes soon! The waiting game is definitely the hardest part.
I'm going through this exact same situation right now! Got my 570 code about 5 days ago and have been checking my transcript obsessively ever since. It's so helpful to see everyone's timelines here - makes me feel like I'm not alone in this. @Lucas Bey I'm in a similar boat as you, trying to stay patient but it's tough when you're expecting that refund! @Noland Curtis your detailed timeline is super reassuring. I didn't claim any unusual credits or anything, so hopefully mine will follow a similar path. Has anyone noticed if the day of the week the 570 appears affects how quickly it gets resolved? Mine showed up on a Tuesday if that matters at all.
OP, one thing nobody's mentioned is state taxes. Even while these unreimbursed employee business expenses are suspended at the federal level through 2025, some states still allow them. For example, California, New York, and several other states still permit deducting these expenses on your state tax return. So make sure you check your state's rules - you might get at least some tax relief that way until the federal deduction potentially returns in 2026.
That's an excellent point about state taxes! I live in Pennsylvania and they actually allow unreimbursed employee expenses on the state return. Saved me a decent amount on state taxes last year even though I couldn't deduct on federal.
I'm a tax professional who works with commission-based salespeople regularly, and I want to clarify a few important points about your situation. First, you're absolutely correct that as a non-statutory employee, you cannot file Schedule C. However, the classification itself might be worth examining - the fact that you work 100% on commission, use your own vehicle extensively, and work from home could potentially support an independent contractor classification depending on other factors in your employment relationship. For your current situation, here's what I'd recommend: 1) Document everything meticulously - mileage logs, home office measurements, all business expenses. Even though you can't deduct them federally right now, this creates a paper trail. 2) Check your state tax laws - many states still allow unreimbursed employee business expense deductions. 3) Definitely explore the accountable plan option that Zoe mentioned - this is often the best solution for commission salespeople. Regarding your home office, make sure it's used exclusively for business to qualify when deductions become available again. For the vehicle, keep detailed mileage logs showing business vs. personal use (though you mentioned 100% business use). The suspended deductions are scheduled to potentially return in 2026, so maintaining good records now will position you well if that happens.
This is really helpful advice, especially about documenting everything even though the deductions aren't available right now. I had a question about the classification review you mentioned - are there specific IRS tests or criteria I should look at to determine if I might actually qualify as an independent contractor? I'm curious because I do set my own schedule, use my own equipment, and don't have supervision over how I do my work - just results-based expectations from my employer.
Sarah Ali
Check if you have any outstanding parking tickets or court fees. That's what mine was for last year š¤¦āāļø
0 coins
Kylo Ren
Had the exact same thing happen to me in 2023! The "Return is completed" status on the same day as the offset is actually good news - it means they've finished all processing and your remaining refund should be coming soon. In my case, the $243 offset was for an old unemployment overpayment I had completely forgotten about from 2020. The notice they mail you will have all the details about which agency the debt was owed to and contact info if you want to dispute it. Since your return shows "completed" on Feb 14th, if you chose direct deposit you should see the remaining refund by this coming Friday (Feb 21st) at the latest. The Michigan system is usually pretty quick once they mark it completed. Also definitely call that hotline number @Benjamin Kim mentioned - they were super helpful when I called and told me exactly what the debt was for without having to wait for the mail notice.
0 coins